I Am Number Four Blu-ray Review
Score: 57
from 4 reviewers
Review Date:
"I Am Number Four" features superb AV quality but suffers from a rushed plot and inadequate supplementary content; worth renting but not buying.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 61
I Am Number Four arrives on Blu-ray with a solid 1080p/AVC-encoded transfer that excels in daylight scenes with vibrant colors and exquisite detail, but struggles with nighttime scenes due to middling delineation and intermittent crush. CGI effects are generally competent, and black levels are inky though occasionally crushed.
Audio: 69
The DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 track on 'I Am Number Four' offers an exhilarating home theater experience with robust bass, detailed directional effects, and clear dialogue, making full use of Disney's bombastic and dynamic sound design to ensure immersive and vividly engaging audio.
Extra: 33
The Blu-ray of "I Am Number Four" offers limited but engaging extras, with filmmaker-introduced deleted scenes and an insightful 12-minute featurette by Teresa Palmer on her role as Number Six, alongside a brief but entertaining 3-minute blooper reel. The 3-disc Combo Pack includes a standard DVD and Digital Copy.
Movie: 51
"I Am Number Four" features dazzling special effects and energetic action sequences in its final act, but is hampered by a derivative script, unengaging early scenes, and underdeveloped characters. Despite a promising start and an explosive conclusion, the film never fully transcends its formulaic young adult roots.
Video: 61
"I Am Number Four" materializes on Blu-ray with a solid 1080p/AVC-encoded transfer that showcases impressive visual fidelity synonymous with modern high-definition releases. The resolution is generally robust, delivering crisp definition and lucid clarity. Daylight sequences stand out with exquisite rendering of textures, vibrant colors, and warm, lifelike skin tones. Detail is exceptional, particularly in well-lit scenes where the nuanced minutia captured by the camera's lens comes to the fore. Primaries explode beautifully, and black levels are satisfyingly deep, though intermittently crushed.
However, the presentation encounters notable issues during darker scenes, such as the opening jungle sequence, which suffers from a lack of detail and clarity. Night-time scenes intermittently grapple with middling delineation and crush, making them somewhat nebulous. These issues appear to stem largely from cinematographer Guillermo Navarro’s lighting choices rather than any inherent defect in the transfer. Despite these imperfections, most CGI effects hold up remarkably well under high-definition scrutiny, and instances of banding, artifacting, aliasing, and ringing are minimal.
The film's visual effects, particularly the energy blasts and explosions, are designed to impress and largely succeed in doing so. The elevated contrast enhances the dynamic range, although it sometimes gives skin tones a bronzed sheen. This slick, trendy appearance is aided by yellow and teal filters, which add to the stylized look typical of contemporary action films. Despite a few fluctuations in sharpness largely attributable to extensive CGI usage, "I Am Number Four" offers a visually compelling Blu-ray experience that should satisfy the majority of viewers, even if it may not fully appease the most discerning videophiles.
Audio: 69
The audio presentation of "I Am Number Four" on Blu-ray is an impressive exemplar of a DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 surround track, which enhances the home theater experience significantly. The surround mix provides an immersive soundstage with seamless integration between front and rear channels, allowing discrete sound effects to follow realistic paths that amplify the film's events. Explosions and energy blasts are delivered with potent LFE output, adding might and muscle to the overall experience. Bass elements are robust yet balanced, never overshadowing the other components in the soundfield. The blend of Trevor Rabins’ dynamic score, spatial ambiance, and crystal-clear dialogue results in a richly textured auditory experience.
Directional effects are executed with precision, providing additional realism as alien creatures and energy blasts move dynamically across the frame. The rear speaker activity is fierce when necessary, enveloping the listener in the cacophony of battle sounds that permeate the atmosphere. Despite the intensity of the action sequences, dialogue remains clean and intelligible, maintaining clarity even amidst the bedlam. The vigorous audio track is anything but subtle, perfectly matching the film's high-energy sound design. Adding further to its appeal, the track is available in several languages including French and Spanish, accommodating a diverse audience.
In summary, Disney’s audio treatment for "I Am Number Four" is high-caliber, exemplifying what fans have come to expect from their releases. The DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 mix delivers an utterly engaging sonic experience with impressive dynamics and invigorating detail. Whether it's the weighty bass during explosions or the nuanced background ambiance during quieter scenes, this track considerably elevates the overall film experience.
Extras: 33
The Blu-ray release of "I Am Number Four" offers a concise array of extras, with deleted scenes providing the only substantial content. Director D.J. Caruso introduces six deleted scenes, offering fans additional context and depth. The standout featurette, Becoming Number Six, dives into Teresa Palmer’s portrayal of the titular character, showcasing the intense physical preparation and visual effects that brought her character to life. Additionally, a brief but enjoyable blooper reel captures behind-the-scenes antics. The package includes a standard DVD and a Digital Copy of the film.
Extras included in this disc:
- Deleted Scenes: Six scenes introduced by Director D.J. Caruso.
- Becoming Number Six: Teresa Palmer covers the stunts and visual effects.
- Bloopers: Light-hearted outtakes and on-set gaffes.
- Bonus DVD: Standard definition version of the film.
- Digital Copy: Bonus digital version of the film.
Movie: 51
"I Am Number Four" marks an ambitious foray into young adult sci-fi cinema, helmed by director D.J. Caruso. The plot follows John Smith (Alex Pettyfer), a teenage alien hiding from intergalactic assassins known as the Mogadorians. The narrative opens with considerable promise; a thrilling sequence introduces the death of Number Three and the subsequent danger looming over our protagonist, Number Four. Caruso employs high-octane action and special effects to keep viewers engaged, initially providing a well-paced spectacle reminiscent of his earlier successes like "Disturbia" and "Eagle Eye."
However, the film’s middle act sagging under derivative writing and formulaic teen drama diminishes its momentum. Pettyfer portrays John with adequate vulnerability, and while Timothy Olyphant brings a sturdy presence as Henri, John's protector, many supporting characters fall into predictable roles. The budding romance with Sarah (Dianna Agron) and tension with school bullies tread familiar ground, providing little innovation. The film adheres strictly to genre conventions, with scenes of telekinetic powers and alien confrontations largely mirroring established teen angst narratives.
The lackluster script, penned by Alfred Gough, Miles Millar, and Marti Noxon, fails to invoke substantial intrigue or develop its mythos sufficiently. Nonetheless, the crescendo arrives in the third act, where intense action sequences elevate the viewing experience. Michael Bay’s production influence becomes evident as explosive battles, high-tech weaponry, and CGI spectacle ensue. Teresa Palmer’s introduction as Number Six injects fresh energy, culminating in a dynamic, albeit cartoonish, finale that offers some redemption from earlier lulls. While "I Am Number Four" ultimately feels more suited for episodic television than cinematic grandeur, younger audiences may find enough excitement within its flashy framework to overlook its structural flaws.
Total: 57
"I Am Number Four" is a moderately entertaining film that fails to live up to its intriguing premise. The narrative, while promising, feels rushed and underdeveloped, suggesting that the story might have been better suited to a television series format. Despite these shortcomings, the movie offers enough action and adventure to captivate its younger audience, particularly those who are fans of the source material. The performances from the cast and the script leave something to be desired, not fully capitalizing on the potential of the story.
On a technical front, Disney's Blu-ray release of "I Am Number Four" excels. The video and audio presentation are of exceptional quality, delivering a crisp and immersive viewing experience that meets the high standards of contemporary Blu-ray releases. However, the special features included in the Blu-ray package are sparse and lack depth, offering little in terms of behind-the-scenes insight or additional content that could enrich the viewing experience.
In conclusion, "I Am Number Four" is a film that might appeal more to younger audiences and fans of the original book, thanks to its engaging action sequences and solid AV presentation. However, it falls short in terms of storytelling and character development, making it better suited for a rental rather than a purchase. For those looking for high-quality video and audio, this Blu-ray is commendable, but the lack of substantial supplemental features is a notable drawback.
Blu-ray.com review by Kenneth BrownRead review here
Video: 80
Otherwise, fine textures are wonderfully refined, edge definition is crisp and clean, and most of the film's visual effects stand up nicely to high definition scrutiny....
Audio: 90
Rear speaker activity is fierce and vicious when it counts, ambience is enveloping and convincing, the subsequent soundfield is airtight on the whole, and a string of impressive directional effects are...
Extras: 40
Becoming Number Six (HD, 12 minutes): Number Six herself, actress Teresa Palmer, guides viewers through the stunts, powers, visual effects and attitude required to bring her feisty fighter to life on the...
Movie: 60
But until Caruso leads his hero through the requisite high school drama, bully showdowns and coming-of-age heart palpitations that litter I Am Number Four's first hour, it's all terribly uninteresting....
Total: 70
I Am Number Four isn't as compelling as its premise; it telegraphs too many punches, fumbles too many seemingly surefire ideas, and doesn't have the cast or script required to make the most out of its...
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 80
Contrast is pumped up, yellow and teal filters are used to give it that sleek, trendy appearance....
Audio: 80
Ambient sound engages the listener during the numerous battles as a cacophony of sounds permeate the rear channels....
Extras: 20
She talks about the physicality that went into the role and her character's hardened outlook....
Movie: 40
A movie that seemed rushed out in order to capitalize on a fanbase, and then ended the movie with the explicit idea of doing sequels that haven't even been green-lit yet....
Total: 60
Instead we're left with a mediocre action movie that promises sequels, and seeing as it made over $140 million worldwide, there's no reason why we shouldn't be seeing 'I Am Number Six,' 'Seven, ooh and...
AVSForumRead review here
Video: 88
The combination gives the image a dynamic enhanced quality that is occasionally distracting but rarely infringes upon fidelity....
Audio: 90
This is an active sound design that incorporates a vast number of sound effects that are intricately mixed to engage the listening position....
Extras: 40
(HD) 6 deleted scenes (including 1 extended scene) with director introduction (HD) Becoming Number six – 11 minute featurette with Teresa Palmer (HD) 3 minute blooper reel Bonus DVD of I am Number Four...
Movie: 50
In the small Ohio town he now calls home, John encounters unexpected, life-changing events-his first love (Agron), powerful new abilities and a connection to the others who share his incredible destiny....
Total: 67
THX Ultra 2 Preamp/Video Processor Sherbourn Technologies - 7/200 Seven Channel Amplifier Oppo BDP-93 Universal Disc/3D capable Blu-ray Player (HDMI Audio/Video)...
Why So Blu?Read review here
Video: 60
It was a black and blue blurry mess and all the drama of the scene is lost as you are trying to squint and decipher the images....
Audio: 80
As with most Michael Bay productions, you can crank up the volume and have the surround sound vibrate the room....
Extras: 40
Movie: 60
Four has spent his life just trying to blend in and be a normal teenager here on Earth but unfortunately for him, with the death of number three, a third scar is burned into his calf during a late night...
Total: 60
Director: D.J. Caruso
Actors: Alex Pettyfer, Timothy Olyphant, Dianna Agron
PlotA teenage boy named John Smith leads an unusual life, constantly moving from town to town with his guardian, Henri, to evade mysterious enemies. John is one of nine alien children who fled to Earth after their planet, Lorien, was destroyed by the deadly Mogadorians. Each of these children possesses unique abilities, referred to as Legacies. John is hiding his true identity and blending in as a normal high school student in Paradise, Ohio, but finds it increasingly difficult as his powers begin to manifest, attracting unwanted attention. As he tries to navigate teenage life, he befriends Sarah, a compassionate photographer, and Sam, an alien conspiracy theorist.
John learns more about his origins and the fate that awaits him while trying to prepare for an inevitable confrontation with the Mogadorians, who have already killed three of his fellow Loriens. As the threats grow closer, Henri and John struggle to stay one step ahead and protect each other. While adapting to his growing powers, John must decide whom he can trust, risking exposure and endangering those he cares about. The situation escalates as relentless pursuers close in, leaving John to face a critical choice that will determine the safety of not just himself, but the future of all the Loriens.
Writers: Alfred Gough, Miles Millar, Marti Noxon
Release Date: 18 Feb 2011
Runtime: 111 min
Rating: PG-13
Country: United States, India
Language: English, French