The Others Blu-ray Review
Score: 59
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
'The Others' offers a hauntingly atmospheric experience with stellar performances and a strong Blu-ray presentation, despite some image quality issues. Highly recommended.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 58
"The Others" Blu-ray impresses with its AVC encoded 1080p transfer, delivering atmospheric fog and mist with strong contrast and solid black levels despite occasional crush. The muted yet natural color palette and detailed set design shine through minor issues like dirt on the HD master and some banding.
Audio: 63
The Others' Blu-ray features a nuanced 5.1 DTS-HD MA soundtrack, masterfully balancing subtle ambient noises with dynamic orchestral crescendos. The audio design emphasizes clarity, crisp dialogue, and precise imaging, with sparing, yet effective LFE to create an immersive, atmospheric soundscape.
Extra: 46
The Blu-ray extras for 'The Others' include a somewhat sparse selection of features, with highlights such as an engaging profile on the Mahar family's struggle with Xeroderma Pigmentosum and an impressive visual effects piece showcasing the use of digital enhancements. Despite their age, these features offer insightful glimpses into the film's production.
Movie: 76
"The Others" excels as a Gothic, atmospheric thriller that eschews cheap scares in favor of a slow burn of eerie mood and tension, bolstered by Nicole Kidman's compelling performance, Amenábar's engaging direction, and standout cinematography by Javier Aguirresarobe. The Blu-ray presentation enhances this effect with excellent visual and auditory quality.
Video: 58
The Blu-ray release of "The Others" features an AVC encoded 1080p transfer presented in a 1.78:1 aspect ratio. The film, directed by Alejandro Amenábar, is rich in fog, mist, and an autumnal amber hue, all of which are effectively rendered in high definition. The misty ambience is well-preserved without devolving into digital noise. However, the film's inherent softness due to the overlay of haze is palpable but not unappealing. The mansion's cavernous and dimly lit interiors contribute to the film's moody atmosphere; nevertheless, the prevalent darkness results in significant black crush, causing heads to float if apparel is black and diminishing shadow details. Despite these drawbacks, the overall image quality is not problematic, lending a fittingly ghostly aura to the storyline.
In its Blu-ray debut, "The Others" employs a 1080p/AVC MPEG-4 encode framed in its original 1.85:1 aspect ratio. The presentation highlights abundant resolution, enriching viewers' experience of the film’s atmospheric set design. Notably, despite the plot's affinity for shadowy settings often lit by candlelight, the contrast remains near reference quality with deep, inky blacks and discernible shadow details sans banding. The film's muted color palette manages to maintain even and natural skin tones. On the downside, the HD Master reveals some dirt on the print and/or negative, which intermittently disrupts the visual experience. Additionally, minor banding and macro-blocking are observable in exterior fog scenes and in the new Miramax logo. Despite these issues, "The Others" remains authentic to its theatrical roots and surpasses the decade-old DVD release significantly in terms of clarity and brightness.
Audio: 63
The audio presentation of "The Others" on Blu-ray showcases a masterfully crafted sound design, utilizing a lossless DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 mix. The soundscape stands out for its focus on subtler auditory elements, eschewing traditional horror tropes like overpowering jump scares. Instead, the track features subliminally disturbing effects and nuanced ambient noises that envelop the viewer. Audio fidelity is consistently impressive, with crystal-clear dialogue and a dynamic range that adeptly handles everything from almost inaudible whispers to piercing screams.
The sound direction in "The Others" adds a profound layer to the film's eerie atmosphere. Environmental sounds like distant voices and wind contribute to a growing sense of unease, meticulously captured in full resolution. Director-composer Alejandro Amenábar’s score, reminiscent of Bernard Herman's iconic compositions, enhances this tension through superb imaging and directionality. The delicate balance of quieter passages and occasional louder moments, supported by judicious LFE usage, ensures that the audio landscape is immersive and cohesive.
Overall, the DTS-HD MA soundtrack of "The Others" aligns expertly with the film’s pacing and mood. It starts with understated quietude, gradually building towards an intense, gothic crescendo, echoing the film's narrative structure. This seamless integration of sound elevates the horror experience, illustrating what surround sound should accomplish in a well-crafted thriller.
Extras: 46
The Blu-ray extras of "The Others" offer a comprehensive and insightful array of behind-the-scenes content that complements the film's eerie atmosphere. Key highlights include an informative profile on Xeroderma Pigmentosum, providing a real-world context to the film's plot. The included making-of documentary, "A Look Inside The Others," though somewhat heavy on movie clips, features engaging interviews with Nicole Kidman, the principal cast, and director Alejandro Amenábar. A visually enlightening segment on the film's visual effects uncovers the technical wizardry behind its atmospheric scenes. Additionally, an intimate profile of Amenábar himself provides valuable insights into his directorial process. Despite the extras being in standard definition and a bit dated, they offer valuable historical and technical perspectives.
Extras included in this disc:
- Xeroderma Pigmentosum: What Is It?: The story of a family dealing with the disease.
- A Look Inside The Others: Interviews with cast and crew.
- Visual Effects Piece: Split screen look at visual effects.
- An Intimate Look at Director Alejandro Amenábar: Profile of the writer-director.
- Theatrical Trailer: Iconic film trailer.
Movie: 76
Alejandro Amenábar’s "The Others," starring Nicole Kidman, is a 2001 film that consistently manages to captivate and unsettle audiences. Set on the Channel Islands post-World War II, the story centrally follows Grace (Kidman) and her two children, Anne (Alakina Mann) and Nicholas (James Bentley), both of whom suffer from xeroderma pigmentosum, a rare disease that necessitates complete darkness. The film’s atmosphere is deeply Gothic, invoking classics such as Henry James' "The Turn of the Screw." What stands out is its blend of eerie, understated horror and psychological tension. Despite predictable plot elements for seasoned viewers, the movie’s richly crafted environment and detailed character interactions maintain its haunting effect. Grace's paranoia intensifies as inexplicable events unfold, supported by strong performances from Fionnula Flanagan and Eric Sykes as the enigmatic house staff.
"The Others" excels as a slow-burn horror that leverages traditional yet effective devices like disembodied voices, creaking doors, and mysterious apparitions. This approach avoids cheap jump scares in favor of building a persistent, creeping tension. The film's visual aesthetic, realized by cinematographer Javier Aguirresarobe, envelops the audience in a world shrouded in fog and muted tones, amplifying its unsettling nature. Amenábar's direction is both intentional and fluid, with his camera work augmenting scene dynamics and pace. Nicole Kidman delivers a compelling performance as Grace, a character teetering on the edge of sanity whose iciness and vulnerability engage the viewer. The children’s performances are equally competent, adding depth without resorting to overacting.
"The Others" is emblematic of masterful horror storytelling that eschews modern, fast-paced trends. It relies instead on atmosphere, character nuance, and a well-developed plot to sustain its palpable tension. The film remains impactful upon repeated viewings, offering a timeless appeal that resonates especially with fans of classic horror cinematography and storytelling.
Total: 59
"The Others" delivers a masterclass in atmospheric tension, deftly crafted by director Alejandro Amenábar. This gothic ghost story stands out due to its exceptional performances, with Nicole Kidman and the supporting cast bringing haunting nuances to their roles. The film's strength lies in its moody, spooky ambiance and the subtle build-up of suspense rather than relying on climactic twists. Despite a potentially disorienting third-act development with the return of the missing father-husband, it remains a compelling thriller that sustains interest across multiple viewings—a rare feat for films of this genre.
Technically, the Blu-ray release is a worthwhile acquisition for fans and new viewers alike. The audio presentation is robust, enhancing the eerie atmosphere, and the video transfer, though slightly marred by minor dust issues, is solid overall. These technical merits, combined with the film’s gripping narrative and emotional depth, make this Blu-ray edition a valuable addition for collectors and enthusiasts of intelligent horror.
In conclusion, "The Others" transcends the typical horror fare through its masterful direction and stellar performances, ensuring it remains an impressive thriller. Despite minor image quality issues, the Blu-ray offers a commendable presentation. Recommended for those seeking a sophisticated and chilling cinematic experience.
Blu-ray.com review by Jeffrey KauffmanRead review here
Video: 70
A lot of this film takes place in the cavernous rooms of the mansion, which is of course kept near blackness due to the children's condition, and while the Blu-ray supports fairly solid black levels, crush...
Audio: 80
There are a couple of loud moments, to be sure, and the DTS track supports them with boisterous LFE, but on the whole, this is a more nuanced track that allows nice ambient environmental noises to populate...
Extras: 40
The Story of a Family Dealing with the Disease (SD; 8:57) is a fascinating profile of the Mahar family, whose daughter is one of the incredibly few people worldwide who suffers from XP, the allergy to...
Movie: 80
Mrs. Mills and Mr. Tuttle seems to be strangely cognizant of events that are impacting Grace and her children, and with a series of things that go bump in the night and other apparitions, Grace descends...
Total: 80
The film makes a potentially disastrous misstep in its third act with the introduction of the missing father-husband, but otherwise this is an impressive thriller that holds up to repeated viewings, something...
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 80
While there was no banding in the shadows, I did note minor banding and macro-blocking in the exterior fog-drenched sequences as well as in the new Miramax logo which precedes the film....
Audio: 80
Imaging and directionality are superb, and the dialog is always audible (well, if the character is actually speaking in the same room as the camera)....
Extras: 60
Another fine piece, where a family with a child suffering from the real version of the disease tell their story....
Movie: 80
Grace's house staff just quit for reasons unknown, and the children have an incurable disease preventing them from encountering daylight....
Total: 80
If you're new to 'The Others' and appreciate creepy, intelligent, emotional horror films, don't read any more about the film, check it out as soon as possible....
Director: Alejandro Amenábar
Actors: Nicole Kidman, Christopher Eccleston, Fionnula Flanagan
PlotIn the aftermath of World War II, Grace Stewart lives with her two photosensitive children, Anne and Nicholas, in a remote country house on the Channel Island of Jersey. The children's ailment prevents them from being exposed to natural light, compelling Grace to establish strict rules: no open doors, no forgotten curtains, and only lamplight during the day. Their quiet lives are disrupted when Grace hires a trio of new servants – Mrs. Bertha Mills, Mr. Edmund Tuttle, and a mute girl named Lydia, to help run the house after the unexplained disappearance of the previous staff.
Tensions escalate when mysterious occurrences begin to unravel the fabric of their secluded existence. Anne claims to see strange apparitions and persistently shares stories of her encounters with 'the others,' which Grace initially dismisses as a child's imagination. Yet, as unaccountable noises, inexplicable shifts in the house's state, and the children's increasing agitation persist, Grace begins to confront the possibility that their home may be inhabited by unseen entities. With events becoming progressively more unsettling and the fog-shrouded house growing ever claustrophobic, Grace's skepticism turns to desperation, compelling her to investigate the haunting mysteries that engulf her isolated abode.
Writers: Alejandro Amenábar
Release Date: 10 Aug 2001
Runtime: 104 min
Rating: PG-13
Country: Spain, United States, France, Italy
Language: English