The Visitor Blu-ray Review
Score: 52
from 3 reviewers
Review Date:
The Visitor offers profound storytelling with stellar acting, leaving a lasting impact despite its modest Blu-ray features.
Disc Release Date
Video: 61
The Visitor's Blu-ray transfer excels with naturally pleasing colors, sharp details, and consistent quality, despite minor speckles and soft shots, making it a visually engaging experience.
Audio: 44
The Visitor combines visually pleasing imagery with a conservative palette and detailed textures, while its PCM 5.1 soundtrack delivers clear dialogue and music, focusing on front channels with minimal rear channel use, fitting the film's dialogue-driven nature.
Extra: 33
The Visitor's Blu-ray boosts insights with McCarthy and Jenkins' relaxed yet detailed commentary, an intriguing look at the Djembe, and modest extras capturing the film’s essence and challenges, albeit in brief glimpses.
Movie: 83
The Visitor poignantly explores connection, change, and the human cost of immigration through a moving tale of friendship and rediscovery.
Video: 61
"The Visitor" arrives on Blu-ray featuring a commendable 1080p transfer that showcases the film’s modest yet effective visual design. Colors across the spectrum are rendered with natural tones, with a conservative and sometimes drab palette that never diminishes the visual experience. Instead, it highlights the film's intentional aesthetic choices, from the subdued lighting schemes to the lifelike flesh tones. The presentation strikes a balance by ensuring that primaries pop in brighter scenes, maintaining a sense of visual fidelity that enhances the realism of both characters and settings. Detail is meticulously captured, from the nuanced environments such as Vale's cluttered office and cozy kitchen to the subtle textures of skin and fabric, presenting a high-definition viewing experience that is both sharp and clear. While there are minor speckles and occasional soft shots, these are largely true to the original print and do not detract from the overall quality of the transfer.
The video's technical prowess is further exemplified by its contrast levels, which steer clear of blowing out whites or muddying blacks, ensuring that even in dimly lit scenes, viewers can discern the smallest of details. Although the film retains a natural grain, particularly noticeable in darker sequences, it does so without succumbing to noise or other distracting artifacts. This careful handling underscores the transfer’s commitment to authenticity, avoiding unnecessary digital enhancements that could compromise the film’s visual integrity. The aspect ratio has been correctly framed at 1.85:1 despite a misprint on the release cover, preserving the director's vision without compromising the image's composition.
Overall, the Blu-ray presentation of "The Visitor" offers a technically sound and visually engaging experience. With its stable color reproduction, excellent detail across both foreground and background, and a disciplined approach to grain and contrast, this release successfully elevates the material beyond its DVD counterpart. Its deliberate visual cues—from the intentionally muted color scheme to the accurate flesh tones—work in harmony to create an image that is as compelling as it is technically proficient. Despite some minor flaws inherited from the source material and occasional inconsistencies in sharpness, this transfer stands as a testament to the film's nuanced aesthetic, making "The Visitor" a worthy addition to any Blu-ray library.
Audio: 44
The audio presentation of "The Visitor" on Blu Ray offers a respectable acoustic experience, primarily showcasing its strength through a PCM 5.1 uncompressed soundtrack that eloquently supports this dialogue-driven film. While not constructed as an auditory spectacle, the clarity and precision of dialogue stand out, alongside the spirited representation of the Djembe beats and musical elements that punctuate the film's score. These components are delivered with a warm, room-filling sound, focusing heavily on the front channels but not completely neglecting the rear, especially in scenes where the ambient contribution of Walter's apartment and other key locations add a subtle but appreciated layer to the soundscape.
Despite the film's reserved approach to sound, there is an evident effort to ensure the audio quality surpasses expectations for what could have been merely functional. The LFE channel provides enough punch to enrich the musical moments without overwhelming, and the mix's naturalism is commendable, particularly in how it handles indoor environments with acuity. The rears, although not extensively engaged, complement the front-heavy mix by enhancing specific atmospheric moments, such as the echoes in a detention center, without introducing unwanted artifacts like hissing or pops, maintaining a clean and immersive listening experience.
In summary, "The Visitor" does not aim to impress with its sonic depth but rather to uphold the film's intimate and personal narrative with an audio track that respects its source material. The precise and sharp dialogue, combined with a judiciously used soundtrack and effective ambient sounds, create an audio presentation that, while not groundbreaking, is executed with an attention to detail that fans and audiophiles will appreciate for its fidelity and restraint.
Extra: 33
The extra presentation of the Blu-ray edition of "The Visitor" is a modest yet insightful collection that provides viewers with a closer look at the making of the film and its thematic elements. Notably, the audio commentary by writer/director Thomas McCarthy and actor Richard Jenkins stands out as a relaxed yet informative session, delving into various aspects of the filmmaking process, despite Jenkins' occasional silences. The featurette "Playing the Djembe" exceeds expectations, offering an engaging exploration of the film's central musical element, while "An Inside Look at 'The Visitor'" provides basic but enjoyable insights into its themes and storyline. The deleted scenes, presented with optional commentary, reveal thoughtful character developments and filming decisions, complemented by the inclusion of the theatrical trailer. Although the extras package might seem slim, it enriches the viewing experience with meaningful content and behind-the-scenes perspectives.
Extras included in this disc:
- Audio commentary with Director/Writer Tom McCarthy: A highlight of the supplements featuring discussions on film pace, tone, and obstacles during shooting.
- Playing the Djembe: A detailed look into the West African instrument prominent in the film.
- An Inside Look at The Visitor: Cast and crew share insights on the film's themes and storyline.
- 4 Deleted Scenes with Optional Commentary: Featuring actor Richard Jenkins and Director Tom McCarthy providing context and reasoning behind each scene.
- Theatrical Trailer: The original trailer for the film.
Movie: 83
"The Visitor," directed by Thomas McCarthy and anchored by a subdued yet powerful performance from Richard Jenkins, unfurls the story of Walter Vale, a widowed college professor whose mundane life gains unexpected depth and purpose through his interactions with a young couple squatting in his New York apartment. Jenkins' portrayal of Vale, a man rediscovering his capacity for compassion and human connection, is a career-highlight, showcasing his ability to carry a film with the nuanced subtlety of his performance. This narrative, grounded firmly in the realities of modern life yet punctuated with moments of profound personal discovery, challenges the viewer with questions of identity, belonging, and the transformative power of empathy.
The synergy between Jenkins and his co-stars, particularly Haaz Sleiman and Danai Jekesai Gurira, lends authenticity to the film's exploration of cross-cultural friendship and shared humanity. McCarthy's direction skilfully balances the film's understated political undertones with its core humanistic themes, avoiding overt partisanship to instead focus on the personal tales within the broader immigration narrative. Such an approach does not simplify the complex issues at hand but rather enriches the film's texture, inviting viewers to ponder the intricacies of the characters' intertwined lives. The cinematography and musical score complement the storytelling, enhancing the film's emotional landscape and reinforcing its central motifs of loss, discovery, and renewal.
At its heart, "The Visitor" is an intimate narrative of reawakening and solidarity amidst the backdrop of New York's multicultural landscape. The film deftly navigates the territory of friendship and societal commentary, reminding us of cinema's power to reflect and shape our understanding of community and self. McCarthy’s craft in storytelling, combined with Jenkins’ compelling lead performance and the richly drawn supporting characters, creates a poignant cinematic experience that resonates on multiple levels, leaving a lasting impression on its audience.
Total: 52
In this review, we delve into the Blu-ray presentation of "The Visitor," a film lauded for its profound storytelling and remarkable performances, particularly by Richard Jenkins. This subtle yet powerful drama has been well-received for its thoughtful exploration of themes such as friendship, humanity, and the struggles of illegal immigrants. The technical aspects of the Blu-ray are scrutinized using an array of high-grade equipment, including JVC DLA-RS1x 1080p High Definition Front Projector and a variety of players like the Oppo 970HD, Toshiba HD-XA2, Panasonic DMP-BD30, and the Sony Playstation 3, among others. The audio and visual output was enhanced through devices such as the Marantz DV7001, Denon AVR 5308CI, and an array of amplifiers and speakers from brands like Outlaw Audio and Canton Ergo. The overall technical setup aimed to provide an encompassing review of the Blu-ray’s delivery.
The Blu-ray version of "The Visitor" brings to light the film’s intentional narrative choice, leaving viewers with an open ending that encourages personal reflection on the fate of its characters. Despite the film’s impactful storyline and stellar acting, the Blu-ray package itself is considered average by technical standards. With a respectable video transfer and a PCM soundtrack that fits well with the movie's tone, the extras included are modest. While the technical merits are not groundbreaking, they do not detract from the film's ability to engage and provoke thought on significant social issues.
In conclusion, while "The Visitor" Blu-ray may not dazzle with supplemental features or the most advanced technical specs, it stands as a necessary addition to the collection of anyone who values cinema that challenges and reflects on real-world issues. The film's emotional depth and the social commentary it presents more than compensate for any lack of technical spectacle. Its average technical presentation does little to hinder the film's lasting impact, making it a recommended acquisition for those who appreciate films that compel viewers to confront their perspectives on humanity and social justice.
Blu-ray.com review by Martin LiebmanRead review here
Video: 80
The transfer never backs away from being sharp and clear, with nice attention to every detail both in the foreground and in the background, where the image rarely goes soft....
Audio: 60
Extras: 40
McCarthy discusses the importance of the "pace and tone" of the film, some of the obstacles to shooting (such as a parade of trick-or-treaters interfering with some shots), the film's set design, and more....
Movie: 90
Walter is not a happy-go-lucky, life-of-the-party type; he's the very definition of a loner, and the story only works thanks to the film's brilliant portrayal of his character's progression from loner...
Total: 70
The Visitor is simple yet powerful filmmaking at its finest, telling a tale that yearns to be told, but also one that many viewers may greet in a myriad of ways....
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 80
The transfer’s realistic textures aren’t hindered by the film’s light grain field, edges are crisp and nicely defined without relying on edge enhancement or other artificial nonsense, and both fine detailing...
Audio: 60
Dialogue is crisp and perfectly prioritized, the LFE channel is aggressive enough to make the djembes sound fantastic, and the entire soundscape demonstrates impeccable naturalism....
Extras: 20
Aside from too many silent pauses, the track gives the candid filmmaker the opportunity to talk about the challenges of a smaller film, his limited budget, as well as the research and authenticity they...
Movie: 100
All of the elements are there -- Walter and Mouna could easily fall in love and ride off into the sunset, Tarek could simply rely on Walter’s connections to get out of prison, everything could end on a...
Total: 60
The Blu-ray edition doesn’t hit with the same impact as the film itself, but it still delivers a technically proficient package that features an excellent video transfer, a faithful uncompressed audio...
AVSForumRead review here
Video: 82
This is nice looking video presentation that features colors that are naturally pleasing with a conservative palette and bland textures....
Audio: 72
This is nice looking video presentation that features colors that are naturally pleasing with a conservative palette and bland textures....
Extras: 50
An inside look at The Visitor featurette 4 deleted scenes with optional commentary featuring Actor Richard Jenkins and Director Tom McCarthy Theatrical trailer...
Movie: 70
When, in a chance encounter on a trip into New York, Walter discovers a couple has taken up residence in his apartment in the city, he develops an unexpected and profound connection to them that will change...
Total: 69
Marantz DV7001 Universal Disc Player Denon AVR 5308CI THX Ultra 2 Preamp/Video Processor Outlaw Audio Model 7700 seven channel amplifier B&K Reference 200.7 Series 2 seven Channel amplifier Canton "Ergo"...
Director: Tom McCarthy
Actors: Richard Jenkins, Haaz Sleiman, Danai Gurira
PlotA lonely widower and economics professor, Walter Vale, discovers an unexpected new lease on life through his mundane trip to New York City. Intending to reluctantly attend a conference, he arrives at his seldom-used apartment to find it already occupied by Tarek and Zainab, a young immigrant couple scammed into believing they were renting the apartment legally. Taken aback by this surprise, Walter's initial impulse to turn them away quickly softens, leading him to allow them to stay with him. Through this unexpected cohabitation, Walter is introduced to the vibrant and complex world of New York's immigrant community, which contrasts sharply with his previously insular and monotonous life.
As Walter becomes increasingly involved in the lives of Tarek, a Syrian drummer, and Zainab, a Senegalese jewelry maker, he forms an unlikely friendship that deeply affects him. Tarek introduces Walter to the joy of playing the djembe, an experience that rekindles Walter's long-dormant passion for life and music. However, the trio's newfound harmony is threatened when Tarek faces a sudden, serious issue, compelling Walter to confront his own feelings of empathy, responsibility, and the complex realities of immigration and cultural integration in contemporary America. This experience challenges Walter to step out of his comfort zone and advocate for his new friends, which ultimately leads to transformative personal growth and an awakening to the world's larger issues beyond his academic bubble.
Writers: Tom McCarthy
Release Date: 23 May 2008
Runtime: 104 min
Rating: PG-13
Country: United States
Language: English, French, Arabic, Romanian