A Man for All Seasons Blu-ray Review

"A Man for All Seasons" is presented on Blu-ray with an impressive AVC encoded 1080p transfer in a 1.66:1 aspect ratio, courtesy of Sony-Columbia. This rendition utilizes a sparkling 4K scan, often showcasing immaculately well-detailed and beautifully organic cinematography. Ted Moore's Academy Award-winning work is preserved with deep, burnished tones that enhance the film’s visual texture. The interiors reverberate with rich burnt umber hues, while costumes and furniture exhibit striking pops of color. The increased resolution over previous DVD releases is palpable, especially in the finer details of fabrics and wall paneling. Shadow detail also holds up remarkably well in the film's often shrouded interior scenes, maintaining a natural grain structure.

However, certain technical anomalies detract from an otherwise stellar presentation. There are intermittent moments of fuzziness and a somewhat unkempt grain field, particularly noticeable in a few scenes. The overall color palette can veer towards brown, occasionally rendering flesh tones muddy. Most notably, the presence of halos in the optically printed credits sequence and some other scenes undermines the remarkable clarity expected from a 4K restoration. These halos, also apparent on the previous DVD release, become unignorable on large format systems. Despite these issues, the bulk of the transfer remains impressive, with sharp detail and deep black levels contributing to an immersive experience for the discerning videophile.

The Blu-ray audio presentation of "A Man for All Seasons" employs a DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 mix, providing a refined auditory experience that excels in both clarity and immersion. Discrete ambient environmental effects are subtly placed in the surrounds, contributing to an atmospheric but understated backdrop. Dialogue, a crucial component of this dialogue-heavy film, remains firmly anchored front and center, ensuring that Bolt's nuanced script is both clear and pristine throughout the runtime.

Georges Delerue's score is a highlight, weaving through the surrounds with finesse, enhancing the narrative without overpowering dialogue or sound effects. This is a testament to the effective prioritization within the mix. Fidelity and dynamic range are commendable, with a robust LFE enhancing the overall presence of the audio. Although the dynamic range has limitations in the context of this largely talk-driven film, it maintains an impressive balance that suits the movie’s needs.

In essence, while "A Man for All Seasons" may not deliver explosive audio moments, its DTS-HD MA 5.1 mix offers an engaging and professionally balanced listening experience that complements its historical and dramatic tones perfectly.

The Blu Ray extras for "A Man for All Seasons" offer a comprehensive and informative look into the film's production and its historical context. The audio commentary by Lem Dobbs, Nick Redman, and Julie Kirgo provides insightful discussions on the film's creation and director Fred Zinneman's career. "The Life of St. Thomas More" documentary, although ported from DVD and in 480i resolution, features valuable interviews detailing Thomas More's significant historical influence. The isolated score track in DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0 allows an immersive experience of the film's soundtrack. Lastly, the original theatrical trailer gives a nostalgic post-Oscars promotional glimpse.

Extras included in this disc:

• Original Theatrical Trailer: Post-Oscars promotional trailer.
• The Life of St. Thomas More: Interviews discussing Thomas More's life and cultural impact.
• Audio Commentary: Insights from Lem Dobbs, Nick Redman, and Julie Kirgo on the film's production and Fred Zinneman's career.
• Isolated Score Track: Film audio with only the score in DTS-HD MA 2.0 stereo sound.

"A Man for All Seasons" is a masterclass in screenwriting and historical drama. Directed by the legendary Fred Zinnemann, who holds an astounding 65 Oscar nominations and 24 wins, this film sets a high bar for period pieces. Robert Bolt’s meticulously crafted screenplay delves into the nuanced political and religious tensions of King Henry VIII's court, primarily focusing on Sir Thomas More, portrayed by Paul Scofield. More’s unwavering moral conviction in the face of royal pressure provides a compelling counterpoint to Henry’s brutal quest for a male heir.

The film begins with England at a critical juncture, as Henry (Robert Shaw) seeks to annul his marriage to Catherine of Aragon to marry Anne Boleyn (Vanessa Redgrave). This incites a cascade of conflict, crucially involving Cardinal Wolsey (Orson Welles) and Sir Thomas More. The stakes are escalated not just by More's personal beliefs but by their broader implications for church-state relations. More’s steadfast loyalty to the Pope sets him squarely against Henry’s ambitions, morphing what starts as a domestic squabble into a theological and political showdown.

Despite its dense subject matter, "A Man for All Seasons" remains engaging, thanks in large measure to Bolt’s articulate and emotionally resonant script. The interplay between More and his family, especially his conversations with his wife Alice (Wendy Hiller) and daughter Margaret (Susannah York), humanizes the narrative. The film sustains its tension through intellectual sparring and moral dilemmas, never devolving into tedious courtroom drama.

The performances are exceptional across the board. Scofield’s portrayal of More is both magnetizing and profound, offering a moral steadfastness that anchors the film. Shaw brings an athletic and intimidating presence to Henry, making the monarch’s demands palpable. Supporting characters like Leo McKern’s scheming Cromwell and John Hurt’s ambitious Richard Rich add layers of intrigue. Zinnemann’s assured direction ensures that every frame contributes to a cohesive and impactful storytelling experience.

Overall, "A Man for All Seasons" is not only an accomplished historical drama but also a profound exploration of integrity, power, and the perennial conflict between temporal authority and spiritual conviction.

A Man for All Seasons has had a rather unfortunate life on home video, especially for such an iconic, well-regarded film, not to mention one that won Best Picture at the Academy Awards (one might perhaps have to defer only to Marty to find a similarly disrespected item). While there are some issues persnickety videophiles (and you know who you are) will want to be aware of, this new Blu-ray of A Man for All Seasons is a generally very pleasing release which offers this beautiful, provocative and challenging film in an appealingly organic-looking presentation. Highly recommended.

Twilight Time has knocked 'A Man For All Seasons' out of the park with this glorious video and audio transfer. This is the best the film has looked since it came out all those years ago. The performances and set pieces still hold up today The extras are worth watching as well, making this excellent Twilight Time release HIGHLY RECOMMENDED!

Twilight Time’s Blu-ray release of "A Man for All Seasons" stands as the most distinguished video and audio presentation of this classic film to date. The transfer exquisitely captures the film’s visual grandeur and presents it with a striking, organic quality that has been missing in previous releases. Although purists may find slight imperfections upon close examination, the overall visual experience invites viewers to appreciate the film with renewed admiration. The restoration effort faithfully upholds the director’s intent while enhancing the color fidelity and sharpness without compromising the film’s original texture.

Audio-wise, this release shines with impeccable clarity, breathing new life into the film’s performances and intricate set pieces. The original soundscape has been preserved deftly, allowing poignant dialogues and the stirring score to resonate deeply. Furthermore, the supplemental materials included in this release enrich the viewing experience, offering insightful perspectives on the film’s production, historical context, and enduring impact.

In conclusion, this Twilight Time Blu-ray release of "A Man for All Seasons" is a triumph in home media restoration. It delivers an experience that both newcomers and long-time admirers will find deeply gratifying. The amalgamation of stunning video quality, remarkable audio enhancement, and valuable extras make this edition highly recommended for any serious collector or cinephile.