Dolphin Tale Blu-ray Review
Score: 69
from 3 reviewers
Review Date:
The film may lack inspiration, but Warner's 3D Blu-ray excels with near-perfect visuals and immersive audio, making it the preferred edition for family enjoyment.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 70
Dolphin Tale's Blu-ray features both 2D and native 3D versions shot with 2K Red One cameras, offering exceptional depth, sharp detail, and natural colors. The 1080p transfer maintains a film-like quality with accurate color timing, deep blacks, and minimal crosstalk or artifacts, making the 3D experience immersive and unobtrusive.
Audio: 67
The DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 soundtrack on the Dolphin Tale Blu-ray is competent yet front-heavy, with well-recorded dialogue and score, minimal LFE and surrounds, and notable underwater immersiveness. It complements the family film's heartwarming nature but misses broader soundstage opportunities.
Extra: 70
The Blu-ray extras for 'Dolphin Tale' offer a variety of content, from an informative featurette on Winter's real-life inspiration and interactions with disabled visitors, to a detailed breakdown of the movie's opening sequence's digital effects, although some content like 'The Hutash Rainbow Bridge' and 'Winter Meets Panama' may seem superfluous.
Movie: 70
Dolphin Tale's Blu-ray offers a touching, family-friendly story with great image quality, presented in both 2D and native 3D, although the 3D feels somewhat gimmicky. The DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1-channel soundtrack is front-heavy, focusing on dialogue and score, while special features include an insightful documentary on the real Winter.
Video: 70
The 1080p/24 Blu-ray release of "Dolphin Tale" is commendable in its technical prowess, making it a visually engaging film for both 2D and 3D viewers. Shot in native 3D using dual Red One cameras with Paradise FX 3D Rigs, the video transfer leverages a 2K digital intermediate, ensuring that both the 2D and 3D versions maintain an impressive visual quality. The 2D transfer, encoded using AVC, showcases a clean print with no banding or compression artifacts, offering deep blacks and substantial shadow detail. The dynamic range is notable, with stark contrasts and a well-delineated color palette dominated by soothing blues. The fine layer of grain added in post-production augments the film-like quality, creating a visually pleasing experience on screen.
The 3D Blu-ray, encoded using MVC, further elevates the viewing experience, making "Dolphin Tale" one of the standout live-action 3D presentations of the year. The meticulous composition for 3D results in an image that offers subtle yet effective depth, particularly beneficial in underwater scenes where dimensionality is accentuated. The film's brighter scenes allow for solid visual penetration without succumbing to darkness when viewed through 3D glasses. This translates to rich visuals with enhanced detail, vibrant colors, and lifelike skin tones. Issues like crosstalk are virtually non-existent, ensuring a smooth and immersive viewing experience.
Overall, the technical execution of the video presentation upholds a high standard, employing excellent encoding techniques that result in a pristine quality devoid of anomalies such as artifacting, banding, or aliasing. While minor instances of softness and crush exist, they do not significantly detract from the remarkable quality of the 3D render. "Dolphin Tale" offers a stunning visual treat that leverages its native 3D roots to provide an engrossing, cinematic experience.
Audio: 67
The Blu-ray of "Dolphin Tale" features a DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 surround track that is consistently front-heavy, reflecting the nature of this heartwarming family film. While the audio mix avoids dramatic pyrotechnics, it excels in delivering clear, intelligible dialogue anchored to the center channel. The soundtrack effectively integrates a combination of production sound and ADR, enhancing spatial integration. The score, primarily composed by Mark Isham, is well-recorded and full of fidelity, adding significant depth to the overall auditory experience. Although the use of LFE and surround channels is minimal, the occasional directional effects and convincing aquatic ambience, such as waves and water ripples, do create an immersive soundfield when required.
Warner's DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 track is also notable for its atmospheric elements, including convincing water tank acoustics and underwater immersiveness. The audio design, while not overly dynamic, achieves a smooth and absorbing auditory environment. The LFE channel supports the score effectively, although bass enthusiasts might find it underutilized in scenes absent of explosive effects. Given the film's dialogue-driven nature, the mix prioritizes clarity and intelligibility of voices, ensuring that every line is bright and serviceable. While it may not make a huge sonic splash like action blockbusters, Dolphin Tale's audio presentation stands out for its clear portrayal of the sounds suited to its thematic narrative.
Extras: 70
The Blu-ray release of "Dolphin Tale" offers a comprehensive range of special features on its 2D disc that enrich the viewing experience. The extras include engaging behind-the-scenes looks, informative featurettes, and light-hearted shorts, all presented in high definition. For a film centered on both human and animal narratives, these bonus materials provide substantial context and depth. The technical quality of each featurette is commendable, though some aspects, such as the animation quality in "The Hutash Rainbow Bridge" and the CGI in "Spotlight on a Scene," may not impress all viewers. Nonetheless, the real highlight is "Winter’s Inspiration," which offers an authentic look at Winter's journey, enhancing the film's emotional resonance.
Extras included in this disc:
The Hutash Rainbow Bridge: A brief animated story based on a Native American legend.
At Home With Winter: Behind-the-scenes featurette, focusing on the real Winter.
Dolphin Tale: Spotlight On A Scene: Insight into the CGI creation of the opening sequence.
Winter's Inspiration: Documentary on Winter’s real-life rescue and recovery.
Ormie and the Cookie Jar: An unrelated animated short about a pig and a cookie jar.
Winter Meets Panama: A deleted scene with another rescued dolphin, Panama.
Gag Reel: Collection of humorous outtakes.
Movie: 70
"Dolphin Tale" is a heartwarming cinematic experience that revives the charm of old-fashioned filmmaking, tailored for both 2D and native 3D viewers. The 1080p/24 Blu-ray showcases excellent image quality across both formats, utilizing dual Red One cameras at a 2K resolution, which are nicely framed at a 1.85:1 aspect ratio and encoded with AVC for 2D and MVC for 3D versions. While the 3D element may appear gratuitous to some, it remarkably complements the film's bright lighting scheme, rendering delightful depth and clarity to its visuals. This attentive craftsmanship enhances the immersive quality of the true story of Winter, the resilient dolphin.
Acoustically, the Blu-ray's DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1-channel soundtrack adopts a more subdued approach, fitting the family drama genre's expectations. The audio experience is front-heavy, focusing primarily on clear dialogue and an emotive score with minimal low-frequency effects. Sparse ambient sounds sporadically activate the surround channels but do so without overwhelming the primary narrative focus. This restrained audio design works beautifully to maintain the film’s emotional impact without unnecessary distractions.
The storyline, inspired by true events, centers around Sawyer, a young boy who discovers an injured dolphin named Winter. Alongside a compassionate marine biologist and a dedicated prosthetist, Sawyer’s determination to help Winter overcome her physical challenges forms the core of this touching narrative. Despite its familiar structure and somewhat fabricated interpersonal dynamics, the film’s earnest performances, especially from its young lead Nathan Gamble and supporting cast including Harry Connick Jr. and Morgan Freeman, imbue it with genuine warmth and appeal. Ultimately, the film’s message of hope and resilience resonates deeply, making "Dolphin Tale" a moving family-friendly feature that stands out within its genre.
Total: 69
"Dolphin Tale" isn't nearly as inspiring as the true story it is based on, yet it represents an engaging and emotionally sincere family film. Warner's 3D Blu-ray release is notably impressive, delivering a natively shot 3D experience that is remarkable in clarity and depth. The video transfer achieves near perfection, reflecting keen attention to visual quality. Meanwhile, the DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 surround track provides an immersive sonic environment, enhancing the overall viewing experience. The supplementary package offers a range of additional content that will engage viewers of all ages, making this edition a comprehensive release.
The technical execution of this Blu-ray release excels across various dimensions. The high-definition visuals are pristine, with the 3D presentation adding a vital dimensionality that elevates the narrative. Audio-wise, the DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 track ensures a rich, immersive soundscape that complements the film's emotional weight and engaging storyline. Such technical prowess contributes significantly to the viewer's experience, ensuring that even an otherwise conventional family film can feel momentously uplifting.
In conclusion, while "Dolphin Tale" as a film might not be groundbreaking, Warner's 3D Blu-ray release certainly enhances its appeal. The exceptional video quality, enveloping audio track, and engaging supplemental content combine to provide an immersive and enjoyable viewing experience for the entire family. This release exemplifies how superior technical execution can elevate a film beyond its inherent limitations, making it a worthwhile addition to any collection.
avforums review by Steve WithersRead review here
Video: 80
The composition for 3D is superb with the stereographer and cinematographer making effective use of the added depth to frame their shots....
Audio: 70
The dialogue is always intelligible, remaining firmly anchored to the centre speaker and as is often the case, the dialogue is a combination of production sound and ADR but the two have been skillfully...
Extras: 60
At Home With Winter (13:22, HD) - This is a short behind the scenes look at the film that focuses on the real Winter playing herself and includes interviews with the principal cast, talking about what...
Movie: 80
Whilst the use of 3D is hardly vital to the story and does rather feel like a gimmick, the good news is that the native 3D is great and the film’s bright lighting scheme really lends itself to the format....
Total: 80
Blu-ray.com review by Kenneth BrownRead review here
Video: 90
The benefits of shooting the film, any film really, in native 3D are numerous, and each one is showcased here: natural, innate and infinite 3D reference points, a brighter, bolder picture, and a higher...
Audio: 100
But Dolphin Tale is a dialogue-driven family film, and it's greatest claim to aural fame is absorbing aquarium ambience, notable water tank acoustics, welcome underwater immersiveness and lightning-quick...
Extras: 80
Spotlight on a Scene (HD, 7 minutes): Director Charles Martin Smith and producer Andrew Kosove dissect the film's opening sequence, the digitally created dolphins that star in it, and the 3D techniques...
Movie: 60
No, Dolphin Tale is a decidedly human tale; and, even then, one very loosely based on the events that inspired it....
Total: 50
Its 3D presentation is a natively shot dream, its video transfer swims incredibly close to perfection, its DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 surround track is a sonic survivor, and its supplemental package will...
AVSForumRead review here
Video: 90
Images are rendered with excellent visual penetration, resolute sharpness and defining detail that is particularly striking during brighter sequences....
Audio: 82
Screen Onkyo PR-SC5508 THX Ultra 2 Audio/Video Processor Sherbourn Technologies - 7/200 Seven Channel Amplifier Oppo BDP-93 Universal Disc/3D capable Blu-ray Player (HDMI Audio/Video)...
Extras: 80
The Hutash’s Rainbow Bridge – 2 minute animated story At home with Winter – 13 minute production featurette (HD) Dolphin tale: Spotlight on a scene – Opening segment (HD) Winter’s inspiration – 18 minute...
Movie: 80
In an inspiring story of the bond between animals and humans, a boy named Sawyer discovers an injured dolphin, who is brought to a marine hospital and named Winter....
Total: 83
Screen Onkyo PR-SC5508 THX Ultra 2 Audio/Video Processor Sherbourn Technologies - 7/200 Seven Channel Amplifier Oppo BDP-93 Universal Disc/3D capable Blu-ray Player (HDMI Audio/Video)...
Director: Charles Martin Smith
Actors: Morgan Freeman, Ashley Judd, Harry Connick Jr.
PlotA young boy named Sawyer Nelson discovers a stranded dolphin caught in a crab trap on a beach in Florida. The injured dolphin, later named Winter, is taken to the Clearwater Marine Hospital where she receives care from Dr. Clay Haskett and his team. Sawyer, despite his struggles at school, forms a special bond with Winter and becomes deeply involved in her rehabilitation. Winter's injuries, however, lead to the loss of her tail, presenting a significant challenge for both her and the marine hospital staff.
As Winter’s condition becomes increasingly complicated, the team at the marine hospital faces mounting pressure to save her. Financial difficulties and further complications arise, putting the future of Winter and the hospital in jeopardy. Sawyer, along with his supportive family and new friends at the hospital, become determined to find a solution, seeking out the expertise of a pioneering prosthetics doctor. Their collective efforts and unwavering dedication to Winter's well-being drive a journey filled with hope, perseverance, and innovation.
Writers: Karen Janszen, Noam Dromi
Release Date: 23 Sep 2011
Runtime: 113 min
Rating: PG
Country: Canada, United States
Language: English