Waves Blu-ray Review
Score: 75
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
Waves, a film with deep themes and stellar execution, comes highly recommended despite debates and imperfections.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 81
Waves' Blu-ray features rich details and vibrant colors across multiple aspect ratios, enhancing drama and emotional depth, with a notable digital grain.
Audio: 86
Waves features a DTS-HD MA 5.1 mix, blending immersive music and SFX with clear dialogue, despite occasional overwhelming elements. Its use of natural sounds notably enhances the experience, though some miss the original Dolby Atmos.
Extra: 46
Engaging extras like a commentary with Trey Edward Shults & Kelvin Harrison Jr., ‘Creating Waves’ interviews, a comprehensive Q&A, and deleted scenes, all in 1080p.
Movie: 71
Waves" showcases the emotional journey of a family facing adversity and finding redemption, highlighted by powerful performances and a message that resonates with the importance of reconciliation.
Video: 81
Waves" graces the Blu-ray format with a visually compelling presentation by Lionsgate Films, offering an AVC-encoded 1080p image that dynamically shifts through multiple aspect ratios. This artistic choice, navigating through 2.67:1, 2.40:1, 1.85:1, 1.35:1, and an additional reported aspect of approximately 3.00:1, serves to embellish the film’s narrative depth. Notably, the changes in framing, particularly the switch to the more confining 1.35:1 ratio during pivotal scenes, create a pronounced effect of claustrophobia and intimacy, capturing the emotional peaks of the storyline. Despite some transitions feeling somewhat arbitrary, their overall impact enhances the storytelling, adding a layer of visual intrigue and emotional gravity.
The digital cinematography, sourced from Arri Alexas and finalized on a 2K Digital Intermediate, lays out an impressive canvas of fine details and vibrant colors that breathe life into the visuals. The digital manipulation introduces a subtle grain that, rather than detracting, adds texture to the vivid display of color and lighting choices throughout the film's runtime. Scenes ranging from the impressionistic to the brightly lit Florida landscapes boast a rich palette and deep black levels, emphasizing the film’s dramatic and aesthetic aspirations equally.
Detail and clarity stand out in this presentation, with close-ups revealing intricate facial features and costume textures that contribute to the film's immersive experience. The dominance of blue hues among the bold colors, alongside consistently natural skin tones, reinforces the emotional undercurrents of "Waves". Despite being mastered in 2K without HDR enhancement, the Blu-ray showcases an exceptional depth of field and shadow detail, free from compression issues, delivering a solid presentation that admirably captures both the stark realism and heightened moments of the narrative.
Audio: 86
The DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 mix provided with the Blu Ray release of "Waves" delivers an audio experience that is both immersive and nuanced, making it an engaging listen for audiophiles and film enthusiasts alike. Despite not being presented in its original Dolby Atmos format— a move that baffles somewhat given the film's atmospheric and spatially aware sound design—the 5.1 mix adeptly capitalizes on its available channels to ensure a rich, enveloping soundstage. Dialogue remains clear and prioritized, ensuring pivotal dramatic sequences are conveyed with clarity, even amidst a bustling backdrop of sound effects and musical cues. The environment it creates is one of careful balance; placing the listener directly within the film's emotionally charged spaces, from the intimacy of a family home to the echoing expanse of a school gym.
Intricate sounds such as the naturalistic whispers of wind or water, which parallel the film's titular theme, are particularly noteworthy for their creative integration into the mix, fostering an absorbing atmosphere. The score by Trent Reznor and Atticus Ross further elevates this soundscape, blending with assorted source cues to enrich the narrative's emotive layering. Scenes are set with an astute awareness of volume and spatial dynamics, ranging from the tight, almost claustrophobic tension of personal conflict to the liberating openness signifying emotional and physical distance. This masterful manipulation of sound not only supports but enhances the storytelling, drawing listeners in through a meticulously crafted auditory experience.
The overall audio presentation of "Waves" on Blu Ray, though arguably diminished from its theatrical potential, remains compellingly articulate and dynamically varied. It demonstrates a thoughtful approach to sound that complements the film’s thematic depth and visual splendor. Even with the 5.1 limitation, the mix showcases an impressive level of technical craftsmanship, with strategic placement of sonic elements creating a believable, engaging audio environment that works in symbiosis with the film's visual and narrative components.
Extras: 46
The extra content of the "Waves" Blu-ray adds significant value for enthusiasts of this heart-wrenching drama, providing an in-depth behind-the-scenes glimpse into the film's creation. The included audio commentary by writer/director Trey Edward Shults and actor Kelvin Harrison Jr. offers fascinating insights into the filmmaking process and character development. "Creating Waves: The Truth in It All" is a compelling EPK that features illuminating interviews with the cast and crew, diving into the emotional depth and real-life inspirations behind the story. The "Q & A with Director and Cast" is an extensive session moderated by Joshua Rothkopf from Time Out New York, offering a broad perspective on the film's themes with thoughtful contributions from key cast members. Additionally, the deleted scenes provide a unique look at what might have been, enriching the overall viewing experience for fans and newcomers alike.
Extras included in this disc:
- Audio Commentary with Writer / Director Trey Edward Shults and Actor Kelvin Harrison, Jr.: Insightful commentary offering a deep dive into the making of the film.
- Creating Waves: The Truth in It All: An engaging behind-the-scenes look featuring interviews with cast and crew.
- Q & A with Director and Cast: A comprehensive discussion with the filmmakers and actors, shedding light on various aspects of the film.
- Deleted Scenes: Exclusive footage not included in the theatrical release.
Movie: 71
Waves," directed by Trey Edward Shults, articulates a poignant narrative that explores the complexities of familial dynamics, unforeseen adversities, and the path toward reconciliation within an African American family living in Florida. The film's title opaquely hints at its thematic undertones, oscillating between literal and metaphorical waves that buffet the family, primarily focusing on the life of star athlete Tyler Williams (Kelvin Harrison Jr.) and the consequential domino effect his decisions have on his close-knit family. Sterling K. Brown delivers an imposing performance as Ronald, Tyler's father, whose tough love and expectations precipitate a familial crisis, especially when Tyler faces a life-altering shoulder injury and subsequent personal turmoil.
The movie unfurls with a meticulous pace, allowing a deep dive into character studies against the backdrop of systemic pressures and personal failures. As Tyler's world spirals out of control following his severe injury and its aftereffects, the narrative broadens to encapsulate the ripple effects on his sister Emily (Taylor Russell), showcasing a seamless transition into her perspective. Emily's storyline introduces sober reflections on damaged relationships and the gentle, tentative steps towards healing and understanding, marked by a budding relationship with Luke (Lucas Hedges), suggesting that amidst despair, there exists a possibility for redemption and mending bonds.
An actor's showcase, "Waves" boasts commendable performances across the board, with Harrison Jr.'s portrayal of Tyler resonating deeply due to its emotional depth and complexity. The film navigates through the tumultuous waters of loss, love, and forgiveness with a profound sensitivity and an eye for the nuances of human emotions, making it a compelling watch. Despite certain critiques regarding its melodramatic elements, it ultimately serves as a testament to the enduring nature of family ties and the resilience required to overcome life's unanticipated challenges. The technical aspects, including stellar cinematography and a hauntingly beautiful score, complement the emotionally charged tapestry that "Waves" weaves, embedding it as a noteworthy cinematic experience.
Total: 75
Waves," as presented on Blu-ray, emerges as an intricate tapestry of familial dynamics and personal growth, much debated over its narrative approach and the potential implications of cultural appropriation in its creation. Amid these discussions, the film distinguishes itself through its bold structure and compelling performances, masterfully captured in this high-quality release. Though its ambitious storyline may seem overextended to some, aiming for a tighter narrative could have distilled its themes more effectively. However, it's the movie's deeply felt exploration of love, forgiveness, and the human condition that ultimately resonates, supported by an exceptional cast and visually striking cinematography. The disc boasts outstanding technical merits, with Lionsgate ensuring a meticulous audiovisual (A/V) presentation complemented by insightful bonus features, including a thought-provoking Q&A segment with director Trey Edward Shults.
Despite certain criticisms regarding its expansive narrative, "Waves" undeniably benefits from its attention to detail in both storytelling and technical execution. The Blu-ray encapsulates this duality, presenting a visually compelling and emotionally engaging experience. Its richness in both aspect provides an intricate look into the characters' lives, underscored by superior sound and picture quality that enhances every scene. The inclusion of bonus content further enriches the viewing experience, offering viewers additional layers of understanding and appreciation for the film's creative process.
In conclusion, the Blu-ray presentation of "Waves" is commendable, offering an immersive viewing experience that highlights the film's aesthetic qualities and emotional depth. While it navigates complex themes that may evoke mixed reactions, its standout performances and technical excellence make it a noteworthy addition to any collection. Whether drawn to its visual artistry or the profound narratives it weaves, "Waves" stands out as a singular cinematic endeavor that warrants attention. The release comes highly recommended, providing both a visual feast and substantial material for contemplation and discussion.
Blu-ray.com review by Jeffrey KauffmanRead review here
Video: 90
There are some intentionally almost impressionistic moments during some party scenes (see screenshot 11) where detail levels are understandably minimal, but on the whole I found detail and fine detail...
Audio: 100
Trent Reznor and Atticus Ross provide another really interesting score, with a few other source cues also being utilized, but for me personally, it was the really interesting use of ostensibly non-musical...
Extras: 50
Q & A with Director and Cast (1080p; 29:49) is moderated Joshua Rothkopf from Time Out New York, and includes Trey Edward Shults, Sterling K. Brown, Taylor Russell, Ren�e Elise Goldsberry, Kelvin Harrison...
Movie: 80
The early part of the film smartly documents the hard charging Type A personality of Ronald, a guy who obviously wants the best for both Tyler and Tyler's little sister Emily (Taylor Russell), but who...
Total: 80
In the Q & A included on this disc as a supplement, Shults kind of addresses what may be an unstated subtext for some, namely is it cultural appropriation for a white guy to try to write and direct a story...
High-Def Digest review by Matthew HartmanRead review here
Video: 90
Things are honestly so clear I was a little surprised to find out that this transfer was sourced only from a 2K master - it's a terrific looking presentation giving facial features, costumes, sets, some...
Audio: 90
While a relatively quiet and contemplative affair, Waves does manage to make great use of the surround soundscape allowing for some impressive pinpoint element placing....
Extras: 50
Audio Commentary Track featuring Writer/Director Trey Edward Shults and Actor Kelvin Harrison Jr....
Movie: 70
Similarly, it's a story marred by tragedy and loss, with a hopeful message - but it didn't stack so much "and then…" on top of the central story....
Total: 80
It's sprawling epic storyline probably could have been trimmed and focused for a tighter narrative - but the film earns high praise for incredible performances, a visually arresting presentation, sharp...
Director: Trey Edward Shults
Actors: Taylor Russell, Kelvin Harrison Jr., Alexa Demie
PlotSet against the vibrant landscape of South Florida, the plot centers on the lives of an African-American suburban family led by a well-intentioned but domineering father. The family navigates love and forgiveness in the aftermath of a tragic loss. The father, Ronald, pushes his teenage son, Tyler, to excel in wrestling and succeed in life, imposing strict disciplinary measures that stem from a place of love but generate an intense pressure cooker environment at home. Tyler, while outwardly successful and popular, struggles internally with the high expectations and begins to unravel as the stress from an injury and personal relationships compounds his sense of isolation.
The narrative shifts to focus on Tyler's quiet and reserved younger sister, Emily, who lives in Tyler's shadow and grapples with her place within the family and her own identity. Emily's journey of self-discovery brings her closer to a compassionate and thoughtful teammate, Luke, who confronts his own family issues. Together they embark on a path of healing and understanding, exploring the complexities of their emotions, relationships, and the human capacity to empathize and connect in the face of hardship and pain. Through her perspective, the story examines the importance of compassion and the resilience of the human spirit.
Writers: Trey Edward Shults
Release Date: 06 Dec 2019
Runtime: 135 min
Rating: R
Country: United States, Canada
Language: English