The Forbidden Room Blu-ray Review
Score: 62
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
Intricately assembled and inventively imagined, 'The Forbidden Room' is a visionary yet periodically insufferable film, blending old school with modern technology seamlessly.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 67
The Forbidden Room’s Blu-ray presentation in 1080p HD, with aspect ratios (1.66:1 & 1.78:1), features intentionally distorted, grainy visuals with accurate yet overly saturated colors, deep black levels, and natural skin tones; detail is respectable, though clarity varies widely by scene with some mild banding and noise detected.
Audio: 67
The 5.1 DTS-HD MA mix for 'The Forbidden Room' creates an engaging, energetic audio experience, with active surround effects and intentional dialogue muddling that aligns with the film's chaotic style. The soundscape, full of anxious energy and depth, complements the sweeping, bass-infused score and well-crafted sound effects.
Extra: 41
The Blu-ray extras for 'The Forbidden Room' offer insightful commentary from directors Guy Maddin and Even Johnson, abstract visuals in 'Endless Ectoloops,' promotional 'Living Posters,' and the esoteric short 'Once a Chicken,' alongside detailed essays in a 26-page booklet, enriching the viewing experience.
Movie: 71
The Forbidden Room, directed by Guy Maddin, is a challenging, avant-garde cinematic experience mixing silent film techniques with digital technology, delivering a series of surreal, genre-blending vignettes featuring horror, comedy, and tragedy. It’s brilliantly unique but not universally palatable, encapsulating Maddin's iconoclastic vision.
Video: 67
The video presentation of "The Forbidden Room" reflects Guy Maddin's avant-garde style, with the Blu-ray disc offering an intentionally abstract and heavily manipulated image that defies conventional clarity. Presented in either a 1.66:1 aspect ratio or 1.78:1, the AVC-encoded 1080p HD transfer strives to retain detail amidst the chaotic visual tapestry. The film employs distorted visuals and layered imagery, delivering an aesthetic reminiscent of aged and decayed film stock. Despite this overwhelming busyness, the texture survives, allowing close-up shots to exhibit sharp skin textures and the intricate details of costumes.
Colors remain strikingly accurate yet saturated, contributing to a surreal and sometimes sickly look. Black levels are deep and inky, contributing to the film’s atmosphere, although Maddin’s deliberate manipulation often leads to solid blacks engulfing parts of the frame. Skin tones fluctuate between natural and intentionally altered. Minor technical issues like mild banding and video noise are present but are largely overshadowed by the film’s busy composition and intent. The overall source is clean, but the grainy, "dirty" quality is a deliberate artistic choice to match Maddin's enigmatic style.
Audio: 67
The 5.1 DTS-HD Master Audio mix for "The Forbidden Room" crafts an immersive and peculiar auditory experience, perfectly mirroring the film's visual eccentricities. This mix meticulously handles Maddin's unique soundscape, creating an active listening event that engages the surround channels to add depth to the film’s nervous energy. The dialogue is deliberately distorted yet trackable, maintaining clarity despite its intentional muddling. Music is presented with a rich low-end and a fresh, full-bodied sound that enhances the overall atmosphere, while the sound effects—ranging from scratches to submersions—are prominently and effectively rendered.
This lossless DTS-HD MA 5.1 mix stands out with its vigorous execution, infusing the feature with an energetic vitality. Ambient noises and sound effects are delivered powerfully through the surround speakers, contributing to the film's overarching theme of anxiety and neuroticism. The score is sweeping and chaotic, bolstered by substantial bass that accentuates key musical moments. Additional auditory flourishes such as pops and cracks are deftly integrated to support the film's quirky aesthetic. Despite its unconventional approach, the audio presentation remains cohesive and impressive, seamlessly aligning with the singular vision of the film.
Extras: 41
The Blu-ray extras for "The Forbidden Room" present an immersive deep dive into Guy Maddin's eclectic and avant-garde filmmaking process. The commentary by directors Guy Maddin and Evan Johnson is particularly notable, offering insights into the film's peculiar production challenges and offbeat narrative. Additionally, the "Endless Ectoloops" and "Living Posters" features push the boundaries of digital art, creating surreal, hypnotic visual experiences. "Once a Chicken" further showcases the directors' experimental edge with its silent, black and white presentation. The inclusion of a 26-page booklet with essays by Hilary Weston and Guy Maddin enriches the viewing experience, providing scholarly perspectives on the film's themes and artistry. Trailers offer a conventional yet essential promotional preview, rounding out a robust suite of special features.
Extras included in this disc:
- Audio Commentary: Directors discuss production challenges, casting, and technical tricks.
- Endless Ectoloops: Abstract imagery extended dips.
- Living Posters: Ectoloop-like promo art.
- Once a Chicken: Silent, black-and-white short.
- Trailers: Teaser and theatrical previews.
- Booklet: Essays by Hillary Weston and Guy Maddin, fully illustrated.
Movie: 71
In "The Forbidden Room," Guy Maddin continues his avant-garde exploration of cinema, refusing to cater to commercial success or conventional storytelling. His latest film is a swirl of imagination and innovation that intertwines numerous bizarre short stories and vignettes, forming a cinematic collage that is both entrancing and challenging. Maddin’s hallmark of silent film construction, executed with modern digital technology, remains a prominent feature, enhancing the abstract narrative with elements of horror, comedy, and tragedy. Familiar faces such as Charlotte Rampling, Udo Kier, and Mathieu Amalric appear, adding layers to the film’s peculiar charm.
"The Forbidden Room" can be viewed as a free-form investigation of Maddin's artistic idiosyncrasies, avoiding a larger plot in favor of dream-like sequences and varied filmic styles. The most consistent story arc involves a submarine crew extending their life expectancy by eating flapjacks containing air bubbles while searching for their missing captain. Other surreal segments include vampire bananas, skeletons selling insurance, and men with eccentric obsessions. Each sequence is stranger than the last, yet achieves a kind of mad brilliance that stays with the viewer long after the film ends.
The presentation itself is intentionally raw and disorienting, akin to an artifact discovered in an underground enclave. Despite its vintage feel, "The Forbidden Room" employs modern techniques seamlessly. At two hours, this film is not for everyone but will be a unique treat for those open to experimental cinema. Each viewing promises a rich experience, revealing more of Maddin’s visionary artistry and unorthodox storytelling.
Total: 62
"The Forbidden Room" Blu-ray brings to home viewers an unparalleled cinematic experience crafted by the audacious imagination of Guy Maddin. This film is a mosaic of surreal and eccentric narratives, each vignette unfolding like an imaginative fever dream. Maddin's robust visual style marries elements of early cinema with modern digital experimentation to create a uniquely compelling atmosphere. The audio and video presentations on this Blu-ray are well-executed, delivering a rich sensory experience that complements the intricate storytelling. The inclusion of equally peculiar bonus features enhances the overall package, offering deeper insights into Maddin's creative process.
Clocking in at two hours, the film's unconventional structure and repetitive motifs may challenge some viewers' endurance. Maddin, true to his visionary form, fully commits to his artistic whims, which results in moments of profound brilliance interspersed with sequences that verge on the insufferable. Despite its meandering pace, the film's originality and innovative assembly make it a singular experience in the realm of contemporary cinema. The Blu-ray format aids in emphasizing the film's aesthetic intricacies, ensuring that every bizarre detail is rendered with precision.
In conclusion, "The Forbidden Room" is not merely a film but an exploration of the boundaries of visual storytelling. While its idiosyncratic nature may require patience, those willing to delve into its chaotic charm will find it deeply rewarding. It's a testament to Maddin's prowess as a filmmaker and a bold addition to any cinephile’s collection.
Blu-ray.com review by Brian OrndorfRead review here
Video: 80
Clarity isn't available, but detail survives, managing actor extremes with attention to skin textures, and craftsmanship remains as sharp as possible....
Audio: 80
The 5.1 DTS-HD MA mix handles Maddin's soundscape with an active listening event, keeping in line with visual impishness....
Extras: 50
"Once a Chicken" (6:51, HD) again restores the ectoloop submersion for this artful short, credited as a "S�ance with Lazslo Moholy-Nagy."...
Movie: 70
I think it's wonderful that Guy Maddin is continuing his exploration of underground cinema, refusing to compromise his vision to entice commercial success, sticking to a plan of impish, artful moviemaking...
Total: 70
Maddin is a visionary, a true artist, but he's never one to quit while he's ahead, with "The Forbidden Room" a feature that's easily appreciated, intricately assembled, inventively imagined, and periodically...
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 80
With this artistic and experimental film that showcases a variety of different stories, all presented in a different visual, there is no real steady way to tackle this video presentation....
Audio: 80
Surprisingly, this is fairly energetic audio mix with sound effects and ambient noises coming from the surrounds at full force....
Extras: 40
Once a Chicken' (HD, 7 Mins.) - An interesting short film that is silent and black and white....
Movie: 80
I guess you could say this is a mixed bag of warped stories of almost every genre that really never form a cohesive narrative plot, but is rather a collection of dream like sequences with different styles...
Total: 60
I imagine this is something that Alex DeLarge from 'A Clockwork Orange' would have loved to watch every week with his fellow droogs....
Director: Guy Maddin, Evan Johnson
Actors: Roy Dupuis, Clara Furey, Louis Negin
PlotA lumberjack mysteriously appears aboard a submarine that has been trapped underwater. The crew, desperate for a solution to escape their watery tomb, is baffled by his presence and listens as he recounts his own bizarre tale of getting lost in a dense forest. Meanwhile, onboard the submarine, tensions rise and fantastical stories begin to intertwine as each person reveals fragments of their past, fears, and desires. What follows is a series of enigmatic vignettes, blending surreal narratives that shift seamlessly from one character's imagination to another's reality.
These stories include a man on a quest to cure his family's unique condition by locating a mythical heirloom, and a woman trying to escape from the clutches of her possessive husband while encountering peculiar characters along the way. Each scene transitions with dream-like fluidity into the next, creating a tapestry of overlapping, absurd, and haunting scenarios. The characters’ interconnected stories form a labyrinthine structure that delves deeper into their psyches, evoking a sense of wonder and disorientation as the detailed visual style draws viewers into a hypnotic exploration of mystery and identity.
Writers: Guy Maddin, Evan Johnson, Bob Kotyk
Release Date: 12 Nov 2015
Runtime: 130 min
Rating: Not Rated
Country: Canada
Language: English