How to Lose a Guy in 10 Days Blu-ray Review
Score: 39
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
RomCom 'How to Lose a Guy in 10 Days' disappoints yet offers fair gender appeal; Blu-ray is decent.
Disc Release Date
Dolby TrueHD
Video: 40
'How to Lose a Guy in 10 Days' Blu-ray offers an adequate yet unexceptional 1080p transfer, with mixed sharpness, muted colors, and some artifact issues, falling short of high-tier quality.
Audio: 35
How to Lose a Guy in 10 Days' Blu-ray features a Dolby TrueHD 5.1 soundtrack that, despite some city ambiance, largely lacks depth, dynamic range, and engaging surround effects, resulting in an overall mediocre audio experience.
Extra: 41
The Blu-ray release of 'How to Lose a Guy in 10 Days' features directorial insights, a mundane making-of, superficial extras, and mixed reviews of the supplemental content's depth and entertainment value.
Movie: 41
How to Lose a Guy in 10 Days" is critiqued for its clichéd, predictable romantic comedy pitfalls, lackluster lead chemistry, and a plot that struggles with pacing and believability, despite attempts to appeal to both genders.
Video: 40
The Blu-ray presentation of "How to Lose a Guy in 10 Days" showcases an acceptable 1080p transfer in the 1.78:1 aspect ratio, which fluctuates between sharpness and a degree of softness throughout. This transfer embraces a film-like vibe, complemented by a serviceable depth, adequate background definitions, and a preserved film grain that adds to the cinematic experience. The color palette, while not overly vibrant, prevents scenes from feeling lifeless, although it occasionally lacks the striking vivacity some may expect from high-definition content. Furthermore, the detail level across the board is satisfactory without tipping into the realm of extraordinary clarity or texture, depicting an overall solid yet unspectacular visual execution.
Technical aspects reveal a mixed bag concerning contrast and color reproduction, where contrasts often appear flat, leading to a somewhat two-dimensional experience that doesn't fully exploit the visual depths Blu-ray can offer. Despite a slight vibrancy in isolated instances, such as the striking reds in Mrs. DeLauer's appearance, the transfer fails to consistently deliver finely replicated colors, with some instances of colors bordering on oversaturation without delivering finer details. Grain levels maintain a non-intrusive presence, albeit at the expense of occasionally blurry backgrounds, particularly noticeable in interior shots.
Detailing in clothing and textures fares better, with darker costumes displaying commendable sharpness. However, facial details present inconsistency; while Matthew McConaughey's visage benefits from discernible characteristics, Kate Hudson's features sometimes blur into undefined regions, raising questions about makeup effects or digital noise reduction applications. Despite these shortcomings, skin tones generally come across as natural, barring occasional imbalances. Black levels are deemed sufficient with good shadow details, although white balances and some sky shots betray minor macroblocking and artifacts, indicating room for improvement in this Blu-ray edition's video performance.
Audio: 35
The Blu-ray audio presentation of "How to Lose a Guy in 10 Days" is equipped with a Dolby TrueHD 5.1 track that, unfortunately, fails to impress or immerse the viewer in its audio environment. Despite the potential for a vibrant sonic experience, especially considering the bustling New York setting, the track is overly front-heavy with a significant underuse of the surround channels, leading to an experience that lacks depth and atmosphere. The sounds of the city, while decently represented in a few exterior shots, provide a glimpse of the auditory scope that could have been achieved. However, even dynamic scenes like those at a Knicks game or during a motorcycle ride feel lacking in energy and spatial dimensionality due to inaudible dialogue, subdued music, and an almost negligible bass response.
Dialogue clarity varies throughout the film, with some lines being challenging to hear, further detracting from the viewing experience. This issue is most notable in scenes where ambient sounds should enhance the realism but instead contribute to an unbalanced audio mix where important dialogue competes with—or is lost amidst—background noise. Moreover, the rear channels are underutilized to the point of nonexistence in many scenes, missing opportunities to envelop the viewer in a more immersive auditory environment. Music and ambient sounds tend to remain confined to the front channels, with little to no leveraging of the soundstage's full potential, resulting in a flat and at times, insipid audio presentation.
The few instances where audio elements are handled well—such as the accurate depiction of bustling city streets or the enveloping crowd noise in isolated moments—serve as fleeting reminders of what could have been a consistently engaging audio experience. While these moments offer a glimpse into a richer soundscape, they are exceptions rather than the rule. The overall presentation fails to capitalize on these opportunities, resulting in a disappointingly mundane auditory journey that does not do justice to the vibrant setting and events of "How to Lose a Guy in 10 Days.
Extras: 41
The Blu-ray release of "How to Lose a Guy in 10 Days" enriches the viewing experience with a well-curated selection of extras, tailored for fans and newcomers alike. Director Donald Petrie’s commentary offers a mixed bag of technical insights and personal anecdotes, providing a deeper understanding of the film's production and character development, though it occasionally veers into tedium. The high-definition extras, particularly "How to Make a Movie in 2 Years," offer a unique look into the adaptation process from book to screen, despite its somewhat dry execution. "Why the Sexes Battle" and "Girls Night Out" attempt to delve into thematic elements and authorial intentions but might not resonate with all viewers due to their superficial analysis. The music video for "Somebody Like You" by Keith Urban and the collection of deleted scenes, while standard fare, round out the bonus materials, delivering a few additional glimpses into the film's world. Despite some shortcomings, this package commendably enhances the overall appreciation of this beloved rom-com.%0AExtras included in this disc:
- Audio Commentary: A full-length commentary track by Director Donald Petrie.
- How to Make a Movie in 2 Years: A behind-the-scenes look at the book's journey to the big screen.
- Why the Sexes Battle: Interviews with experts on the dynamics between men and women.
- Girls Night Out: A Q&A session with authors Michele Alexander and Jeannie Long.
- Music Video: Keith Urban's "Somebody Like You" featuring clips from the film.
- Deleted Scenes: Five segments with optional director's commentary.
Movie: 41
How to Lose a Guy in 10 Days" presents an intriguing premise wrapped in the shiny packaging of a romantic comedy, but unfortunately, it falters in execution and fails to fully exploit its potential. The film embarks on a journey with Andie Anderson (Kate Hudson) and Benjamin Barry (Matthew McConaughey), who find themselves intertwined in a bet that cleverly forms the backbone of the narrative. Andie aims to pen an article on how to drive a man away in 10 days, while Ben is determined to make a woman fall in love with him within the same timeframe for a career advantage. This setup promises a comedic exploration of romantic faux pas but ends up delivering a mixed bag of results.
Despite the commendable efforts of Hudson and McConaughey, the film struggles with pacing issues and an overreliance on clichés that sap its vitality. Clocking in at nearly two hours, "How to Lose a Guy in 10 Days" meanders through its plot with a sluggish pace that tests the audience's patience. The lack of authentic chemistry between the leads exacerbates this problem, rendering the unfolding romance less than believable and diluting the impact of its more dramatic scenes. Moreover, the film disproportionately straddles the line between catering to its target female audience while attempting—and not quite succeeding—to engage male viewers with a blend of sappy romance and attempts at humor that often misses the mark.
Technically, the movie showcases no groundbreaking achievements, adhering instead to the standard norms of romantic comedy presentations without challenging or innovating within the genre. Its reliance on an absurdly contrived setup could have been forgivable had the rest of the movie compensated with genuine humor and heart. Instead, "How to Lose a Guy in 10 Days" serves as a stark reminder that a promising concept alone cannot sustain a film; it requires a harmonious blend of solid performances, compelling chemistry, and a narrative that resonates with its audience beyond the superficial allure of its premise.
Total: 39
How to Lose a Guy in 10 Days" emerges as a contentious title within the Romantic Comedy genre, eliciting a wide spectrum of opinions. On one hand, it's criticized for its formulaic plot and the absence of genuine romantic sparks between its protagonists, leading it to fall short when compared to contemporaries like "13 Going on 30." The narrative's predictability and a general lack of originality contribute to its perception as an insipid addition to the RomCom lineup. Despite an intriguing premise, it's bogged down by an extended runtime and characters that fail to leave a noteworthy impression. From a technical standpoint, Paramount’s Blu-ray presentation offers a satisfactory, albeit unremarkable, visual and audio experience. The transfer is adequate, ensuring that the film is provided in a quality that meets basic expectations, while the inclusion of a conventional array of supplementary materials adds a modicum of value for enthusiasts.
Contrastingly, the film finds redemption in its broader appeal, managing to transcend the typical gender biases associated with chick flicks. The packaging and menu design may suggest an overt leaning towards feminine tastes, yet the storyline endeavors to offer something of substance to a diverse audience. This attempt at neutrality in appeal is indicative of a more evenly balanced approach in addressing romantic themes, which could entice viewers beyond its anticipated demographic.
Conclusively, "How to Lose a Guy in 10 Days" serves as a polarizing entrant into the Blu-ray market. While it might not ascend to the heights of critical acclaim due to its narrative and character shortcomings, the Blu-ray release by Paramount partially redeems the film by providing an acceptable technical rendition and by endeavoring to captivate a wider audience. Those intrigued by the premise or fans of the genre might find it worth their time, albeit with moderated expectations on cinematic innovation or depth.
Blu-ray.com review by Martin LiebmanRead review here
Video: 70
Though it wavers between fairly sharp and slightly soft, the image enjoys a fair film-like quality that's helped along by a decent sense of depth, background detail, and a fine layer of visible film grain....
Audio: 60
The sounds of the city as heard during several exterior shots produce what proves to be the best overall listens in the film....
Extras: 40
Why the Sexes Battle (1080p, 5:00) features a series of interview snippets with experts that discuss the evolution of how men and women choose one another and how those evolutionary observations fit into...
Movie: 40
How to Lose a Guy in 10 Days grates on the nerves, just like Andie, never relenting in its attack on the audience and the result is a collection of scenes that might otherwise be funny but, generally,...
Total: 50
Hindered by an overlong runtime, bland characters, and a lack of romantic chemistry between the leads, How to Lose a Guy in 10 Days doesn't hold a candle to 13 Going on 30 or even several of the fledgeling...
High-Def Digest review by Nate BossRead review here
Video: 50
Clothing is very detailed, with black suits and jackets showing strong, with the occasional pinstripe coming in clear and not jagged....
Audio: 50
Music shares the same lack of emphasis, no matter how much you crank your system, giving off a muted feel that is easily dominated by other audio elements that are far from loud....
Extras: 50
On the bright side, there are new features not found in the previous edition DVD, though a few features from that release did not make their way over....
Movie: 50
In consecutive sequences, the title of the film is just blurbed, along with the entire premise (no, that wasn't just a bad case of deja vu), for those in the theater or at home too busy sucking face to...
Total: 50
"Chick flicks" are a tough sell for me, as they're often so focused on appealing to one gender that they create films more akin to torture for us guys....
Director: Donald Petrie
Actors: Kate Hudson, Matthew McConaughey, Adam Goldberg
PlotAndie Anderson, an aspiring journalist working for a women's magazine, is tired of writing fluff pieces. Seeking to tackle more serious topics, she pitches an unorthodox article idea to her editor: "How to Lose a Guy in 10 Days," where she will start dating a man and then drive him away using common mistakes women make in relationships. The goal is to document her steps and prove her thesis for the magazine's readers. Andie sets out to find her unsuspecting subject for this social experiment, looking for someone she can quickly entangle in a relationship and just as quickly drive away.
Ben Barry, a confident advertising executive, is an ambitious charmer who's equally tired of frivolous encounters and is focused on landing a major diamond account at work. He enters a bet with his boss: if he can make a woman fall in love with him in 10 days, he'll get the account, believing his marketing skills make him irresistible to women. Coincidentally, Andie and Ben cross paths, unwittingly becoming the perfect candidates for each other's schemes. As Andie employs increasingly brazen tactics to sabotage their burgeoning relationship, Ben counters with charm and persistence, unbeknownst to them both that they are effectively working against their own personal goals. Their careers hang in the balance as the 10-day deadline approaches, with neither aware of the other's hidden agenda.
Writers: Michele Alexander, Jeannie Long, Kristen Buckley
Release Date: 07 Feb 2003
Runtime: 116 min
Rating: PG-13
Country: United States, Germany
Language: English