Bright Victory Blu-ray Review
Score: 73
from 3 reviewers
Review Date:
Bright Victory's remastered Blu-ray delivers compelling WWII drama with standout performances, a sensitive script, and a satisfying high-definition presentation.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 78
A new 2K master provides a high-quality 1080p MPEG-4 AVC transfer with excellent clarity and contrast, preserving the black-and-white cinematography despite minor print imperfections. While a few scratches and frame issues arise, the rich detail and pleasing grain structure ensure a compelling viewing experience.
Audio: 79
The audio presentation of 'Bright Victory' in DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0 mono boasts clear dialogue and dynamic sound effects, with no notable hiss or distortion. Frank Skinner’s score is delivered with crisp fidelity, demonstrating why the film's sound recording received Oscar recognition.
Extra: 50
The Blu-ray extras for "Bright Victory" are sparse, featuring only an engaging audio commentary by film historian Gary Gerani, who provides insightful analysis of the film's themes and its adaptation from the novel, though lacking in additional video content like interviews or documentaries for a more comprehensive experience.
Movie: 82
Bright Victory tackles blindness and racism with honesty and sensitivity, buoyed by Arthur Kennedy's Oscar-nominated nuanced performance. Mark Robson’s direction provides a semi-documentary style that imparts clinical efficiency to the rehabilitation scenes. The film is a modest gem, rich in emotional resonance and social commentary, deserving of rediscovery.
Video: 78
The Blu-ray release of "Bright Victory" from Kino Lorber presents this classic film in 1080p MPEG-4 AVC high definition, adhering to its original 1.37:1 full frame theatrical aspect ratio. Leveraging a new 2K master, this transfer offers impressive clarity and contrast, accentuating the film's timeless black-and-white cinematography by William Daniels. Despite occasional sporadic imperfections, such as thin scratches and slight marks, these elements seldom distract from the overall superior viewing experience. The high bit-rate video encoding is particularly noteworthy, providing a substantial boost in video quality compared to streaming options, ensuring a richly detailed and immersive presentation.
The meticulous restoration pays homage to the traditional cinematographic techniques of the era. Exteriors might occasionally appear hot, especially during the opening sequences, yet they maintain a balanced visual appeal. The image exhibits a natural grain structure that enhances the film-like authenticity, with deep blacks, stable whites, and a nuanced grayscale spectrum crafting a vibrant, dynamic picture. Although certain frames exhibit softness and accentuated texture, these aspects are characteristic of films from this period. Scenes shot with rear screen projection for jeep sequences and static framing choices highlight the conventional storytelling methods of the era.
While a few jarring frame disruptions occur early on and some scenes bear minor blemishes, these instances are rare and do not overshadow the overall clean presentation of the source print. With sharply defined background elements and crisp costume details, the Blu-ray transfer captures defining facial features effectively. This solid restoration may not reach dazzling heights but suffices in revitalizing the long-neglected film, offering enthusiasts a faithful rendition that honors its original artistic vision.
Audio: 79
The Blu-ray audio presentation of "Bright Victory" features a DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0 mono track that delivers outstanding clarity and fidelity. Despite the inherent limitations of its mono format, the lossless encoding provides a listening experience that is remarkably crisp and devoid of common audio artifacts such as hiss, crackle, or pops. Dialogue maintains exceptional clarity throughout—whether in hospital scenes or varied regional settings—ensuring that every word is comprehensible and nuanced. This clarity is matched by a dynamic range that effectively captures both subtle ambient sounds, like chirping crickets and city street noise, and piercing sound effects such as gunfire.
Frank Skinner’s music score is finely integrated into the audio landscape, enhancing the film's patriotic themes with both power and subtlety. The high-quality encoding provides a wide dynamic range, preventing distortion even at its most intense moments. Ambient noises, from background sounds in a bar to the tapping of Larry's cane on pavement, are rendered with precision, enriching the viewing experience by immersing the audience in the film's atmospheric settings. Presented by Kino Lorber, this audio track underscores its technical superiority over lossy streaming alternatives, solidifying the release's commitment to high-fidelity sound.
Overall, the audio package accompanying "Bright Victory" is a testament to superior sound engineering. It faithfully preserves the film's sonic integrity while providing a contemporary auditory experience that highlights its original sound recording accolades. This release not only does justice to the film's dialogue and sound effects but also honors Skinner's esteemed score, delivering an experience as vibrant and compelling as the day it was first heard.
Extras: 50
The Blu Ray of "Bright Victory" offers limited but valuable extras, encapsulated primarily in an insightful audio commentary by film historian and screenwriter Gary Gerani. This commentary delves into the narrative’s adaptation from book to film, illuminating its thematic exploration of overcoming prejudice and adversity. Gerani’s detailed professional discourse covers cast biographies, including insights into Arthur Kennedy’s distinguished career and Mark Robson’s transition from law to filmmaking. It emphasizes the film’s place in Universal’s catalog, hailed as one of its best. Despite the absence of interviews or featurettes, Gerani’s thorough analysis compensates with a robust discussion that engages fans and newcomers alike.
Extras included in this disc:
- Audio Commentary by Film Historian/Screenwriter Gary Gerani: Comprehensive insights on adaptation, themes, and notable contributions of cast and crew.
- So Proudly We Hail! – Trailer: Promotional material in SD.
- Fixed Bayonets! – Trailer: Promotional material in SD.
- Time Limit – Trailer: Promotional material in SD.
- Boomerang – Trailer: Promotional material in HD.
- Bend of the River – Trailer: Promotional material in SD.
- Paths of Glory – Trailer: Promotional material in HD.
Movie: 82
"Bright Victory," a WWII romantic-drama directed by Mark Robson, delivers an introspective narrative that blends emotional depth with a nuanced examination of societal issues. The film is anchored by Arthur Kennedy's commendable performance as Sergeant Larry Nevins, who faces the daunting reality of blindness following a wartime injury. Kennedy skillfully portrays a man grappling with personal transformation and societal prejudices. His character's journey from despair to enlightenment is both touching and profound. Collaboratively, Peggy Dow provides a supportive and empathetic portrayal as nurse Judy Greene, adding a delicate layer to the romantic subplot. James Edwards stands out with his portrayal of Joe Morgan, challenging racial prejudices and enhancing the film’s exploration of post-war race relations.
The film's artistic achievements are accentuated by expert craftsmanship. Bernard Herzbrun and Nathan Juran’s art direction creates a strikingly authentic hospital environment, while Rosemary Odell’s costume design complements character storytelling seamlessly. The cinematography by William H. Daniels is striking in its black and white elegance, employing a classical style which enhances the narrative's emotional undertones. Frank Skinner’s score underscores the film’s dramatic beats, adding a subtle yet affecting auditory experience. The editing by Russell F. Schoengarth ensures a cohesive narrative flow that maintains focus on intimate character moments rather than broader wartime conflict.
Screenwriter Robert Buckner focuses narratively on personal development within difficult contexts, crafting dialogues that are both thoughtful and compelling. His screenplay does not shy away from addressing racism, tackling this issue with forthrightness that was notable for its time. The film's semi-documentary style, coupled with on-location shoots, lends authenticity to the portrayal of rehabilitation processes for blinded veterans, offering audiences a vivid insight into life’s adaptability post-disability. "Bright Victory" remains a poignant historical drama that transcends its era with continued relevance through its graceful handling of complex themes and deeply resonant performances.
Total: 73
"Bright Victory" emerges as a profoundly stirring WWII drama, deftly portraying human resilience amidst adversity. Under the direction of Mark Robson, with a script by Robert Buckner, the film presents a potent narrative enriched by standout performances from Arthur Kennedy, James Edwards, and Peggy Dow. The film artfully navigates the themes of personal reinvention and social progress, compelling viewers to reflect on the enduring struggles against prejudice. Kino Lorber has genuinely honored this cinematic gem by sourcing the Blu-ray release from a new 2K remaster. Although not as immaculate as certain 4K offerings, this high-definition transfer significantly enhances the visual experience, accompanied by a commendable lossless audio encoding.
Supplementary to the viewing experience is an insightful commentary by film historian Gary Gerani, who underscores "Bright Victory" as a tale of adaptation and triumph over regressive ideologies. The film diverges from its source material in particular details, such as the protagonist's injury and recovery. This creative decision fortifies the cinematic portrayal of Larry's journey from despair to determination. By situating "Bright Victory" in a broader cinematic landscape, Gerani enriches our understanding of its thematic and historical context. The commentary resonates with those familiar with other works from Robson, illustrating his capacity to tackle complex social issues with tact and clarity.
In conclusion, "Bright Victory" remains an indispensable piece of cinema, offering a blend of gripping narrative and historical insight. Kino Lorber's Blu-ray release ensures that this overlooked classic receives the technical treatment it merits. Enthusiasts of vintage cinema will find significant value in this release, as it promises to restore and revitalize a film that continues to possess relevance and emotional resonance. "Bright Victory" is highly recommended for collectors and new audiences alike, deserving rediscovery and enduring appreciation.
Blu-ray.com review by Neil LumbardRead review here
Video: 80
The higher bit-rates of the Blu-ray format offer a significant advantage is video quality overing streaming services....
Audio: 80
The high-quality lossless encoding is one of the best strengths of the format (with movie streaming services offering only a lossy and compressed data stream by comparison)....
Extras: 60
Audio Commentary by Film Historian/Screenwriter Gary Gerani Unfortunately, the release does not include any video interviews, behind-the-scenes documentaries, or other featurettes....
Movie: 80
James Edwards is similarly impressive in the supporting role of Joe Morgan and the character has some noteworthy moments to shine during the WWII tale � an important character in the film and one that...
Total: 70
Though the print used on this release isn't as pristine as is sometimes found with the best 4K remasters, this is still a satisfying presentation of Bright Victory....
The Digital Bits review by Dennis SeulingRead review here
Video: 90
Bright Victory was shot by director of photography William Daniels on 35 mm black-and-white film with spherical lenses, finished photochemically, and presented in the aspect ratio of 1.37:1....
Audio: 95
Even when first brought to the hospital and likely under the influence of painkillers, Kennedy’s Larry speaks clearly, without slurring his words....
Extras: 80
Both the book and the film begin the same way, with the wartime event that sets the story in motion....
Movie: 95
At one point, he’s discovered trying to commit suicide, but hospital personnel intervene to provide a strong support system....
Total: 90
Both the book and the film begin the same way, with the wartime event that sets the story in motion....
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 80
Exteriors run a bit hot, especially during the opening sequence, but the picture is otherwise well balanced, with a natural grain structure, deep blacks, bright yet stable whites, and nicely varied grays...
Audio: 80
A wide dynamic scale handles all the highs and lows of Frank Skinner's understated music score without any distortion, and all the dialogue is well prioritized and easy to comprehend....
Extras: 20
Gerani expresses his reverence for Bright Victory throughout his discussion, which includes an array of cast and crew bios, a look at the differences between the source novel and film adaptation, and analysis...
Movie: 80
Almost every classic film fan has seen Dark Victory, the enduring Bette Davis weepie about a spoiled socialite who learns to accept the inevitability of blindness and death after receiving a terminal diagnosis,...
Total: 80
Arthur Kennedy's Oscar-nominated performance, a sensitive script, and fluid direction loft this little-known and long-neglected movie onto a higher plane, and Kino honors it with a newly remastered transfer,...
Director: Mark Robson
Actors: Arthur Kennedy, Peggy Dow, Julie Adams
PlotDuring World War II, an American sergeant stationed in North Africa is blinded by a gunshot wound. After being evacuated home, he begins rehabilitation at an army hospital specializing in veterans with visual impairments. Struggling with his new reality, he initially grapples with anger and frustration, resisting the very support designed to help him. Caught between acceptance and denial, he experiences moments of profound despair but finds solace through burgeoning friendships with other blinded soldiers who also face daunting adjustments. Slowly, he comes to terms with his disability, guided by doctors and therapists committed to showing him that life is still full of possibilities.
Central to his journey is a romance with his hometown sweetheart and interactions with other patients contending with their futures. Despite the love and support from those around him, he faces challenges in tackling personal biases and prejudices emerging from within. He learns valuable lessons about empathy, identity, and resilience, gradually adapting to a world he can no longer see but must now navigate in profoundly different ways. This story of hope and personal growth highlights the courage required to overcome personal adversities while exploring themes of healing and the transformative power of perseverance in finding one’s path to a brighter future.
Writers: Robert Buckner, Baynard Kendrick
Release Date: 01 Aug 1951
Runtime: 97 min
Rating: Approved
Country: United States
Language: English