Claudine Blu-ray Review
Score: 76
from 3 reviewers
Review Date:
With vivid performances and a sharp script, Claudine is a touching 1970s drama revitalized by Criterion's excellent 4K restoration and enriching supplements.
Disc Release Date
Video: 75
This new 4K digital restoration of 'Claudine,' presented in 1080p/AVC, offers excellent contrast, natural skintones, and vibrant colors with a realistic film-like appearance. Heavy but diminishing grain and pristine source material result in the best visual presentation of the film to date.
Audio: 85
The Blu-ray's 1.0 LPCM mix delivers clear, well-balanced sound with crisp dialogue, rich soundtrack fidelity featuring Curtis Mayfield and Gladys Knight, and minimal distortive elements, making it the best audio presentation for 'Claudine' on home video.
Extra: 60
The Blu-ray extras for 'Claudine' offer a rich exploration of the film's legacy, featuring insightful commentary from cast members, in-depth interviews including Robert Townsend discussing the film’s impact and director John Berry's career, and a 1974 seminar with Diahann Carroll, enhancing the historical and cultural context.
Movie: 83
Claudine deftly combines family drama, light comedy, and social critique, with standout performances from Diahann Carroll and James Earl Jones. Director John Berry and writers Tina and Lester Pine deliver an authentic and impactful narrative on welfare struggles, black identity, and 1970s Harlem, complemented by Curtis Mayfield’s soulful soundtrack.
Video: 75
The new 4K digital restoration of "Claudine," encoded in AVC with a 1.85:1 aspect ratio, delivers satisfactory clarity and a commendable film-like appearance. Textured facial surfaces, dimensional apartment visits, and characteristic urban city shots are consistently well-represented. The costuming appears fibrous and colors saturated, foregrounding the 1970s orange and brown hues while also featuring vibrant primary colors in clothing and decorations. Despite Criterion’s characteristic teal tint affecting blue skies and welfare office walls, skintones remain natural throughout. Grain, while heavy and occasionally processed, diminishes over the film's runtime, maintaining a satisfying authenticity. The source material is in excellent condition, free from significant scratches, dirt, or tears.
The 1080p/AVC MPEG-4 rendering offers excellent contrast and clarity, enhancing fine details and depth. Rich blacks anchor the image convincingly, whites are crisp, and shadow delineation is robust. Bold colors such as reds and greens exhibit a lush quality, and the orange hues intrinsic to the era’s decor exude a pleasing sheen. Notably, Diahann Carroll’s complexion is captured beautifully, with stable and natural flesh tones showcased in numerous close-ups. The pristine print exhibits minimal errant marks and no digital anomalies detract from the viewing experience. This transfer of "Claudine" substantially upgrades the visuals while preserving the essential urban grit pivotal to the film's atmosphere. This release, surpassing previous home video versions, stands as the definitive representation of the movie.
Audio: 85
The audio presentation of "Claudine" on Blu-Ray showcases a meticulously remastered 1.0 LPCM soundtrack, remastered from the original 35 mm magnetic tracks. The result is an emotionally urgent mix that excels in delivering crisp and clear dialogue exchanges. The sonic fidelity enables dynamic interactions and argumentative scenes to remain comfortable, avoiding any distortive extremes. Ambient sounds effectively convey the busy atmosphere of urban living, from hectic apartment activities to office commotion, enhancing the film's environmental realism.
The soundtrack, featuring an array of Curtis Mayfield songs performed by Gladys Knight and the Pips, is a standout aspect. With exceptional depth of tone and brilliant clarity, the music transports listeners, capturing the full dynamic scale from rich instrumentals to powerful vocals without any distortion. The audio track meticulously prioritizes dialogue, ensuring it remains easily comprehensible amidst various sonic accents like car horns and sirens. Notably, the transfer is devoid of age-related hiss, pops, or crackles, offering a pristine listening experience. This PCM track represents a significant improvement over previous releases, making it the definitive audio presentation for "Claudine."
Extras: 60
The Blu-ray edition of "Claudine" offers a robust selection of extras that provide valuable context and further appreciation of this classic film. The commentary track, featuring actors Diahann Carroll, James Earl Jones, and Lawrence Hilton-Jacobs alongside filmmaker George Tillman Jr. and Dan Pine, provides insightful reflections although some listeners might find the lengthy gaps and narrower actor focus less engaging. Robert Townsend's interview, moderated by Ashley Clark, stands out for its heartfelt recounting of the film's impact on Townsend's career and its relatable portrayal of urban life. Additionally, the audio interview with Diahann Carroll sheds light on her early career and the challenges she faced, enhancing understanding of her substantial contributions to the film. Finally, Imogen Sara Smith's piece on director John Berry offers a fascinating retrospective on his career and the adversities he overcame, rounding out a comprehensive extras package.
Extras included in this disc:
- Commentary: Insightful reflections from actors, filmmaker, and screenwriter's son.
- Interview with Robert Townsend: Discusses the film's impact and significance.
- Audio Excerpts from AFI Seminar: Diahann Carroll shares her career insights and "Claudine" experiences.
- Uncovering John Berry: Critic Imogen Sara Smith examines the director's career.
- Booklet: Contains an essay by Danielle A. Jackson.
Movie: 83
"Claudine," directed by John Berry and released in 1974, stands out among the era's cinematic landscape by providing a heartfelt exploration of African-American life that diverges sharply from the prevalent blaxploitation genre. The film, scripted by Tina and Lester Pine, centers on Claudine Price (Diahann Carroll), a single mother of six, who balances welfare dependency and work as a housecleaner, all while managing a burgeoning romance with Rupert "Roop" Marshall (James Earl Jones), a sanitation worker. Imbued with both humor and drama, "Claudine" navigates through significant social issues such as welfare, black identity, and family dynamics without descending into melodrama or preachiness.
The narrative unfolds within Claudine's cramped Harlem apartment, which director Berry presents as a microcosm of chaotic familial life. Carroll delivers an Oscar-nominated performance, capturing the exasperation and resilience of a mother striving to maintain her sanity amidst incessant welfare inspections and the challenges posed by her children's varying needs. Jones complements her with a layered portrayal of Roop, who battles his own demons while seeking solace in his relationship with Claudine. The supporting cast, including Lawrence Hilton-Jacobs and Tamu Blackwell as Claudine's older children, adds depth to the story, highlighting the intersectional struggles of black family life during the 1970s.
What elevates "Claudine" is its refusal to adhere to easy clichés. The film’s gritty yet uplifting spirit is further buoyed by Curtis Mayfield’s soulful soundtrack performed by Gladys Knight and the Pips, enriching the narrative's emotional texture. Through vivid characterizations and a sharp screenplay, "Claudine" renders an authentic portrayal of love and survival. This blend of social commentary and personal narrative continues to resonate today, marking "Claudine" as a crucial cinematic work that addresses both historical and ongoing societal issues while celebrating familial bonds and resilience.
Total: 76
Criterion's Blu-ray release of "Claudine" is nothing short of spectacular, offering a brand new 4K restoration that vividly enhances the film's visual and emotional landscape. This 1974 classic, directed by John Berry, is both a social commentary and a romantic comedy, bringing to life the story of Claudine Price, a single mother navigating the challenges of raising six children in Harlem. The performances by James Earl Jones and an Oscar-nominated Diahann Carroll are particularly noteworthy, blending the film's theatrical elements with genuine emotional depth. The essence of dissatisfaction and resilience is keenly captured, complemented by Curtis Mayfield's excellent soundtrack, which seamlessly manages mood and enriches the storytelling.
The audio quality is equally solid, ensuring that every nuance of dialogue and musical score is crystal clear. Criterion has also included a range of compelling supplements that provide additional context and enhance the viewing experience. From behind-the-scenes footage to insightful commentaries, these extras offer a deeper look into the film’s cultural and historical significance. The restoration work done by Criterion is remarkable, rescuing this gem from obscurity and presenting it in a format that does justice to its original intent and brilliance.
While the screenplay offers many subplots, it's the performances that keep "Claudine" fascinating, watching Carroll and Jones embrace the acting challenge, juggling the theatrical nature of the screenplay and the abyssal feelings the lead characters struggle to process. The picture has a vivid understanding of dissatisfaction, though Berry remains committed to providing something sweet to go along with all the aggravation, managing mood with an excellent soundtrack (written by Curtis Mayfield) and scenes of tenderness. Even at its most artificial, "Claudine" feels real, addressing issues and identifying resilience with interesting sharpness. Criterion's Blu-ray release is an essential upgrade for any film enthusiast or collector. Highly recommended.
Blu-ray.com review by Brian OrndorfRead review here
Video: 70
Colors are vibrant, dealing with period hues which favor orange and brown, while more direct primaries emerge on clothing and decorations....
Audio: 100
The 1.0 LPCM mix secures the emotional urgency of "Claudine," delivering crisp dialogue exchanges, while argumentative behavior remains comfortable, never slipping into distortive extremes....
Extras: 80
"Uncovering John Berry" (19:54, HD) is an appreciation piece from critic Imogen Sara Smith, who details the subject's experiences as a young man in New York, working his way to the stage, soon joining...
Movie: 90
There's a wild level of agitation overseen by director John Berry, who generate an exact understanding of Claudine's headspace as she juggles responsibilities and concerns, including her welfare status,...
Total: 80
While the screenplay offers many subplots, it's the performances that keep "Claudine" fascinating, watching Carroll and Jones embrace the acting challenge, juggling the theatrical nature of the screenplay...
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 80
Excellent contrast and clarity highlight fine details and heighten depth, and bold colors lend the picture a fair degree of pizzazz....
Audio: 80
Terrific fidelity and depth of tone bring the vocals and instrumentals (Mayfield also scored the movie) to brilliant life, and a wide dynamic scale handles all the highs and lows without a hint of distortion....
Extras: 40
No Strings, her groundbreaking part in the TV sitcom Julia, and her experiences on Claudine, including how she became the character, her loves scenes with Jones, her respect for director John Berry, and...
Movie: 80
Though this smart, sensitive film about a twice-divorced mother of six who lives in a tiny New York City ghetto apartment may lack the flash of the street-wise blaxploitation flicks that flooded theaters...
Total: 80
Director John Berry's film about a single mother, her rowdy brood, and the strapping sanitation worker who steals her heart addresses some potent themes within the rom-com format and features excellent...
Home Theater Forum review by t1g3r5fanRead review here
Video: 100
Film grain is organic throughout, with the color palette and fine details represented faithfully; there’s little to no problems like scratches, dirt, dust or tears present....
Audio: 100
Dialogue is strong and clear, with sound effects and the soulful Curtis Mayfield score – performed by Gladys Knight and the Pips – both given equally faithful representations as well; there’s very little...
Extras: 70
Commentary with actors Diahann Carroll, James Earl Jones, Lawrence Hilton-Jacobs, filmmaker George Tillman Jr. and Dan Pine, son of screenwriters Lester & Tina Pine – Carried over from the Fox DVD, the...
Movie: 90
Among the children here, one of the two standouts here include Lawrence Hilton-Jacobs as Charles, who’s both resistant to his mother’s relationship with Roop and a bit embarrassed by his living in poverty;...
Total: 80
A success with both critics and audiences, Claudine is a social conscience drama with comedic touches that’s all heart and soul....
Director: John Berry
Actors: Diahann Carroll, James Earl Jones, Lawrence Hilton-Jacobs
PlotClaudine Price, a single mother of six children, works as a housekeeper in Harlem to support her family. Struggling to make ends meet, she contends with the complexities and frustrations of navigating the welfare system. Her life takes a turn when she meets Rupert "Roop" Marshall, a jovial and hardworking garbage collector with his own share of responsibilities and past relationships. Their budding romance faces numerous obstacles, not least of which are Claudine's protective children and the intrusive welfare authorities, who scrutinize every aspect of her personal life.
As Claudine and Rupert grow closer, they confront the societal pressures and systemic challenges that impact their lives and relationship. Claudine's children have mixed reactions to Rupert's presence, reflecting their own fears and uncertainties about change. The film explores themes of love, dignity, and resilience amidst poverty, as Claudine strives to provide a better future for her family while finding personal happiness in her bond with Rupert. Throughout their journey, humor and warmth interweave with the serious issues they face, painting a poignant picture of life and love in the face of adversity.
Writers: Tina Pine, Lester Pine
Release Date: 14 Sep 1974
Runtime: 92 min
Rating: PG
Country: United States
Language: English