Some Came Running Blu-ray Review

"Some Came Running" on Blu-ray is a testament to Warner Archive's commitment to preserving the original cinematic experience through high-quality home video presentations. The film’s Technicolor cinematography is beautifully translated with a 1080p transfer that gives justice to both fine detail and the authentic texture of film grain. The Metrocolor palette is effectively showcased, presenting viewers with a frequently breathtaking clarity that highlights the vivid, dramatic hues, especially during the iconic final sequence at Parkman's centennial fair. This particular scene, now crisp and vibrant compared to previous releases, stands out for its intense rainbow-colored lights and a powerful red hue that accentuates the building tension. While a few instances of posterization can be noted, these are minimal distractions in an otherwise outstanding visual presentation.

The faithful rendering of the Cinemascope aspect ratio at 2.40:1 ensures an immersive viewing experience, utilizing the AVC codec to provide sharp and vibrant image quality. The transfer addresses potential issues with Metrocolor by managing Shayne MacLaine’s pronounced makeup elements and the striking colors used throughout key scenes, such as the town carnival climax. With 36 chapters encompassing the film, viewers have an easy method for navigating through this visually captivating journey. Overall, this Blu-ray transfers "Some Came Running" with an admirable emphasis on illustrative details and engaging color dynamics, making it a near-flawless visual treat for any classic cinema enthusiast.

The Blu-ray audio presentation of "Some Came Running," encoded in 2.0 mono via DTS-HD Master Audio, maintains a high standard of clarity, effectively delivering dialogue and background effects. Despite originating from a four-track stereo source, the transition to a lossless mono format allows for a clean and smooth auditory experience. Dialogue is particularly well-rendered, crucial for a film abundant in conversational scenes. The mix, though limited by its mono constraints, manages to sidestep age-related issues such as hiss, crackle, or pops, offering a commendable experience for a film of its era.

Despite these strengths, the compressed mono mix somewhat undercuts the potential richness of Elmer Bernstein's score and more action-driven scenes. These elements likely suffer in breadth and dynamic impact, which a true stereo track might have enhanced. Some listeners may find the split one-channel presentation to restrain the film's more vibrant soundscapes, occasionally leading to a cramped auditory environment for pivotal moments.

A notable oversight in the Blu-ray release is the absence of English (SDH) subtitles for bonus content. While available during the main feature, their exclusion from supplementary materials marks a regression from previous editions. Consequently, this edition could benefit from the addition of optional subtitles across all its features to enhance accessibility and comprehension for all viewers. Overall, while the setup largely serves its purpose well within these limitations, expanding subtitle support and reintroducing stereo elements could significantly elevate the listening experience for audiences.

The Blu Ray extras for "Some Came Running" offer viewers a compelling glimpse into the film’s historical and cinematic context. "The Story of Some Came Running," a 20-minute featurette, provides an engaging albeit somewhat superficial retrospective with insights from film historians and experts such as Drew Casper, Dana Polan, and Peter Travers. This segment examines the film's production nuances, impactful cinematography, and the cultural resonance of both the film and its source novel by James Jones. While it lacks deep analytical detail, it remains an informative piece worth viewing. Additionally, the original Theatrical Trailer, available in high definition, enhances the nostalgic appeal of the extras package.

Extras included in this disc:

• The Story of Some Came Running: Insightful retrospective with various film historians discussing the film's significance.
• Theatrical Trailer: Original promotional piece presented in HD.

Vincente Minnelli's "Some Came Running" offers a visceral exploration of post-war America's societal constraints through its narrative and character portrayals, distinguishing it as a complex cinematic piece. Adapted from James Jones' extensive novel, the film juxtaposes melodramatic storytelling against technically adept cinematography. The story follows Army veteran Dave Hirsh, portrayed by Frank Sinatra, who returns to the rigid environment of his Indiana hometown after a 16-year absence. The film critiques small-town America through its settings and relationships, notably focusing on Dave's interactions with figures like card hustler Bama Dillert (Dean Martin) and free-spirited Ginny Moorehead (Shirley MacLaine).

While Minnelli's direction successfully emphasizes the atmosphere of repressed emotions and outdated societal norms, the film suffers from uneven pacing and occasionally overblown dramatics. The adaptation by John Patrick and Arthur Sheekman skillfully highlights the town's gossip-driven culture against the backdrop of a slowly evolving post-war ideological landscape. Although the screenplay sometimes falters with its melodrama, the cast delivers several memorable performances. Sinatra's portrayal of Hirsh is intense, capturing a fractured psyche searching for purpose beyond societal judgment. MacLaine provides a nuanced depiction of Ginny, balancing vulnerability and resilience, which earned her an Oscar nomination. Similarly, Dean Martin's performance adds depth to the film's commentary on freedom versus conformity.

Despite its ambitious thematic canvas, "Some Came Running" is not without flaws. The film pays homage to its phenomenal cast with arresting sequences—especially the climactic moments where Minnelli's directorial style flourishes. However, the narrative is occasionally bogged down by its attempts to condense the novel's breadth into 136 minutes. Minnelli skillfully uses static long takes to reflect the town's suppressive nature, punctuated by dynamic sequences that heighten tension as danger threatens the protagonists. Ultimately, while the film exhibits commendable technical prowess and engaging character performances, its narrative cohesion remains inconsistent.

Vincente Minnelli's "Some Came Running" presents a visually striking and emotionally engaging narrative set against the backdrop of post-war American society. While the film's storyline, populated by mostly unlikable characters entrenched in the soapiness of melodrama, might polarize audiences, there is no denying the compelling craftsmanship in its widescreen cinematography. Minnelli's adept use of framing and color contributes significantly to the film’s visual appeal, creating a vivid viewing experience. Despite the mixed reception due to its character-driven narrative and thematic musings, the committed performances provide moments of genuine connection.

The Warner Archive Blu-ray of "Some Came Running" significantly enhances the film's aesthetic qualities through an impressive 1080p transfer. This high-definition presentation showcases Minnelli’s directorial flair with remarkable clarity and detail, bringing out the vibrant color palette that underscores the film’s tonal shifts. Accompanying the stellar visual quality are several thoughtful bonus features from the DVD era, serving as insightful supplements for enthusiasts and new viewers alike. This release effectively captures the intended artistic vision, allowing audiences to appreciate the nuances of this classic drama.

In conclusion, "Some Came Running" on Blu-ray is an essential acquisition for established fans and a recommended viewing for those intrigued by its socio-cultural commentary and visual style. While newcomers may wish to test the waters before committing to purchase due to the film's unique narrative stance, the technical excellence of this Blu-ray edition ensures it provides an optimal viewing experience for all who venture into its melodramatic yet aesthetically captivating world.