Scott Pilgrim vs. the World Blu-ray Review

Universal's Blu-ray of "Scott Pilgrim vs. the World" delivers a visually impressive, though occasionally inconsistent, viewing experience. The 1080p AVC-encoded transfer offers high level detail, razor sharpness, and precise definition that accurately captures lifelike textures. Fine rendering is notably clear throughout most scenes, enhancing the film’s vibrancy. Colors are generally lavish and eye-popping, with oversaturated primaries and warm tonality, though some reviewers noted instances where they appeared slightly muted compared to the original theatrical presentation. Black levels are impressive, particularly when backgrounds fade into an inky void, highlighting the deep contrast.

The intentional stylistic choices made during production, such as low-fi visual effects and post-processed elements, are retained in this transfer. These aspects contribute to an overall lo-fi aesthetic, which aligns with the film’s artistic direction. Earlier scenes featuring special effects, like the inventive CGI and wire work, are effectively rendered. Shadow detail adds significant depth in low lighting sequences, with only occasional softness due to inherent photographic techniques rather than any transfer issues.

Although some viewers mentioned an absence of the 'HD oomph' in fine details such as facial textures, the delineation remains appreciable. Despite the subdued color palette compared to its theatrical run, natural grain is maintained, avoiding any compression artifacts or noise. The disc handles digital anomalies like banding and aliasing proficiently, presenting a clean image free from unintended visual disruptions. Overall, while this Blu-ray presentation may not fully capture the theatrical vibrancy, it remains a technically strong and visually engaging representation, sure to satisfy most videophiles and fans of the film.

Scott Pilgrim vs. the World's DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 mix is a veritable showcase of audio excellence. This powerful and dynamic mix transforms the film into an immersive aural experience, meticulously utilizing the entire sound system to create a theater-like atmosphere. Sound staging is remarkably executed, with seamless integration of front and rear channels. The soundtrack is a riot of activity with foley effects continuously pinging around the surround channels, providing a captivating and engaging environment. Crucially, despite the overwhelming variety of sound effects catapulting from side to side, the dialogue maintains clarity and presence, ensuring all verbal interactions are distinct and well-defined.

The auditory presentation truly shines during the action-packed fight sequences, where sound effects briskly traverse the room. The mix's aggressive nature makes regular and effective use of the subwoofer, delivering tactile low bass impact that resonates with clean, deep energy. The floor-rattling LFE, particularly during scenes like the bass battle between Scott and Todd, is impactful yet does not overpower the rest of the sound spectrum. The music is equally impressive, with stellar fidelity across all frequencies, enriching the listening experience with bass-thumping techno beats and crystal-clear musical numbers.

Surround activity is thoughtfully employed, such as in club scenes where ambient sounds bristle with life while crucial dialogue remains intact. The directionality of sound effects and dialogue is spot-on, with out-of-frame characters' voices effectively contributing to the immersive experience. This presentation's dynamism ensures that both subtle and bombastic elements are delivered with precision and clarity. Overall, this DTS-HD Master Audio track warrants high praise for its inventiveness and execution, making it a prime candidate for demo-worthy material in any serious home theater setup.

The extras section of the "Scott Pilgrim vs. the World" Blu Ray is a comprehensive and meticulous collection that provides an in-depth look into the making, creative process, and fun behind-the-scenes moments of the film. Notable among the features are four distinct audio commentaries, each offering unique perspectives—from director Edgar Wright and co-writers to cast members in varying configurations. The Feature and Technical Commentaries are particularly insightful, delving into the nuances of adaptation, cinematography, and directorial vision. The disc also includes 21 deleted or extended scenes with optional commentary, richly documenting the film’s editing choices. Various pre-production materials and music promos further enhance the viewer's understanding of the film's development. Additional highlights include a gag reel, a music featurette, and a trivia track that elucidates numerous hidden references.

Extras included in this disc:

Feature commentary: With Edgar Wright, Michael Bacall, and Bryan Lee O'Malley. Technical commentary: With Edgar Wright and Bill Pope. Cast commentary (1): With Michael Cera, Jason Schwartzman, Mary Elizabeth Winstead, Ellen Wong, Brandon Routh. Cast commentary (2): With Anna Kendrick, Aubrey Plaza, Kiernan Culkin, Mark Webber. Deleted/extended scenes: 21 scenes with optional commentary by Edgar Wright. Scott Pilgrim vs. the bloopers: A collection of humorous outtakes. Making of Scott Pilgrim vs. the World: Two segments detailing behind-the-scenes work. Music featurette: Shows actors rehearsing and recording. You too can be Sex bob-omb: A brief guitar tutorial by Mark Webber. Alternative footage: Scene edits, bits and pieces, and outtakes. Pre-production footage: Animatics, rehearsal videos, casting tapes, props, and hair/make-up tests. Music promos: Music videos and Osymso remixes. Visual effects: Comparisons of before & after footage with commentary. Soundworks collection: Profile on sound for film. Adult swim: Animated short. Scott Pilgrim vs. the censors: Re-looped dialogue with censored content. Blogs, Galleries, Trivia track, Trailers, My Scenes bookmark feature, BD-Live, D-Box Motion Code, Pocket Blu, Universal's U-Control, Digital Copy, Bonus DVD.

"Scott Pilgrim vs. the World" is a surreal, genre-defying film crafted by the imaginative Edgar Wright, who previously directed "Shaun of the Dead" and "Hot Fuzz." Based on Bryan Lee O'Malley's graphic novel series, this movie merges elements from alt-rock, anime, and video game culture into an idiosyncratic narrative. Michael Cera stars as Scott Pilgrim, a 22-year-old musician with the band Sex Bob-omb, who falls head over heels for Ramona Flowers (Mary Elizabeth Winstead). However, the relationship can't progress until Scott defeats her seven evil exes in video game-style battles. This sets up a series of whimsically absurd combat scenes featuring everything from a martial artist summoning fireball-throwing demon chicks to vegan rock stars with psychic powers. The movie’s refusal to adhere to conventional genre boundaries is both its greatest strength and a potential stumbling block for older viewers who may find its exuberant silliness overwhelming.

Technically, "Scott Pilgrim vs. the World" is a marvel of inventive filmmaking. Wright's clever direction employs an array of visual tricks and special effects—such as characters exploding into video game coins or the seamless transitions between different locations within a single scene—that keep the viewer engaged. Onscreen depictions of sound effects, reminiscent of 1960s Batman TV show aesthetics, accompany everything from fight sequences to everyday sounds like ringing phones. Performances are uniformly stellar with Cera embodying the quirky charm of Scott, while Winstead and Ellen Wong energize their roles through dynamic portrayals of Ramona and Scott's other love interest, Knives Chau. The supporting cast, including Kieran Culkin as Scott’s roommate Wallace and Alison Pill as his cynical ex-girlfriend Kim, deliver pitch-perfect comedic performances that enliven the narrative.

Though it didn’t achieve box office success during its initial theatrical release, "Scott Pilgrim vs. the World" has garnered a devoted cult following in the aftermarket, much like a modern-day "Rocky Horror Picture Show." This proliferation suggests the film resonates deeply with its target audience - predominantly those steeped in video game and geek culture. Backed by electrifying visuals, clever writing, and an unapologetically eccentric approach to storytelling, "Scott Pilgrim vs. the World" offers a fresh reprieve from the standard fare occupying cineplex screens and is likely to remain a favorite among its core demographic for years to come.

"Scott Pilgrim vs. The World" on Blu-ray is an outstanding testament to Edgar Wright's visionary direction and storytelling. The film, which combines elements of comic books, video games, and indie rock culture, provides a distinctive cinematic experience. Michael Cera leads a talented ensemble cast, delivering a performance marked by charm and wit amidst a whirlwind of visual and auditory creativity. Wright’s direction amplifies this unique blend, making it a highly engaging watch. The high-octane action sequences are interlaced with clever writing and humor, keeping viewers thoroughly entertained.

Technically, the Blu-ray presentation of "Scott Pilgrim vs. The World" is impressive, though not without minor flaws. The video quality does not fully capture the vibrant color palette seen in theaters, presenting a somewhat dimmer visual experience. However, the audio quality more than compensates, providing an immersive soundscape that will reverberate through any home theater setup. The bass is powerful during action scenes and musical segments, capturing the essence of the film’s dynamic soundtrack and energetic sequences.

The bonus content on this release is exhaustive and worthwhile. With four commentaries—particularly those featuring Edgar Wright—and a plethora of special features including a trivia track and storyboard PiP feature, fans are given comprehensive insights into the film’s creation. This collection stands out as one of the most content-rich packages available, ensuring that both newcomers and longtime followers find value.

In conclusion, despite minor video presentation issues, "Scott Pilgrim vs. The World" on Blu-ray is highly recommended for its exceptional audio quality, extensive special features, and above all, its unique and compelling storytelling. This release captures the heart and whimsy of the film, making it a must-own for anyone looking to experience a cinematic adventure that's as daring as it is entertaining.