My Girl Blu-ray Review
Score: 61
from 3 reviewers
Review Date:
"My Girl" on Blu-ray combines a wonderful 4K master, fine DTS-HD track, and strong performances to deliver a heartfelt story that holds up remarkably well.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 73
My Girl's 4K mastered 1080p Blu-ray delivers exquisite detail and organic, filmic texture with medium-density grain. Colors are lively despite a slightly warm palette, while shadows occasionally suffer from blue/purple hues. Overall, a striking and well-defined high-definition presentation from Sony.
Audio: 57
My Girl's DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 track offers clear dialogue and balanced ambient effects, though it's not particularly dynamic or powerful, fitting the film's gentle nature without aggressive use of surround channels.
Extra: 37
The Blu-ray extras for 'My Girl' include a well-articulated commentary by writer Laurice Elehwany, insightful background on specific scenes through short featurettes, an original behind-the-scenes snippet, and a theatrical trailer. While valuable, the absence of retrospectives is noted.
Movie: 80
"My Girl" on Blu-ray offers a timeless coming-of-age narrative, intricately exploring themes of life, death, and growth, driven by Anna Chlumsky's compelling performance, Dan Aykroyd's solid dramatic turn, and Jamie Lee Curtis's nuanced role, all under the sensitive direction of Howard Zieff.
Video: 73
The Blu-ray release of "My Girl," mastered in 4K and presented in 1080p HD, delivers an impressive visual experience, marred only by a few minor imperfections. The film maintains an organic, medium-density grain structure throughout, adding an authentic, film-quality texture. Detail is exquisitely captured, providing natural sharpness and rich image clarity in every scene. Textures such as concrete, brickwork, clothing, and faces exhibit excellent definition. Although colors are slightly muted with a warm palette, certain scenes—like a grocery store produce section and an American flag—exhibit lively and rich hues. Flesh tones tend to appear warm and rosy, yet remain mostly accurate.
Despite these strengths, there are some concerns with black levels. Dark scenes occasionally become overpowering and may display a purple or noisy tint, particularly noticeable later in the film during the carnival scene. This inconsistency could possibly be attributed to the source elements rather than the transfer process itself. Less shadowy moments earlier in the film appear more balanced and true to life. Overall, however, "My Girl" offers a strikingly beautiful high-definition presentation that respects its original filmic integrity. This release does much to retain the movie's period charm and visual appeal, making it a fine testament to Sony's mastering efforts.
Audio: 57
The DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 lossless soundtrack on "My Girl" is an adequately satisfying presentation that suits the film's needs. While it's not particularly aggressive or revelatory in its delivery, the audio quality remains serviceable. The soundtrack is characterized by balanced back-channel support, and the mix features light ambient sounds like daytime children at play and nocturnal insects, which are impressive in placement and relative distance. Notably, a few well-executed directional effects and a buzzing swarm of bees add a sense of energy and space to the mix. Dialogue is centrally focused and cleanly delivered, ensuring the clarity of speech throughout the film.
The inclusion of surround channels in this DTS-HD MA 5.1 track provides a reasonable auditory experience but lacks significant immersiveness. The score by James Newton Howard is sweetly nostalgic, though its musical impact can feel slightly limp at times. The low frequency extension is subtle, rarely making its presence felt except during certain soundtrack choices. Levels are consistently balanced and free from distortion, while the imaging serviceably fits the film's non-action-oriented scenes. Additional multilingual surround tracks -- including Portuguese, French, Italian, German, Spanish, and Japanese -- are present, expanding accessibility.
Overall, while this audio presentation won’t blow listeners away with dynamic soundscapes or powerful effects, it adequately meets the requirements of the film. It maintains appropriate balance between dialogue, environmental sounds, and music, ensuring viewers can comfortably engage with this heartfelt story.
Extras: 37
The Blu-ray extras for "My Girl" provide a robust assortment of supplementary content, appealing to both casual viewers and dedicated fans. The Audio Commentary by Writer Laurice Elehwany stands out as a particularly insightful feature, delving into the film's conception, personal inspirations, casting choices, and thematic elements with a refreshing perspective that deviates from typical director-led tracks. The A Day on the Set segments, though brief, offer fascinating glimpses into the production process of specific scenes. The Original Behind the Scenes Featurette serves as a nostalgic throwback with its vintage EPK-style presentation, which is both informative and a stark reminder of the advancements in filming technology. Additionally, viewers can appreciate the inclusion of the Theatrical Trailer and a voucher for a UV digital copy for modern viewing convenience.
Extras included in this disc:
- Audio Commentary with Writer Laurice Elehwany: In-depth insights into the film and Elehwany’s personal experiences.
- A Day on the Set: Brief on-set footage for two key scenes.
- Original Behind the Scenes Featurette: Vintage making-of content.
- Theatrical Trailer: Original trailer in HD.
- UV Digital Copy of the Film: Voucher included for digital access.
Movie: 80
"My Girl" stands as a poignant coming-of-age film, deftly handling themes of life, death, and growth with both maturity and sensitivity. Directed by Howard Zieff and penned by Laurice Elehwany, this 1991 classic navigates complex emotional terrain through the experiences of its protagonist, Vada Sultenfuss (Anna Chlumsky). Set in the summer of 1972, the story revolves around Vada's life in a small-town funeral parlor operated by her widowed father Harry (Dan Aykroyd). With close friend Thomas J. (Macaulay Culkin) at her side, Vada grapples with her preoccupation with death—a theme vividly compounded by her living environment and personal losses. Yet, despite the film's heavy themes, it radiates an uplifting spirit, showcasing the resilience of youth.
At its core, the film is carried by strong performances. Anna Chlumsky's portrayal of Vada is remarkable, capturing the character’s internal conflicts and curiosity with authenticity. Dan Aykroyd shines as Harry, bringing warmth and empathy to his role as a father navigating his daughter's emotional complexities. Jamie Lee Curtis adds a layer of romantic and maternal dynamic as Shelly, the new make-up artist at the funeral home who becomes entwined with Harry. Macaulay Culkin, though in a relatively limited role, offers a charming and endearing performance that remains pivotal to the narrative. The film's technical execution, including an evocative score and period-appropriate set design, further immerses viewers into its nostalgic early 70s setting.
"My Girl" is not simply another "coming-of-age" movie; it’s a nuanced exploration of a young girl's journey through life's inevitable challenges and joys. The film balances innocence with the gravity of its themes, making it both emotionally resonant and compelling. The cinematography is understated yet effective, complementing the narrative's flow, while the music underscores key emotional beats. Through its honest storytelling and rich character development, "My Girl" remains a timeless piece that appeals across generations.
Total: 61
Sony’s Blu-ray release of "My Girl" proves to be a well-crafted presentation of this timeless film. The story is heartfelt and good-natured yet grapples with themes of loss, life, and death through the eyes of a young girl. The movie's strength lies in its rich understanding of life's complexities and its ability to address them openly and honestly. The film features stellar performances from its leads, making it both a poignant and entertaining watch. Despite the serious undertones, "My Girl" remains accessible and genuinely reflective of life's realities.
Technically, the Blu-ray offers an impressive 4K master, providing sharp visuals that enhance the viewing experience. The video quality is robust, maintaining clarity and detail throughout. Accompanied by a fine DTS-HD track, the audio ensures immersive sound quality that complements the film's atmospheric storytelling. Though the supplementary features are somewhat limited, the overall quality of the presentation compensates for this shortfall.
In conclusion, "My Girl" tells a timeless story with grace and beauty, effectively capturing the complexities of life through a child’s perspective. Combined with high-quality performances and solid technical execution, Sony's Blu-ray release stands as a highly recommended addition to any film collection. It’s a testament to the film medium's ability to explore challenging narratives with nuance and accessibility.
Blu-ray.com review by Martin LiebmanRead review here
Video: 90
Still, the picture benefits from lively, rich color presentations, evident where the most robust array of hues appear, notably in a grocery store produce section around the 52-minute mark and moments later...
Audio: 70
There are a few good directional effects as well, while a couple of heavier elements, like a buzzing swarm of bees, play with an adequate sense of energy and space....
Extras: 40
Audio Commentary: Writer Laurice Elehwany offers a nicely spoken track in which she discusses getting the film out of the gate and her career as a writer, the original title, the film's setting, real life...
Movie: 90
Macaulay Culkin is good in a somewhat limited role in terms of screen time, not importance to the story, but the movie belongs to then-newcomer Anna Chlumsky who hits a home run with a fully agreeable,...
Total: 70
Combined with high quality performances from every lead, My Girl ranks as not only one of the better movies of 1991 but a testament to the film medium's ability to so finely yet accessibly explore even...
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 80
It’s an intermittent effect as shot to shot it can change, which makes me wonder if that isn't a part of the source elements rather than a transfer issue....
Audio: 60
This just isn’t an action packed movie with a lot of sound effects to clutter the mix other than ambient sounds here and there to fit the scene....
Extras: 40
It’s a nice commentary track all around, she discusses the background of the film, writing it, and it’s basis on experiences she had growing up in small town Pennsylvania....
Movie: 80
Through it all her father, Dan Aykroyd, does what he can to help the girl, believing this obsession is just part of a phase....
Total: 60
Going into this review for Sony’s Blu-ray release of ‘My Girl’ I was worried my fond memories of the movie wouldn’t hold up well and this would be another case of nostalgia gone awry....
Why So Blu? review by Aaron NeuwirthRead review here
Video: 90
Audio: 80
Hearing the soundtrack, the sound effects, the dialogue, and the ambient noise mixed together is quite nice, as far as the balance goes....
Extras: 40
Features Include:Audio Commentary with Writer Laurice Elehwany – Lots of good tidbits of information concerning the film, which was nice to hear....
Movie: 80
She has since grown up, received a proper education, and now stars on the acclaimed HBO comedy Veep, but it is nice to see how at a young age, Chlumsky had the chops to not only play a cute kid, but one...
Total: 70
That said, My Girl has a lot more drama associated with it and the film manages to navigate those areas quite well, while also work as a strong piece of entertainment....
Director: Howard Zieff
Actors: Anna Chlumsky, Macaulay Culkin, Dan Aykroyd
PlotVada Sultenfuss is an 11-year-old girl living in small-town Pennsylvania during the early 1970s. Her mother passed away when she was young, and she grows up with her father Harry who runs a funeral parlor out of their home. Vada is a curious and imaginative girl who often feels neglected due to her father's preoccupation with his work. She spends most of her time with her best friend, Thomas J. Sennett, a boy around her age who is allergic to almost everything. Vada is also struggling with her own fears, particularly of death, stemming from the environment she lives in and the traumatic loss of her mother.
As Vada navigates the complexities of adolescence, she forms a unique bond with Shelly, a cosmetologist who begins working for Harry and eventually becomes romantically involved with him. This new relationship forces Vada to confront her feelings about change and attachment. Throughout the summer, Vada contends with her father's budding romance, her own developing emotions and relationships, and the inevitable shifts that come with growing up. The story captures Vada's coming-of-age journey as she grapples with love, loss, and understanding the world around her.
Writers: Laurice Elehwany
Release Date: 27 Nov 1991
Runtime: 102 min
Rating: PG
Country: United States
Language: English