The Climbers Blu-ray Review
Qomolangma 攀登者
Score: 66
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
The Climbers offers thrilling climbing sequences and solid technical merits, albeit weighed down by melodrama and nationalistic overtones.
Disc Release Date
Video: 81
The Climbers, presented in an AVC encoded 1080p transfer at 2.39:1, showcases exceptional close-up shots and razor-sharp detail, despite minor banding and slightly impressionistic CGI effects. Captured with RED cameras up to an 8K source, the 2K DI finish delivers demo-worthy visuals, especially in aerial shots.
Audio: 81
The Climbers' DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 Mandarin track delivers an engaging and immersive experience, with fierce windstorms and avalanches creating dynamic, expansive soundscapes that perfectly balance with clear, intelligible dialogue throughout.
Extra: 16
Extras include concise 'Behind the Scenes' clips featuring Wu Jing and Zhang Ziyi, and two trailers, all in 1080p. Well Go USA's Blu-ray authoring automatically sequences these features, creating a streamlined viewing experience.
Movie: 56
"The Climbers" offers a visually arresting portrayal of the 1960 and 1975 Chinese ascents of Mount Everest, but its gripping climbing sequences are undermined by heavy-handed nationalism and inartfully woven fictional romances. Its lack of emotional depth and omission of key factual details leave viewers wanting more from this solid yet flawed thriller.
Video: 81
The Blu-ray release of "The Climbers" by Well Go USA offers an impressive visual presentation, rendered in an AVC encoded 1080p transfer with a 2.39:1 aspect ratio. Shot using several variants of RED digital cameras, capturing imagery at a source resolution of up to 8K, the final product was mastered down to 2K due to the extensive use of CGI and special effects. This results in a generally high-quality image, highlighted by exquisite close-up shots and razor-sharp details, particularly on the slopes of Everest. A minor downside includes occasional banding issues and some obvious CGI elements which are not as polished as those seen in major U.S. blockbusters.
The transfer maintains an excellent visual standard, preserving breathtaking actual location photography with remarkable depth of field, especially in aerial shots. While some green-screened backgrounds can appear relatively soft, and certain scenes exhibit CGI snowfall that comes across as impressionistic, these are exceptions rather than the rule. Details on fabrics such as parkas and other hiking gear are rendered with exceptional clarity. Outside the mountainous regions, the film's color palette shifts to a golden tinge, sometimes leading to washed-out blacks. However, once the climbers reach Everest, a cool blue tint prevails, reinforcing the icy and formidable environment. Overall, this Blu-ray encode is highly commendable and stands as a true demo-worthy release.
Audio: 81
The audio presentation of "The Climbers" on Blu-ray is robustly delivered through the DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 Mandarin track, notably absent of any English dubs but supplemented with optional subtitles. This composition seamlessly balances quieter dialogue-driven sequences, especially during the introductory phase of the climb, with dynamic, high-intensity scenes as the narrative progresses. Technical execution shines during the perilous mountain expeditions where Fang's injury serves as a focal auditory experience. Here, the immersive soundscape excels, capturing the roars of fierce storms and the thundering mass of avalanches with an impressive clarity and force.
In high-altitude scenes, notably during the avalanches and tumultuous windstorms, the track's capabilities are fully realized. The winds sweep around the listener with remarkable precision, creating an enveloping sound field that intensifies the viewer's engagement. Bass response is particularly noteworthy, striking deeply during the most dramatic moments to heighten tension. Intelligibility of dialogue remains pristine throughout the entire presentation, ensuring narrative clarity irrespective of the surrounding sonic chaos. Dynamics within the mix are both aggressive and spacious, executing an auditory experience that is as technically proficient as it is thrilling.
Extras: 16
The Blu-ray of "The Climbers" offers a concise yet insightful set of extras that enhance the viewing experience. The main supplements consist of behind-the-scenes segments featuring Wu Jing and Zhang Ziyi, each providing brief yet meaningful insights into their roles and the film's production. Additionally, the disc includes two promotional trailers, although their automatic sequential playback and inclusion of other Well Go USA trailers might feel somewhat intrusive. The auto-play function, while convenient for continuous viewing, might not cater to those who prefer selecting content individually.
Extras included in this disc:
- Behind the Scenes: Wu Jing (1080p; 2:01)
- Behind the Scenes: Zhang Ziyi (1080p; 2:00)
- Trailer A: Promotional content (1080p; 1:20)
- Trailer B: Promotional content (1080p; 2:16)
Movie: 56
"The Climbers" endeavors to bring the harrowing true story of Chinese expeditions to the summit of Mount Everest to the screen, delivering mixed results. The film chronicles both the controversial 1960 ascent, which was criticized internationally for its lack of photographic evidence, and the subsequent 1975 expedition aimed at reclaiming Chinese honor. Led by Fang Wuzhou (Wu Jing), who had also been part of the original attempt, the plot thrusts viewers into a perilous adventure. Despite its gripping premise and visually arresting depictions of nature’s hazard, the movie often falls short in character development, opting to inject fictional romances and nationalistic fervor rather than delving into deeper personal backstories.
The depiction of mountaineering itself is striking, combining intense climbing scenes and impressive action sequences. However, it is occasionally marred by overly obvious CGI effects and somewhat exaggerated scenarios, such as the recurrent avalanches confronting the climbers. The narrative also suffers from a jingoistic slant that seems tailored primarily for Chinese audiences, often sidelining the broader international context of Everest expeditions as well as glossing over significant historical and geopolitical nuances like China's fraught relationship with Tibet.
At a runtime of over two hours, "The Climbers" feels like it has left much on the cutting room floor. The fictionalized romances add little to the story and detract from the central tension of the climb, leaving certain aspects, such as the relationship between Fang Wuzhou and meteorologist Xu Ying (Zhang Ziyi), feeling shallow and unnecessary. A documentary-style approach or a tighter focus on factual events might have served the story better. While not reaching its full dramatic potential, "The Climbers" remains a viscerally compelling portrayal of one of mountaineering history’s remarkable quests.
Total: 66
"The Climbers" is a dynamic portrayal of a historical Everest expedition, capturing the tension and excitement of high-altitude mountaineering. Directed by Daniel Lee and starring Jing Wu, Ziyi Zhang, and the cameo by Jackie Chan, the film focuses on a China-led ascent of Everest, immersing viewers in both the perilous climbs and the human stories driving them. Despite its gripping action sequences, the narrative sometimes gets bogged down by melodramatic elements and overt nationalistic themes, which can feel heavy-handed to international audiences.
The Blu-ray release of "The Climbers" boasts impressive technical credentials. Featuring a 2.39:1 AVC aspect ratio that provides stunning visual clarity and DTS-HD MA 5.1 audio in Mandarin, the climb sequences deliver immersive and adrenaline-pumping experiences. These are complemented by English subtitles, making the film accessible to a broader audience. While the disc’s extra features are minimal, they're sufficient to enhance the viewing experience.
In conclusion, "The Climbers" excels in delivering thrilling adventure and shedding light on an often overlooked historical event, though it is occasionally hindered by its dramatic liberties and propagandist overtones. Its technical presentation on Blu-ray is exemplary, making it a worthwhile addition to any collection. Recommended for those who appreciate adventure cinema with a historical backdrop, and especially for aficionados of mountaineering stories.
AV Nirvana review by Michael ScottRead review here
Video: 90
The 2.39:1 framed film is quite exceptional 99% of the time, giving us exquisite close up shots, razor sharp detail levels on the slopes, and only minimal banding to keep it from looking “perfect” (well,...
Audio: 90
The 5.1 Mandarin track (no English dubs) is a great mix for this film, giving simple and quiet dialog driven sequences for the precursor to the climb, and once we get up into the mountains it roars with...
Extras: 20
...
Movie: 60
While The Climbers is a solid thriller, it just doesn’t latch onto the characters and give them a truly emotional resonance with the audience, instead inserting fictional romances and jingoistic nationalism...
Total: 70
The movie does suffer from excess melodrama and nationalistic jingoism (some patriotism and nationalism is expected, but the Chinese are typically very heavy handed with their applications), but is overall...
Blu-ray.com review by Jeffrey KauffmanRead review here
Video: 90
Aside from some momentary banding issues, this is a solid looking transfer that preserves some jaw dropping actual location photography, especially in some aerial shots which feature some pretty stunning...
Audio: 90
The Climbers' DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 track (in the original Mandarin, with optional English subtitles) occasionally roars into action in some of the outdoor scenes, notably the two aforementioned avalanches...
Extras: 20
Note: As tends to be the case with Well Go USA Blu-ray releases, the supplements have been authored to follow one another automatically (so that clicking on the first Behind the Scenes featurette is essentially...
Movie: 60
That said, The Climbers is yet another Asian film that seems designed to appeal mostly to Chinese audiences, since it has the unmistakable whiff of jingoism itself, including a rather notable lack of any...
Total: 60
This is another offering from the Asian film market, which, kind of like the recently reviewed Korean film The Battle of Jangsari (also available on Blu-ray from Well Go USA), tells an actual historical...
Director: Daniel Lee
Actors: Jing Wu, Ziyi Zhang, Yi Zhang
PlotIn 1960, a Chinese mountaineering team embarks on an arduous and perilous mission to summit Mount Everest from its treacherous north face, a route that had never been successfully conquered. The team, driven by national pride and determination, faces extreme weather conditions and life-threatening challenges. Their climb is complicated by avalanches, blizzards, and the thin air at high altitudes, which test their resilience and teamwork. With limited resources and outdated equipment, the climbers must rely on their training, instincts, and each other’s strengths to overcome the numerous obstacles in their path.
Years later, in 1975, a new expedition is planned to reach the summit once again, led by some members of the original team alongside fresh recruits. This climb is backed by advanced technology and international support, reflecting the growing stature of China on the global stage. As they prepare for the ascent, personal histories and unresolved conflicts resurface, adding emotional complexity to the already formidable task ahead. The mountaineers' journey becomes not only a physical battle against Everest’s mighty forces but also an internal struggle as they confront their fears, regrets, and dreams. The narrative delves into themes of perseverance, sacrifice, and the unyielding human spirit.
Writers: Alai, Ying Shang, Daniel Lee
Release Date: 30 Sep 2019
Runtime: 125 min
Rating: Not Rated
Country: China
Language: Mandarin, Tibetan