I, Robot Blu-ray Review

The 3D Blu-ray presentation of "I, Robot" showcases a mixed bag of video quality aspects. The AVC-MPEG transfer effectively maximizes the capabilities of the 2K intermediate, delivering a bright, clean picture adorned with striking detail and razor-sharp definition. Film grain is present but subtle, maintaining overall integrity. Colors are vibrant and eye-catching with natural flesh-tones, thanks to meticulous grading and exposure control. Contrast levels are bold with deep black levels, enhancing low-light and mixed content sequences. However, the conversion to 1.78:1 from the original 2.35:1 aspect ratio is notable, adding extra visual elements on the top and bottom while slightly clipping the sides. Regrettably, some scenes exhibit edge enhancement, and the CGI-heavy areas reveal occasionally noticeable green screen artifacts and halos around actors.

On the other hand, the 3D conversion itself leaves much to be desired. While certain sequences such as those featuring long hallways or slow-motion action scenes provide an appreciable sense of depth, consistency eludes the overall presentation. The image often feels flat, and depth varies arbitrarily between scenes. Some shots deliver impressive layered depth, yet others fall short, rendering them indistinguishable from their 2D counterparts. The few standout 3D moments, such as the city introduction text or shootout debris effects, are overshadowed by pervasive issues like artificial layering and occasional crosstalk. This undermines the immersive potential that one might expect from a sci-fi action film prime for 3D enhancement.

In contrast, the 2D version remains exemplary in its clarity and fidelity, even though it also utilizes the unmated 1.78:1 ratio. Fine detail is exceptional, revealing intricate textures on skin and robots alike. The cold, sterile color palette maintains its intended aesthetic without degradation in brightness or clarity through the 3D glasses. Contrast is sharp, enhancing the film's intentional somewhat lifeless tone while maintaining rich black levels and vivid shadows. Despite minor issues such as moiré effect in an early cityscape shot, the 2D presentation stands as a testament to high-definition video quality, unlike its lackluster 3D counterpart.

The DTS-HD Master Audio soundtrack of "I, Robot" on Blu-ray retains the heightened energy and vibrancy of the original release, making it a powerful and engaging auditory experience. The orchestral score by Marco Beltrami, while not as instantly memorable as those by John Williams, effectively supports the film’s intense action sequences. The surround speakers are heavily utilized for dynamic effects, such as bullets and trucks traversing the soundscape, which induces an immersive environment. Though the dynamic range might not rival more modern releases, it remains satisfactory. Note that while the LFE channel is solid, there are instances of unevenness in the lowest frequencies resulting in occasional boominess.

The audio presentation is marked by an expansive front soundstage with extraordinary channel separation that delivers warmth and fidelity. It showcases precise dynamic range and striking clarity, distinguishing highs and mids effectively without losing focus. Highlights such as the tunnel attack scene exhibit remarkable detailing where even the smallest shrapnel is distinguishable alongside the loudest crashes. The low-end frequencies are primarily contained within the mid-bass range but still provide a substantial punch with sporadic thunderous moments that feel impactful.

Additionally, the rear speaker activity is exceptional and adds to the immersive experience by delivering various background sounds and commotion seamlessly. Bullet whizzes, glass shattering, and robots moving around create a 360° soundfield that envelops the listener with convincing directionality and pans. The audio environment remains lively even during quieter scenes, with ambient sounds like distant arguments, traffic noise, or dogs barking, enhancing believability. Overall, the DTS-HD MA track on "I, Robot" is a robust and dynamic auditory journey that serves the film’s action-oriented narrative well.

The Blu-ray release of "I, Robot" includes all supplemental features on an accompanying DVD, which appears to be a legacy disc from a previous release. The extras are robust, providing insightful material for fans of the film and behind-the-scenes processes. Key highlights include multiple audio commentaries, with an especially engaging track from Director Alex Proyas and Screenwriter Akiva Goldsman discussing their creative choices and modifications from Isaac Asimov's original stories. Additionally, a standard yet informative "Making of" featurette offers interviews with the cast and crew as well as backstage footage. Despite the standard definition (SD) limitation, these features are well produced and valuable for enthusiasts.

Extras included in this disc:

• Audio Commentary: Insightful track with Director Alex Proyas and Screenwriter Akiva Goldsman.
• The Making of I, Robot: Cast & crew interviews and BTS footage.
• Still Gallery: Concept art, CG renderings, and production stills.
• Inside Look: Pieces on 'Mr. & Mrs. Smith,' 'Robots,' and 'Elektra.'
• Trailer: Preview for 'Arrested Development' series.

In "I, Robot," director Alex Proyas presents a high-tech thriller set in a futuristic Chicago where robots have become an integral part of daily life by 2035. Will Smith stars as Detective Del Spooner, who distrusts these humanoid helpers and soon finds himself investigating the murder of a scientist allegedly by a robot named Sonny. Unlike most labor-bots, Sonny appears sentient, thrusting Spooner into a dangerous conspiracy that questions the ethics and dangers of advanced robotics. Although the film loosely ties back to Isaac Asimov's themes and the famed Three Laws of Robotics, it adapts more from Eando Binder's work, focusing on explosive action scenes more than deep philosophical introspection.

The recent Blu-ray reissue of "I, Robot" includes a 3D conversion that sadly falls short of expectations. While the prospect of experiencing a 3D version is intriguing, the actual execution feels lackluster. Foreground objects often appear unnaturally layered onto backgrounds, detracting from the immersive experience one would expect from high-quality 3D. Moreover, the film is presented in a cropped aspect ratio rather than its original scope format, further disappointing purists. Despite these shortcomings, the disc does boast a top-tier lossless soundtrack that enhances the film's intense action scenes and dramatic moments.

Despite its production issues, the narrative and performances in "I, Robot" stand strong. The director injects thought-provoking questions and ethical dilemmas surrounding artificial intelligence while ensuring the story is action-packed. Alan Tudyk’s voice work as Sonny is notably exemplary, providing the character with an endearing depth. Supporting cast members like Bridget Moynahan and Chi McBride add substantial layers to the plot, while Will Smith's combination of charisma and intensity manages to ground the film even when it leans heavily on stereotypes and action tropes. Though laced with flaws, "I, Robot" delivers a compelling blend of sci-fi action and thoughtful commentary on technology's role in society.

The 3D Blu-ray release of "I, Robot" by 20th Century Fox presents a visually appealing rendition of Alex Proyas' adaptation of Isaac Asimov's stories, though it falls short in several key areas that are worth noting. Although the film itself is engaging with its mix of sci-fi action, humor, and Will Smith's confident performance, the 3D conversion does not add significant value, making the enhancement almost redundant except for a few scenes towards the latter part of the movie. Another point of contention is that the disc does not retain the theatrical exhibition aspect ratio, which might be a letdown for purists and enthusiasts.

Technically, the lossless multichannel soundtrack remains outstanding, delivering a demo-worthy auditory experience. However, this release is sparse on extras, which diminishes its appeal compared to its 2D counterpart that includes additional content. While the absence of supplemental material might not deter die-hard fans, it becomes hard to justify an upgrade solely for the 3D effect, especially considering that the original film remains thoroughly entertaining without it.

In summary, while "I, Robot" continues to be a thought-provoking and enjoyable sci-fi action movie, the 3D Blu-ray release doesn’t offer enough to warrant a strong recommendation for purchase. The mediocre 3D conversion and lack of extras make it a tough sell unless budget and curiosity are abundant resources for potential buyers. If you already own the 2D version, there’s little incentive to switch unless you’re particularly enthusiastic about seeing even minor enhancements in 3D.