Muay Thai Giant Blu-ray Review
Somtum
Score: 37
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
'Muay Thai Giant' is a mediocre action-comedy with lackluster video and audio, sporadic creativity, and an R-rating that targets a narrow audience.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 37
The 1080p/AVC transfer of 'Muay Thai Giant,' although reasonably sharp with some vivid colors, suffers from a processed, video-like feel with grayish blacks and occasional blown-out highlights. Despite moments of clarity and fine texture, the overall presentation is underwhelming with soft details and potential DNR issues.
Audio: 47
Muay Thai Giant's DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 tracks, both in original Thai and English dub, feature melodic and light music with clear and full sound, though dialogue can be low in the mix and overall dynamic range is flat. Surround channels enhance action scenes, but integration is sometimes forced.
Extra: 16
Extras on the Blu-ray of 'Muay Thai Giant' offer two brief featurettes in standard definition, focusing on behind-the-scenes footage and interviews, with additional trailers for other Magnolia releases in higher resolution and quality audio. While concise, they highlight genuine care for stunt safety.
Movie: 41
Muay Thai Giant blends goofy, unassuming humor with lackluster fight choreography and a nonsensical plot about a gentle giant who gains superhuman strength from spicy somtum. Although Nathan Jones delivers an endearing performance, the film's overall mediocrity and juvenile silliness will only vaguely entertain action fans.
Video: 37
The video presentation of the Blu-ray edition of "Muay Thai Giant" is delivered in a 1080p/AVC MPEG-4 transfer with an aspect ratio of 1.78:1. While it may not offer the most striking visual experience, it performs reasonably well for a niche martial arts film. The encode maintains a natural grain structure typical of film, providing a decent level of sharpness and clarity throughout most scenes. However, the image does come across somewhat processed and flat, with occasional blown-out highlights and inconsistent color grading that can sometimes render skin tones pasty or hues slightly off. Additionally, black levels can appear more grayish than deep black, impacting the overall depth and contrast.
In terms of fine detail and texture, the presentation varies. Some scenes exhibit a commendable amount of detail and vibrant colors, enhancing the viewing experience. On the other hand, several parts appear soft and lack the expected sharpness, potentially due to DNR application. Motion handling could also be improved, as some scenes demonstrate a smearing effect, particularly noticeable on actors' faces during rapid movement sequences. Furthermore, minor edge enhancement is visible at times, though specific instances might be a result of the unique visual effects employed rather than faults in the transfer itself.
Despite these technical shortcomings, the Blu-ray transfer of "Muay Thai Giant" manages to deliver adequate visual performance for fans of the genre. It may not reach the heights of reference-quality releases but offers a reasonably good presentation for what it is.
Audio: 47
The audio presentation of the "Muay Thai Giant" Blu-ray is provided in dual DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 tracks in both the original Thai/English mix and a full English dub. The audio allows for an engaging experience, especially during action sequences. The soundtrack deviates from the cliché butt-rock or subpar hip-hop, instead offering lighter, more melodic elements. This results in sounds that are sufficiently clear and full-bodied, with impactful bass during fight scenes. Although rear channels are primarily used for music, ambient noises like monkey chatter, crickets, and crowd cheers intermittently add depth, enhancing the overall immersion. Additionally, cross-channel movements are utilized effectively during intense sequences, adding to the dynamic audio environment.
However, the audio does exhibit some drawbacks. Dialogue tends to sound low in the mix and lacks the depth and crispness needed for clarity, though it remains intelligible. Dynamic range appears somewhat flat; while the sound effects and bass deliver a notable punch, they don't reach the level of impact one might expect from a modern DTS-HD track. Unfortunately, integration between music, effects, and ambient noises occasionally feels forced and unnatural, diminishing the immersive experience.
Furthermore, while subtitles in English, English SDH, English Narrative, and Spanish are provided and easy to read, they cannot fully compensate for the lacking finesse in audio fidelity. Despite its shortcomings, the audio track does manage to deliver a serviceable performance with some impressive moments, particularly in action scenes where surround effects energize the viewing experience.
Extras: 16
The extras included with the Blu-ray release of "Muay Thai Giant" offer a modest but insightful look into the film's production process. The "Making of Muay Thai Giant" featurette provides a mixture of behind-the-scenes footage and interviews with the cast and crew, while the "Behind the Scenes" segment focuses primarily on the stunt work and showcases the commendable safety measures taken during filming. Additionally, the package includes trailers for "Muay Thai Giant" as well as other Magnolia Home Entertainment titles, presented in varying video and audio formats. Although not extensive, these extras provide a concise overview of the effort and dedication behind the movie's action-packed sequences.
Extras included in this disc:
- The Making of Muay Thai Giant: Behind-the-scenes footage intermixed with interviews.
- Behind the Scenes of Muay Thai Giant: Showcases some of the stunt work and fight sequences.
- International Trailer: The film's trailer.
- Also from Magnolia Home Entertainment Blu-ray: Trailers for other releases.
Movie: 41
"Muay Thai Giant" manages to be unexpectedly bearable despite its inherent silliness and plot absurdities. At the heart of this goofy adventure is Barney Emerald, portrayed by Nathan Jones, an imposing 6'11" former WWE wrestler and World Strongman. Jones, usually typecast due to his powerful physique and past roles, notably in "Troy" and "Tom-Yum-Goong," steps into a more comedic role here. He plays a gentle giant who, after being drugged and robbed in Thailand, befriends two local sisters including Dokya, a young Muay Thai champion played by Sasisa Jindamanee. The film's standout quirk involves Barney's reaction to somtum, a spicy papaya salad that triggers berserk fits of rage and superhuman strength comparable to the Hulk. Despite these eccentricities, it manages to inject some charm and humor amid the chaos.
The narrative sees an overly simplistic plot with Barney and the girls facing off against bungling criminals involved in a diamond smuggling operation. The film leans heavily into slapstick humor and over-the-top action sequences that often border on ridiculousness, including a ludicrous showdown where Barney faces off against a taxiing airplane. While aiming to entertain with a blend of martial arts action and comedy, it mostly delivers clichéd fight choreography and uninspired dramatic conflict. Jones’ fighting prowess, albeit downplayed, is overshadowed by Jindamanee’s dynamic performance, engaging viewers only intermittently throughout the film.
Technically speaking, the action sequences struggle to provide anything novel to seasoned martial arts enthusiasts, though they do offer occasional bursts of creativity, such as a memorable scene involving an intricate fight with a papaya stand. Despite pedestrian writing and uneven performances, “Muay Thai Giant” acknowledges its own lack of seriousness. In conclusion, its blend of juvenile humor and straightforward action might best appeal to an undemanding audience looking for light-hearted entertainment.
Total: 37
"Muay Thai Giant" presents itself as a unique blend of action and comedy, but unfortunately falls short of striking the right balance. The film’s tone oscillates between being excessively silly and mildly thrilling, making it hard to ascertain its target audience. The movie is too violent for younger viewers and too frivolous for mature audiences. Despite these shortcomings, "Muay Thai Giant" doesn’t take itself too seriously, which is somewhat refreshing.
From a technical standpoint, the Blu-ray release of "Muay Thai Giant" leaves much to be desired. The video quality hovers around average, failing to take full advantage of the Blu-ray format’s potential for high-definition clarity. Audio performance is equally underwhelming, lacking the depth and precision that could have enhanced the viewer’s immersion into the action sequences. Extras are sparse, offering little incentive for collectors or hardcore fans of the genre.
In conclusion, "Muay Thai Giant" is an effort that misses the mark on multiple fronts. While it has moments of humor and action, they are fleeting and diluted by poor execution and subpar production quality. Prospective viewers might find an ounce of entertainment value if approached with tempered expectations and accompanied by lighthearted viewing conditions, perhaps with a refreshing drink in hand. Proceed with caution if considering this addition to your collection.
Blu-ray.com review by Casey BroadwaterRead review here
Video: 70
Soft, almost out-of- focus shots creep in more than once, but most of the film has a decent level of clarity, displaying a modicum of fine texture in the actors' faces and other areas where you usually...
Audio: 70
The rear channels are mostly used for the score, but ambience occasionally ekes out�chittering monkey sounds, crickets, cheering crowds, etc.�and there are a few big cross-channel movements during the...
Extras: 20
The Making of Muay Thai Giant (SD, 6:50): Your usual assortment of behind-the-scenes footage intermixed with interviews from the actors and director....
Movie: 50
At their mom's beachside restaurant, the sisters introduce Barney to somtum�a salad made with papaya and peppers �but when he takes the first bite, he turns red, goes berserk, and tears the place to the...
Total: 50
Still, I suppose someone is getting a kick out of this stuff, otherwise Magnolia wouldn't bother with the U.S. distribution rights....
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 40
I did detect some minor edge enhancement, specifically when Barney is in his somtum fits of rage, though the haloing here may be a result of the process used to turn the actor red, and not a fault of the...
Audio: 60
Dynamic range is on the flat side, with effects and bass lacking a little bit of the punch one might expect, though balance between elements is fine....
Extras: 20
Making of Muay Thai Giant (SD, 7 min) - A quick behind the scenes look at the film's production, featuring some brief interviews with the cast and crew as well as some on set footage....
Movie: 40
There are a few interesting fight scenes and an occasional intentional laugh to be had, but overall it's just dumb, and rarely in a good way....
Total: 40
If for some reason you do choose to rent, or even purchase 'Muay Thai Giant' be advised that there is only one way to correctly watch this film, and that is while drinking soda out of a plastic bag....
Director: Nontakorn Taweesuk
Actors: Dan Chupong, Kessarin Ektawatkul, Jason Fenton
PlotA giant of a man named Barney, who stands out not only because of his size but also his childlike innocence, finds himself in Thailand. After being drugged and robbed, he is left with no money or passport, essentially stranded in a foreign land. Fortuitously, he crosses paths with two nice but fierce Muay Thai fighting sisters, Katen and Katoon, who offer him food and shelter. The sisters are soon impressed by Barney's unexpected combat abilities, which he discovers upon facing a local gang that harasses them. Recognizing his potential, the sisters invite Barney to train with them in Muay Thai, hoping that his giant stature and newfound skills can help them compete in a local fighting tournament and win the prize money.
As Barney becomes more adept in Muay Thai, he attracts the attention of various unsavory characters, including those looking to exploit his fighting talent for their own gain. The story balances action with the comedic elements of Barney's struggles to adjust to a culture and discipline that are entirely new to him. Throughout his training and the developing bond with Katen and Katoon, Barney learns about honor, friendship, and self-discovery, all while navigating the dangers that come with the world of underground fighting. This journey sets the stage for a showdown that tests Barney's limits and the strength of his new relationships.
Writers: Nontakorn Taweesuk
Release Date: 29 May 2008
Runtime: 103 min
Rating: R
Country: Thailand
Language: English, Thai