Midnight Express Blu-ray Review
DigiBook
Score: 55
from 4 reviewers
Review Date:
Intense film & tech marvel, 'Midnight Express' intrigues & stirs debate, solid Blu-ray upgrade.
Disc Release Date
Dolby TrueHD
Video: 55
Midnight Express' Blu-ray delivers a faithful, grainy 1080p transfer, enhancing the film's grim aesthetics without compromising its original drab and muted style, despite minor flaws.
Audio: 44
The Blu-ray's audio favors clarity with Dolby TrueHD 5.1, enhancing the original mono but remains mostly front-centered, sparingly using surrounds, echoing the visual fidelity's faithful but subdued presentation.
Extra: 63
Blu-ray of 'Midnight Express' features in-depth extras including Parker's commentary, a detailed essay, documentaries on production, casting, and controversies, and a look at the film's legacy.
Movie: 76
Midnight Express," a gripping drama directed by Alan Parker and written by Oliver Stone, tells the harrowing true story of Billy Hayes's brutal Turkish prison ordeal, sparking both acclaim and controversy for its portrayal and artistic execution.
Video: 55
The video presentation of "Midnight Express" on Blu-ray provides a viewing experience that captures the essence of its source material with admirable fidelity. Delivered in widescreen 1.85:1, 1080p using the MPEG-4/AVC codec, the transfer strikes a commendable balance between preserving the film’s original grain and achieving a clean, blemish-free appearance. The grain, heavier in some scenes, does not detract from the sharpness and detail that come through, especially in the depiction of the deteriorating Turkish institutions. Despite some softness, which seems inherent to the cinematic techniques employed during its production rather than a flaw in the transfer itself, colors are rendered with a muted saturation that aligns with the filmmakers' intentions. This creates a drab and lifeless atmosphere, reflective of the grim setting and tone of the narrative.
Fine details such as the grimy prison walls and rusted iron bars are adequately reproduced, enhancing the film’s gritty aesthetic. Flesh tones appear natural though occasionally flat, underscoring the harsh reality of Billy's imprisonment without resorting to excessive digital manipulation. Blacks are generally deep, contributing to the visibility of shadowy details, despite sometimes lacking in richness which leads to a slight wash-out of finer details in darker scenes. The print remains largely free of artifacts, maintaining a film-like quality throughout.
The overall video quality speaks to the commitment to remain true to the original visuals of "Midnight Express." While it may lack the vividness and high-definition pop of more recent digitally remastered films, this Blu-ray presentation excels at conveying the movie's stark reality through stable imagery. A few visible artifacts and occasional brightness inconsistencies notwithstanding, the transfer does justice to this classic film, serving up a picture that respects its visual and thematic complexity.
Audio: 44
The Blu-ray release of "Midnight Express" provides viewers with two auditory experiences: a lossless Dolby TrueHD 5.1 and a traditional lossy Dolby Digital mono soundtrack. The 5.1 remix, while an improvement over the original mono in terms of clarity and depth, mainly enhances the crispness of dialogue and offers a modest increase in ambient sound precision, especially in scenes set within lively Turkish markets. Dialogue is more defined in the 5.1 mix, yet there remain moments where audibility is strained, indicating a lower overall volume level necessitating adjustment for an optimal listening experience.
The surround channels are sparingly used, with noted exceptions being the occasional motorcycle or birds, which, although aiming for a more immersive environment, appear somewhat forced and inconsistent with the overall frontal focus of the audio presentation. Moroder's influential score benefits from a slight spread across the front channels, augmenting its presence without overstating its stereo dimensionality. However, the majority of sound effects and dialogue continue to be anchored in the center channel, limiting the potential expansiveness of the audio field.
Notwithstanding these enhancements, the remixed 5.1 track does not significantly deviate from the source's original mono essence. The fidelity of the audio mirrors the limitations of its era, resulting in a soundstage that, while serviceable and occasionally atmospheric (notably in scenes such as the mental ward), lacks dynamic range and exhibits a certain brittleness in higher frequencies. Both audio tracks illustrate a faithful adherence to preserving the film’s original auditory intentions, bypassing the temptation to artificially modernize the soundscape, thus offering listeners a choice between historical accuracy and a slightly enriched listening experience.
Extras: 63
The 30th Anniversary Blu-Ray edition of "Midnight Express" is complemented by a rich selection of extras that dive deep into the making and legacy of this controversial classic. The highlight is certainly the detailed commentary from director Alan Parker, which, despite its dry delivery, offers invaluable insights into the film's production, the groundbreaking electronic score by Giorgio Moroder, and the intricate logistics behind shooting. The segmented featurettes—“The Producers,” “The Production,” and “The Finished Film”—though designed to collectively offer a comprehensive view, provide detailed explorations of the film's conception, the challenges encountered during production, and its reception. These are supplemented by interviews with key figures like Oliver Stone and Peter Guber, and further enriched by Alan Parker's reflections on his contentious relationship with Stone. The inclusion of original promotional content, a vintage piece on Billy Hayes, and a meticulously curated photo gallery add depth to the narrative. Despite a slight redundancy across the commentary and the booklet essay, both deliver frank and engaging anecdotes that reflect on the filmmaking process, from casting trials to location scouting. The Blu Ray package is an essential for aficionados, offering both technical details and personal stories behind the film's enduring impact.
Extras included in this disc:
- Commentary with Director Alan Parker: A comprehensive commentary track by Alan Parker.
- The Producers: Insightful interviews with Peter Guber, David Puttnam, and Alan Marshall.
- The Production: Detailed recount of the film's production with input from key crew members.
- The Finished Film: A continuation of the production story, focusing on post-production elements.
- The Making of ‘Midnight Express’: A vintage documentary providing additional perspective on the film’s story.
- Photo Gallery: A collection of production stills presented as a slideshow.
- Trailers: Including trailers for other notable films and series.
Movie: 76
Alan Parker's "Midnight Express" stands as a cinematic testament to the harrowing journey of Billy Hayes, an American caught smuggling hashish out of Turkey, portrayed with gripping intensity by Brad Davis. The film delves deep into the psyche of Hayes as he endures the brutality of a Turkish prison, supported by standout performances from John Hurt among others. The narrative is compelling, highlighting Hayes' struggle and the inhuman conditions he faces, brought to life through Parker's skilled direction and Oliver Stone's bold screenplay. Despite its controversy, particularly regarding its portrayal of Turkish characters and its dramatic liberties, "Midnight Express" remains a powerful drama about endurance, hope, and the human spirit's capacity for survival.
The film's technical execution enhances its storytelling, with a palpable atmosphere of tension and despair meticulously crafted through cinematography and sound design. Giorgio Moroder's Oscar-winning score further elevates the film, intertwining with the narrative to accentuate the emotional and physical turmoil faced by Hayes. This raw and unfiltered portrayal captures not only the personal ordeal of one man but also serves as a broader critique of draconian drug laws and the injustices within certain judicial systems.
While "Midnight Express" has faced criticism for its depiction of Turkey and potential xenophobia, it cannot be denied that this work has left an indelible mark on cinematic history. Its artistic achievements, underscored by its critical acclaim and multiple Oscar accolades, reflect a film that, beyond its controversies, offers a poignant exploration of survival and resistance against overwhelming odds. This Blu-ray presentation by Sony ensures that both new audiences and long-time fans can experience the film's visceral impact with outstanding visual and audio quality, preserving its status as a classic in the realm of prison dramas.
Total: 55
The Blu-ray presentation of "Midnight Express" brings a gritty and sharp clarity that elevates the already intense narrative and poignant performances delivered by Davis, Hurt, and Randy Quaid under the superb direction of Parker. Enhanced by Stone's politically edged screenplay, this release not only captures the film's cinematic brilliance but also its controversial impact on Dutch-Turkish relations, hinting at the complex international ramifications stemming from the movie's portrayal. This edition stands out with a significant upgrade in video and audio quality, providing a more immersive experience than previous versions, though it may not reach the pinnacle of current high-definition offerings.
Tested on an extensive and calibrated setup which included the JVC DLA-RS20 1080p High Definition Front Projector and the Oppo BDP-83 Universal disc/Blu-ray Player among other high-end components, the Blu-ray's technical merits were thoroughly vetted. The 1080p transfer shines on a calibrated display, bringing the dark corridors of the Turkish prison and the emotional depth of the characters to life with striking detail and auditory clarity. The inclusion of a robust package of bonus materials and a collector-friendly digibook format makes this release a commendable addition for cinephiles, although its appeal may vary for casual viewers due to the contentious nature of the film’s content.
In conclusion, the Blu-ray release of "Midnight Express" is a testament to the film's enduring legacy, presenting a technical upgrade that respects its source material while enriching viewers' experience with stellar audiovisual enhancements and insightful extras. It navigates the moral ambiguities and historical liberties of the original work with finesse, offering an essential view for enthusiasts of seminal cinema. Despite its potential divisiveness among audiences, this edition ultimately stands as a recommended purchase for those looking to dive deeper into the film’s complex narrative and appreciate its technical achievements in a home theater setting.
avforums review by AVForumsRead review here
Video: 70
There are some very minor brightness fluctuations in some very light swathes of colour (the prison walls for instance) but they are pretty fleeting and don't really affect your viewing to any great degree....
Audio: 60
The track itself is a little low, nowhere near reference and I had to crank it a few notches just to get the best from it....
Extras: 70
Puttnam, Marshall and Parker all admit that the initial draft of Stone's script was excellent even though it was set like the book in multiple prisons rather than the one we're used to in the final screen...
Movie: 80
The viewer feels an affinity for the protagonist and that's something of an eye opener because the man in question is a drug smuggler....
Total: 70
Stone has produced an excellent screenplay and even still manages to get a little political kick in there with his walking circle; you can't keep a good man down....
Blu-ray.com review by Martin LiebmanRead review here
Video: 80
The Blu-ray delivers a solid picture quality that never jumps off the screen with crystal-clear images and vibrant colors, but it is representative of and faithful to its source....
Audio: 70
Music often plays with little in the way of volume at reference levels, a chase scene in chapter 3 playing as a rather cut-and-dry experience that delivers the sound but doesn't do all that much with it....
Extras: 80
The Producers (1080i, 25:54) features Producers Peter Guber, David Puttnam, and Alan Marshall speaking on a broad range of topics about how the film came together, including their initial involvement with...
Movie: 90
Midnight Express was, is, and will continue to be, an oft-analyzed film for both its artistry and its many controversial under- and overtones, including the painting of a drug smuggler as a sympathetic...
Total: 80
Managing to turn a drug-smuggling character into a sympathetic figure due to his disdainful treatment in a hellish foreign prison and taking liberties with a true story for dramatic and artistic license...
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 60
The picture is reasonably sharp and detailed, if not necessarily exceptional in that regard....
Audio: 40
Giorgio Moroder's Oscar-winning electronic score has been spread to the front left and right speakers with a little stereo dimensionality, but dialogue and sound effects remain rooted in the center channel....
Extras: 40
They cover the genesis of the project, the hiring of Stone, the casting (the studio wanted Richard Gere; Dennis Quaid was also in the running), and working off the studio radar with a low budget....
Movie: 60
To the contrary, the film, which was written by Oliver Stone during the time period when he had quite a bit of first-hand experience with the subject, argues that drugs aren't the problem at all....
Total: 60
Depending on your point of view, 'Midnight Express' is either a classic inspirational story about the triumph of the human spirit, or a vile racist screed....
AVSForumRead review here
Video: 80
I think that this coincides with the creative decisions of the filmmakers which results in stable imagery that lacks the eye popping high definition that some may expect going from Blu-ray....
Audio: 74
I think that this coincides with the creative decisions of the filmmakers which results in stable imagery that lacks the eye popping high definition that some may expect going from Blu-ray....
Extras: 70
Commentary with Director Alan Parker (HD) The Producers – 26 minute featurette (HD) The Production – 24 minute featurette (HD) The finished film – 23 minute featurette The making of Midnight express –...
Movie: 80
Busted for attempting to smuggle hashish out of Istanbul, American college student Billy Hayes (Davis) is thrown into the city's most brutal jail....
Total: 76
Denon AVR 5308CI THX Ultra 2 Preamp/Video Processor Sherbourn Technologies - 7/200 Seven Channel Amplifier Philips TSU9400 Pro Series Touch Panel Remote Control Canton "Ergo" Series speakers Axiom Audio...
Director: Alan Parker
Actors: Brad Davis, Irene Miracle, Bo Hopkins
PlotIn 1970, an American college student named Billy Hayes is caught attempting to smuggle drugs out of Turkey. The drugs, taped to his body, are discovered by customs officials at the Istanbul airport just as he is about to board a flight home. The scene is tense, as Billy initially passes through a metal detector without issue, only to be called back by a suspicious officer. His plan to return to the United States with the drugs, intended to be a quick and profitable venture, quickly unravels. Billy's arrest marks the beginning of a harrowing journey through the Turkish legal system. Initially, he is confident and even somewhat naive about his situation, believing that money and American influence will easily secure his release.
However, Billy's situation takes a dramatic turn for the worse when his initial sentence of four years is made drastically longer by a court decision following an appeal by the prosecution. The new sentence is nothing short of a nightmare: 30 years in a notorious Turkish prison known for its harsh conditions and brutal treatment of inmates. The prison is a grim, harsh place where violence and cruelty are part of daily life. Billy must navigate this new, terrifying reality, contending with the psychological and physical challenges of life behind bars in a foreign country. His fight for freedom becomes a test of human will, as he encounters a cast of characters that includes fellow prisoners and a sympathetic doctor, each affecting his chances of survival and escape in different ways.
Writers: Oliver Stone, Billy Hayes, William Hoffer
Release Date: 27 Oct 1978
Runtime: 121 min
Rating: R
Country: United Kingdom, United States
Language: English, Turkish, French