Earth Blu-ray Review
Disneynature
Score: 64
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
An educational and engrossing family documentary with superb video quality, engaging DTS-HD audio, and a rich set of extras.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 66
The Blu-ray presentation of 'Earth' is reference-quality with stunning colors, impeccable resolution, and rich contrast that provides extraordinary depth and detail. While minor issues like noise and artifacting exist, the overall visual experience is captivating and near-transcendent in high definition, akin to the original BBC series.
Audio: 62
The DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 soundtrack of 'Earth' excels in delivering James Earl Jones' narration with impeccable clarity and smooth intonation, effectively utilizing the front channels and ambient rear effects to create an immersive atmosphere that captures the essence of the documentary's varied environments, with notable LFE presence during critical scenes.
Extra: 61
Despite the sparse list on the case, the Blu-ray edition of 'Earth' delivers an unexpectedly extensive package, including a 42-minute behind-the-scenes documentary, engaging filmmaker annotations via BonusView, and innovative Living Menu interactivity with dynamic pop-up trivia and videos. A rewarding exploration.
Movie: 71
Earth, despite utilizing footage from the BBC's Planet Earth, emerges as a vibrant, family-friendly documentary with compelling narratives and rich cinematography. Narrated by James Earl Jones, it captivates children and educates families on nature's fragility and the circle of life, making it a highly memorable experience.
Video: 66
The Blu-ray presentation of "Earth" offers a superb high-definition experience that rivals the acclaimed BBC series. This 1080p/AVC-encoded transfer delivers an impressive array of vivid colors, specifically deep reds, succulent blues, and rich earth tones that practically leap from the screen. The 1.78:1 framed video exhibits impeccable contrast balance, with shades of gray, bright whites, and deep blacks preserving intricate details. This attention to detail ensures that low-light scenes benefit from excellent shadow delineation and depth of field. The nature-defined color palette enriches viewing with a near-infinite sense of dimension, effectively showcasing the grandeur of Earth's landscapes in stunning high-definition.
The level of detail captured is extraordinary, allowing viewers to witness minute elements such as individual hairs on a fleeing gazelle or the delicate texture of falling leaves. The transfer excels in scenes captured from aerial views, presenting herds, individual animals, and natural elements with remarkable clarity and depth. However, the presentation is not without its minor flaws. Occasional errant noise, spiking grain in nighttime shots, and artifacting can be noticed, particularly during slow-motion sequences or scenes involving underwater footage. These issues, while present, stem more from the source material than the quality of the transfer itself.
Despite these minor inconsistencies, the transfer's more awe-inspiring moments are likely to overshadow any imperfections for most viewers. Planet Earth enthusiasts will find this presentation familiar yet fresh, while newcomers to the series will be captivated by the cinematic splendor it delivers. Overall, while there are some slight distractions due to technical limitations, the Blu-ray presentation of "Earth" remains a visual feast that will please both casual viewers and videophiles alike.
Audio: 62
The DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 soundtrack for "Earth" is nothing short of a polished and proficient presentation that significantly enhances the documentary's immersive qualities. James Earl Jones’ commanding narration is delivered with exceptional clarity and articulation, though some may find it slightly recessed in the front soundstage. The three front channels are masterfully integrated, providing high-level detail and pinpoint imaging, ensuring every word and music note is presented with utmost precision. George Fenton’s score benefits from this, offering appreciable top-end air, smoothly rendered instrumentation, and discerning focus through the front speakers, while low-level rear channel ambience subtly broadens the soundstage.
The surround channels are adeptly employed to create an enveloping soundscape, replete with various animal sounds, near-field panning effects, and environmental nuances such as blowing winds. Although primarily ambient, the surround usage succeeds in immersing the listener deeply into the film's diverse settings. LFE presence is notable; the bass response is robust enough to shake the room during intense scenes like a caribou stampede or an impending thunderstorm. While the mix isn't aggressive by nature and deliberately avoids overwhelming the viewer, it handles everything it's given with remarkable ease.
Disney's DTS-HD MA track proves that a lossless audio experience can significantly elevate a documentary's impact. The mix expertly balances subtle ambient noises and occasional dramatic moments, ensuring a rich and satisfying auditory experience without detracting from the filmmakers' vision or the narrative flow. Whether it’s tiny creatures hopping through the underbrush or humpback whales diving beneath icy waves, "Earth" delivers a sonic experience that documentary enthusiasts will find both immersive and unforgettable.
Extras: 61
The Blu-ray release of "Earth" provides an unexpectedly comprehensive array of special features, making it a standout among similar titles. Alongside a standard DVD, the disc features a 42-minute behind-the-scenes documentary, titled "Earth Diaries." This documentary explores the movie's creation in detail, covering various aspects such as presentation challenges and the filmmakers' journey to capture the film's stunning visuals. The Living Menu feature adds interactivity, allowing users to explore hotspots on a globe interface that reveal pop-up videos and trivia about different regions. The Filmmaker Annotations track offers an immersive Picture-in-Picture experience where the creators provide in-depth commentary on filmmaking techniques and narrative development. These robust extras significantly enhance the viewer’s understanding and appreciation of the film.
Extras included in this disc:
- Disney’s Living Menu: Selectable points on Earth with pop-up trivia and videos.
- Earth Diaries: A 42-minute behind-the-scenes documentary.
- Filmmaker Annotations: Picture-in-Picture commentary with extensive insights.
- Bonus DVD: Standard definition copy of Earth.
Movie: 71
Disneynature's "Earth" offers a mesmerizing exploration of our planet through the journeys of three distinct animal families: polar bears, elephants, and humpback whales. The film utilizes select footage from the critically acclaimed BBC documentary series "Planet Earth," yet it stands out by weaving a more focused narrative that makes it accessible and captivating for viewers of all ages. What sets "Earth" apart is its remarkable clarity and filmic beauty, capturing nature's raw splendor and fragility with both grandeur and intimacy. The transitions between the breathtaking landscapes and the detailed close-ups of wildlife create a gripping visual experience that is both educational and entertaining.
The narrative centers on the struggles and survival of each featured animal family. The polar bears battle starvation in the thawing Arctic, elephants brave a treacherous migration across the dust storm-prone African savannah, and humpback whales embark on a perilous journey to the Antarctic feeding grounds. The film introduces a diverse array of creatures, from playful mandarin ducklings to formidable great white sharks, ensuring that audiences remain engaged throughout the 90-minute runtime. James Earl Jones' narration adds an essential emotional layer, guiding viewers with a mix of gravitas and warmth, which enhances the storytelling without diluting the raw authenticity of wildlife documentation.
However, it's important to note that "Earth" doesn't shy away from portraying life's harsh realities. Scenes hint at the inevitable death and predation that are integral parts of the natural world, offering valuable teaching moments about the circle of life. While these elements are depicted with sensitivity to maintain a G-rating, they may prompt questions from younger viewers. This balance of adventure and education makes "Earth" not just a visual delight but a thought-provoking film that can inspire curiosity in children, motivate them to learn more about nature, and foster an appreciation for wildlife conservation.
Total: 64
The Blu-ray edition of "Earth" is an excellent rendition of an already fantastic family-friendly documentary. A masterfully presented film balancing education and entertainment, "Earth" captivates both young viewers and adults. The video transfer on this Blu-ray is outstanding, exhibiting a high level of clarity and detail that makes the stunning visuals even more breathtaking. Coupled with a surprisingly immersive DTS-HD Master Audio track, the sensory experience delivered here is compelling from start to finish.
Beyond its visual and auditory excellence, this Blu-ray release includes an impressive array of supplementary materials. These extras add substantial value, offering deeper insights into the making of the documentary and extending its educational reach. The technical proficiency displayed in both the main feature and additional content is noteworthy, indicating meticulous craftsmanship in the transition from the big screen to home viewing.
In conclusion, the Blu-ray of "Earth" stands as a premium example of what the format can achieve. Its superior video and audio quality, combined with rich supplementary content, make it a must-have for families and nature documentary enthusiasts alike. It serves as a promising indicator of the potential resurgence of family-friendly educational films in the modern media landscape.
Blu-ray.com review by Kenneth BrownRead review here
Video: 80
Granted, several sequences are hindered by errant noise and spiking grain (particularly nighttime shots and dust storm scenes), but every instance should be attributed to the film's source, not the quality...
Audio: 80
Proving a lossless experience can make all the difference -- even when a narrator's voice is the primary element of a mix -- Disney's efforts are on full display, granting James Earl Jones' commanding...
Extras: 70
Filmmaker Annotations: More than a fluffy trivia track with a few video clips thrown in for good measure, this Picture-in-Picture tracks gives the filmmakers and documentarians ample opportunity to discuss...
Movie: 80
Sure, Jones' imbues the wildlife with characteristics viewers will automatically project onto every action they make, but it's all within the realm of reason....
Total: 80
Family-friendly documentaries may be a relative rarity in this age of Spongebob and Hannah Montana, but films like Earth give me hope for a genre resurgence....
AVSForumRead review here
Video: 92
These beautifully captured images of our planet can be captivating as the richness of color, transparently rendered detail, and near infinite sense of depth and dimension are assuredly conveyed in high...
Audio: 84
George Fenton’s music had appreciable top end air, smoothly rendered instrumentation, and discerning focus as its primary elements were delivered through the front speakers with low level rear channel...
Extras: 60
Disney’s Living Menu feature - an interactive feature with uses selectable points on the earth that offer pop-up trivia, video clips, and other ecological information that is based upon locations around...
Movie: 70
Filmed with spectacular clarity and beauty, Earth is both majestic and intimate as it captures rare footage of nature's wildest and most elusive animals....
Total: 77
Denon AVR 5308CI THX Ultra 2 Preamp/Video Processor Sherbourn Technologies - 7/200 Seven Channel Amplifier Philips TSU9400 Pro Series Touch Panel Remote Control Canton "Ergo" Series speakers Axiom Audio...
Director: Alastair Fothergill, Mark Linfield
Actors: James Earl Jones, Patrick Stewart, Anggun
PlotThe film captures the raw beauty and harsh realities of life on Earth by following the journeys of three animal families. It begins with a mother polar bear and her cubs as they emerge from their den in the thawing Arctic, struggling for survival in a world where the ice is rapidly melting. Transitioning to the African savanna, the narrative spotlights a herd of elephants navigating their terrain in search of water, enduring searing heat and dwindling resources. Lastly, we are introduced to a humpback whale and her calf on a monumental migration across oceans, exploring the wonders and dangers encountered in the marine environment.
As the story progresses, the camera journeys through various biomes and environments, presenting breathtaking footage of landscapes and wildlife. From the lush Amazon rainforest teeming with life to the stark, desolate Antarctic wilderness, the film showcases the planet's ecological diversity and interconnectedness. Alongside these visual marvels, it underscores the grave environmental threats and challenges these animals face due to changing climates and human activities, invoking a sense of urgency and a call to action to preserve the fragile beauty of our planet.
Writers: Alastair Fothergill, Mark Linfield, Leslie Megahey
Release Date: 22 Apr 2009
Runtime: 90 min
Rating: G
Country: United Kingdom, Germany, United States, France
Language: English