The Iron Giant Blu-ray Review
Signature Edition
Score: 79
from 4 reviewers
Review Date:
'The Iron Giant' Blu-ray delivers impressive HD video and audio, including new and classic extras, making it an essential purchase for fans and newcomers alike.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 79
The Iron Giant Blu-ray showcases exceptional 1080p AVC MPEG-4 video quality, with a 2.39:1 aspect ratio, combining traditional hand-drawn and CG animation. The visual presentation excels with bright daylight scenes, deep blacks, and soft sepia tones, all free from distortion, aliasing, or banding. This transfer, supervised by Brad Bird, delivers a refined, film-like experience.
Audio: 80
The Iron Giant's DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 channel mix delivers a dynamic, engaging sound experience with broad range, thundering LFE, and immersive surround panning; offering crystal clear dialogue, robust Foley effects, and impressive bass response that enhances action scenes and environmental details.
Extra: 73
The Blu-ray extras for 'The Iron Giant' are a remarkable blend of past and new content, featuring an extensive 55-minute documentary 'The Giant's Dream', a mix of HD and SD materials from previous releases, insightful audio commentaries, deleted scenes, and featurettes on various production aspects, complemented by motion galleries and trailers.
Movie: 88
Brad Bird's 'The Iron Giant,' a nostalgic yet innovative animated classic, failed at the box office despite critical acclaim but found enduring love on home media. The Signature Edition Blu-ray offers both original and extended cuts, with added scenes and a fascinating making-of documentary, preserving its emotional depth and technical brilliance. Despite missing a 3D release, the hand-drawn animation, compelling voice cast, and masterful storytelling prove timeless and universally cherished.
Video: 79
The Blu-ray release of "The Iron Giant" is a visual triumph, boasting a stunning 1080p AVC encode that breathes new life into both its hand-drawn and CG-animated elements. This meticulously crafted presentation benefits from Warner’s Motion Picture Imaging facility's 35mm preservation scans and color correction, under director Brad Bird's guidance. The animation, framed in the original 2.39:1 aspect ratio, looks breathtaking with excellent resolution and clarity. The color palette, rich in sepia tones, enhances the period authenticity while the vivid primary colors pop without oversaturation. Dark backgrounds and intricate shading levels offer noteworthy depth and dimension, creating a near-three-dimensional experience.
Although the blacks occasionally appear as dark greys, the contrast remains strong, delivering crisp whites and detailed shadows. The image showcases exceptional cleanliness with minimal grain, devoid of any significant banding, macro-blocking, or distortion. The fine grain structure maintains a film-like quality, ensuring that the animation feels both handmade and magical. While the lack of a 4K Ultra HD release might be lamented by some, this Blu-ray edition is notably superior to previous HD versions available on streaming or cable services. It captures the essence of Brad Bird’s vision accurately and vividly, making it an essential addition for any animation aficionado.
Audio: 80
"The Iron Giant" roars onto Blu-ray with an impressive DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 channel mix, retaining the integrity of the original soundtrack while adding a modern polish. This dynamic and engaging audio presentation features high-level detail across dialogue, sound effects, bass, and music. Discretely placed effects and atmospherics fully utilize the sound field, providing a surround experience that encompasses the listener from all sides. Moments such as Hogarth encountering the giant at the power station and the subsequent scene at the lake add dimension to the front and rear soundstages, delivering a well-balanced mix that seamlessly integrates larger elements with subtle details. While not dynamically enhanced, the bass response is both appropriate and occasionally substantial, supporting the film's various elements with crystalline clarity and without age-induced edginess.
Broad dynamic range and deep bass extension are significant highlights of this mix, effectively conveying the Giant's massive presence and his myriad activities. Michael Kamen's orchestral score transitions smoothly with the film's fluctuating moods, ranging from comic playfulness to intense dramatic conflict. The climax between the Giant and General Rogard’s forces is particularly sonically rich, rivaling many contemporary action films in intensity. Dialogue is expertly prioritized within the overall mix, maintaining clear and precise vocalization throughout. Thundering LFE elements ensure that each giant step generates a room-shaking experience, fully immersing viewers in the cinematic spectacle. The adept panning of sound effects accentuates off-screen character placements and on-screen action scenes, contributing to a compelling auditory experience.
Finally, this robust track, although originating from a late '90s film, impressively holds its own against more recent offerings. Supporting Dolby Surround or DTS:Neural:X capable AV Receivers, it up-mixes exceptionally well, particularly during action-packed or weather-heavy scenes, enhancing immersion even further. Vocal clarity, balanced integration of audio elements, and rigorous sound design make this one of the standout 5.1 DTS-HD MA tracks of its time, certain to satisfy even the most discerning surround sound enthusiasts.
Extras: 73
The Blu-ray release of "The Iron Giant" offers a comprehensive collection of special features that thoroughly explore the making of this beloved animated film. It includes both Signature Edition and Original Theatrical versions, with a notable addition being the new documentary, "The Giant's Dream," which provides an in-depth, candid look at the creation process from Brad Bird’s initial concept to the film’s release. The disc also retains the audio commentary from the 2004 Special Edition DVD, enhanced with new commentary segments specific to the Signature Edition. Other extras include deleted scenes, featurettes covering various aspects of production, and several vintage behind-the-scenes clips.
Extras included in this disc:
- The Giant's Dream: A documentary detailing Brad Bird’s career and the creation of the film.
- Audio Commentary: Insightful track featuring Brad Bird and key team members.
- Deleted Scenes: Six animated storyboards with an introduction by Brad Bird.
- Behind the Armor: Short featurettes on production elements.
- Motion Gallery: Comparison of drawings and animatics to the finished film.
- Vintage Easter Eggs: Hidden clips from the original DVD release.
- The Salt Mines: Insights into the storage of original drawings.
- Hand Drawn: Brad Bird discusses his preference for hand-drawn animation.
This array of extras provides a detailed and engaging look into the artistry and effort behind "The Iron Giant."
Movie: 88
"The Iron Giant," directed by Brad Bird, is a critically acclaimed animated feature that seamlessly blends 1950s nostalgia with poignant storytelling. Adapted from Ted Hughes's novel, "The Iron Man," the film shifts the setting to Cold War-era Rockwell, Maine, where heightened paranoia after Sputnik's launch forms the backdrop. The narrative follows young Hogarth Hughes, who discovers and befriends a colossal robot with no memory of its past. As their bond deepens, Hogarth introduces the Giant to the concepts of life, death, and morality, contrasting sharply with the military and government agents who view the robot as a threat. The movie's charm lies in its complex emotional core, where a seemingly menacing machine proves to have a gentle spirit under the guidance of Hogarth.
Technically, "The Iron Giant" is a masterpiece of hand-drawn animation that evokes classic Disney while heralding modern sensibilities akin to Bird's later works like "The Incredibles." The film includes visually stunning sequences and expertly balanced tones that shift from awe-inspiring to heart-wrenching with ease. The voice cast adds depth to the characters; Vin Diesel's portrayal of the Giant is particularly noteworthy, while Christopher McDonald's performance as the zealous government agent Kent Manley elevates the film’s tension. Additional scenes in the Signature Edition provide greater character backstory and enrich the narrative, such as Dean and Annie's diner conversation and the Giant's nightmarish flashbacks.
Despite its initial box office failure, "The Iron Giant" found an enduring legacy through home media, becoming a beloved family classic over time. This Blu-ray release offers both the original and the extended Signature Edition, allowing audiences to experience the film's full artistic vision. Its success showcases that true cinematic value isn't always reflected in box office numbers but in a film’s ability to evoke powerful emotional responses and resonate across generations.
Total: 79
Brad Bird’s "The Iron Giant" on Blu-ray is a masterful presentation that appeals both to aficionados and newcomers alike. Warner has released an outstanding package featuring the director's preferred version of the film alongside the original cut that has garnered a devoted following since its initial release. The HD video quality is exceptional, vividly capturing the film's painterly aesthetic. Complementing this, the 5.1 DTS-HD Master Audio soundtrack is superb and gains a nuanced enhancement when upmixed with DTS:Neural:X.
The Blu-ray extras are noteworthy. The package includes all bonus materials from the 1999 and 2004 DVD releases, as well as an impressive new documentary that offers deep insights into the making of this animated classic. Enthusiastic fans might also consider the Ultimate Collector's Edition, filled with additional goodies. Although some may wish for a UHD or Dolby Atmos release, the current coverage is comprehensive and satisfying.
In conclusion, "The Iron Giant" Blu-ray edition is a superior release that secures its place as a must-have for film enthusiasts. The combination of top-tier video and audio quality, coupled with extensive bonus content, makes this Blu-ray package highly recommended. If you're an Iron Giant mega-fan, this edition will undoubtedly exceed your expectations and is a worthy addition to any collection.
Blu-ray.com review by Michael ReubenRead review here
Video: 90
The Iron Giant is composed of both traditional hand-drawn animation and CG elements (notably, the Giant himself)....
Audio: 90
Broad dynamic range and deep bass extension help convey the Giant's massive stature and the details of his many activities, and the sound editing becomes more elaborate as the Giant's full capabilities...
Extras: 90
The Salt Mines (1080p; 1.78:1; 7:06): Iron Giant crew member Andrew Jimenez visits the Hutchinson Facility in Kansas, where all of the physical drawings for the film (including abandoned scenes and concepts,...
Movie: 90
Warner dubbed its new group "Warner Bros. Feature Animation", and like every other in-house division, it failed to replicate Disney's success in an era when animation was being redefined by the creative...
Total: 90
Warner has delivered an impressive package that provides both the director's preferred version of the film and the original cut that has attracted such a loyal following in the years since Iron Giant died...
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 80
While CG animation dazzles HD and UHD displays, I adore the way hand-drawn animation looks in high definition where, in some cases and depending on the print you saw back in the day, the image quality...
Audio: 80
'The Iron Giant' roars onto Blu-ray with a robust 5.1 DTS-HA Master Audio soundtrack that features excellent dynamic range, engaging surround panning, and thundering LFE.While I would have loved this film...
Extras: 40
'The Iron Giant' was released on DVD twice prior (along with Laserdisc and VHS) -- the first time in 1999 following the film's theatrical release, and a 2004 Special Edition....
Movie: 80
I like the simplicity, but there's no RESUME PLAY feature so any time you power down, want to swap to a different cut of the movie, watch a Special Feature, or engage Audio Commentary, the movie starts...
Total: 80
While I would have loved to see this film in UHD and/or with Dolby Atmos, 'The Iron Giant' Signature Edition Blu-ray comes highly, highly recommended for film fans of all ages....
AVSForum review by Ralph PottsRead review here
Video: 96
Based on the period in which the story takes place, colors maintain a limited and softer palette that is most decidedly a stylistic choice that mates well with the source in a satisfying way....
Audio: 92
The audio is crystal clear, free of the edginess and never shows its age which says something for the care that went into the encoding....
Extras: 80
Using stylized animatics, archival footage, original concept art, and revealing interviews, The Giant’s Dream charts the incredible ups and downs, industry firsts, and amazing history behind this iconic...
Movie: 100
It's even harder when a nosey government agent arrives in town to hunt down and destroy the "alien invader" and the combined land, sea and air might of the U.S. military is sent to assist him....
Total: 92
Universal Disc/3D capable Blu-ray Player Samsung UBD-K8500 Ultra HD Blu-ray Player Sony Playstation 3 Blu-ray disc Player System Controller: Apple iPad/iRule Pro HD Universal Remote Control Canton "Ergo"...
Why So Blu?Read review here
Video: 90
...
Audio: 100
Movement and character/object placement for sound is also well done in the front channels....
Extras: 90
The Voices of The Iron Giant (SD, 8:16) – Brad Bird, the animators and Vin Diesel go over the voice acting process for the movie....
Movie: 90
Looking back, this is a real treasure as its one of the best and last of the hand drawn movies as 2000 would really start pushing out more CG things or meshing the two formats frequently....
Total: 90
Brad Bird’s The Iron Giant finally makes its way to Blu-ray, and honestly, you could not have asked for a better presentation....
Director: Brad Bird
Actors: Eli Marienthal, Harry Connick Jr., Jennifer Aniston
PlotIn the 1950s town of Rockwell, Maine, a young boy named Hogarth Hughes discovers a giant metal robot that has fallen from space. Initially startled, Hogarth soon realizes that the Iron Giant is harmless and even friendly. Despite their immediate bond, Hogarth decides to keep the giant a secret to protect him from potential threats. With the help of local beatnik artist Dean McCoppin, Hogarth hides the Iron Giant in Dean's scrap yard, allowing them to form a close friendship. They teach the giant about humanity while also attempting to keep him out of sight.
As the U.S. government becomes aware of strange happenings in Rockwell, Agent Kent Mansley arrives to investigate. Suspicious and driven by Cold War paranoia, Mansley will stop at nothing to find the rumored giant. He closely monitors Hogarth, causing the situation to escalate. The bond between Hogarth and the Iron Giant is put to the test as they navigate growing dangers and misunderstandings. As tensions rise, the true nature of the Iron Giant and his purpose on Earth begin to unravel, culminating in a situation that challenges the very essence of heroism and friendship.
Writers: Tim McCanlies, Brad Bird, Ted Hughes
Release Date: 06 Aug 1999
Runtime: 86 min
Rating: PG
Country: United States, Czech Republic, United Kingdom
Language: English