Cartouche Blu-ray Review

Presented in its original aspect ratio of 2.35:1 and encoded with MPEG-4 AVC at 1080p, "Cartouche" on Blu-ray, courtesy of Kino Lorber, showcases a noteworthy restoration effort by L'immagine Ritrovata on behalf of StudioCanal. However, the visual quality presents a dichotomy. While the transfer benefits from an excellent 4K restoration process, capturing a spotless appearance with stable imaging, the color grading detracts significantly from the overall presentation. Many scenes suffer from incorrect primary color values and destabilizing gray tones that impart an undesirably digital feel to the film. These issues overshadow the intended organic color richness and nuanced shadows, particularly noticeable on larger screens.

Despite these color balance challenges, the film grain remains pleasingly organic, with fine details rendered with precision, suggesting that this could be among the better home video versions of the film. Nevertheless, the visually inherent flaws due to the grading missteps result in a product that does not wholly reflect its cinematic roots. Minimal artifacts such as scratches or dirt appear, which maintains a high standard for image cleanliness. It's imperative to note this is a Region-A locked Blu-ray release, requiring compatible hardware for access. This edition stands as a complex amalgam—a display of technical prowess marred by significant artistic decisions in the grading process.

The Blu-ray release of "Cartouche" boasts a singular audio presentation via a French DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0 track, complete with optional English subtitles. The audio quality is exceptional, characterized by crystalline clarity and a balanced mix that captures both dialogue and music with precision. This dynamic range is particularly noteworthy, allowing the robust action sequences and Georges Delerue’s rousing score to resonate without any compromise in fidelity.

Notably, the original mono soundtrack has been adeptly translated into the DTS-HD Master Audio format, ensuring strong, clear dialogue and an authentic representation of the overall sound mix. Reviewers have commended its faithful preservation, highlighting the absence of any detrimental audio issues such as crackling, hissing, or popping. The track enhances the viewing experience, providing what is arguably the finest audio rendition of "Cartouche" available on home video.

The Blu-ray extras for "Cartouche" provide a comprehensive dive into the film's historical and production nuances, curated with professionalism and depth. The newly recorded audio commentary by film critic Simon Abrams stands out, offering insights into the film’s production history and detailed biographies of key cast and crew members, a valuable resource for cinema enthusiasts seeking a deeper understanding of the production's context. Additionally, the documentary "Adventure with a Capital C," produced in collaboration with StudioCanal, features engaging discussions with Alexandra de Broca and journalist Thomas Morales, effectively exploring the film’s conception and enduring appeal. The collection rounds off with a classic theatrical trailer, appropriately preserving the film's original French flair complemented by English subtitles, along with additional KLSC trailers for thematic context.

Extras included in this disc:

• Commentary: Exclusive new audio commentary by critic Simon Abrams.
• Adventure with a Capital C: Documentary discussing the film's making and impact.
• Trailer: Vintage trailer in French, with English subtitles.

Philippe de Broca's "Cartouche" (1962), available on Blu-ray via StudioCanal, showcases a vibrant blend of action and slapstick, echoing the charm of classic Errol Flynn swashbucklers while crafting its own distinct narrative. The film's narrative takes inspiration from the legendary tales of the 18th-century highwayman Louis Dominique Bourguignon, alias Cartouche, portrayed with charismatic flair by Jean-Paul Belmondo. As a French rendition of Robin Hood, Cartouche embarks on a journey from serving a notorious gang leader to forming his own group of thieves, striking a noble chord by stealing from the rich to aid the poor. His companionship with Venus, a captivating gypsy played by Claudia Cardinale, adds a poignant romantic layer to the adventure, further invigorated by Philippe de Broca’s lively direction that ensures the film’s almost two-hour runtime whizzes by invitingly.

Remarkably executed stunts by Belmondo lend authenticity to the character’s dashing reputation, while Cardinale’s portrayal of Venus imbues the film with elegance and depth. The supporting cast, including Jess Hahn and Jean Rochefort as Cartouche's loyal allies, complements the lead performances, adding nuance and dynamic interplay reminiscent of literary musketeers. The film's use of slapstick humor enriches its comedic undertone without deviating towards overt satire, maintaining a balanced approach that pays homage to its genre inspirations.

The screenplay skillfully weaves historical liberties with folklore, enhancing its period authenticity through careful choreography of action sequences and strategic soundtrack deployment. The film’s brisk pacing is a testament to de Broca's expertise in sustaining viewer engagement. Despite its adventurous and comedic ambitions, "Cartouche" retains an enduring appeal nearly 60 years after its debut, capturing the essence of escapist cinema with a distinct French twist intertwined with nostalgia for classic European escapades.

The Blu-ray release of "Cartouche" offers a nuanced experience that’s unfortunately polarized by its restoration quality. This 1962 film, a hit at the French box office, famously starred Jean-Paul Belmondo and was directed by Philippe de Broca, leading to their subsequent collaboration on "That Man from Rio". The 4K restoration has sparked heated criticism due to its controversial color-grading practices that seem to be derived from less than favorable European lab standards, although the HD transfer provided by Kino is gracefully executed and mostly well-received.

The physical release does redeem itself with the inclusion of informative special features, which contribute positively to the overall value of the package. Fans of the film will appreciate these additions despite the visual discontent brought about by the restoration choices. The underlying qualities of "Cartouche"—its acting, direction, and cultural impact—pierce through the technical mishaps to make the experience still worthwhile for avid viewers and collectors.

In conclusion, while the 4K restoration might dilute its visual authenticity for some purists, the dominant essence of Cartouche remains intact, buoyed by its compelling narrative and strong performances. Consider this Blu-ray offering if you prioritize substance and special features over pure visual fidelity, keeping in mind the know-how of the talent behind. As always, each viewer may react differently to these restorative decisions, but the film's core charm undeniably persists.