Human Desire Blu-ray Review
Score: 77
from 4 reviewers
Review Date:
Fritz Lang's 'Human Desire' delivers a stylish, engaging noir with convincing performances, notably Gloria Grahame's, and superb Blu-ray video transfer. Highly recommended.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 84
Presented in 1080p using an MPEG-4 AVC transfer, this Blu-ray of 'Human Desire' features a film-like appearance with stable image fidelity but fluctuating clarity and contrast. While sourced from an older Sony remaster, it faithfully represents Burnett Guffey's cinematography, enhancing grayscales and shadow details, though a new 4K master could further improve visuals.
Audio: 89
The Blu-ray's DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0 mono track offers clear, stable sound, with a wide dynamic range handling the score and train noises without distortion. Dialogue is comprehensible, and age-related audio imperfections are absent, making it the best audio presentation for 'Human Desire' to date.
Extra: 44
The Blu-ray extras for 'Human Desire,' notably the insightful 'Terror and Desire' featurette with Emily Mortimer, provide an engaging exploration of the film's themes and style, though the absence of an audio commentary is a surprising omission, given the usual offerings of similar releases.
Movie: 74
"Human Desire" (1954), directed by Fritz Lang, diverges from Emile Zola’s original novel and Jean Renoir's earlier adaptation by crafting a unique film noir. Despite critiques of its plot holes and studio-enforced dilution of darker themes, it remains notable for its rich atmosphere, driven performances (notably Gloria Grahame's), and Lang's adept melding of gritty naturalism with stylized noir. Though less acclaimed than Lang's other works, it presents an engaging narrative with complex character dynamics.
Video: 84
"Human Desire" arrives on Blu-ray with a 1080p transfer using the MPEG-4 AVC codec, presented in its original 1.85:1 aspect ratio. Sourced from an older remaster likely provided by Sony Pictures, this release by Kino Lorber impresses with its film-like character, maintaining Burnett Guffey's stark cinematography. The image stability is excellent, with no age-related imperfections, offering a clean and consistent viewing experience. Clarity and contrast levels occasionally fluctuate, but they effectively capture the essence of the film. This Region-Free Blu-ray allows playback across geographic locations.
The grayscale ranges effectively, enhancing the depth with lush blacks and crisp whites that avoid blooming. Shadow delineation is noteworthy, emphasizing fine detail and minimizing crush in darker scenes. While a new 4K master could potentially offer superior visuals, this transfer maintains an attractive organic appearance that will satisfy most viewers. Areas where density levels drop lend the film a documentary quality integral to its aesthetic. Minor adjustments could improve blacks and grays, yet the current master already performs commendably in handling these elements.
Film grain and fine details are rendered faithfully, surpassing previous DVD versions and offering likely the best home video presentation of "Human Desire." Although minor scratches and marks are present, they do not detract significantly from the overall viewing experience. Fans with the 2010 DVD edition will find this Blu-ray a worthy upgrade, while those owning the 2019 Eureka release might not deem it necessary to double-dip. Overall, this Blu-ray offers a well-rounded visual presentation that aligns with professional expectations for classic film restoration on contemporary home media.
Audio: 89
The Blu-ray release of "Human Desire" features an English DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0 mono track that impressively preserves the sonic integrity of this classic film. The audio presentation is defined by its clarity and stability, offering a listening experience free from age-related imperfections such as hiss, pops, and crackle. Dialogue is consistently clear and easily comprehensible, which maintains the authenticity of the film's interpersonal tensions. Optional English SDH subtitles enhance accessibility for viewers who may require them.
This audio track handles Daniele Amfitheatrof's score with a wide dynamic range, allowing for the melodramatic highs and lows to be presented without distortion. The strong bass frequencies adeptly convey the atmospheric rumblings of the train, which serves as a central auditory element within the film. Distinct sonic details, including facial slaps and train whistles, contribute to a soundscape that is both engaging and immersive.
Overall, the DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0 track represents a significant upgrade over previous DVD releases, presenting "Human Desire" with enhanced audio fidelity on home video. It captures the full spectrum of sound with precision, allowing audiences to fully appreciate the rich acoustic nuances that define Fritz Lang's black-and-white classic.
Extras: 44
The Blu-ray of "Human Desire" includes a robust set of extras, albeit missing an anticipated audio commentary. The absence of such a track is peculiar given the presence in similar releases, yet the disc's content still provides valuable insights. The highlight is "Terror and Desire," a featurette with actress Emily Mortimer, who thoughtfully explores the film's themes, claustrophobic tension, and the influence of German Expressionism, while also noting Gloria Grahame's enigmatic performance. Despite the mystery around Mortimer's selection for this task, her commentary is insightful and adds depth to the understanding of the film. The additional inclusion of a vintage theatrical trailer further complements the viewing experience by giving historical context to the film’s marketing approach. Collectively, these extras enrich the value of this release for aficionados and scholars alike.
Extras included in this disc:
- Terror and Desire: Emily Mortimer discusses film themes and style.
- Theatrical Trailer: Original preview highlighting the film’s intrigue.
- Bonus KLSC Trailers: Trailers for other notable films.
Movie: 74
"Human Desire" (1954), directed by Fritz Lang, is a notable entry in the film noir genre, even if it doesn't fully meet the lofty expectations set by Lang's previous masterpieces. The film, a remake of Jean Renoir’s "La Bête humaine," adapts Émile Zola's novel with some unique twists. The narrative seamlessly transplants the story from 1930s France to post-World War II America. The new setting enriches the narrative's dark tone and visuals, skillfully captured by cinematographer Burnett Guffey. Lang's directing prowess shines as he layers gritty realism with the stylization emblematic of film noir, creating a foreboding atmosphere that is expertly punctuated by the actual railroad scenes.
The story revolves around Jeff Warren (Glenn Ford), a war veteran caught in a treacherous love triangle with Vicki Buckley (Gloria Grahame) and her possessive husband Carl (Broderick Crawford). Ford brings his characteristic cocksure presence to Jeff, evoking the internal conflict of a man torn between seduction and morality. Grahame delivers an impactful performance as Vicki, embodying the femme fatale archetype with depth and nuance that might have been elusive with an actress like Rita Hayworth. Crawford's portrayal of Carl brings palpable menace to the screen, enhancing the film’s tense dynamics. These character portrayals are crucial, given that the plot sometimes stretches believability, hinging on dubious motivations and substantial plot holes.
While "Human Desire" holds its place as a solid noir film, it grapples with pacing issues and occasionally struggles to sustain its narrative momentum. Still, its emotive performances and strong visual style make it a compelling watch for noir enthusiasts. Though not Lang’s best, this film presents an intricate tale of lust and betrayal that provides fleeting yet profound cinematic pleasures.
Total: 77
"Human Desire," directed by Fritz Lang, is a compelling yet divisive piece within the noir genre, with its roots embedded in Emile Zola's novel. The film diverges significantly from Jean Renoir's "La Bête Humaine," with which it shares an inspirational source, offering a distinct American interpretation that takes the narrative in an entirely new direction. Lang's characterizations stand out for their depth, particularly Gloria Grahame's performance, which many reviewers regard as one of her finest. Grahame's portrayal is nuanced and compelling, surpassing initial plans to cast Rita Hayworth in the role.
The technical aspects of the Blu-ray release by Kino are noteworthy, featuring excellent video and audio transfers that enhance the film’s moody aesthetic. This release also includes engaging extras such as a candid interview with actress Emily Mortimer and a vintage trailer, adding layers to the film’s historical appreciation. While some critics argue that the film doesn’t reach the height of Lang's preceding work, "The Big Heat," the stylish direction and potent themes of infidelity and jealousy make it a worthwhile addition to any noir enthusiast's collection.
In conclusion, although "Human Desire" may not fully meet the high expectations typically associated with Fritz Lang's oeuvre, it remains a stylistically impressive and narratively intriguing film. Its compelling performances, particularly by Gloria Grahame, along with Kino’s high-quality Blu-ray presentation, render this film highly recommended for both classic cinema fans and those interested in the intricacies of noir storytelling.
Blu-ray.com review by Dr. Svet AtanasovRead review here
Video: 80
If you have a larger screen or project, you will rightfully conclude that a brand new 4K master will deliver superior visuals, but at the moment the film has an attractive organic appearance....
Audio: 100
There is only one standard audio track on this Blu-ray release: Eng;osh DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0....
Extras: 40
Terror and Desire - in this archival program, actress Emily Mortimer discusses the nature of some of the conflicts that are depicted in Human Desire as well as the film's style and personality....
Movie: 80
In the second part, Jeff realizes that his encounter with Vicki was not accidental, and that it is almost certainly related to the murder that occurred on the train at the same time....
Total: 80
With Rita Hayworth playing the same character, which apparently was the original plan, I don't think that the film would have turned out as nicely as it did....
The Digital Bits review by Stuart Galbraith IVRead review here
Video: 90
Audio: 90
Kino’s Blu-ray of Human Desire presents the black-and-white film in its original theatrical aspect ratio: 1.85:1....
Extras: 75
Movie: 85
Reuniting the director and stars of the noir classic The Big Heat (1953), Human Desire (1954) remakes Jean Renoir’s La Bête humaine (1938) though not as well, partly because of Production Code- and studio-demanded...
Total: 85
In any event, Mortimer’s segment is better than one might expect as she discusses her admiration of the film largely from an actor’s perspective, which is interesting....
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 80
Clarity, contrast, and grain levels all fluctuate, but the overall presentation exudes a fetching film-like feel and faithfully captures the stark cinematography of Burnett Guffey, who won an Oscar the...
Audio: 80
A wide dynamic scale handles all the highs and lows of Daniele Amfitheatrof's melodramatic score without any distortion, while strong bass frequencies enhance the rumbling, rattling train noise that supplies...
Extras: 20
That said, an appreciation of Human Desire by actress Emily Mortimer is a welcome addition and it's always nice to see the original theatrical trailer....
Movie: 60
Though Hayworth impeccably played one of the most memorable femme fatales in film history in The Lady from Shanghai, it's tough to imagine her tackling Vicki with the same conviction as Grahame, who specialized...
Total: 80
Ford, Grahame, and Crawford give the material their all, but their characters often seem more like cardboard cutouts than flesh and blood....
Home Theater Forum review by t1g3r5fanRead review here
Video: 100
Overall, this Blu-ray release is likely the best the movie will ever look on home video and surpasses the previous DVD release of the movie....
Audio: 100
All in all, this release is likely the best the movie will ever sound on home video and bests the film’s previous DVD release....
Extras: 50
The actress – the daughter of writer John Mortimer – shares her appreciation of the movie, particularly the acting performances, in this archival featurette from the Film Noir Collection:...
Movie: 80
As the hot-headed Carl, Broderick Crawford returns to his roots playing the heavy convincingly here; he would make a few more noirs – notably in Big House U.S.A. (1955) – before a sojourn acting in Europe...
Total: 80
Kino has done a decent job bringing the movie to Blu-ray, with a solid HD transfer and carrying over the appreciation featurette from the film’s previous DVD release....
Director: Fritz Lang
Actors: Glenn Ford, Gloria Grahame, Broderick Crawford
PlotA veteran railroad engineer named Carl Buckley is fired from his job after a heated altercation with his boss. Desperate to regain employment, Carl pressures his young wife, Vicki, to use her past acquaintance with a powerful man to influence his decision. Reluctantly, Vicki complies but soon finds herself in a precarious situation as Carl's jealousy and suspicion turn violent when he learns Vicki's meeting may have been more intimate than she let on. In a fit of rage, Carl confronts the man, which leads to a tragic event. As the situation spirals out of control, it attracts the attention of Jeff Warren, a returning war veteran working as a train engineer. Jeff becomes entangled in their tumultuous relationship.
Things become even more complicated when Jeff finds himself drawn to the troubled Vicki. Their burgeoning affair is hounded by deceit, passion, and danger, as Jeff is torn between helping Vicki escape her oppressive marriage and the moral dilemma of getting involved with a married woman whose life is enmeshed in murder. As he delves deeper into their world, Jeff uncovers secrets that threaten to unravel everything he knows about desire and justice. Suspense intensifies as each character struggles with their internal constraints and desires, propelling them towards an unpredictable confrontation where each must face their own limitations and choices in this dark tale of longing and redemption.
Writers: Alfred Hayes, Émile Zola
Release Date: 03 Nov 1954
Runtime: 91 min
Rating: Approved
Country: United States
Language: English