You Only Live Once Blu-ray Review
Score: 58
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
The Blu-ray release of 'You Only Live Once' from ClassicFlix boasts impressive video restoration, informative commentary, and honors Fritz Lang's direction with top-notch quality. Highly recommended.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 68
The new 1080p transfer of 'You Only Live Once' from ClassicFlix, using 35mm elements provided by the British Film Institute, is a significant restoration achievement. Despite minor age-related wear, the transfer boasts improved clarity, contrast, and detail, effectively showcasing Leon Shamroy's cinematography with natural grain and robust blacks.
Audio: 58
"You Only Live Once's DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0 mono track delivers clear dialogue and impressive atmospheric subtleties despite its age, though it occasionally suffers from tinny sound effects and upper register clipping, maintaining a clean presentation with minimal hiss."
Extra: 26
Expert commentary and 1080p restoration comparison enhance the Blu-ray experience of 'You Only Live Once,' filling the void left by earlier DVD releases.
Movie: 91
You Only Live Once is a visually stunning, emotionally gripping film by Fritz Lang that highlights the societal challenges faced by reformed criminals through Henry Fonda’s memorable performance. Despite its initial reception, its rich thematic depth and expressionist style have solidified its status as an underappreciated classic.
Video: 68
The Blu-ray presentation of "You Only Live Once" by ClassicFlix showcases a meticulous AVC encoded 1080p transfer in a 1.37:1 aspect ratio. Sourced from 35mm archival elements provided by the British Film Institute, the restoration entailed hundreds of hours of careful work. The result is an impressive visual improvement over previous versions that suffered from significant damage such as scratches, dirt, and warped frames. These issues have been effectively mitigated, delivering a near-miraculous transformation. Though some minor age-related wear remains, the overall image is much more robust with a natural, organic appearance. The grain can be quite heavy at times, but it contributes to the authentic filmic look, though detail levels understandably don't match modern standards.
Clarity and contrast in this remastered transfer are especially noteworthy, highlighting Leon Shamroy's striking cinematography. While a touch of softness persists, the image features rich blacks and bright whites that avoid blooming. The grayscale spectrum shows pleasing variance, and the detail in shadows, foggy scenes, and night sequences is particularly commendable without significant crush issues. Background elements are distinctly visible, adding depth and texture to the film's gritty atmosphere. This restoration not only revives a classic but also reframes its artistic value for contemporary audiences, deserving high praise for its technical finesse and dedication to cinematic preservation.
Audio: 58
The audio presentation of "You Only Live Once" on Blu-ray features a DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0 mono track that showcases both its age and the preservation efforts involved. Despite the limitations inherent in 80-year-old recording technologies, the track delivers clear, well-modulated sound. The dialogue is clear and easy to comprehend, surviving the age-related challenges without significant issues. Some subtle background noises, like chirping crickets and driving rain, successfully provide essential atmosphere, adding to the overall viewing experience.
Despite occasional boxy and tinny characteristics typical of the era's audio quality, key sound effects such as blaring alarms, sirens, and gunfire remain crisp and distinct. Alfred Newman's music score, although uncredited, benefits from surprising resonance and tonal depth, enhancing the film's emotional impact. While slight hiss can be detected in quieter scenes, the track is free from disruptive pops, crackles, or other surface noise. In summary, this audio transfer does an admirable job capturing the essence of its time while providing a surprisingly clean and immersive auditory experience.
Extras: 26
The Blu-ray of "You Only Live Once" offers a commendable collection of extras that significantly enhance the viewing experience for cinephiles and film historians alike. The Audio Commentary by Author and Film Historian Jeremy Arnold is engaging and insightful, providing deep contextual background and analysis that enriches the film’s appreciation. The inclusion of a detailed Restoration Comparison (1080p; 5:12) is particularly illuminating, showcasing the meticulous effort involved in restoring this classic film to its current high-definition form. This Blu-ray effectively bridges the gap left by the bare-bones previous DVD release, making it a substantial upgrade for collectors and enthusiasts.
Extras included in this disc:
- Audio Commentary by Author and Film Historian Jeremy Arnold: In-depth commentary offering historical and cinematic insights.
- Restoration Comparison: Demonstrates the differences between the original and restored versions, highlighting the restoration process.
Movie: 91
"You Only Live Once," directed by Fritz Lang, is a gripping, fatalistic tale of social injustice that combines intense crime drama with a heartfelt love story. The film, starring Henry Fonda and Sylvia Sidney, presents a bleak view of a society unwilling to provide second chances. Fonda portrays Eddie Taylor, an ex-convict determined to reform but repeatedly thwarted by societal prejudices and circumstantial evidence. Sidney's character, Jo, stands steadfastly by Eddie, creating a poignant narrative of star-crossed lovers ensnared by fate. Lang's direction imbues the film with stylistic flourishes, utilizing stark shadows and tight close-ups, expertly captured by cinematographer Leon Shamroy.
The narrative's melancholy tone and unforgiving outlook make "You Only Live Once" a precursor to the film noir genre. Fonda's performance balances warmth, anger, and inner turmoil, making Eddie a sympathetic figure despite his flaws. Sidney brings raw emotion to her role, providing the film its emotional core. Supporting performances by Barton MacLane, Jean Dixon, and Jerome Cowan enhance the film’s depth, with Cowan’s portrayal of a cowardly prison doctor standing out.
Technically and artistically robust, the film showcases Lang's mastery in evoking tension and empathy through visual composition and narrative structure. Despite its initial lukewarm reception, "You Only Live Once" has gained critical acclaim over time for its powerful portrayal of social issues and personal struggles. This 1937 production remains relevant today, highlighting the timeless nature of Lang's vision and the exceptional performances that drive this tragic tale.
Total: 58
Fritz Lang's "You Only Live Once" stands as a testament to his directorial prowess, bolstered by compelling performances from Henry Fonda and Sylvia Sidney. This timeless narrative of one man's tragic entanglement within an unrelenting society continues to resonate profoundly, even eight decades after its original release. The film's evocative portrayal of social injustices is heightened by Lang's masterful direction and striking visual storytelling, delivering a potent cinematic experience.
ClassicFlix has showcased its meticulous restoration capabilities with this Blu-ray release. The video quality is largely impressive, bringing newfound vibrancy to Lang's breathtaking imagery, while the audio restoration ensures clarity and immersion. Film historian Jeremy Arnold’s commentary lends further depth, offering insightful perspectives that complement the viewing experience and enhance appreciation for the film’s historical and thematic significance.
For my money, this is the best release yet from ClassicFlix. The video restoration is largely quite impressive, and the commentary by Jeremy Arnold is also enjoyable and informative. The film itself is notable from any number of angles and should certainly appeal to cineastes with a taste for Lang or the film's iconic stars. Highly recommended.
Blu-ray.com review by Jeffrey KauffmanRead review here
Video: 80
The results here are generally excellent, and in fact when watching the restoration comparison and seeing some of the damage the original elements displayed, some may term it as near miraculous....
Audio: 60
The entire track has the typically boxy and occasionally tinny sound of its era's recording technologies, and as a result some of the sound effects don't resonate with any particular force....
Extras: 30
Audio Commentary by Author and Film Historian and Jeremy Arnold Restoration Comparison (1080p; 5:12)...
Movie: 90
There's circumstantial evidence which seems to implicate Eddie, and despite his denials and with his troubled past providing lots of newsprint for the tabloid journals of the day, Eddie is soon enough...
Total: 80
The film itself is notable from any number of angles and should certainly appeal to cineastes with a taste for Lang or the film's iconic stars....
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 80
Background elements are always easy to discern, depth is palpable, and only a few errant nicks and marks dot the source material....
Audio: 80
All the dialogue is clear and easy to comprehend, despite the primitive recording equipment, and Alfred Newman's music score (for which he did not receive screen credit) enjoys a surprising amount of resonance...
Extras: 0
...
Movie: 100
Depression-era viewers hungry for optimistic escapism spurned the film due to its downbeat nature, but had they bothered to take a closer look, they surely would have identified with and drawn comfort...
Total: 60
Classicflix honors this moving motion picture with top-notch video and audio restorations that enhance its appeal and help this powerful, engrossing, and visually arresting film regain its luster....
Director: Fritz Lang
Actors: Sylvia Sidney, Henry Fonda, Barton MacLane
PlotEddie Taylor, a hardened ex-convict trying to turn his life around, finds solace in the love and support of his girlfriend, Joan. Determined to start anew, Eddie marries Joan and secures a job as a truck driver. However, his criminal past overshadows his attempts at redemption, as society and law enforcement continue to view him with suspicion. When a bank robbery occurs, Eddie is wrongfully accused due to circumstantial evidence, including his criminal record, which makes him a prime suspect. Despite their pleas of innocence, Eddie is convicted and sentenced to death, devastating Joan who believes wholeheartedly in his innocence.
As Eddie faces execution, Joan tirelessly works to clear his name, discovering new evidence that might prove his innocence. The story then takes an unexpected turn with a dramatic prison escape that sends Eddie and Joan on the run. The fugitive couple tries desperately to reach safety while being pursued by law enforcement. Their journey is fraught with danger and heartbreak, setting the stage for an emotional and gripping climax that questions whether true redemption is possible in an unforgiving world.
Writers: Gene Towne, C. Graham Baker
Release Date: 29 Jan 1937
Runtime: 86 min
Rating: Approved
Country: United States
Language: English