Saving General Yang Blu-ray Review
忠烈楊家將
Score: 66
from 4 reviewers
Review Date:
Saving General Yang: A visually stunning historical action drama with great picture and audio, though it occasionally skims historical depth.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 72
The 1080p AVC-encoded transfer of 'Saving General Yang' offers a visually robust presentation with excellent fine detail, vivid colorization, and deep black levels, despite some occasional CGI softness. The film's deliberate use of a limited color scheme supports its period aesthetic effectively.
Audio: 75
The DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 mix of 'Saving General Yang' delivers an immersive, powerful, and dynamic soundscape with clear dialogue and impactful low-frequency effects. It offers precise imaging and active surround channels that enhance both the action-packed sequences and more ambient moments, providing an engaging home theater experience.
Extra: 38
The Blu-ray extras for 'Saving General Yang' are robust, featuring a 9-minute making-of segment with intriguing behind-the-scenes footage, an extensive 94-minute collection of in-depth interviews with the director and cast, and an HD trailer—all presented in high definition.
Movie: 68
Saving General Yang, despite lacking deep character development and narrative complexity, offers an epic visual spectacle with stunning action sequences and sumptuous production design, making it an engaging watch for fans of historical war epics.
Video: 72
"Saving General Yang" receives a commendable Blu-ray video presentation, demonstrating high technical proficiency and strong aesthetic sensibility. Encoded with AVC/MPEG-4 in 1080p and presented in a 2.39:1 aspect ratio, the transfer boasts a sharp and precise image with excellent detail. The film’s period setting is effectively rendered through a limited yet purposeful color scheme predominated by steely blues, grays, and blacks, occasionally punctuated with vibrant splashes of crimson, and warm accents to offset the monochromatic palette. This stylistic choice works exceptionally well in highlighting both the film’s subject matter and time period, preserving the filmic quality vital for historical narratives.
The high-definition transfer captures fine detail superbly, especially in close-ups that reveal the intricate designs of the costumes and sets. Contrast levels are spot-on, ensuring whites remain punchy and grays multi-staged, enhancing depth and clarity. Black levels are robust and maintain a consistent quality throughout, displaying full-bodied shadows with excellent delineation and no evidence of banding. The colors used in battle scenes are vividly saturated, making dramatic moments stand out visually without appearing unrealistic. Despite the occasional softening due to CGI or green screen elements, these incidences don't detract significantly from the viewing experience.
The transfer impeccably handles the varying tones as it shifts from vibrant to dark and drab scenes. Flesh tones maintain a natural appearance without veering into pastiness or unnatural hues. Shadow delineation is particularly strong, allowing for detailed low-light sequences that contribute to the film's immersive atmosphere. The overall image quality is cleanly rendered, free from video-related anomalies or artifacts, affirming "Saving General Yang" as an exemplary representation of Blu-ray’s high-definition capabilities.
Audio: 75
The DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 track in "Saving General Yang" delivers a highly immersive and dynamic sonic experience. The original Mandarin DTS-HD MA track is notably superior for its authentic and detailed soundscape compared to the dubbed English version. This high-resolution, lossless format allows for extended dynamic range that renders the film’s intense action sequences with impactful energy. Dialogue is consistently clear, richly textured, and exhibits excellent spatial presence. The clarity and resolution of sound effects, including clashing swords and swirling objects, are impeccable, ensuring a fully engaging home theater experience. Imaging is precise, providing seamless integration across the surround channels, enveloping the listener in a coherent and compelling auditory environment.
In terms of sound design, the track employs a rich balance of aggressive action and nuanced environmental effects. The sound field opens up considerably when battle sequences commence, effectively utilizing all channels to create a sense of immersive chaos. The frontal channels deliver heavy battle noises with precision, while the rear channels enhance the experience with discrete use of ambient sounds and low-frequency effects. This ensures that even quieter scenes benefit from thoughtful attention to directional audio cues. Low-frequency detail is authoritative and contributes to the palpable impact of physical clashes. Although there are minor instances where the film's score slightly overwhelms other audio elements, these moments are few and do not detract significantly from an otherwise stellar audio presentation.
The sound mix's ability to adjust dynamically based on the on-screen action keeps the viewer engaged throughout. Whether it’s rendering the subtleties of an arrow whizzing by or the intense cacophony of large-scale battles, the DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 track maintains a high level of fidelity and immersion. Overall, "Saving General Yang" offers an exemplary auditory experience that enhances its narrative and visual elements significantly.
Extras: 38
The extras on the Blu-ray of "Saving General Yang" offer a mixed bag but are ultimately satisfying. The "Making Of" featurette provides intriguing behind-the-scenes footage, showcasing the intense effort behind the film's battle scenes, though it's primarily promotional. The standout is the extended 94-minute documentary featuring comprehensive interviews with director Ronny Yu and the cast, which offers deep insights into the production and character portrayals. This segment, nearly as lengthy as the film itself, ensures a thorough understanding of the creators' vision. The collection is rounded off with an HD trailer.
Extras included in this disc:
Making Of: Typical promotional feature with interesting behind-the-scenes action shots.
Interviews with Director and Cast: Extensive 94-minute documentary with in-depth interviews.
Trailer: Official movie trailer in HD.
Movie: 68
"Saving General Yang" is an ambitious historical war epic directed by Ronny Yu, set in Northeast China during the early Northern Song dynasty (AD 986). The film depicts General Yang Ye's (Adam Cheng) capture by the Khitan army and his seven sons' perilous journey to rescue him. The plot follows the brothers—led by the eldest, Ekin Cheng—braving Wolf Mountain's treacherous terrain and facing an army of thousands. While the storyline itself isn’t particularly innovative, Yu infuses the narrative with visual grandeur through impressive overhead and crane shots. The production design is sumptuous, enriching the film with a vibrant historical aesthetic.
The film attempts to strike a balance between epic battles and poignant family drama. However, the focus leans heavily towards spectacle, with well-staged action sequences overshadowing character development. Critics noted that although the battles are thrilling, such as an arrow fight amidst shoulder-high grass, the characters often come across as two-dimensional. This lack of depth makes it difficult for viewers to form an emotional connection with the brothers, whose unique fighting styles are more memorable than their personal traits. Despite this, Yu's dynamic direction delivers a visually captivating experience that sustains interest throughout its 102-minute runtime.
"Saving General Yang" is notable for its compelling set pieces, particularly a prolonged battle atop Wolf Mountain that bridges the film's second and third acts. However, the narrative suffers from a weak script that fails to flesh out relationships between the brothers adequately. The film's dedication to visual splendor does help compensate for these deficiencies, highlighting Yu’s skillful direction reminiscent of his previous works like "Fearless." For enthusiasts of war epics imbued with elements of folklore and brutal combat scenes, "Saving General Yang" is worth watching, promising a mix of historical intrigue and effective, if not deeply engaging, cinematic spectacle.
Total: 66
"Saving General Yang" offers viewers a visually breathtaking experience and does justice to its historical epic roots, albeit with certain limitations. Directed by Ronny Yu, this film balances intense action sequences with a nuanced emotional undertone, albeit briefly skimming through its rich historical context. While the characters may sometimes seem like ancient archetypes, the film compensates for this with its stunning cinematography and elaborate battle scenes. The Blu-ray presentation amplifies these visual elements significantly, making it a worthwhile addition for fans of historical dramas and Asian cinema.
The technical aspects of the Blu-ray are notably impressive. The picture quality is exceptional, providing crisp and vibrant visuals that capture the film's intricate set designs and lush landscapes. Audio quality is equally robust, delivering clear and dynamic sound that enhances the immersive experience of the film’s action-packed scenes. Additionally, the Blu-ray comes loaded with special features that offer deeper insights into the making of the movie, adding value for collectors and movie buffs alike.
In conclusion, while "Saving General Yang" might not delve deeply into historical intricacies, its captivating visuals, well-executed action scenes, and high-quality Blu-ray presentation make it highly recommendable. With an engaging directorial approach from Ronny Yu and a solid array of extras, this Blu-ray release is a commendable purchase for those interested in action-packed historical dramas.
Blu-ray.com review by Jeffrey KauffmanRead review here
Video: 90
Colors are often bold and extremely vividly saturated, and fine detail is excellent, especially in close-ups which reveal the finery of the sets and costumes....
Audio: 90
The big action set pieces provide a wealth of surround activity, but even in quieter moments there is some good attention paid to directional ambient effects....
Extras: 30
Making Of (1080i; 8:58) Interviews with Director and Cast (1080i; 1:34:12) Trailer (1080p; 2:22)...
Movie: 70
While the story here is not especially innovative, director Ronny Yu's visual sense heightens the enjoyment factor considerably, lending a suitably epic feel to much of the proceedings, not necessarily...
Total: 80
The problem with revisiting ancient folk tales is that it's often difficult to make the characters seems like anything more than ancient archetypes, and that's the case here as well, though truth be told,...
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 80
As it stands, aside from the odd spurt here or there, the film does not focus a great deal of bloodshed in the actual moment of battle; instead, it waits until afterward to show the cost of what is essentially...
Audio: 80
There are a few moments when the whisper soft sound of arrows whizzing through the air is a little unconvincing, as well as a few moments when the film's score tends to overwhelm the other components of...
Extras: 40
Not a lot here, but some pretty interesting behind-the-scenes shots of the action and the enormous amount of extras that went into making some of the battle scenes....
Movie: 60
To his credit, Yu manages to make the most of what he's working with, as certain deficiencies in the story and characters don't necessarily deter him from attempting to construct some kind of emotional...
Total: 60
There's plenty of history here, to be sure, but most of it is merely surface-level stuff; the kind you'd get from reading the brief synopsis on the back of the box....
AVSForumRead review here
Video: 90
It’s cleanly rendered with plenty of subtle refinement and delineation that enhance depth and reveal fine detail in objects, clothing, and physical features....
Audio: 92
Dynamics range is extended which renders the film’s action based sequences with definitive impact and energy....
Extras: 30
(HD) Making of Saving General Yang – 9 minutes (HD) Cast/Director Interviews – 94 minutes (HD) Trailer...
Movie: 70
Led by the first son (Ekin Cheng), the seven - two of whom have never seen combat - set out with a small band of fighters to face an army of thousands, brave the treacherous Wolf Mountain, face the nemesis...
Total: 71
Sony Playstation 3 Blu-ray disc Player (HDMI Audio/Video) System Controller: Apple iPad/iRule Pro HD Universal Remote Control Canton "Ergo" Series speakers Axiom Audio QS8 Quadpolar speakers SV Sound PB-13...
Why So Blu?Read review here
Video: 80
The color palette can shift from vibrancy to dark and drabness depending on the locale and scene in the film and both of these shifts in colors are handled flawlessly by the transfer....
Audio: 90
Extras: 60
The first is a making of featurette that plays with just music in the background and we get to see the actual filming of the movie, with cameras and cranes swinging about all over the place....
Movie: 80
This poses some problems, because two of the sons have zero combat experience, which may bring more harm than good to the rest of the clan should they meet with evil forces....
Total: 80
The video, audio and excellent special features make for a cool Blu-ray package that all lovers of Asian film should add to their collection....
Director: Ronny Yu
Actors: Fan Xu, Adam Cheng, Ekin Cheng
PlotSet during the Song Dynasty, the story follows an esteemed noble family, the Yangs, who are fiercely loyal to their country. When the Khitan army invades, General Yang is entrusted with the task of leading the Imperial forces to repel them. However, due to a treacherous scheme orchestrated by rival families, General Yang and his troops fall into a deadly trap. As the enemy grows closer, his seven sons, each skilled in martial arts and warfare, take it upon themselves to rescue their father from impending doom.
Embarking on a perilous mission against overwhelming odds, the brothers face numerous challenges and formidable opponents. Their fiery loyalty and unwavering determination to save their father unite them on this grim journey. Each brother must summon their unique skills and courage to navigate hostile territories and fend off relentless adversaries. With time running out, bonds are tested, sacrifices are made, and family honor hangs in the balance as the brothers strive to bring their father back to safety.
Writers: Katherine Lo, Edmond Wong, Ronny Yu
Release Date: 10 May 2013
Runtime: 102 min
Rating: Not Rated
Country: Hong Kong, China
Language: Mandarin