Bedtime Stories Blu-ray Review
Score: 57
from 4 reviewers
Review Date:
Despite excellent video transfer, 'Bedtime Stories' falls short with forgettable performances and superficial content, rendering its technical brilliance wasted.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 67
"Bedtime Stories' Blu-ray offers a vibrant and meticulously detailed 1080p/AVC-encoded transfer with a 2.35:1 aspect ratio, showcasing excellent depth, saturated colors, and sharp contrast. Despite occasional minor issues like oversaturated skin tones and brief inconsistencies, the overall visual quality impresses with its clean presentation and inky blacks.”
Audio: 58
The DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 track for 'Bedtime Stories' provides a clear, dynamic surround mix with well-rendered dialogue, balanced ambient effects, and subtle bass. While not flawless, it captures the whimsical elements fitting a kids' fantasy-comedy, though it occasionally falters with overly aggressive rear channels.
Extra: 48
The 'Bedtime Stories' Blu-ray 3-disc set has its moments with high-definition features like 'Until Gravity Do Us Part' and 'To All the Little People,' but overall, it falls short with its lackluster supplemental content. Despite the HD presentation, extras such as bloopers, deleted scenes, and brief featurettes feel insufficient for a package of this calibre.
Movie: 41
Bedtime Stories fails to captivate any audience with its lackluster plot, predictable narrative, and diluted performances, despite delivering good video and audio quality on Blu-ray. The film's attempts at whimsy fall flat, leaving it too dull for kids, too uninspired for adults, and ultimately disappointing for all.
Video: 67
The Blu-ray video presentation of Bedtime Stories boasts a pristine 1080p High Definition transfer, maintaining the film's original 2.35:1 aspect ratio. Detail quality is consistently high throughout, from wide shots to close-ups, with no noticeable issues such as grain or digital noise reduction. The color palette is notably broad and vibrant, particularly enhanced by the film's fantasy sequences which feature visually stimulating scenarios, from Roman times to futuristic worlds. Black levels are deep and well-defined, enhancing the overall image sharpness and creating a rich visual experience.
In terms of technical execution, the video presentation excels with its saturated colors, strong contrast, and impressive three-dimensional depth. Low lighting scenes retain significant depth, and shadow delineation is precise with inky blacks providing convincing dimensionality. Small issues such as slightly oversaturated skintones and occasional noise in nighttime shots are present but do not detract from the overall high quality. The transfer is impressively clean, free from distracting artifacts or print inconsistencies.
Despite minor pitfalls like occasional miscolored moments and inconsistent sharpness in certain scenes, the visual presentation of Bedtime Stories makes a strong impact. The film's bright, textured aesthetic almost rivals that of animated features, with excellent contrast and crisp detail throughout. These elements underscore Disney's unwavering commitment to delivering top-tier high-definition content.
Audio: 58
The audio presentation of the Blu-ray release of "Bedtime Stories" is delivered via a DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 track, which performs competently for its genre, offering a clean and engaging auditory experience. Dialogue, which forms a core mechanic of the storytelling, is well-rendered through the center channel, maintaining clarity and coherence throughout. The surround channels are diligently employed to create an immersive environment that underscores the narrative's whimsical tone, evidenced by the lively ambient sounds ranging from the chirping of birds to the clattering of hotel kitchenware. Directionality and balance are generally commendable, ensuring that both subtle and prominent audio cues are effectively presented without detracting from the viewer's immersion.
However, there are elements that are less than stellar. The sound design, while active, occasionally overreaches with its aggressive rear speaker activity and an overwhelming dynamic range that may disrupt the listening experience. While scenes involving roaring Ferrari engines or chariot gallops are convincingly portrayed, the overall mix sometimes loses finesse, resulting in a soundscape that can be more disorienting than engaging. Low frequency effects, while certainly present, do not assert much intensity, providing a supportive backdrop rather than a commanding presence.
Even with these minor shortcomings, the surround mix accomplishes its primary objective—bringing the vivid dreams and fantasies to life. The background score, though largely forgettable, is seamlessly integrated with both discrete and ambient sounds to encapsulate the film’s ebullient spirit. Despite some heavy-handed moments, younger audiences will likely find the dynamic, sometimes bombastic audio engaging. Overall, the audio track delivers a solid performance suitable for the colorful and energetic nature of "Bedtime Stories."
Extras: 48
The Blu-ray extras for "Bedtime Stories" offer a somewhat underwhelming experience, especially given its 3-disc packaging. The supplemental content includes a collection of humorous yet unremarkable bloopers and deleted scenes, alongside brief featurettes that delve into the movie's characters and special effects. Notably thin in depth, these extras may not hold the interest of a discerning audience looking for more comprehensive behind-the-scenes content. However, the high-definition presentation does ensure that the limited additional material is at least visually appealing. For those not wholly invested in extensive extras, these features might nevertheless provide some minor entertainment value.
Extras included in this disc:
- Until Gravity Do Us Part: A glimpse into the making of the space-themed fight sequence.
- To All the Little People: Behind-the-scenes with the young stars of the film.
- It's Bugsy: Insights on bringing the bug-eyed guinea pig to life using animals and CGI.
- Laughter is Contagious: A compilation of amusing outtakes.
- Cutting Room Floor: A collection of 12 deleted scenes.
- Disney BD-Live: Online interactive features.
- DisneyFile Digital Copy: Standard-definition version for portable devices.
- Bonus Disc - DVD version: Standard definition copy of the film.
Movie: 41
"Bedtime Stories" as a Blu-ray release presents itself as a mixed bag. The film stars Adam Sandler as Skeeter Bronson, a handyman who dreams of managing his father's former hotel. When tasked with babysitting his niece and nephew, Skeeter discovers that his imaginative bedtime stories somehow turn into reality. Despite a promising, whimsical premise designed for family entertainment, the execution leaves much to be desired. Sandler’s attempts to blend his comedic style with a Disney-esque family appeal fall flat, alienating both children and his long-time fans. The resulting film oscillates awkwardly between too soft and sappy for adults and too convoluted and slow-paced for kids.
The narration lacks coherence, and the script is cluttered with poorly integrated subplots, significantly detracting from narrative stability. Supporting characters, such as the greedy hotel owner Barry Nottingham (Richard Griffiths) and the conniving Kendall (Guy Pearce), are one-dimensional, offering little in terms of depth or memorability. Highlights are sporadic, with only the children’s imagination sequences and Russell Brand's lively performance providing brief moments of engagement. However, these scenes are not enough to salvage the overall production from its predictable and formulaic structure.
From a technical perspective, the Blu-ray offers commendable video and audio quality but does not compensate for the underwhelming cinematic content. The bonus features included in the 3-disc set are also lackluster, unlikely to provide additional value for most viewers. "Bedtime Stories" ultimately comes across as a film that fails to hit its mark on multiple fronts, making it a questionable purchase. Prospective viewers might find it more prudent to rent before committing to ownership, particularly when superior family-oriented alternatives are readily available.
Total: 57
The Blu-ray edition of "Bedtime Stories" aspires to rekindle the whimsical charm of classic family films like "The Princess Bride." Yet, it fundamentally misses the mark with its forgettable performances, contrived characters, and superficial life lessons. While Adam Sandler's antics may entertain some children, the film's overall contribution to children's entertainment falls short when compared to what's readily available in the market. The Blu-ray boasts a visually stunning video transfer from Walt Disney, but this is counterbalanced by a lumbering DTS-HD Master Audio track. The audio heavily emphasizes volume over intricate sound design, diminishing its impact.
Despite its high-quality visuals, the sound mix leaves much to be desired. It delivers a sub-par auditory experience that arguably does not match the standard set by the visual presentation. Supplementary materials provided with the Blu-ray also fail to impress; they are short and lack depth, which might disappoint collectors and fans looking for more comprehensive content. Nevertheless, parents may find the film effective in calming their children, though it primarily serves as a temporary distraction rather than a memorable cinematic experience.
In conclusion, "Bedtime Stories" on Blu-ray is an amalgamation of visual brilliance and auditory mediocrity, held back further by uninspired storytelling and weak supplemental features. While it may suffice for a one-time watch to keep the kids entertained, it does not stand out as a worthy addition to a home theater collection. Those who truly enjoy the film might find it satisfactory, but a broader audience will likely find little incentive to revisit it frequently.
avforums review by Casimir HarlowRead review here
Video: 80
Detail is excellent throughout, from the longer shots (even during the dream sequences) to the close facial representations, with no noticeable softness, no grain and negligible digital side-effects (i.e....
Audio: 70
The effects are often a big thing, and get decent enough representation in this respect, both in terms of ambience and big screen fun, with everything from the roaring Ferrari engines to the galloping...
Extras: 50
Although this is a 3-disc set, the extras are a little bit disappointing because basically what we get is the Blu-ray disc (with the extras), a DVD copy of the movie and a Digital copy of the movie for...
Movie: 50
It fails on every level, being utterly misguided and diluting the kind of performances you would expect from all those involved in a purported attempt to entertain a younger generation who will likely...
Total: 60
Blu-ray.com review by Kenneth BrownRead review here
Video: 90
In fact, the only issues I have with the arguably gorgeous presentation -- the appearance of slightly oversaturated skintones, the abundance of overpowering primaries, and the presence of some dodgy CG...
Audio: 70
While it's tough to tell where Bedtime Stories' pedestrian sound design ends and the shortcomings of its overworked technical mix begins, one thing is clear: it takes more finesse than heightened volume...
Extras: 40
Cutting Room Floor (HD, 11 minutes): A series of twelve deleted scenes that wouldn't have added anything of note to the final film....
Movie: 40
Bedtime Stories may sound like it has all the makings of a family classic, but Sandler's well-intentioned but occasionally mean-spirited protagonist will alienate children, his PG-themed jokes and gags...
Total: 60
Bedtime Stories tries to recapture the magic of timeless family classics like The Princess Bride, but falls far short of greatness with forgettable performances, contrived characters, and superficial life...
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 80
There was also the moment with the mock campfire, where shots on every character, save for Sandler's, are sharp and clean, while close ups on him are grainy and a bit fuzzy, just a bit inconsistent....
Audio: 80
The neighborhood these children live in sounds like it borders a forest, as it's that full of bird chirping and random activity....
Extras: 60
From discussion of training a few identical guinea pigs (with normal eyes, mind you), to the actors discussing their enjoyment working with the fuzzy little critters, this feature doesn't delve too deep,...
Movie: 40
It seems that lately, when vulgar comic actors pump out a few duds in their genre of choice, a safe family picture is lurking around the corner, much like your friendly neighborhood smack dealer....
Total: 60
In more modern times, all parents need to do is pop in a copy of 'Bedtime Stories,' as it is more than likely to subdue even the rowdiest of beast children into a quiet slumber....
AVSForumRead review here
Video: 90
Low frequency effects aren't intense but the subwoofer is kept busy as it works in tandem with the rest of the system to convey the low level bass and dynamic impact during the story/fantasy based sequences....
Audio: 84
Low frequency effects aren't intense but the subwoofer is kept busy as it works in tandem with the rest of the system to convey the low level bass and dynamic impact during the story/fantasy based sequences....
Extras: 50
eyed friend/pet Bugsy (HD) Laughter is contagious: Outtakes/Bloopers - 6 minutes (HD) Cutting room floor: 12 Deleted scenes Disney BD-Live enabled DisneyFile Digital Copy - Includes a standard definition...
Movie: 40
When his sister Wendy (Courteney Cox) asks Skeeter to babysit her kids for a week while she's out of town, Skeeter entertains his niece and nephew with elaborate, original bedtime stories that transport...
Total: 66
Marantz DV7001 Universal Disc Player Denon AVR 5308CI THX Ultra 2 Preamp/Video Processor B&K Reference 200.7 Series 2 seven Channel amplifier Philips TSU9400 Pro Series Touch Panel Remote Control Canton...
Director: Adam Shankman
Actors: Adam Sandler, Keri Russell, Courteney Cox
PlotSkeeter Bronson is a handyman at a hotel once owned by his father. Despite his hard work, Skeeter is never promoted to a management position and instead watches the hotel's success benefit others. When his sister Wendy needs to go out of town, Skeeter agrees to babysit his niece and nephew. To entertain them, he tells elaborate bedtime stories. Miraculously, the fantastical events from these tales start coming to life in Skeeter's real world.
As the bedtime stories' magical influence continues, Skeeter tries to harness their power to improve his own situation. He crafts tales where he becomes the hero and wins over his boss, Mr. Nottingham, to secure a promotion. However, things don't go exactly as planned, and Skeeter learns that reality has its own twists and turns. The adventures lead him to unexpected lessons about family, love, and the true meaning of success.
Writers: Matt Lopez, Tim Herlihy
Release Date: 25 Dec 2008
Runtime: 99 min
Rating: PG
Country: United States
Language: English