The Philadelphia Story Blu-ray Review

The Criterion Collection's Blu-ray release of "The Philadelphia Story" showcases a 4K digital restoration that breathes new life into this 75-year-old classic. Framed in its original 1.37:1 aspect ratio and featuring a 1080p/AVC-encoded High Definition video presentation, the restoration process involved an ARRISCAN film scanner working with a 35mm fine-grain positive, as the original camera negative was lost in a fire in 1978. This arduous restoration effort employed MTI Film's DRS for removing dirt, debris, scratches, and splices, while Digital Vision's Phoenix technology managed jitter, flicker, grain, and noise. The result is an impressively clean image, bringing out the finer details in clothing textures, hair, set designs, and even carpets.

Despite the film's age, the restoration offers a vivid and well-balanced grayscale, showcasing a striking texture in wider shots and excellent black levels. While some panoramic scenes might benefit from slightly better depth and density, the overall presentation is both consistent and aesthetically pleasing. Grain is adequately maintained without any notable anomalies. The dark scenes particularly stand out, with a wide range of nuanced tones enhancing the visual storytelling. This video presentation on Blu-ray marks the best shape the film has ever been in, achieving a quintessential blend of historical authenticity and contemporary clarity.

The Blu-ray release of "The Philadelphia Story" features a commendable uncompressed Linear PCM 1.0 monoaural soundtrack that impresses with its clarity and stability. Considering the film's vintage, the audio presentation is quite refined. Dialogue remains clear and coherent throughout, with no evident tinny or shrill edges, and Criterion has done an admirable job cleaning up any pops, crackles, or hiss. This sterling preservation contributes to a respectable range in atmospherics, creating a decent ambiance despite the film's restricted setting, primarily shot in a single house. The score is pristinely presented, avoiding any distortion.

While there is some occasional thinness in the upper register and extremely light background hiss, these occurrences are minimal and should not detract from the viewing experience. The audio's dynamic balance is also proper for a period film of this era, offering good depth that enhances the overall soundscape. Optional English SDH subtitles are provided for the main feature, adding accessibility without compromising the audio's integrity. Overall, this Linear PCM track provides a strong and fitting audio accompaniment to a classic film.

The Blu-ray extras for "The Philadelphia Story" provide a meticulously curated assortment of supplementary content that elevate the viewing experience. Headlining the package is a compelling 2005 audio commentary by film scholar Jeanine Basinger, thoroughly dissecting the origins and historical context of the film. In addition, the collection features the new documentary "In Search of Tracy Lord," examining Katherine Hepburn's iconic character, complemented by another fresh featurette on Hepburn’s pivotal role in producing the film. The extras also include valuable archival content, such as three episodes of "The Dick Cavett Show" featuring Hepburn and director George Cukor. The Lux Radio Theatre adaptation from 1943 and a comprehensive restoration demonstration further enrich this disc. This Criterion release is rounded off with an informative booklet penned by critic Farran Smith Nehme.

Extras included in this disc:

• Audio Commentary: Insight from film historian Jeanine Basinger.
• In Search of Tracy Lord: Documentary on the lead character.
• A Katharine Hepburn Production: Analysis of Hepburn's career impact.
• Katharine Hepburn on The Dick Cavett Show: Archival interview episodes.
• George Cukor on The Dick Cavett Show: Archival interview excerpt.
• Lux Radio Theatre: 1943 adaptation with introduction by Cecil B. DeMille.
• Restoration Demonstration: Insights from restoration experts.
• Trailer: Original trailer.
• Booklet: Featuring essay by Farran Smith Nehme.

Criterion's release of "The Philadelphia Story" stands as a testament to Katharine Hepburn's indelible mark on cinema. This Blu-ray edition, featuring a stunning new 4K remaster, revitalizes Hepburn’s electrifying performance that marked her legendary comeback. Adapted from Philip Barry's successful Broadway play, the movie showcases Hepburn alongside Cary Grant and James Stewart in a narrative that blends sharp wit with deep emotional undercurrents. As Tracy Lord, a wealthy socialite whose wedding plans are upended by her ex-husband and an intrusive tabloid reporter, Hepburn delivers a multifaceted portrayal—balancing fierce independence with palpable vulnerability—as her character navigates chaos and self-discovery.

Director George Cukor masterfully orchestrates this screwball comedy, allowing its star-studded cast to display their charisma and chemistry. James Stewart’s role as the inquisitive reporter earned him an Academy Award, although speculation suggests it also served as compensation for his prior year's snub. Cary Grant, too, excels as Tracy's clever ex-husband, adding layers of charm and complexity to their dynamic. While certain elements of Hepburn’s character arc, including her inebriated escapades, may appear exaggerated or occasionally detract from the plausibility of the narrative, these moments are largely overshadowed by the film’s engaging dialogue and vibrant interactions.

The Blu-ray release is further enriched by an array of supplemental features, including archival interviews with Hepburn, expert commentary by Jeanine Basinger, and newly produced documentaries illuminating the film’s production history. The restoration demonstration is particularly insightful, underscoring Criterion's commitment to preserving cinematic history with meticulous care. The disc also includes an 18-page illustrated booklet with critical essays that provide deeper context and appreciation for this timeless classic. In sum, "The Philadelphia Story" on Blu-ray is not just a viewing experience but an educational journey into the golden age of Hollywood filmmaking.

Criterion's Blu-ray release of "The Philadelphia Story" stands as a testament to their commitment to cinematic preservation and quality. This British region B release features a meticulous 4K restoration that breathes new life into the 1940 classic, boasting extraordinary visual fidelity that highlights the film's timeless appeal. The visuals are complemented by robust audio, ensuring an immersive viewing experience. Criterion’s efforts extend beyond mere restoration; the Blu-ray includes a comprehensive suite of supplemental materials, including newly-produced and archival features.

Fans will particularly appreciate the inclusion of two insightful episodes from The Dick Cavett Show featuring Katharine Hepburn, which offer deep dives into Hepburn's perspective and the film's production nuances. Additionally, Criterion has thoughtfully included a special restoration program. This feature delves into the intricate challenges overcome during the restoration process, offering enthusiasts a deeper appreciation of the technical prowess and dedication required to bring such a classic film back to its former glory.

In conclusion, Criterion delivers an unsurprisingly excellent package in this new Blu-ray release of “The Philadelphia Story.” With its exceptional 4K restoration, sound quality, and rich array of extras, this release is a must-have for both devoted fans and new viewers alike. It's very highly recommended.