Avatar Blu-ray Review
Limited 3D Edition
Score: 79
from 3 reviewers
Review Date:
Avatar's Blu-Ray 3D release excels in visual spectacle with state-of-the-art effects, yet its recycled story leaves some viewers craving more narrative depth.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 77
Avatar's Blu-ray 3D transfer offers an immersive 1080p experience, praised for its perfect depth, vivid color palette, and realistic CGI and physical integration. Minor ghosting and aliasing notwithstanding, it delivers stunning 3D visuals that make Pandora feel incredibly real, making it a top demo disc.
Audio: 77
The Avatar Blu-ray boasts a reference-quality DTS-HD MA 5.1 lossless soundtrack, delivering seamless and mesmerizing audio with impeccable balance and precision. From potent yet controlled bass to crisp dialogue and dynamic soundscapes of Pandora, it stands as a stellar example of Blu-ray audio excellence.
Extra: 96
The Blu-ray release of Avatar is minimalist, focusing strictly on presenting the 3D transfer and including only the theatrical cut, a 2D version, and a DVD copy. For comprehensive extras on the making of Avatar, the Extended Edition Blu-ray is recommended.
Movie: 57
The Blu-ray 3D release of 'Avatar' remains technically identical to the initial Panasonic-exclusive edition, boasting mesmerizing audiovisual qualities that enhance its visually spectacular, albeit narratively flawed, immersive experience. Enthusiasts praise its technological advancements and 3D integration but lament its clichéd plot and lack of emotional depth.
Video: 77
The Blu-ray edition of "Avatar" offers an unparalleled visual experience that continues to stand up as a benchmark for 3D technology in home entertainment. The 1080p transfer is virtually flawless, presenting a mesmerizing depth and immaculate detailing that elevate the overall viewing experience. Whether showcasing the lush, tropical environments of Pandora or the technologically advanced interiors, the 3D image remains seamlessly integrated, transporting viewers directly into the world James Cameron meticulously crafted. Instances of ghosting are exceedingly rare and almost negligible, with only slight artifacts in subtitled scenes. The 3D effects are precisely executed, ensuring a stable and natural depth of field without over-exaggeration or diminished impact.
The color palette on this Blu-ray is exceptional, rendering vibrant purples, oranges, blues, and greens with stunning clarity and consistency across both CGI and physical elements. This cohesion lends a palpable sense of realism to Pandora and its inhabitants. Blacks are deep and rich, marred by only minor imperfections in a few select scenes. Flesh tones maintain their natural appearance without any discernible banding or blocking, further enhancing the disc's visual fidelity. The level of detail captured—from environmental textures to the intricate scars on Stephen Lang's character—is nothing short of extraordinary, making "Avatar" one of the definitive Blu-ray 3D releases available.
Despite its many accolades, minor shortcomings prevent this disc from achieving absolute perfection. Aliasing issues on diagonal lines can detract from the otherwise smooth presentation, notably during shots of the ship approaching Pandora or the glowing roots of the soul tree. Ghosting is virtually absent, but a few subtitles exhibit minor shadowing. Nevertheless, these quibbles are overshadowed by the disc's stunning overall quality. For anyone looking to showcase their 3D setup or seeking a pinnacle of home theater demonstration material, "Avatar" remains an indispensable addition to any collection.
Audio: 77
The Blu-ray release of "Avatar" delivers a nearly flawless DTS-HD MA 5.1 lossless soundtrack, setting a high standard for audio presentation. Immersing the listener in a seamless and mesmerizing experience, the audio track boasts of perfect harmony across various sound elements, whether it's the subtlest background nuances or the most powerful action-oriented effects. Explosions, machine gun fire, and vehicle rumbles are well-balanced, providing a realistic sound without overwhelming the listener. The impeccable imaging ensures that sound elements move fluidly around the soundstage, offering an open and expansive auditory environment throughout the movie.
What's particularly impressive is the exquisite handling of atmospheric effects. James Horner's magnificent score is delivered crisply, maintaining clarity and detail across the listening area. Environmental sounds from Pandora, alongside the metallic and artificial ambiances of human habitats, create a rich 360-degree field of sound. The auditory distinction between various environments is meticulously maintained, enhancing viewer immersion. Dialogue reproduction is near perfect, though there are minor inconsistencies with pitch and volume in certain lines. Despite this, the overall audio quality stands tall, making it close to demo material for showcasing home theater systems.
Though comparisons to other demo tracks reveal it may lack in sheer raw power, "Avatar's" DTS-HD MA 5.1 track excels in precision and balance. The constant engagement of the soundstage from all angles, pitch-perfect pans, and beautiful dynamics affirm its superior quality. The powerful yet proportionate bass levels further contribute to a stellar auditory experience. This release holds its ground firmly, showcasing what Blu-ray has to offer in terms of premium audio presentation. Subtitles and dub options remain consistent with previous editions, including English (SDH), French, Spanish, and Portuguese options.
Extras: 96
The Extras section of the "Avatar" Blu-ray release is notably barebones, focusing primarily on the 3D and 2D theatrical cuts of the film. Dedicated fans or those interested in in-depth features regarding the film’s production will find this edition lacking, as it does not include any substantial bonus content. Those seeking a comprehensive exploration of the making of "Avatar" should consider the Extended Edition Blu-ray, which is renowned for its extensive array of supplementary materials. This version, however, conveniently includes both the 3D and 2D versions, as well as a DVD copy for standard viewing.
Extras included in this disc:
- 3D Theatrical Cut: The film presented in full 3D.
- 2D Theatrical Cut: Standard version of the film.
- DVD Copy: A DVD version of the film included.
Movie: 57
James Cameron's "Avatar" is a monumental work in the realm of visual effects and digital storytelling, captivating audiences with its breathtaking portrayal of the world of Pandora. Released in late 2012, the Blu-ray 3D version offers an experience that avid fans of high-quality cinema will appreciate. This edition maintains all the technical specifics of its predecessor – identical menus, chapter stops, audio options, and both 3D and 2D transfers. Technically, the film is a masterclass in leveraging advanced digital technology; Cameron's personally-developed 3D camera system affords an immersive depth unparalleled in previous cinematic efforts. However, it must be noted that this release is not the definitive package collectors might crave, as it lacks many supplemental features.
As a narrative, "Avatar" follows Jake Sully (Sam Worthington), a paraplegic Marine who navigates the avatar of his late scientist brother to study Pandora's rich moon. Discovering the Na'vi, a native tribe, Sully becomes entangled in their world while grappling with conflicting loyalties between his human mission and newfound affiliations. The plot weaves themes of environmentalism and corporate greed transparently through a science fiction lens. Despite its compelling premise, the storyline falters with clichéd elements and predictable outcomes. The characters, notably Colonel Quaritch (Stephen Lang) and the Na'vi leader Neytiri (Zoe Saldana), though well-acted, often fall into archetypal roles.
The true strength of "Avatar" lies in its unparalleled visual spectacle. The seamless integration of CGI creates a living, breathing ecosystem that transports viewers to another world. Cameron's dedication to creating a fully immersive experience is evidenced by his use of multiple effects houses and groundbreaking 3D techniques which enhance the immersive quality without relying on gimmickry. James Horner's evocative score further cements the film's place as a significant milestone in modern cinema, complementing its grand visual narrative with auditory brilliance. Despite some narrative shortcomings, "Avatar" remains an essential watch for its technological achievements alone.
Total: 79
The newly-released Blu-ray of "Avatar" offers an exceptional 3D visual experience, cementing its status as a technological marvel. This release marks the first time the 3D version has been widely available in stores since its initial exclusive period. Technically, the film's high-definition transfer is impeccable, presenting razor-sharp imagery and vibrant colors that fully realize James Cameron's vision. The 3D effects add a level of immersion that enhances the viewing experience, making viewers feel as though they are part of the lush world of Pandora. However, it should be noted that for those who already own earlier Blu-ray versions, the main attraction here is the 3D format; additional content remains consistent with previous editions.
"Avatar" is renowned for its groundbreaking visual effects and epic scope, earning its place among iconic visual effects films like "Star Wars" and "Jurassic Park". Despite this, the film faces criticism for its storyline which some view as clichéd and emotionally lacking. These narrative shortcomings are somewhat offset by the movie’s entrancing world-building and kinetic action sequences. The home release does an excellent job maintaining this awe-inspiring aesthetic, ensuring that even years after its cinematic debut, "Avatar" continues to impress with its audiovisual presentation.
In conclusion, the Blu-ray release of "Avatar" not only provides fans an affordable way to enjoy the film in 3D but also reinforces its place in cinematic history as a visual milestone. While it may not bring new narrative depth, it delivers on its promise of an immersive viewing experience. This edition is highly recommended for fans seeking to experience the film in its intended 3D format, although those satisfied with earlier releases may find little additional value here. Nevertheless, this release stands as the definitive way to enjoy "Avatar" in the home environment today.
Blu-ray.com review by Martin LiebmanRead review here
Video: 100
Avatar's depth is nothing short of remarkable, and it tends to look so real that viewers might occasionally forget that this is 3D; with many other releases, there have been instances where the effect...
Audio: 100
Bass, then, is exceptionally potent without ever becoming monstrously agressive; vehicles rumble around the soundstage, various object explode, and the ear-piercing thuds of machine gun fire send plenty...
Extras: 100
...
Movie: 70
The technology is new and with every frame comes a spectacle of moviemaking the likes of which have never been seen before, but each of those frames is saddled with a predictable and shallow plot, generic...
Total: 0
When dissecting Avatar and granting it that overly-important numerical "score" that's ultimately going to carry more weight than a commentators' words, one must determine just how much of an impact on...
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 80
The amount of detail in the fore and background is astounding, and the way it surrounds you as layers stack towards and away from the viewer make for something truly magical on this release....
Audio: 80
I still feel that the dialogue, while always clear, has some lines that come across very poorly, like they were recorded on the fly, with different pitch and volume, that just don't seem to mesh or fit...
Extras: 0
...
Movie: 20
He merely exists, and we're forced to either empathize with him, or disconnect from the film, a none too nice piece of film blackmail, considering you still have about two and a half hours worth of film...
Total: 60
This release finally brings the 3D version of the film to stores nationwide, after almost two years spent in exclusivity limbo, and does so quite literally, dropping the same disc some people spent a few...
Why So Blu?Read review here
Video: 100
The thrill of viewing this world and being fully immersed thanks to how Cameron handled the filming of Avatar is captured on this release and without any sort of issue concerning brightness levels....
Audio: 100
The sounds of the dragon-like creatures that Jake Sully and others all ride into battle are a great example of unique sounds as well, with even more coming from the sounds of the wings flapping, the noises...
Extras: 0
If one is truly seeking out extras regarding the making of the film, the Extended Edition Blu-ray release is the one to seek out, as it is jam-packed with extra features that dive into how Avatar was put...
Movie: 90
Playing one of the Na’vi, it’s not just a vocal performance, but the performance capture work and, essentially, the acting that she has done for this role, which was a great piece of work in bringing this...
Total: 80
Anyone that already owns other versions of Avatar on Blu-ray, there is nothing else to gain from this release, aside from the 3D version of the film....
Director: James Cameron
Actors: Sam Worthington, Zoe Saldana, Sigourney Weaver
PlotIn the mid-22nd century, humanity is mining a precious mineral called unobtanium on Pandora, a lush and Earth-like moon of the gas giant Polyphemus in the Alpha Centauri star system. The planet's atmosphere is toxic to humans, necessitating the use of "avatars," genetically engineered human-Na'vi hybrids that are remotely controlled by mentally linked human operators. Jake Sully, a paralyzed former Marine, is recruited to join the Avatar Program after his twin brother's untimely death. Given the opportunity to walk again through his avatar, Jake accepts the mission to infiltrate and spy on the indigenous Na’vi in order to help the corporation force them to relocate and make way for the mining operations.
As Jake's avatar is embraced by the native Na'vi tribe, he begins to appreciate the rich and vibrant culture of this alien society and the deep spiritual connection they share with their environment—particularly the sacred Tree of Souls. The Na’vi are led by the wise and stern Eytukan, the chief of the tribe, and his daughter Neytiri, a skilled and fierce warrior, takes on the task to teach Jake their ways. During his immersive training in their world, Jake grows increasingly sympathetic to the Na’vi's plight, finding himself emotionally and ethically torn between the military-industrial interests he was sent to assist and the alien culture that has accepted him as their own.
Writers: James Cameron
Release Date: 18 Dec 2009
Runtime: 162 min
Rating: PG-13
Country: United States
Language: English, Spanish