The Bamboo Saucer Blu-ray Review
Score: 35
from 3 reviewers
Review Date:
The Bamboo Saucer's ambitious ideas and nostalgic charm are hampered by its modest budget and lack of compelling acting, but it offers decent picture quality.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 46
The Bamboo Saucer's Blu-ray presentation by Olive Films features a 1080p AVC encoded transfer in 1.78:1, with a mix of sharp and faded visuals. Non-effects sequences boast decent color, clarity, and sharpness, while process and matte shots suffer from increased softness and grain. Despite age-related damage, overall improvements outweigh minor issues.
Audio: 42
The Bamboo Saucer's lossless DTS-HD Master Audio Mono track offers clear dialogue and full midrange sound but lacks depth, occasionally sounding shallow, with minor issues like thin upper-register music and some background hiss indicative of its 1968 origins.
Extra: 0
The Blu-ray of 'The Bamboo Saucer' lacks supplements, though it merits praise for its sturdy case featuring original artwork.
Movie: 43
"The Bamboo Saucer" is a lo-fi 1968 B-movie that merges Cold War tension and sci-fi elements with surprising character depth and progressive themes for its era, though hindered by simplistic special effects and overt moralizing. Ideal for fans of vintage sci-fi, it offers a unique, if not entirely polished, cinematic experience.
Video: 46
Olive Films presents "The Bamboo Saucer" on Blu-ray with an AVC encoded 1080p transfer in a 1.78:1 aspect ratio. The visual fidelity of this transfer is a mixed bag, heavily dependent on the type of scene. Sequences devoid of special effects generally boast respectable, if somewhat faded, color saturation, and exhibit above-average clarity and sharpness. This is particularly evident in close-up shots which reveal fine details such as facial features and textures, delivering a surprisingly bright and clean image. However, the use of process photography and matte shots deteriorates the video quality significantly, presenting increased softness, grain, and noticeably faded colors. Despite some efforts in digital cleanup, there are persistent signs of age-related damage including dirt, white flecks, and scratches.
In terms of technical specifics, the MPEG-4 AVC encoding does tend to soften the image overall, with evident grain and scratches in the print. Depth is relatively flat, though select scenes such as those involving the parked UFO and the climactic shootout do offer more engaging visual depth. Color reproduction varies; while there is potential for a rich palette typical of 60s films, colors here are more muted and struggling to fully 'pop'. Skin tones remain cold but consistent throughout. Black levels perform adequately in well-lit scenes but obscure detail in darker areas.
Overall, while there are clear improvements in some aspects of the video quality, the persistent minor issues—ranging from noise and artifacts to subpar black levels—prevent this release from achieving top-tier video standards. Nonetheless, the effort to clean up and present a largely detailed image grants it a certain degree of visual appeal, especially for scenes without heavy reliance on special effects.
Audio: 42
The DTS-HD Master Audio Mono track for "The Bamboo Saucer" presents a clear yet somewhat limited listening experience. Dialogue is crisp and easy to understand, showing no signs of damage or age-related wear. While the midrange frequencies perform admirably, providing richness, the upper registers of the score occasionally sound thin. The soundtrack, though sometimes intrusive, maintains clarity throughout. However, it lacks the depth and immersion that modern lossless tracks often offer.
The track delivers well on dialogue clarity but struggles with dynamic range and depth in other audio elements. Sound effects and portions of the score appear shallow and tinny, particularly during action sequences, partly because they lower in prominence to prioritize dialogue. This results in a sometimes muted and less energetic audio experience during key scenes. Atmospheric effects are minimal, a likely drawback of the film's era.
Despite its limitations, the track reveals some complexity in specific scenes, such as the climactic battle sequence where multiple audio components are effectively balanced. Nevertheless, an underlying analog hiss persistently intertwines with dialogue and other audio elements, unmistakably anchoring the listener in its 1968 heritage. Overall, while functional and clear in dialogue reproduction, the track underscores its vintage origin and does not fully leverage the capabilities of modern audio formats.
Extras:
The Blu-ray release of "The Bamboo Saucer" unfortunately does not include any special features, extras, or supplements. While the sturdy Blu-ray case and original artwork are commendable, viewers looking for in-depth behind-the-scenes content or additional material will be disappointed.
Extras included in this disc:
- None: There are no extras included on this disc.
Movie: 43
"The Bamboo Saucer," directed by Frank Telford and produced by Jerry Fairbanks, is an engaging mix of Cold War intrigue and low-budget 1960s sci-fi. The film starts with test pilot Fred Norwood (John Ericson) encountering a UFO while testing a new jet, an event that leads to his tarnished reputation and dismissal from his job. This incident kicks off a sequence of events that includes the death of Norwood’s brother-in-law in a similar pursuit, and Norwood's subsequent involvement in a secret mission to Red China. Enlisted by U.S. Secret Service officer Hank Peters (Dan Duryea), Norwood’s team finds themselves journeying into Communist China to unearth a flying saucer allegedly rooted there.
Upon arrival, Norwood’s group stumbles upon a Soviet team on the same mission. Despite initial tensions, both teams decide to collaborate in the face of the larger threat posed by patrolling Chinese armies. The narrative, albeit simple, achieves an unexpected depth as it navigates themes of unity and peace against the backdrop of Cold War stakes. Although the acting—by TV regulars like Bernard Fox and Lois Nettleton—is occasionally stiff, it lends an endearing quality typical of B-movies of the era.
Despite the palpable '50s B-movie vibe and dated special effects, "The Bamboo Saucer" impressively blends genres including spy thriller and war drama. While it may fill its runtime with generalizations and some overt moralizing, the film shines in its progressive depiction of international camaraderie. The flying saucer mostly serves as a narrative device to catalyze character development and promote a message of global unity, which transcends its otherwise rudimentary execution. With some unexpectedly touching moments and clever plot turns, this film emerges as a compelling piece reflective of its Cold War context and offers more than just sci-fi kitsch, making it an interesting watch for fans of vintage cinema.
Total: 35
"The Bamboo Saucer" is an ambitious film that strives to explore the complexities of international relations and the implications of humanity's first encounter with extraterrestrial technology. However, its lofty aspirations are somewhat diminished by a limited budget and performances that lack depth. The cast, largely composed of television regulars, gives the film a made-for-TV feel. Despite these drawbacks, the movie maintains a certain charm, particularly for enthusiasts of vintage science fiction and war films.
Technically, the Blu-ray presentation by Olive Films offers a better-than-average picture quality and serviceable sound. The visual upgrade is noticeable and does justice to the film’s cinematography, ensuring a significantly improved viewing experience over previous releases. Unfortunately, the package is devoid of any supplementary materials, which could make the nearly $30 price tag seem excessive. This omission is particularly disappointing for collectors who anticipate bonus content as part of the Blu-ray experience.
In conclusion, "The Bamboo Saucer" is worth considering for aficionados of classic sci-fi and retro cinema, especially given the scarcity of its availability in high definition. Despite its shortcomings in execution and extra features, this Blu-ray represents the best available version of the film. Those already inclined towards its niche appeal are likely to appreciate this release, though newcomers might be advised to preview it before committing to a purchase.
Blu-ray.com review by Jeffrey KauffmanRead review here
Video: 60
On the other hand, the process and matte shots look decidedly worse than the bulk of the film, in some cases offering noticeably faded color and a more expected increase in softness and grain....
Audio: 70
The Bamboo Saucer's lossless DTS-HD Master Audio Mono track is a bit on the narrow side but actually has no real damage or age related wear and tear to report, and sounds nicely full, especially in the...
Extras: 0
...
Movie: 40
Fairbanks in fact made his early reputation producing shorts, but he was also farsighted enough to be one of the first film guys to make a foray into television, and Fairbanks is sometimes credited with...
Total: 50
The Bamboo Saucer tries to be sober minded about international relations and what Mankind's first contact with extraterrestials (or at least their spaceship) might mean for the future of our species, but...
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 60
It looks as though the image has been cleaned up some, as the presence of grain lessens gradually, giving way to a smooth, mostly detailed image that is surprisingly bright and, for much of the time, quite...
Audio: 60
Some of this is due to the sound dropping farther than necessary to make way for the actors' dialogue, which results in action sequences that lack energy and sound effects and music that can sound somewhat...
Extras: 0
...
Movie: 40
Other times, though, as in the case of 1968's 'The Bamboo Saucer,' science fiction is blended with reality in order to draw a more distinct and overt connection to a palpable concern like, say, the Cold...
Total: 40
Like its competing groups, 'The Bamboo Saucer' has a lot of ideas; it just doesn't know how to convincingly portray them or to deliver them in a way that also creates a truly compelling sci-fi feature....
Why So Blu?Read review here
Video: 60
Color Reproduction: Having seen a lot of high def mastering on 60s films, they usually provide some of the richest and most popping colors you could get on catalog Blu-ray titles....
Audio: 40
You can make them out, they’re clear and loud, but this movie’s audio track does nothing to hide this being a 1968 film....
Extras: 0
...
Movie: 60
And while this film would be classified in the 50s sci fi realm, it feels a bit different because the saucer merely plays sort of a MacGuffin role for most of it....
Total: 40
As the big bummer, the film contains no bonus materials, not even a trailer making the almost $30 price tag seem incredibly steep....
Director: Frank Telford
Actors: Dan Duryea, John Ericson, Lois Nettleton
PlotIn the midst of the Cold War, American test pilot Fred Norwood stumbles upon evidence of a mysterious flying saucer that has crashed in rural China. The saucer’s advanced technology piques the interest of both American and Soviet intelligence agencies. As tensions mount between the two superpowers, Norwood, accompanied by a diverse team including scientists and soldiers, is dispatched to investigate and secure the craft before the Soviets can reach it. Upon arriving in a remote Chinese village, the team discovers that the locals have hidden the saucer in an abandoned temple. The Americans set up a temporary base to study the alien technology, which appears far more advanced than anything on Earth.
However, their efforts are soon interrupted by the arrival of a determined Soviet team with similar goals. Faced with the dilemma of working together or engaging in conflict, both teams are forced to navigate a landscape fraught with political tension and mutual distrust. Unexpected challenges arise, including deciphering cryptic alien symbols and dealing with treacherous terrain. As the race to unlock the saucer's secrets intensifies, ethical dilemmas and strained alliances push the mission to its breaking point.
Writers: Frank Telford, Alford Van Ronkel, John P. Fulton
Release Date: 01 Sep 1974
Runtime: 103 min
Rating: G
Country: United States
Language: English, Russian, Mandarin