Bulletproof Monk Blu-ray Review

The Blu-ray release of "Bulletproof Monk" is presented in 1080p/MPEG-2 on a BD-25 single-layer disc. While this transfer avoids any significant compression artifacts, such as macroblocking or excessive edginess, it is let down considerably by the condition of the source print. The print displays a notable amount of dirt and debris, which is particularly surprising and disappointing for a relatively recent film. Additionally, white flecks are occasionally visible, detracting from the overall viewing experience. The inconsistency in sharpness from scene to scene further undermines the transfer's quality.

Clarity and color saturation are upgraded in brightly lit sequences, with hues appearing punchy and fleshtones accurately rendered. However, this improvement does not extend to darker scenes, where elevated contrast results in distracting film grain. Shadow delineation suffers greatly in these moments, which compromises detail and depth. The overall experience is more in line with an upgraded SD-DVD rather than what one would expect from a high-definition Blu-ray release. Given these issues, "Bulletproof Monk" is not a recommended showcase for home theater setups.

The DTS-HD MA 5.1 mix in the "Bulletproof Monk" Blu-ray release stands out as the most dynamic aspect of the audio presentation. While the mix captures some sporadic, fantastically immersive sequences with rich foley effects, explosions, and bullet sounds that enhance the action-packed segments of the film, it suffers from inconsistency. These lively moments are balanced with more languid dialogue scenes, which, despite being cleanly transmitted with excellent directionality, can feel disproportionately prominent compared to the high-energy sequences. The result includes occasional spells of audio excitement overshadowed by extended periods of rather mundane dialogue.

The mix achieves impressive surround use during the fight scenes, with aggressive, effective rear presence and discrete effects with pinpoint accuracy. These peaks in the soundscape allow for an immersive experience that makes full use of the surround capabilities. However, this intensity can sometimes overwhelm the dialogue, necessitating frequent volume adjustments. Despite these volume concerns, quieter moments remain clean and clear, even during rapid-fire deliveries by Seann William Scott. The mix showcases notable dynamics, with a strong base and robust upper range providing a rich audio experience. Nevertheless, a more balanced approach could have further enhanced the listening experience, avoiding occasional overemphasis during action scenes.

The Blu-ray release of "Bulletproof Monk" offers minimal supplementary content, maintaining a standard set by other MGM catalog titles. There are no substantial extras specific to the film, leaving audiences without any behind-the-scenes insights or additional material that could enhance their viewing experience. The disc includes only the trailer gallery for other MGM/Fox titles, and notably lacks a dedicated trailer for "Bulletproof Monk." This bare-bones approach underscores a missed opportunity for enriching the movie’s home entertainment release.

Extras included in this disc:

• Trailer Gallery: Contains trailers for other MGM/Fox titles but lacks a specific preview for 'Bulletproof Monk.'

"Bulletproof Monk" is a film that delivers an entertaining, albeit overly familiar, romp through the genre of martial arts-meets-supernatural action. The movie stars Chow Yun-Fat as a nameless Monk entrusted with protecting an ancient scroll that holds the key to unimaginable powers. His journey begins in 1943 Tibet fending off Nazi hordes and extends to modern-day New York City, where he teams up with a wisecracking street hustler, Kar (Seann William Scott), and a formidable mob princess known as Bad Girl (Jaime King). Despite a captivating premise, the plot soon unravels into a mishmash of predictable twists and uninspired action sequences that fail to live up to the standards set by genre predecessors and filmmakers like John Woo.

The undeniable charm of Chow Yun-Fat, coupled with the surprisingly effective dynamic between him and Scott, does provide some respite amid the film's narrative chaos. The character interactions are underscored by a self-deprecating humor that helps keep viewers engaged. While the film makes several nods to "Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon" with its wire work and Eastern philosophical undertones, these elements often fall short, seeming more like derivative homages than fresh interpretations. The visually impressive, if sometimes lackluster, fight scenes are complemented by CGI moments that appear as if plucked from Westernized versions of Asian cinematic lore.

Though "Bulletproof Monk" struggles under the weight of an overly complex screenplay and some clichéd character arcs, it ultimately manages to entertain through its sheer irreverence and comic sensibility. Elements like a mind-reading machine or improbable action scenes involving magic powers might make little sense upon scrutiny, but the film doesn't pretend to be anything more than lightweight escapism. For those willing to suspend disbelief and indulge in some martial arts whimsy, "Bulletproof Monk" offers a fitfully engaging experience. However, for those seeking more sophisticated narratives or meticulously choreographed combat sequences, there are far better choices available in high-definition formats.

The Blu-ray release of "Bulletproof Monk" is a mixed bag that will likely elicit varying reactions from viewers. In its favor, the film brings a distinctive blend of East meets West silliness, evoking a certain charm reminiscent of cult classics like "Big Trouble in Little China." The leads present an engaging dynamic, providing moments of genuine entertainment and levity. However, this potential is hampered by a plot that feels derivative and cobbled together from multiple, underdeveloped ideas. Technical aspects further dampen the experience; the Blu-ray transfer suffers due to a dirty print that undermines visual quality, making the cinematography less appealing than it could be.

The audio experience is solid with an enjoyable soundtrack, but this alone cannot compensate for the DVD's shortcomings. One glaring omission is the lack of extras that viewers have come to expect, especially given the $39.95 list price. Such a price point warrants additional content that could potentially enrich viewing, such as behind-the-scenes features or insightful commentary. MGM's effort here seems cursory, detracting from what should have been a definitive edition of a cult martial arts flick.

In conclusion, "Bulletproof Monk" on Blu-ray lands in a middling category. While the leads are appealing and occasionally elevate the film above its narrative flaws, the combination of a subpar transfer and the absence of supplementary content ultimately holds it back. This release might satisfy those with a specific penchant for quirky martial arts comedies but will leave others wanting more. As it stands, most viewers will probably opt to pass on this lackluster offering.