The Man with the Iron Fists Blu-ray Review
Score: 61
from 3 reviewers
Review Date:
The Blu-ray of 'The Man with the Iron Fists' offers sharp AV quality but suffers from convoluted storytelling and disappointing supplemental content.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 72
The Man with the Iron Fists boasts a stunning, near-reference quality 1080p/AVC video transfer with razor-sharp detail and lifelike textures. Richly saturated colors, deep black levels, and spot-on contrast provide an engaging visual experience free of noticeable artifacts or noise.
Audio: 72
The 5.1 channel DTS-HD Master Audio soundtrack delivers an intense, theater-like experience with seamless integration across channels, clean and hard-hitting low frequencies, clear dialogue, and excellent rear speaker activity. The dynamic range and punchy LFE output provide a reference-quality, immersive audio presentation.
Extra: 33
The Blu-ray extras for 'The Man with the Iron Fists' offer a range of behind-the-scenes content, from insightful though brief featurettes like 'A Look Inside' and 'A Path to the East' to a substantial set of deleted scenes. The 'On the Set with RZA' segments are concise yet engaging, providing a compact glimpse into the film’s production process.
Movie: 43
The Man with the Iron Fists is an ambitious yet overindulgent debut from RZA, blending classic kung fu elements with an array of characters and chaotic action. Despite its fragmented storytelling and uneven execution, the film offers entertainment for genre enthusiasts, enhanced by a feature-packed Blu-ray release.
Video: 72
"The Man with the Iron Fists" Blu-ray presents a superb high-definition video performance, offering a visually stunning 1080p/AVC-encoded transfer. The razor-sharp imagery, achieved through the Red One camera system, captivates with exceptional clarity and near-flawless detail perception. Each pore and imperfection on the cast's faces is exposed, while complexions remain lifelike and natural. The architecture and design intricacies of the village are vividly revealed, from the wood grain in furniture to the exquisite artwork of the Pink Blossom brothel. The 2.40:1 aspect ratio digital-to-digital transfer adds to this detailed presentation, showcasing precise costume stitching and designs.
Colors in "The Man with the Iron Fists" are vibrant and deeply saturated, creating a visually rich experience. Primary colors, notably reds, stand out with striking intensity, while secondary hues, including the bright yellow golds, radiate with energy. The depth of black levels is impressive, delivering inky richness and excellent shadow detail that enhances three-dimensionality within the frame. Contrast levels are meticulously balanced, producing brilliant whites that only occasionally show slight dips. Despite these minor issues, compression artifacts are minimal, maintaining an immersive and engaging visual standard throughout the film.
The film's overall video quality is notably pristine, marked by stable black levels and devoid of deleterious video artifacts or noise. Grain remains intact, preserving cinematic texture while avoiding significant compression anomalies. As a testament to its high-definition pedigree, "The Man with the Iron Fists" exemplifies a blend of outstanding color execution, precise contrast calibration, and meticulous detail rendering that will undoubtedly satisfy both fans and critics.
Audio: 72
The audio presentation of "The Man with the Iron Fists" on Blu-ray is a robust offering that showcases the potency of the DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 surround track. Designed to immerse viewers in the film's chaotic energy, the soundstage effectively utilizes both front and rear channels to create a theater-like experience. The dynamic range is commendable, with punchy sound effects that traverse the room during intense fight sequences, and a meaty, aggressive LFE output that at times borders on overwhelming. Directionality is seamless, allowing pans to transition gracefully between channels, while dialogue remains clear and well-prioritized despite occasional challenges during the most chaotic scenes.
Bass performance is particularly noteworthy, delivering impactful low-frequency energy that enhances every kick, punch, and explosion with clean, hard-hitting resonance. The subwoofer experiences a satisfying workout throughout the film, contributing to the dynamic, tactile impact that resonates with each action sequence. The upper ranges are equally impressive, with a sharp distinction between mids and highs, ensuring clarity during high-octane moments involving swinging swords and smashing iron fists. The detailed channel separation further bolsters the audio experience, generating an expansive and immersive soundfield that engages the listener.
Rear speaker activity is abundant and consistently employed to enrich the atmospheric elements of the film. The sound design maintains a high level of enthusiasm for RZA's audacious cinematic vision, with convincing directionality and lively effects that sweep from one speaker to another seamlessly. Even during quieter moments, the mix exhibits elegant subtleties, enveloping the viewer with a high-quality surround sound experience. Overall, this is a reference-quality presentation that will delight fans and audiophiles alike, providing demonstration-worthy material for home theater systems.
Extras: 33
The Blu-ray release of "The Man with the Iron Fists" includes a modest yet intriguing set of extras, providing insights into the film's production and offering additional scenes to flesh out the narrative. The extras are professionally presented in HD, though they may leave some viewers desiring more in-depth content. Particularly notable is the collection of deleted scenes, which offer substantial additions to the film's story. RZA's enthusiasm is palpable throughout the featurettes, making for an engaging and informative experience. However, many of the behind-the-scenes segments are quite brief, functioning more as promotional snippets rather than comprehensive documentaries.
Extras included in this disc:
- Deleted Scenes: Five deleted and extended scenes, adding depth to characters and key moments.
- A Look Inside: A quick 2-minute promo with RZA discussing the production.
- A Path to the East: Another 2-minute featurette focused on location shooting in China.
- On the Set with RZA: Series of five 1-minute segments covering various aspects of production.
Movie: 43
RZA’s debut, "The Man with the Iron Fists," presents itself as an extravagant homage to classic kung fu cinema. Helmed by RZA, who co-wrote the screenplay with Eli Roth, the film is a vibrant amalgamation of martial arts tropes, infused with eccentric characters and excessive violence. The narrative is centered around a chaotic Jungle Village in 19th century China, where the assassination of Gold Lion triggers a power struggle among rival clans. In the thick of it is the Blacksmith (RZA), a fugitive slave turned weapon maker, whose loyalties are stretched thin as he faces an onslaught of colorful adversaries like Brass Body (David Bautista) and Jack Knife (Russell Crowe). RZA’s enthusiasm for the genre is palpable, although his lack of restraint leads to a cluttered and overindulgent storyline, packed with more characters and subplots than it can cohesively handle.
Technically, "The Man with the Iron Fists" is a mixed bag. While RZA's intimate knowledge of kung fu cinema is evident, his execution lacks finesse. The direction often feels too eager, cramming countless elements without cohesion. Performance-wise, Russell Crowe provides a notably unrestrained portrayal that highlights his rapport with RZA, but other key actors like Lucy Liu occasionally falter into wooden territory. The fight scenes, masterminded by Corey Yuen, are energetic but sometimes lack the precision and fluidity that elevate martial arts choreography to art form. Additionally, the soundtrack, while reflecting RZA’s hip hop roots, sometimes veers towards being distracting rather than complementary.
Despite its flaws, "The Man with the Iron Fists" achieves moments of amusement and spectacle. It stands as a hyper-kinetic mosaic of kung fu nostalgia filled with blood-soaked action, exaggerated characters, and a penchant for stylistic excess. However, its appeal heavily relies on the viewer's familiarity with and appreciation for the genre's historic context and idiosyncratic charm. While seasoned fans might enjoy the chaotic blend of sights and sounds, casual viewers may find themselves overwhelmed by its disjointed narrative and over-the-top antics.
Total: 61
"The Man with the Iron Fists" offers an ambitious homage to classic Chinese martial-arts cinema, helmed by RZA in his big-screen debut as writer and director. While RZA's passion and enthusiasm for the wuxia genre shine through, the film is often hampered by convoluted storytelling and inconsistent dialogue. These shortcomings make it less of a neo-grindhouse kung fu classic and more of an uneven attempt at genre filmmaking.
However, the Blu-ray release partially redeems the film with near-reference quality audio and video presentation. Viewers can expect sharp, detailed visuals and immersive sound that enhance the overall viewing experience. Despite the limited supplemental features, fans of both the genre and the filmmaker will find satisfaction in this technically solid Blu-ray release.
In conclusion, "The Man with the Iron Fists" may not achieve the status of a martial-arts classic, but its Blu-ray presentation offers enough audiovisual excellence to merit a watch. For genre enthusiasts and RZA aficionados, it's worth at least a rental.
Blu-ray.com review by Kenneth BrownRead review here
Video: 90
(Slight macroblocking mingles with the grainfield on occasion -- watch RZA's face closely at the 33:00 minute mark for the worst of it, minor as it still is -- but it's a rarity, and one that will go unnoticed...
Audio: 90
Directionality is mischievous and convincing, pans leap gracefully from channel to channel, dynamics are dead on, and the soundfield has as much fun as the cast....
Extras: 40
A Look Inside (HD, 2 minutes): The RZA, self-proclaimed Abbott of the Wu Tang Clan, talks about teaming up with "my boy Quentin Tarantino and Eli Roth to make a fat joint of my own" in this brief EPK....
Movie: 40
RZA clearly adores the genre and all the rickety martial arts cult classics that go with it, but he exercises little restraint, cramming anything and everything remotely kung fu into a clunky splatterhouse...
Total: 70
The Man with the Iron Fists is too slick to be a neo-grindhouse kung fu classic, too convoluted to make a whole lot of sense and too undisciplined and unwieldy to be an able-bodied genre pic....
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 80
Blacks are inky rich and luxurious, penetrating deep into the frame with excellent gradational details within the shadows and adding a great deal of three-dimensional depth....
Audio: 80
The quieter moments exhibit a more subtler elegance and a lighter touch while the score and song selections spread all around, enveloping the listener with highly satisfying and immersive soundfield....
Extras: 20
Deleted Scenes (HD) — The meatiest of the bonus selections is a collection of five deleted and extended scenes which add more to the movie's beginning and one that with extra footage of the mirror-maze...
Movie: 60
The Man with the Iron Fists' is far from perfect or even the best imitation of exploitation cinema, but it's not bad for a first-time filmmaker, done with lovingly admiration and intimate knowledge of...
Total: 60
Essentially a wet-dream of the wuxia genre, your level of enjoyment pretty much amounts to your familiarity with those classic kung fu movies, which is both the movie's strength and weakness, but ultimately...
AVSForumRead review here
Video: 92
Shadow detail is good enough that I could make out plenty of discernible texture in the low lighting and dark backgrounds....
Audio: 92
This is a reference quality audio/video presentation that offers demonstration worthy material for those who like to show of their home theater systems....
Extras: 50
(HD) 5 Deleted scenes (HD) A look inside The man with the iron fists – 2 minute featurette (HD) A path to the east – 2 minute featurette (HD) On the set with RZA (five 1 minute segments): The journey begins...
Movie: 40
Starring Academy Award® winner Russell Crowe, RZA, and Lucy Liu, The Man with the Iron Fists Unrated Extended Edition includes jaw-dropping martial arts action that you couldn’t see in theaters....
Total: 69
Screen Onkyo PR-SC5508 THX Ultra 2 Audio/Video Processor Sherbourn Technologies - 7/200 Seven Channel Amplifier Oppo BDP-103 Universal Disc/3D capable Blu-ray Player (HDMI Audio/Video)...
Director: RZA
Actors: Russell Crowe, Cung Le, Lucy Liu
PlotIn a fictional 19th-century Chinese village, a humble blacksmith becomes entangled in a fierce conflict between several warring clans vying for control. The blacksmith, originally working peacefully to save enough money to free his love from a local brothel, is inadvertently drawn into the chaos when a treasure of gold is threatened by betrayal, greed, and brutal violence. Alongside him, an opium-addicted British soldier and a skilled warrior contribute to the escalating battle as numerous factions seek to claim the treasure for themselves, each showcasing their unique martial arts expertise and deadly weapons.
As tensions rise, alliances form and break rapidly, leading to high-stakes confrontations and complex betrayals. Brothel owner Madam Blossom and other key players weave their own intricate schemes, further complicating the power struggle. The blacksmith’s fate becomes increasingly intertwined with the village’s survival as he faces brutal enemies and embraces his own hidden, formidable strength. Amidst the swirling conflict and relentless pursuit of power, the village’s very existence hangs in the balance, leading to a final showdown that determines the future for everyone involved.
Writers: RZA, Eli Roth
Release Date: 02 Nov 2012
Runtime: 95 min
Rating: R
Country: United States, Hong Kong
Language: English, Mandarin