Brave Blu-ray Review
Ultimate Collector's Edition
Score: 78
from 4 reviewers
Review Date:
Though 'Brave' may be a softer Pixar entry, its Blu-ray release is visually stunning, boasts impeccable 3D, and offers superb audio and extras, ensuring a top-tier home theater experience.
Disc Release Date
Dolby TrueHD
Video: 83
Brave's Blu-ray presentation offers breathtaking animation with pristine 1080p/MVC-encoded video, remarkable detail, and perfect color. While 2D delivers an exemplary experience, the 3D presentation slightly falters during fast action scenes, yet remains among the year's best for depth and dimensionality.
Audio: 79
Brave's Dolby TrueHD 7.1 mix offers superb dynamic range, crystal clarity, and immersive surround sound, beautifully capturing subtle nuances and powerful accents. The soundtrack masterfully balances dialogue and music, from delicate reeds to visceral action, making it one of Disney's finest lossless mixes.
Extra: 71
The Brave Blu-ray Extras deliver an extensive and engaging collection, featuring high-definition behind-the-scenes featurettes, insightful audio commentary, compelling short films like 'La Luna' and 'The Legend of Mor'du,' and richly detailed character design explorations, offering a comprehensive dive into the movie's production process.
Movie: 73
While 'Brave' dazzles with its stunning animation, exceptional voice talent, and top-tier sound quality, it falls short in storytelling compared to Pixar's best, delivering a simpler, more formulaic narrative. Nonetheless, the film's heartfelt themes of family and bravery make it an enjoyable watch, particularly for younger audiences.
Video: 83
The Blu-ray presentation of "Brave" in 1080p/MVC-encoded video is a masterpiece that transcends standard animated features with its meticulous attention to detail. The transfer offers a stunningly clean and razor-sharp image, exhibiting the vibrant and varied color palette of Merida's world. Lush greens, fiery reds, deep blues, and impressive inky blacks combine to create a visual feast, enhanced by pristine contrast levels. The clarity extends to the tiniest details, from the wild curls of Merida’s hair to the tattered seams of kilts and the rough fur of Mor’du, resulting in an animation that feels extraordinarily lifelike. Furthermore, technical performance is top-notch, with no visible signs of macroblocking, aliasing, or noise; even banding is nearly nonexistent.
In the realm of 3D, "Brave" continues to excel but with certain caveats. Depth perception is outstanding, particularly in scenes featuring vast landscapes and intricate interiors such as castles and forests. The sense of space and scale enriches the viewing experience, making it immersive and engaging. However, certain fast-paced sequences, like Merida’s rapid horse ride, can prove too challenging for some 3D displays to handle smoothly, potentially causing strobing effects or a confusing visual experience. While the volume and realism of character renders stand out in specific scenarios, there are moments when the 3D layering inhibits the natural roundedness one would expect. The 3D presentation’s aim is more focused on creating an immersive environment rather than indulging in frequent pop-out effects.
Conclusively, both 2D and 3D formats provide unique advantages. While the 2D version promises an exemplary animation experience replete with impeccable detail and color dynamics, the 3D version offers a potent sense of immersion marred slightly by speed-related visual artifacts in some scenes. Together, they present "Brave" as a visually breathtaking title that remains one of Pixar’s finest in Blu-ray format.
Audio: 79
The Dolby TrueHD 7.1 mix of the "Brave" Blu-ray stands as a benchmark for Disney's audio presentations. Initially introduced in cinemas with the Dolby Atmos format, it offers unparalleled precision in the positioning of sound effects and dialogue. While the home release does not implement the full Atmos experience, the TrueHD 7.1 mix provided is exceptional. The mix boasts superb dynamic range and crystal clarity that beautifully transitions from delicate atmospheric details, such as wind rustling and subtle background noises, to visceral action scenes brimming with robust sound effects. The nuanced Celtic-inspired soundtrack seamlessly integrates into the mix, enhancing the film’s narrative without overshadowing dialogue. However, there are rare instances where dialogue might seem slightly buried under thick Scottish accents, yet it generally remains comprehensible and well-delineated.
From the very opening scenes, the Dolby TrueHD 7.1 mix emphasizes its immersive qualities. Distinct sound elements, like the crunching of grass or the fearsome roar of a demon, highlight the powerful use of LFE channels that add palpable heft and presence throughout. The surround activity is remarkable, creating an enveloping soundfield that engages all channels dynamically. The forests and castle settings are sonic marvels, with impeccable directional sound and smooth panning effects that place the listener right in the heart of the action. Even subtle nuances such as birds chirping or leaves rustling are delivered with precision. Bass frequencies underscore powerful moments with depth without overpowering finer details.
Additionally, Patrick Doyle's score receives pristine treatment, showcasing reeds' purity and percussion’s rhythmic intensity that drives excitement without overwhelming other elements. Multiple lossless options, including 5.1 and 7.1 mixes, ensure flexibility and quality for diverse setups. No imperfections mar this high-quality track; no distortions, break-ups, or noise issues are present. Overall, Pixar's meticulous craftsmanship shines through once again, offering a home theater experience that is both technically impressive and emotionally engaging.
Extras: 71
The Blu-ray of "Brave" is packed with an extensive and varied set of extras that will undoubtedly appeal to fans and animation enthusiasts alike. Featuring a mix of insightful behind-the-scenes content, character studies, and deleted scenes, the disc reveals the meticulous effort and creativity that went into the making of the film. Highlights include the comprehensive and lively audio commentary by the film's creative team, which delves into diverse aspects such as story development, character design, and animation challenges. Two standout short films, "La Luna" and "The Legend of Mor’du," enrich the viewing experience with their enchanting storytelling and impressive animation. The various featurettes cover everything from Scottish cultural influences to the technical intricacies of rendering moss and hair. Overall, this Blu-ray offers a deep dive into the film's production, making it a valuable addition for any collector.
Extras included in this disc:
- La Luna: An endearing short film about family and responsibility.
- The Legend of Mor’du: Explores the backstory of Brave's formidable villain.
- Audio Commentary: In-depth discussion featuring the director and production team.
- Brave Old World: A featurette on the research trip to Scotland.
- Merida & Elinor: Focuses on the lead characters' design.
- Bears: Character design featurette centered on bears.
- Brawl in the Hall: Development of the clans' comedic clash.
- Wonder Moss: Examination of the creation of background moss.
- Magic: Exploration of Brave's fairy tale elements.
- Clan Pixar: Introduces the Pixar team.
- Once Upon a Scene: Insights into various versions of key scenes.
- Extended Scenes: Four sequences with pop-up annotations.
- Promotional Pieces: Includes deleted scenes and trailers.
- Fergus & Mor’du: An alternate opening sequence.
- Fallen Warriors: Montage of nearly finished but unused scenes.
- Dirty Hairy People: The meticulous animation of grime and hair.
- It is English… Sort Of: Featurette on Scottish slang used in the film.
- Angus: Design and animation of Merida’s horse, Angus.
- The Tapestry: Focus on Merida's family tapestry and its significance.
- Art Galleries: Showcases characters, development art, environments, and more.
Movie: 73
Pixar's "Brave" is a visually stunning and aurally captivating film that excels as both an animated marvel and a technical showcase. Set against the mystic backdrop of 11th century Scotland, "Brave" follows the adventurous Princess Merida, voiced by Kelly Macdonald, whose defiance of age-old traditions sets off a series of events that lead her to seek a transformative spell from a mysterious witch. The movie shines in its meticulously detailed animation and finely tuned voice acting by talents like Billy Connolly and Emma Thompson. While some critics argue that the story lacks the depth and emotional punch of earlier Pixar classics, it's clear that its blend of humor, heart, and vividly rendered landscapes keeps audiences engrossed.
Technically, "Brave" is a gem. The Blu-ray release, presented in 1080p/AVC MPEG-4, offers an impressive range of visual clarity with colors that are both vibrant and meticulously detailed. The character designs and intricate backgrounds blend to create an immersive viewing experience, albeit with minor reservations regarding the depiction of character roundness and layering in faster scenes. The audio is nothing short of spectacular, featuring both 7.1 and 5.1 Dolby TrueHD tracks that envelop you in rich, crystal-clear soundscapes. The voice work harmonizes perfectly with a lush musical score, making for one of Pixar’s most acoustically impressive films to date.
Despite some criticism regarding its simplistic plot and limited geographical scope within the narrative, "Brave" retains substantial appeal. Younger viewers will undoubtedly be captivated by its engaging characters and comedic moments, while adults can appreciate its underlying themes of family, respect, and tradition. Isn’t it remarkable how such a visually and auditorily exceptional film could still manage to embed valuable lessons on familial bonds? While it may not attain the lofty heights of Pixar’s crowning achievements like "Toy Story" or "Up," "Brave" remains a highly recommended watch, both as an entertaining film and a technical marvel deserving a place in any animation aficionado's collection.
Total: 78
Pixar’s "Brave," while often considered a lesser entry in the studio’s acclaimed filmography, still stands out with its compelling narrative and technical execution. Set in 11th century Scotland, the film chronicles the adventures of Merida, a strong-willed princess who defies traditional expectations. The Blu-ray presentation of "Brave" solidifies its position as one of the best releases of 2012. The high-definition video transfer is breathtaking, with stunning visuals that are even more captivating in 3D. Accompanying the visual splendor is a pitch-perfect Dolby TrueHD 7.1 surround sound track that fully immerses the viewer in the film's rich auditory landscape.
The supplementary features on this Blu-ray release are extensive and meticulously curated, spread across two discs. Extras include a variety of featurettes, behind-the-scenes footage, and insightful commentary that delve into the film’s production process. This wealth of supplemental material enhances the viewing experience, offering fans a deeper appreciation for the artistry and creativity that went into making "Brave." Despite some criticism about the film not reaching the narrative heights of other Pixar classics, it remains a magical and engaging experience, particularly for younger audiences.
In conclusion, Pixar’s "Brave" Blu-ray release excels in every technical aspect. The superior video and audio quality, combined with a rich array of extras, make this release an essential addition for any collector or fan of animated films. Although the movie itself may not be Pixar’s finest offering, its home theater presentation is undoubtedly impressive. For those seeking both visual and auditory excellence in their Blu-ray collection, "Brave" comes highly recommended.
avforums review by AVForumsRead review here
Video: 90
Some of the action scenes – an obvious example being towards the start of the movie when Merida is riding fast through the forest on her horse, are simply too fast for 3D to work well....
Audio: 100
The idea is to allow for very precise positioning of spot effects, dialogue and in fact anything the sound designer desires and then route it to multiple speakers with different time delays etc. to make...
Extras: 90
Turning now to the extras disc, we get a third Blu-ray with a varied selection of clips and shorts:Fergus and Mordu – Alternate opening to film: Introduced by director Mark Andrews, this is the unfinished...
Movie: 80
The movie is great looking in 2D and not at all bad in 3D. I do have a few minor reservations regarding some of the faster scenes and a lack of roundness with some of the characters, leading to a certain...
Total: 80
Blu-ray.com review by Kenneth BrownRead review here
Video: 100
Dimensionality follows suit, lending volume and free-spiritedness to Merida's untamed locks of hair, intimidating mass to Mor'Du's hulking frame, and a pleasing realism to the roundness of faces, the curve...
Audio: 100
The LFE channel, bold and boisterous as ever, remains undeterred and unhindered throughout, injecting heft and presence into any and every element that requires even the least bit of its support....
Extras: 100
Promotional Pieces (Disc 2, HD, 14 minutes): Some pieces in this collection could have easily been billed as deleted scenes and snippets -- "Feast Your Eyes Montage (Wee Bits of Animation)," "Relics,"...
Movie: 70
The story is simple and formulaic by any standard, the characters are lovable but all-too-expected genre archetypes, the conflict is minimal, there's no real villain to point to (especially with a kindly...
Total: 80
Regardless of how you respond to Brave -- by most every account a lesser entry in the Pixar canon that still manages to outclass most animated films on the market -- its Blu-ray release will go down as...
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 100
Large scale fight scenes and chases fare particularly well, with isolated bits of action crossing the screen's plane to deliver greater excitement and a thrilling sense of motion and velocity....
Audio: 80
Bass frequencies are also strong, lending some oomph to stomping feet and the powerful roars of Mor'du, yet the LFE track seamlessly blends into the whole....
Extras: 20
They talk about, among other things, adding fresh elements to stereotypical figures, such as princesses and witches, various concepts that never materialized, balancing comedy and dramatic intensity, managing...
Movie: 80
After all, princesses are as vital to Disney as ice cream is to apple pie, and though Pixar possessed a smattering of prior experience with young female royalty (remember Atta and Dot in 'A Bug's Life'?),...
Total: 80
With as much muscle as its more masculine Pixar counterparts, this captivating portrait of a willful, free-thinking lass in 11th century Scotland combines action and mysticism with a relatable emotional...
AVSForumRead review here
Video: 100
The attention to detail in the construction of the animated characters physical features as well as objects within each frame is superb....
Audio: 94
The voices of the cast are reproduced with good tonal delineation and crystal clarity even during more active sequences....
Extras: 80
The legend of Mor’du – 6 minute animated short film Audio commentary by director Mark Andrews, co-director Steve Purcell, story supervisor Brian Larsen, editor Nick Smith (HD) Brave old world – 12 minute...
Movie: 70
When Merida's actions inadvertently unleash chaos in the kingdom, she must harness all of her skills and resources - including her clever and mischievous triplet brothers - to undo a beastly curse before...
Total: 86
Screen Onkyo PR-SC5508 THX Ultra 2 Audio/Video Processor Sherbourn Technologies - 7/200 Seven Channel Amplifier Oppo BDP-93 Universal Disc/3D capable Blu-ray Player (HDMI Audio/Video)...
Director: Mark Andrews, Brenda Chapman, Steve Purcell
Actors: Kelly Macdonald, Billy Connolly, Emma Thompson
PlotIn the rugged and mythic Scottish Highlands, princess Merida is the impetuous daughter of King Fergus and Queen Elinor, who is more at home with her bow than with royal responsibilities. Merida's spirited nature and defiance of an age-old custom angers the Highland lords and leads to chaos in the kingdom. Determined to forge her own path in life, Merida makes a reckless choice that unleashes unintended peril and forces her to harness all of her skills and resources to undo a beastly curse before it's too late.
As the kingdom teeters on the brink of turmoil, Merida encounters an eccentric old witch who grants her an ill-fated wish. The young princess's actions inadvertently set off a dramatic and dangerous chain of events that challenge her bravery and her archery skills. Merida's adventure tests her relationships, her wit, and her heart as she seeks to reverse the curse while discovering the true meaning of bravery and what it means to be a leader.
Writers: Brenda Chapman, Mark Andrews, Steve Purcell
Release Date: 19 Jun 2012
Runtime: 93 min
Rating: PG
Country: United States, Japan
Language: English