Home of the Brave Blu-ray Review
Score: 41
from 3 reviewers
Review Date:
Despite minor video and audio issues and a bare-bones presentation, Olive's Blu-ray release of 'Home of the Brave' remains a recommended wartime psychological drama.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 52
Home of the Brave's AVC-encoded 1080p Blu-ray transfer delivers a reasonably solid vintage experience marked by visible texture, consistent contrast, and rich black levels despite occasional scratches, flecks, and minor instability issues, confirming no digital tampering.
Audio: 49
Home of the Brave's DTS-HD Master Audio Mono track demonstrates clean dialogue and distinct sounds, but is marred by midrange distortion, background hiss, and virtually non-existent low bass, indicating a need for remastering and restoration.
Extra: 0
Adding no supplements and featuring only basic cover art, this Blu-ray release of 'Home of the Brave' is a bare-bones edition that lacks any additional content.
Movie: 60
'Home of the Brave' represents a compelling examination of racial prejudice within the military and the psychological trauma of war, skillfully utilizing flashbacks and standout performances—especially from James Edwards—to navigate its sociopolitical themes, though its message may sometimes feel ambivalent and dated.
Video: 52
"Home of the Brave" arrives on Blu-ray courtesy of Olive Films, presenting a 1949 war classic with an AVC encoded 1080p transfer in the original 1.37:1 aspect ratio. The video presentation reflects the age and condition of the source material, which is evident given that this transfer appears not to have been struck from a new remaster. Clarity and definition are commendable considering its vintage, though occasional softness detracts slightly from the otherwise sufficient resolution. The film showcases a good level of detail, with textures and skin details appearing clean and distinct.
Contrast levels are generally pleasing, albeit inconsistent at times, especially in scenes with stock footage that tend to exhibit lower contrast and more pronounced damage. Black levels are mostly accurate, providing a rich depth to the image, whereas whites can appear overly strong in certain sequences. The picture maintains a good gradation of detail within darker scenes, although noticeable scratches, flecks, and the occasional vertical line appear periodically.
Overall, despite slight instability issues and the presence of grain and artifacts typical of older prints, "Home of the Brave" is presented in a manner that honors its historical and cinematic value without the application of digital tampering. While the presentation is not perfect, it captures the essence of this war-time film effectively, making it possibly the best this title has appeared on home video, preserving its authenticity for both current and future audiences.
Audio: 49
The DTS-HD Master Audio Mono track for "Home of the Brave" offers an experience with mixed results. While the dialogue is distinct and crisp, there are noticeable shortcomings. The track exhibits a persistent, low-level hiss and light noise, particularly evident during quieter scenes and amidst intense sequences. Despite these minor disturbances, the fidelity generally holds up, ensuring that dialogues remain easily discernible. However, the narrow midrange somewhat restricts imaging and presence, rendering the overall audio landscape somewhat constrained.
The music score by Dimitri Tiomkin, unfortunately, suffers the most due to these issues. The opening credits theme, for instance, finds itself overwhelmed by gunfire, resulting in a diminished auditory impact. Moreover, there is a hint of low-level distortion in the lower midrange that becomes more apparent with Tiomkin's music than with other elements like dialogue or battle scenes. Additionally, a tad of brightness can be detected in the higher frequencies during action sequences, slightly detracting from the listening experience. Notably, deep bass response is practically nonexistent, resulting in an audio mix that feels light and somewhat uniform.
Overall, while the audio track for "Home of the Brave" manages to deliver clean and crisp dialogue, it fails to provide a dynamic and immersive sound environment. A remastering could significantly enhance its fidelity and robustness.
Extras:
The "Home of the Brave" Blu-ray release unfortunately lacks any supplemental material. The disc is a bare-bones edition, offering no behind-the-scenes footage, interviews, or commentaries. While the packaging includes cover art, it falls short in providing additional content that enriches the viewing experience. This absence leaves much to be desired for fans and collectors looking for an immersive, comprehensive look into the film's production and context.
Extras included in this disc:
Cover Art: The disc features professionally designed cover artwork.
Movie: 60
"Home of the Brave," a 1949 film directed by Mark Robson and produced by notable social activist filmmakers, intriguingly explores themes of wartime struggle, bigotry, and psychological trauma. The narrative is driven by the character of Private Peter Moss, portrayed brilliantly by James Edwards, who navigates the physical and emotional afflictions of war. The film addresses Moss's experiences during a perilous reconnaissance mission in the South Pacific, interwoven with flashbacks that methodically reveal his tragic journey. While the film appears somewhat quaint today, it effectively juxtaposes wartime violence with intense personal drama, providing a window into the often overlooked mental health struggles faced by soldiers.
The portrayal of racial tensions is pivotal in "Home of the Brave," given that Moss is a black soldier confronting systemic prejudice within his unit. These deep-seated prejudices are manifested through frequent, provocative use of the N-word, serving to accentuate the discrimination faced by Moss. A highlight is Moss's psychological evaluation by a compassionate Army psychiatrist, who attempts to uncover the roots of Moss's amnesia and psychosomatic paralysis. This choice of a benevolent psychological helper stands in stark contrast to more malevolent portrayals in later films. Despite this empathetic approach, the psychiatrist's ultimate prescription for Moss – to simply "get over" the lifetime of bigotry he suffered – feels oddly superficial and reductive.
Robson's direction, coupled with Carl Foreman's adaptation of Arthur Laurents' play, imbues the film with a sense of urgency and understated suspense. While some scenes may come across as overly talky or melodramatic, they ground the film in the harsh realities of wartime camaraderie and racial conflict. The closing reference to Eve Merriam's poem "The Coward" poignantly encapsulates the dual battles faced by soldiers: confronting both external enemies and internal fears. This richly layered depiction renders "Home of the Brave" a compelling historical drama, albeit sometimes simplistic in its resolution of complex issues.
Total: 41
"Home of the Brave," a 1949 war drama predominantly told through flashbacks, delves into the experiences of five soldiers during a covert reconnaissance mission in the South Pacific. The narrative, set against the psychological war backdrop, addresses the sociopolitical issues faced by African-American soldiers—a bold and prescient choice for its era. James Edwards delivers an impressive performance, supported by a dedicated cast, which elevates the film's exploration of psychological and racial themes, despite occasionally simplistic resolutions.
The Blu-ray release by Olive Films provides an average yet respectable audio and video presentation. The visual quality maintains the film's integrity, presenting a faithful transfer from available prints. However, the lack of supplementary materials is a notable shortcoming. The audio quality is adequate if not outstanding, ensuring that the crucial dialogues and poignant moments retain their impact.
In conclusion, "Home of the Brave" serves as an intriguing time capsule from the late forties, blending psychological scrutiny with sociopolitical commentary. Despite its minor technical flaws and the absence of bonus content in this Blu-ray release, it comes recommended for genre enthusiasts and collectors interested in wartime dramas with historical and cultural significance.
Blu-ray.com review by Jeffrey KauffmanRead review here
Video: 70
This presentation is much in line with another vintage forties' title also released recently by Olive, Johnny Come Lately, though Home of the Brave doesn't boast quite the consistent contrast that the...
Audio: 70
Home of the Brave's lossless DTS-HD Master Audio Mono track has just the barest hint of low level distortion in the lower midrange, something that is more noticeable when Dimitri Tiomkin's music is playing...
Extras: 0
...
Movie: 70
There's a certain patness as well to the way the film utilizes the "N-word" as both a thoughtless pejorative and (believe it or not) an instrument of healing, but that's perhaps at least a little understandable...
Total: 70
Bolstered by an impressive performance by James Edwards, along with great work by a small but dedicated supporting cast, Home of the Brave probably finds too many easy answers to ever seem very real or...
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 60
The occasional scratch and vertical line also rear their ugly heads from time to time, but for the most part, the video is consistent with generally pleasing contrast levels....
Audio: 60
The biggest gripe would have to be the consistent hissing and light noise heard in the background, made all the more apparent during quieter conversations and a few sequences with a good deal of yelling....
Extras: 0
...
Movie: 60
Although not the first to confront the issue of veteran's suffering from posttraumatic stress, the film captivates with a blend of psychological war drama with another sociopolitical concern....
Total: 40
The plot digs a bit deeper as a psychological war drama with sociopolitical themes of African-American soldiers, a controversial but topical subject matter explored while the wounds of war remained fresh....
Why So Blu?Read review here
Video: 70
...
Audio: 60
...
Extras: 0
...
Movie: 60
Rashomon is the film that ultimately gets the credit for capitalizing on this storytelling device and influencing all of cinema with it....
Total: 40
Home Of The Brave is a solid wartime psychological drama that may be a bit on the nose with its racial dealings, but likely worked like gangbusters during its own modern times....
Director: Mark Robson
Actors: Douglas Dick, Steve Brodie, Jeff Corey
PlotA group of soldiers embarks on a mission to a Japanese-held island during World War II, united in their task but carrying individual burdens. Among them is Peter Moss, an African American private who faces not only the dangers of war but also the prejudice of his fellow soldiers. As they navigate the jungle and confront the enemy, the stress of combat exacerbates underlying tensions within the group. The team's dynamics are further strained as Captain Murdock, their commanding officer, attempts to keep them focused on their objective amidst the escalating fear and uncertainty of their situation.
The grueling mission forces each man to confront his fears and prejudices, creating a crucible for personal growth and understanding. A traumatic event triggers Moss's memories of discrimination and alienation, both within the military and in civilian life. The intense psychological and physical challenges of the mission expose the vulnerabilities of all the soldiers, testing their camaraderie and resilience. Through these harrowing experiences, the men come to realize the profound impacts of racial and emotional scars, leading them towards a tumultuous and enlightening journey of self-discovery.
Writers: Arthur Laurents, Carl Foreman
Release Date: 14 Sep 1949
Runtime: 88 min
Rating: Passed
Country: United States
Language: English