Salmon Fishing in the Yemen Blu-ray Review
Score: 54
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
Salmon Fishing in the Yemen is a charming, well-acted, and visually appealing film, though the Blu-ray falls slightly short on extra content.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 68
The 1080p/AVC MPEG-4 transfer of 'Salmon Fishing in the Yemen' delivers a clean, filmic quality with splendid colors and stable fine detailing. Despite some soft spots and minor banding, the natural grain and rich saturation capture the diverse locales vividly, making for an engaging visual experience.
Audio: 53
The Blu-ray of 'Salmon Fishing in the Yemen' offers a steady and impressively clear DTS-HD MA 5.1 soundtrack with a precise and atmospheric soundstage. Gentle background effects like rain and water are subtly immersive, though dialogue can occasionally be overshadowed by heavier sound effects. Overall, the mix is stable and well-balanced, bringing solid clarity and immersive moments to the film.
Extra: 26
The Blu-ray extras for "Salmon Fishing in the Yemen" offer a standard definition, Dolby Digital 2.0 set of features including a basic 13-minute production overview and a brief 3-minute author interview, both providing minimal depth into the film's themes, cast, and production challenges.
Movie: 66
"Salmon Fishing in the Yemen" on Blu-ray is praised for its touching, charming narrative and strong performances from Ewan McGregor and Emily Blunt. Director Lasse Hallström skillfully balances humor, drama, and heartfelt themes of faith and perseverance, despite some predictable romantic comedy elements.
Video: 68
The Blu-ray video presentation of "Salmon Fishing in the Yemen" exhibits a commendable 1080p/AVC MPEG-4 transfer in a 2.40:1 aspect ratio. The image quality remains consistently robust with a pristine print, offering a natural, filmic quality thanks to a subtle layer of unobtrusive grain. Fine detailing impresses particularly in bright scenes where textures and finer elements are rendered sharply. The transfer captures the film’s diverse settings with remarkable integrity—from the vivid, picture-perfect natural greens to the soft, yet impressively detailed Scottish Highlands and Moroccan stand-ins for Yemen.
Color representation is excellently handled, displaying both rich, vibrant tones and more subdued earthen shades with equal finesse. This allows for a splendidly honest look that perfectly complements the movie's whimsical and diverse visual aesthetic. Contrast levels are high, avoiding any substantial blooming issues, while black levels are mostly solid if occasionally inconsistent. However, shadow detail remains reliable throughout.
Despite very few instances of banding and the occasional softer look in dimly lit scenes, the overall visual integrity is superb. The video remains free from any notable digital manipulation or distracting artifacts, maintaining an authentic viewing experience that stays true to the film’s original cinematic essence. In summary, this is another strong effort by Sony, showcasing the Blu-ray format’s capability to deliver high-quality presentations that balance visual clarity with a film-like feel.
Audio: 53
The Blu-ray release of "Salmon Fishing in the Yemen" boasts an impressively steady DTS-HD MA 5.1 lossless soundtrack that masterfully balances clarity and immersion across its runtime. The gentle musical score is consistently clear and well-defined, even through subtler notes, ensuring a continuous auditory delight. Atmospheric effects are particularly noteworthy, providing an accurately immersive experience. For example, gentle rain in chapter three fills the soundstage with finely detailed droplets, complemented by distant rumbles of thunder. Similarly, serene scenes near fishing spots offer lightly rolling waters that contribute to the tranquil ambience, contrasted sharply by a later sequence featuring rushing liquid that energetically surges through the listening area.
The front soundstage excels in separating and directing music and speech, ensuring dialogue remains crisp and clear despite occasional moments where heavier effects, like the thump-thump of helicopter rotors or the pushing force of rushing water, might momentarily overshadow it. Surround channels, while often subdued, effectively enhance the atmosphere with ambient sounds including background traffic, rain, and buzzing insects whenever appropriate. These subdued instances amplify the mix's scope without detracting from its primary focus on dialogue. Additionally, the dynamic range of the track is notably wide, capturing a broad frequency gamut free from distortion, while also delivering some solid bass activity during key moments, particularly in the film's climax.
Overall, this audio presentation cautiously avoids becoming a sonic powerhouse in favor of maintaining stable and balanced clarity from beginning to end. The sound field may not be as enveloping as one might anticipate for a more action-driven feature, but considering the dialogue-heavy nature of "Salmon Fishing in the Yemen," the track proves to be exceptionally solid and fitting for the material at hand.
Extras: 26
The Blu-ray disc for "Salmon Fishing in the Yemen" offers a limited but insightful collection of extras. The featurette "Miracles Happen: Making Salmon Fishing in the Yemen" provides an engaging look into the film's production, covering the story’s origins, casting choices, character development, and filming challenges. Although informative, it remains somewhat superficial. Meanwhile, "The Fisherman in the Middle East" is a short but enlightening interview with novelist Paul Torday, touching on the novel's adaptation to film, character formations, and narrative structure. Both extras are presented in standard definition with Dolby Digital 2.0 audio and optional English subtitles, which slightly diminishes their appeal.
Extras included in this disc:
- Miracles Happen: Making Salmon Fishing in the Yemen: Cast and crew discuss the film’s production, themes, and characters.
- The Fisherman in the Middle East: Novelist Paul Torday: Brief interview with the author about the novel’s transition to screen.
- Previews: Additional Sony titles.
Movie: 66
"Salmon Fishing in the Yemen," directed by Lasse Hallström, emerges as a multifaceted narrative teeming with subtle emotions, grand ideas, and complex relationships. The film adeptly balances humor and seriousness, presenting a touching yet heartwarming story. Ewan McGregor, portraying Dr. Alfred Jones, embodies a stoic and practical fisheries expert who transitions from skepticism to belief in the seemingly impossible project of introducing salmon fishing to Yemen. Alongside him, Emily Blunt's character, Harriet Chetwode-Talbot, brings warmth and adventurous spirit, forming an affinity through their shared endeavor. Amr Waked's Sheikh Muhammad adds a layer of dignified wisdom and compassion that enriches the narrative. The film delves into the themes of faith, perseverance, and human ingenuity, crafting a tale that feels intimate despite its larger-than-life premise.
Kristin Scott Thomas, as Patricia Maxwell, injects comedic charm into the political subplot, connecting the personal struggles of the characters to broader geopolitical tensions. The screenplay maintains a clever humor that prevents it from becoming overly sentimental or preachy. It intertwines Fred Jones' metaphorical journey of swimming upstream against life's various currents with the literal lifework of bringing salmon to Yemen. Hallström's direction focuses on character-driven storytelling rather than extravagant visuals, providing a platform for nuanced performances marked by genuine chemistry.
The film's narrative is not without its predictable romantic comedy tropes; existing relationships pose obstacles for the budding romance between Fred and Harriet. However, these elements are executed with sincerity and wit, ensuring that the core story remains compelling. The movie’s ability to uplift through its positive approach to seemingly impossible dreams underscores its earnestness. Despite minor shortcomings in exploring the logistical challenges of the salmon project, "Salmon Fishing in the Yemen" triumphs as a whimsical, heartfelt exploration of faith, love, and human connection.
Total: 54
'Salmon Fishing in the Yemen' directed by Lasse Hallstrom, is a heartfelt romantic dramedy that seamlessly blends elements of faith, determination, and the intrinsic human capacity to unite under a common goal. Anchored by stellar performances from Ewan McGregor and Emily Blunt, the film transcends its genre clichés through sincere execution and a genuinely touching narrative. Blunt and McGregor’s chemistry and depth bring authenticity to their roles, making the film both relatable and encouraging. The movie conveys a magical synergy of comedic whimsy and earnest storytelling, underpinned by themes that resonate universally.
The Blu-ray release of 'Salmon Fishing in the Yemen' by Sony stands out with its high-quality video and audio transfers. The picturesque cinematography is given justice, with crisp visuals that capture the beauty of its diverse locations, while the audio mix brings clarity and immersive soundscapes to the viewer. However, the Blu-ray extras are lacking in depth and quantity; the brief featurettes fail to provide substantial insights into the film’s creative process. Despite these shortcomings, the overall technical presentation on this Blu-ray disc enhances the film’s charm and appeal.
In conclusion, 'Salmon Fishing in the Yemen' is a delightful, soulful film that inspires belief in the impossible and celebrates the power of friendship and shared dreams. While the Blu-ray release may disappoint those looking for extensive bonus content, it excels where it matters most – delivering top-notch video and audio quality. This film, embodied with whimsical charm and heartfelt messages, is indeed a must-see, and the Blu-ray does it fitting justice. Overall, highly recommended for both the film and its Blu-ray release.
Blu-ray.com review by Martin LiebmanRead review here
Video: 90
To be sure, the image is a hair soft in spots, but this is a silky-smooth, true-to-film transfer that captures the picture's various locales with integrity and great attention to detail....
Audio: 80
Quieter scenes near the fishing spots offer the calming and serene sound of very lightly rolling waters, countered by a heavy gust of rushing liquid later in the movie which loudly and actively but clearly...
Extras: 30
Miracles Happen: Making Salmon Fishing in the Yemen (480p, 13:07): Cast and crew, in this fairly basic overview piece, discuss the source novel, the story's qualities and themes, casting the lead roles,...
Movie: 80
His portrayal of the Sheikh never accentuates the wealth; he finds the character from the inside out rather than the outside in, and it's because he plays a real man rather than a body and mind and soul...
Total: 70
It's a light but purposeful outing, a picture that will leave audiences feeling good and believing in the power of man to come together in harmony, under a shared goal and the bond of friendship, never...
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 80
The print is in pristine condition, and a very light layer of unobtrusive grain is visible, giving the image a natural, filmic quality....
Audio: 60
The front soundstage has some solid separation and directionality with music and speech, but for the most part, discrete and disperse effects are minimal....
Extras: 0
We get some cast & crew interviews interspersed with behind-the-scenes footage as the participants discuss the movie's plot, themes, source material, locations, and characters....
Movie: 60
It might not be the deepest of allegories, but the simple parallel works very well, and the pragmatic man's potential transformation into a genuine dreamer is compelling and humorous....
Total: 60
Though flawed, the film has a fun, whimsical charm, and this disc is certainly worth a look....
Director: Lasse Hallström
Actors: Ewan McGregor, Emily Blunt, Amr Waked
PlotDr. Alfred Jones, a British fisheries expert, is approached by Harriet Chetwode-Talbot, a consultant representing a wealthy Yemeni sheikh with a seemingly impossible dream: to bring salmon fishing to the desert. Initially dismissing the idea as ludicrous, Dr. Jones faces pressure from his superiors and the Prime Minister's office, eager for a positive story from the Middle East. Reluctantly, Dr. Jones joins Harriet and the sheikh on this ambitious project. The sheikh believes that the endeavor will enrich the lives of his people and bridge cultural divides.
As Dr. Jones and Harriet work closely together on the project, they face numerous technical and logistical challenges, forcing them to re-evaluate their personal priorities and beliefs. While Harriet deals with her own personal hardships, Dr. Jones starts to see the visionary potential of the sheikh's dream. Through their shared efforts, they begin to form a connection that transcends professional boundaries, setting the stage for unforeseen developments.
Writers: Simon Beaufoy, Paul Torday
Release Date: 20 Apr 2012
Runtime: 107 min
Rating: PG-13
Country: United Kingdom
Language: English, Arabic, Mandarin