Blackenstein Blu-ray Review
Black Frankenstein
Score: 60
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
Blackenstein offers era-specific charm and notable supplementary material, though it remains an artifact of its time, with decent but imperfect technical merits.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 63
Blackenstein's Blu-ray release by Severin Films and Vinegar Syndrome offers AVC encoded 1080p transfers in 1.78:1 for both Theatrical and Video Releases. The Theatrical Release maintains decent detail in close-ups despite color fluctuations, while the Video Release suffers from poor quality transitions and frame misalignments.
Audio: 61
The audio presentation of 'Blackenstein' includes DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0 mono and Dolby Digital 2.0 mono tracks, with occasional distortion and slight crackling, particularly in the music. Dialogue and effects are clear despite some segues with differing amplitude and hiss levels, and English SDH subtitles are available.
Extra: 66
Packed with intriguing extras, the Blu-ray release of 'Blackenstein' features both the Theatrical and Video releases in 1080p, compelling interviews with those who knew Frank R. Saletri, archival photographs of the Lugosi mansion, an insightful news broadcast, and an engaging audio discussion on prosthetic FX by Bill Munns.
Movie: 36
Despite 'Blackenstein's lackluster execution and comparison to superior films like 'Blacula,' Severin Films' Blu-ray release shines with intriguing supplements focused on writer-producer Frank R. Saletri, who brought a unique spin to the Frankenstein mythos through the story of a disfigured Vietnam vet turned monster.
Video: 63
The Blu-ray release of "Blackenstein" from Severin Films and Vinegar Syndrome offers AVC encoded 1080p transfers in a 1.78:1 aspect ratio for both the Theatrical Release and the Video Release. Notably, the Video Release includes a disclaimer about its quality, and it visibly suffers from degraded source material. Transition sequences within the Video Release exhibit noticeable differences in clarity, color temperature, and frame alignment, culminating in a ragged visual presentation. Meanwhile, the Theatrical Release, while displaying occasional dupiness and color temperature fluctuations, provides a more solid color palette and relatively decent detail levels, especially in close-ups. Certain darker sequences appear milky, likely due to age-related wear and tear that remains evident despite restoration efforts.
The creature in "Blackenstein" is deliberately obscured in many scenes, with handheld camera movements that introduce quick pans, negatively impacting detail levels. This approach, likely intentional, aligns with the film's aesthetic but further exacerbates the lack of visual clarity in these sequences. Though marketed as restored, both releases retain signs of their vintage origins, including slight yet noticeable wear and tear representative of their age and handling.
Audio: 61
The audio presentation of "Blackenstein" on Blu-ray features DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0 mono tracks, which deliver a generally clear experience with some minor issues. Dialogue and sound effects are intelligible, though occasional slight distortions, especially in the music tracks, are noticeable. The film's score, an enjoyable albeit dated component, retains its charm despite some high-end crackling. The middle and lower frequency ranges are full and appealing, enhancing the overall audio experience. Additionally, the disc includes a Dolby Digital 2.0 mono mix, accessible through remote control options, but there's no Setup Menu indicating these choices.
The audio tracks remain consistent with the video counterpart, providing relatively clear dialogue and effects despite some inherent baked-in sound design flaws such as overdubbing issues. Music and score come through with a slight tinny quality but maintain clarity. Occasional differences in amplitude and hiss levels are perceptible during transitions, but these don't present major obstacles to enjoyment. For accessibility, English SDH subtitles are available, though they contain a few typographical errors. Overall, while the audio presentation isn't flawless, it competently preserves the film’s original sound design.
Extras: 66
The Extras included in the Blu-ray release of "Blackenstein" provide a fascinating and detailed glimpse into both the making of the film and the intriguing backstory of its creator, Frank R. Saletri. Two versions of the film are available - the Theatrical Release and the Video Release - accompanied by submenus that grant access to a range of supplementary materials. These extras notably include heartfelt interviews, archival photographs, and news broadcasts that showcase historical Hollywood artifacts and enigmatic elements surrounding Saletri's life and work. Collectively, they offer a rich narrative that extends beyond the main feature, delivering content that adds significant value for enthusiasts of classic horror and Hollywood history.
Extras included in this disc:
- Monster Kid: Interview featuring June Kirk with archival photographs of the Lugosi mansion.
- Archive News Broadcast: Coverage of perplexing aspects of Frank Saletri’s murder case.
- Producers/Directors/Actors Ken Osborne and Robert Dix Remember Frank R. Saletri: Interviews about Saletri.
- Bill Created Blackenstein: Audio interview with prosthetic FX creator Bill Munns with archival stills.
- Theatrical Trailer: Original promotional material for the film.
Movie: 36
"Blackenstein," also known as "Black Frankenstein," is a curious and arguably low-rent entry into the horror blaxploitation genre from 1973. The film was conceived as a capitalistic effort to replicate the unexpected success of "Blacula." However, where "Blacula" succeeded in blending horror with social commentary, "Blackenstein" falls short, lacking even the baseline finesse that would render it comparable. Despite this, the film earns points for its inventive, albeit rudimentary, reinvention of the Frankenstein mythos. The narrative pivots around Vietnam vet Eddie Turner (Joe De Sue), whose horrific injuries from a landmine and subsequent inhumane treatment at a VA hospital offer glimpses of socio-political undercurrents, although these themes are not fully explored.
In a unique twist, Eddie's transformation into the monstrous Blackenstein is initiated while he's still alive, a concept that strays from traditional Frankenstein lore. His fiancée, Dr. Winifred Walker (Ivory Stone), seeks out the expertise of Dr. Stein (John Hart), whose DNA research has earned him a Nobel Peace Prize—a detail that feels both tangential and bewildering. Yet, it's Dr. Stein’s nefarious assistant Malcomb (Roosevelt Jackson) who catalyzes Eddie’s grotesque metamorphosis through dubious means. These plot elements offer a distinctive take but suffer from a lack of coherent execution. The film has sporadic detours into unnecessary subplots, though they occasionally feature interesting, albeit brief, moments such as a nightclub sequence with soulful singer Cardella Di Milo.
Metabolizing like an Ed Wood film adapted for the blaxploitation era, "Blackenstein" is marred by amateur performances and meandering storytelling. Nevertheless, it manages to build an odd charm through scenes that strangely linger in memory. For those intrigued by the peculiar mix of low-budget horror and unfulfilled potential, "Blackenstein" offers sporadic flickers of engagement beneath its flawed surface.
Total: 60
The Blu-ray release of "Blackenstein" delves into the curious intersection of classic horror and 1970s blaxploitation cinema, presenting an archival piece rather than a conventional film experience. While the movie itself is undeniably dated, riddled with low-budget quirks and unintentional humor, it possesses an undeniable charm reflective of its era. The narrative, marred by wooden performances and questionable production values, is bolstered by a peculiar appeal that aficionados of cult horror might appreciate.
The technical presentation on this Blu-ray release is respectable, albeit not devoid of imperfections. Video quality improvements are discernible, preserving authenticity while improving clarity and color depth compared to previous formats. The audio restoration is satisfactory, capturing the essence of the period’s raw aesthetic, though it doesn’t fully eliminate the inherent limitations of the original recording. Supplementary materials add substantial value, offering insightful context and background on the film’s production and cultural significance.
In conclusion, "Blackenstein" is far from a cinematic masterpiece but has a niche appeal with its distinct era-specific charm. The release thrives more on its historical and cultural relevance than on merit as a standalone film. Those with a penchant for post-modern irony sprinkled with vintage horror tropes may find it an intriguing addition to their collection. Despite some technical shortcomings, this Blu-ray presentation encapsulates a slice of 70s exploitation cinema that holds intrinsic value for genre enthusiasts.
Blu-ray.com review by Jeffrey KauffmanRead review here
Video: 70
Quality for this secondary source is obviously pretty ragged and the segues to the film elements are frequently pretty ragged looking as well, with what amount to dissolves showing clear differences in...
Audio: 70
As mentioned above, the film has a perhaps unexpectedly enjoyable (if admittedly dated sounding) score, and while the high end has occasional very slight crackling, the mid and lower ranges sound full...
Extras: 60
Archive News Broadcast (1080p; 6:17) is from around a year after the murder (as evidenced by the reporter's introduction) and covers some of the more perplexing aspects of the case....
Movie: 40
Unfortunately for both Winifred and Eddie, Stein's assistant Malcomb (Roosevelt Jackson) has some nefarious ulterior motives which ultimately make Stein's attempts to heal Eddie backfire horribly, reducing...
Total: 50
I doubt even fans of Blackenstein would claim it's any kind of unappreciated masterpiece, but the film has a certain era specific charm, along with a low rent sensibility that may in fact recommend it...
The Digital Bits review by Tim SalmonsRead review here
Video: 80
Audio: 75
The overdubbing and other sound issues that are baked into the film’s sound design are just as obvious as ever, but there are no major hurdles to get over....
Extras: 80
Movie: 40
However, the film managed to, not exactly thrive, but at least get seen by folks on home video in its afterlife and build up a reputation....
Total: 69
Although a follow-up called Black the Ripper was planned, perhaps it’s best that Blackenstein was a one and done kind of deal....
Director: William A. Levey
Actors: John Hart, Ivory Stone, Joe De Sue
PlotDr. Winifred Walker, a brilliant scientist, seeks the help of Dr. Stein to aid her Vietnam War veteran boyfriend, Eddie Turner, who lost his limbs in combat. Dr. Stein is known for his groundbreaking work in limb reattachment and human regeneration and agrees to help. Eddie undergoes a revolutionary procedure involving DNA injections and advanced surgical techniques. Unfortunately, despite Dr. Stein's best efforts, complications arise due to a jealous assistant sabotaging the experiment, leading to unexpected and horrifying transformations in Eddie's body and mind.
Eddie's physical changes turn him into a monstrous figure with superhuman strength but severe cognitive regression. As he struggles to adapt to his new existence, his inner torment grows, eventually leading him to embark on a violent rampage. The once hopeful love story between Winifred and Eddie takes a dark turn as Winifred desperately seeks a solution to reverse Eddie's condition. Meanwhile, the city faces increasing terror from Eddie's uncontrollable actions. The tale explores themes of scientific ambition, unintended consequences, and the struggles of a man left shattered by war, now grappling with a monstrous existence.
Writers: Frank R. Saletri
Release Date: 01 Aug 1973
Runtime: 78 min
Rating: R
Country: United States
Language: English