Stand Off Blu-ray Review
Whole Lotta Sole
Score: 53
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
Terry George's 'Stand Off' showcases his lighter side with humor and charm, but suffers from inconsistency; a great transfer and sound make it a rental at best.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 69
'Stand Off' Blu-ray delivers a 1080p AVC-encoded image that is clear, detailed, and noiseless, with lifelike skin tones and excellent black levels. The film showcases a diverse color palette, effectively transitioning from earthy interiors to natural outdoor settings, maintaining high contrast and excellent shadow detail.
Audio: 64
Stand Off's DTS-HD MA 5.1 soundtrack delivers clear dialogue and distinct ambient sounds, though it sparingly uses its audio prowess for gunfire or explosive scenes. Street traffic and pedestrian noise enhance the immersive experience, while the musical score by Foy Vance adds a soulful Irish touch.
Extra: 6
The 'Stand Off' Blu-Ray offers no extras except the film's trailer (1080p; 1.85:1; 1:22). Initial startup includes skip-able trailers for other films, which are not accessible post-load.
Movie: 56
Renamed 'Stand Off' for North America, Terry George’s film loses its nuanced dark comedy in favor of misguided marketing that positions Brendan Fraser as a gangster, despite his character's mild-mannered role. The tangled narrative and miscast characters fail to unite the film’s many convoluted subplots.
Video: 69
The Blu-ray presentation of "Stand Off" delivers an impressive 1080p AVC/MPEG-4 transfer, bringing a lifelike and highly detailed image to the screen. The film, shot with a Panasonic Genesis HD camera and finalized through a digital intermediate process, offers a clear and noiseless visual experience. Black levels are consistent and detailed, providing excellent shadow detail and contrast that transitions smoothly from day to night scenes. There is no presence of crush or banding, contributing to a polished and immersive viewing experience throughout the film’s entirety.
Director George and cinematographer Des Whelan have crafted a diverse and balanced color palette that avoids the overused teal-and-orange trend in favor of more natural tones. Earthy hues dominate interior shots, such as ochres in Maguire’s shop, a sickly green in the back room, and amber lighting in public settings. The transition into night scenes is seamlessly managed, maintaining the natural feel of Belfast’s streets under emergency floodlights. The localized atmospheres are enhanced by bright and clear visuals that distinguish different settings effectively.
Skin tones are rendered warmly yet accurately without veering towards overly red or orange hues. The Blu-ray's compression onto a BD-25 disc maintains a respectable bitrate under 27 Mbps, ensuring that the high-quality image is preserved without artifacts. The cinematography effectively uses Belfast’s overcast sky to differentiate locations, with subtle shifts in the film’s look from earthy greens to more intense reds and yellows that underscore the narrative’s complexity. This transfer exemplifies how technical proficiency can elevate the storytelling through meticulous visual presentation.
Audio: 64
The DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 soundtrack for "Stand Off" delivers a subtle but effective auditory experience. Gunfire and explosive elements, although sparse, are rendered with precision, offering a brief but intense sonic impact. The soundtrack excels when detailing the various Belfast environments, from bustling street scenes and a gypsy encampment by the shore to more modest settings like shop interiors and intimate conversations. Ambient sounds such as street traffic and pedestrian noise are well-integrated into the rear channels, enhancing the immersive quality of the mix.
Dialogue clarity is consistently maintained across the film's diverse array of accents, ranging from easily understood to more challenging. While viewers might need subtitles for comprehension, this is more due to the accents themselves rather than any deficiencies in the audio mix. The musical score, composed by Foy Vance, enriches the atmosphere with its distinctively Irish tones, blending jaunty and soulful elements seamlessly into the narrative.
Overall, while not the most robust or bombastic audio presentation, "Stand Off's" DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 track is well-suited for the film's comedic and dramatic nuances. It manages to provide a lively listening experience that supports rather than overwhelms the onscreen action.
Extras: 6
The Blu Ray edition of "Stand Off" lacks a robust set of extras, with minimal content provided beyond the main feature itself. The primary extra is a concise trailer for "Stand Off," spanning just over a minute in HD quality. Additionally, upon startup, the disc presents trailers for other films such as "Assassin's Bullet," "For Greater Glory," "Mafia," and "Red Dog." These can be bypassed using the chapter forward button but are not accessible from the main menu once it has loaded. This limited offering of extras may disappoint enthusiasts seeking in-depth insights or supplementary content.
Extras included in this disc:
- Trailer: Brief high-definition preview of "Stand Off."
Movie: 56
The film "Stand Off," originally titled "Whole Lotta Sole," is a dark comedy woven with uniquely Irish humor, directed and co-written by Belfast native Terry George. The rebranding for North American audiences, including the misrepresentative Blu-ray cover art featuring Brendan Fraser, does the film a disservice by suggesting a different genre. This disparity is disappointing given George's pedigree, with previous works such as "Hotel Rwanda" and "In the Name of the Father." The story follows American Joe Maguire (Fraser) who relocates to Belfast, getting entangled in the misadventures of Jimbo (Martin McCann), a bumbling thief indebted to ruthless gangster Mad Dog Flynn (David O'Hara).
The narrative hinges on a botched fish market robbery leading to a hostage situation at an antique store managed by Joe, all under the watchful eye of Detective Inspector Weller (Colm Meaney). With a blend of characters from Irish gypsies to federal SAS agents adding layers of chaos, the film attempts to balance farcical elements with the intensity of gangland drama. Though some performances stand out, particularly Meaney and McCann, they are often overshadowed by the convoluted plot and Fraser's underwhelming portrayal of the pivotal outsider.
Despite its succinct 89-minute runtime, “Stand Off” struggles to effectively harmonize its disparate storylines and character arcs. The film's engagement is occasionally buoyed by its quirky script and adept cast but ultimately falters due to over-reliance on coincidences and contrivances. While aiming to entertain through chaos and dark humor, the movie lacks the cohesive narrative strength needed to elevate it beyond its mismarketed packaging.
Total: 53
"Stand Off" offers a refreshing glimpse into Terry George’s comedic repertoire, distinctly different from his more somber undertakings like "In the Name of the Father" and "Hotel Rwanda." The film oscillates between light-hearted quips and engaging storytelling, embodying George's intent to leave the audience with smiles rather than sobering reflections. Notably, the Blu-ray transfer is impressive, delivering crisp visuals and commendable audio quality that enhance the viewing experience.
The film's charm is bolstered by its whimsical moments, such as the playful curtain call at the end, where characters break the fourth wall to bid farewell to the audience. This meta-narrative element intriguingly aligns with George's storytelling style, adding a layer of authenticity and humor. However, the film’s inconsistent tone may alienate fans expecting a more dramatic narrative, as suggested by the misleading action-oriented cover and title change.
Despite these tonal disparities, "Stand Off" remains a testament to Terry George's versatility as a filmmaker. With its robust technical presentation and George's engaging direction, the Blu-ray of "Stand Off" highlights his ability to pivot away from weighty themes towards more light-hearted fare. Highly recommended for those keen on experiencing a different facet of Terry George’s directorial prowess.
Blu-ray.com review by Michael ReubenRead review here
Video: 90
The color palette chosen by director George and his cinematographer, Des Whelan, should provide a welcome change to the many internet posters currently protesting the trend in mainstream Hollywood films...
Audio: 80
Otherwise, the track does a nice job of distinguishing the various Belfast environments where the film takes place, whether it's the normal street scene outside Maguire's shop, the gypsy encampment by...
Extras: 10
At startup, the disc plays trailers for Assassin's Bullet, For Greater Glory, Mafia and Red Dog, which can be skipped with the chapter forward button and are not otherwise available once the disc loads....
Movie: 80
The Irish gypsies have joined the crowd pushing at the barricade for reasons too complicated to explain, and Weller's son, Randy (Michael Legge), who is also on the force, has come with them, because his...
Total: 80
That I have a softer side, and I like, I actually prefer, people walking out of the cinema with a laugh and a smile, rather than feeling the weight of the world on their shoulders."...
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 80
The film appears to have been shot in HD, and the image conveys a lifelike detail in the actors' faces, with skin tones that register more on the warm side of things without developing an unfortunate red...
Audio: 80
But for the most part, this is a comedy that relies heavily on dialogue, and while there are several different accents on display that range from readily understood to nearly unintelligible, the audio...
Extras: 0
...
Movie: 40
It's never a good sign when the bizarre marketing and even more incomprehensible re-titling of a film for North American audiences becomes a focal point of discussion, but that happens to be the case with...
Total: 40
And while this more humorous outing is indeed a welcome departure from the likes of 'In the Name of the Father' and 'Hotel Rwanda,' there's a general inconsistency that keeps this from being a substantial...
Director: Terry George
Actors: Brendan Fraser, Colm Meaney, Martin McCann
PlotIn a small Irish town, a desperate young man named Jimbo robs a fish market to pay off his gambling debts to a local gangster named Mad Dog Flynn. During the heist, things go disastrously wrong, leading Jimbo to flee and seek refuge in a nearby antique shop owned by a reclusive American antiquarian named Joe Maguire. Unwittingly, Jimbo takes Joe and the shop itself hostage, creating a tense standoff situation as the police surround the building. The pressure mounts as Jimbo tries to negotiate a way out, while Joe attempts to understand the troubled young man and defuse the escalating situation.
As the standoff continues, the dynamics between Jimbo and Joe evolve, revealing deeper motivations and personal struggles. Outside, Detective Weller tries to navigate the volatile situation, balancing his duty with an understanding of the human drama unfolding inside the shop. As hours pass, secrets from both Jimbo's and Joe's pasts come to light, adding layers of complexity to their predicament. Amid the negotiations and building tension, personal connections and unexpected alliances form, setting the stage for a confrontation where everyone must face their own truths. The standoff itself becomes a catalyst for reckoning and resolution, affecting everyone involved in unforeseen ways.
Writers: Thomas Gallagher, Terry George
Release Date: 17 Jan 2013
Runtime: 89 min
Rating: R
Country: United Kingdom
Language: English