Incendiary Blu-ray Review
Score: 44
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
'Incendiary' disappoints, failing to impact, with miscast roles and unrealism despite good Blu-ray quality.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 60
Incendiary boasts a superb 1080p Blu-ray transfer by Image, with brilliant colors, deep blacks, and detailed definition, enhancing its stylized visuals and narrative impact despite the film's storytelling flaws.
Audio: 50
The audio, with its 24-bit, 48kHz DTS-HD Master Audio, impresses with clear voices and detailed treble yet sparingly uses rear channels and keeps deep bass minimal. Both mixes are solid but not extraordinary, prioritizing clarity over dynamic range.
Extra: 16
'Incendiary's sparse bonus content, limited to HD trailers and still galleries, echoes its minimal impact and the viewer's relief at the lack of extensive extras post a disappointing watch.
Movie: 26
Incendiary, while visually appealing with Michelle Williams' stellar performance, fails as a disjointed and unbelievable story, receiving criticism for poor writing and misused themes despite its ambitious attempt.
Video: 60
Image Entertainment has once again proven its ability to master the art of high-definition transfers, particularly evident in the Blu-ray presentation of "Incendiary". This film shines in 1080p, displaying a heightened contrast ratio and stylized camera work that adeptly complements its dramatic and emotional narrative. With a meticulous attention to detail, the color palette bursts with brilliance, creating an image that is both rich and vibrant. Deep blacks add to the visual depth, making every scene a visual feast despite the varying levels of stylistic softness intended for emotional effect. The sharpness of the London skyline, down to the minutiae of architectural elements and distant cranes, is rendered with an above-average definition that demonstrates the capabilities of Blu-ray technology.
Managing to maintain a spotless print, "Incendiary" excels in reproducing fine textures and wide shots with remarkable clarity, the result of a meticulous production and post-production process. The rich and natural colors display an impressive level of saturation without succumbing to bleeding or noise issues, showcasing the film’s visually arresting palette. Despite a minor critique regarding shadow delineation, where a slight black crush was noticed, the overall sharpness remains unaffected—free from edge enhancement or encoding problems. This indicates not just a successful transfer but also a respectful handling of the film’s original aesthetic qualities.
However, this release does not escape minor flaws; there is some boosted contrast that, at times, seems to flatten the image slightly. But these issues are far from detracting significantly from the viewing experience. On the contrary, they might only be noticeable to those specifically looking for such details. "Incendiary" stands out as a testament to Image Entertainment's commitment to quality, showcasing a very good-looking presentation that transcends the film's intrinsic narrative and emotional complexities, making it a commendable piece for any Blu-ray collection.
Audio: 50
The audio aspect of "Incendiary" on Blu-Ray, through its DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 Surround track at 48kHz/24-bit, showcases a competent but not groundbreaking auditory experience. The composition of the audio track shines in its clarity and detailed treble, where voices emerge crisply and with distinct clarity from a broad soundstage centered around the dialogue. This focus on clear vocal reproduction is commendable, given the film's narrative-driven nature. However, the mix lacks the low frequency effects (LFE) punch, with deep bass frequencies scarcely represented, making the track feel somewhat lacking in depth for more dynamic scenes. Mid-bass delivers a consistent linearity with the rest of the audio spectrum, ensuring a balanced yet underwhelming low-end performance.
On surround implementation, the audio mix utilizes the rear channels modestly, creating moments of ambient immersion but largely remaining front-focused. Such a choice underscores the film's dialogue over action, where surround bursts are fleeting rather than pervasive. Despite this restrained use of surround elements and a somewhat muted bass presence, the overall sound field remains spacious, with cleanly segregated dynamics across frequencies ensuring that dialogue generally remains king amidst varying levels of on-screen activity.
In sum, while "Incendiary’s" audio presentation maintains polished technical aspects and provides clean, detailed dialogues alongside a well-balanced midrange, it falls short of delivering an enveloping home theater experience. The conservative use of LFE and surround channels does not detract from a solid mix but leaves one yearning for a more immersive and impactful auditory journey that could complement the visual storytelling with equal vigor.
Extras: 16
The extras on the "Incendiary" Blu-ray offer a succinct, rather underwhelming collection, reflecting the film's modest reception and indie status. Viewers are treated to a minimal assortment of bonus content, comprising mainly still galleries and the film's theatrical trailer. The still galleries provide a closer look at the main cast through six sections of publicity shots, which, for fans, might be a modest highlight. Conversely, the inclusion of the theatrical trailer in 1080p serves as a straightforward companion piece to the movie itself. This sparse selection underscores the production's limited resources and the film's low impact at the box office, aligning with expectations for releases of this scale.
Extras included in this disc:
- Still Galleries: Six sections featuring publicity shots of the main cast.
- Theatrical Trailer: Presented in full 1080p high definition.
Movie: 26
"Incendiary," a cinematic translation of Chris Cleave's novel turned into a psychological thriller, presents an audacious yet flawed exploration of personal grief against the backdrop of terrorism. Led by Michelle Williams, whose performance is notably strong despite the constraints of a lackluster script, the film attempts to navigate the complexities of loss, guilt, and recovery. Williams portrays a young mother trapped in an unfulfilling marriage, whose life is irreversibly altered by a terrorist bombing that claims the lives of her husband and son. The portrayal of her ensuing emotional turmoil and fraught relationships, notably with characters played by Ewan McGregor and Matthew Macfadyen, aims to delve into the seldom-explored personal aftermath of such tragedies. However, the execution falls short, with critics pointing out weaknesses in writing, character development, and plausibility.
The narrative's focus on the protagonist's sexual and emotional journey post-tragedy as she engages with McGregor's journalist character and Macfadyen's police detective is both a strength and a downfall. While Williams' on-screen presence is magnetic, capturing the audience's attention with a realistic display of glamour that shines through in high-resolution Blu-ray format, the film's script and character dynamics detract from its potential impact. The movie's attempt to blend a personal story of grief with elements of romance and political commentary is ambitious, yet it ultimately compromises its authenticity and emotional depth.
Critically, "Incendiary" has been described as an opportunity missed, with its portrayal of terrorism's impact on survivors mired in unbelievable plot developments and an overreliance on its lead's performance to carry the narrative. Technical merits aside, including proficient direction by Sharon Maguire and a solid Blu-ray presentation that showcases Williams' commanding performance, the film struggles to effectively convey its intended messages or evoke a genuine connection with its audience. While ambitious in its scope and visually appealing, "Incendiary" is hampered by its execution, leaving viewers with a sense of what might have been in a more focused and nuanced handling of its sensitive subject matter.
Total: 44
"Incendiary," a film that had the potential to delve deep into the scars left by terrorism on a personal level, ultimately stumbles in its execution and fails to deliver the emotional resonance expected from such a premise. Despite Michelle Williams' commendable effort to bring depth to her character, the film's focus on her promiscuous traits and a lack of realistic portrayals severely hinder its impact. The screenplay, penned and directed by Sharon Maguire, draws from Chris Cleeve's book but fails to translate the emotional gravity onto the screen, leaving the characters feeling unrealistic and unrelatable, such as the wealthy journalist driving a Maserati and the oddly-behaving bomb-squad cop.
On the technical front, "Incendiary" is presented on Blu-ray with commendable quality, as one might expect from Image. The video and audio presentation are both recognized as strong points, offering a technically satisfying experience despite the film's narrative shortcomings. However, the absence of supplementary materials on the Blu-ray disc leaves much to be desired for those looking for an in-depth exploration into the making or themes of the film. This aspect could have offered additional value to the release but remains a missed opportunity.
In conclusion, while the Blu-ray release of "Incendiary" demonstrates technical proficiency in terms of picture and sound quality, it is overshadowed by the film's inability to effectively engage with its subject matter. The misalignment of audience expectations with the film’s focus, combined with miscast roles and a disjointed mix of politics and romance, render it a challenge to recommend. Even for fans of Michelle Williams or aficionados of the Blu-ray format looking for a technically sound addition to their collection, "Incendiary" falls short as a compelling narrative experience.
Blu-ray.com review by Greg MaltzRead review here
Video: 80
Combined with the blacks and shadow detail, the camera use provides good depth and at times an emotional impact missing from the narrative....
Audio: 80
And even though the 48 kHz mastering is not much better than CD quality, the voices are delivered with crispness and realism, and not much "digititis"....
Extras: 20
Having spent two hours watching a movie that was really not worth the time, I was a bit relieved that there was no need to wade through audio commentary or other bonus content....
Movie: 20
As if that isn't weird enough, Williams' character (who is never identified by name at any point in the film), not only tries to befriend the young son of the bomber but ends up saving his life after a...
Total: 40
Incendiary had a unique opportunity to cut through the news numbers and numbness and deliver emotional impact addressing terrorism's effect on the psyche....
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 80
I had issues with 'Incendiary' as a film, but without a doubt, it is well photographed and produced....
Audio: 60
The largely dialogue-driven film, with its mix of mushy romance and relatively flat action, doesn't provide much ammo for great surrounds, except in small bursts....
Extras: 0
Not too much here -- given 'Incendiary's next-to-non-existent US box office showing, that's no surprise....
Movie: 40
I hated the mawkish narration that Williams was given, as well as the ham-fisted social statements the film tries to make about the bombing in the movie, the big plot reveals, and the weak way the romance...
Total: 40
I like Michelle Williams, but she's miscast here, and the film's muddy mix of politics and romance just falls flat....
Director: Sharon Maguire
Actors: Michelle Williams, Ewan McGregor, Matthew Macfadyen
PlotIn London, a young mother’s life is shattered when she loses her husband and four-year-old son in a suicide bombing at a soccer match. Devastated by grief, she struggles to cope with her overwhelming loss, grappling with the unbearable pain of her newfound loneliness. Her life, once filled with the joy of her small family, now feels desolate and empty. As she navigates her way through the aftermath of the tragedy, her story is one of profound sorrow and the harsh reality of losing everything dear to her in an instant.
Complicating her journey of grief and recovery is her entanglement with two men: a journalist who was with her at the time of the bombing and the head of the police bomb squad who is investigating the attack. Both offer her a chance to find solace and understanding, yet their relationships are fraught with tension and conflicting emotions. As she becomes more involved with them, she is drawn into a world of secrets, guilt, and the question of her own culpability in the tragedy that changed her life. Her quest for redemption and peace becomes a complicated path, reflecting on themes of love, betrayal, and the human capacity for resilience in the face of heartbreak.
Writers: Chris Cleave, Sharon Maguire
Release Date: 24 Oct 2008
Runtime: 96 min
Rating: R
Country: United Kingdom
Language: English