It's a Wonderful Life 4K Ultra HD Blu-ray Review
Score: 80
from 8 reviewers
Review Date:
The native 4K restoration with Dolby Vision and TrueHD audio masterfully revives It's a Wonderful Life's timeless charm, despite minimal extras.
Disc Release Date
True 4K
HDR10
Dolby Vision
Dolby TrueHD
Video: 89
This 4K UHD restoration of 'It's a Wonderful Life' offers an astonishing visual upgrade, showcasing the classic film in native 4K with Dolby Vision and HDR10. The meticulous restoration leverages original nitrate negatives and fine-grain prints, presenting unparalleled detail, contrast, and texture without previous digital noise reduction, elevating its timeless black-and-white beauty to new heights.
Audio: 77
The 4K UHD Blu-ray of "It's a Wonderful Life" features a Dolby TrueHD 2.0 mono track, epitomizing clarity with strong dialogue and integrated environmental details. While the lack of surround effects might disappoint some, the track masterfully preserves the film's vintage charm, offering a noticeable improvement over previous versions without distortion or hiss.
Extra: 60
This 4K UHD release of "It's a Wonderful Life" offers insightful new featurettes, especially a detailed restoration documentary, showcasing intricate technical processes with stunning results. Although it discards previous extras and disappointingly includes only the colorized Blu-ray, its historical and technical depth remains engaging.
Movie: 98
Frank Capra's 'It's a Wonderful Life,' now remastered in 4K UHD from the original nitrate negative, remains a timeless classic featuring James Stewart’s powerful performance as George Bailey. The film, offering a poignant exploration of human spirit and the impact of one man’s life on his community, is enriched with a new Dolby TrueHD 2.0 mono soundtrack, embodying Capra's mastery in storytelling with added technical brilliance.
Video: 89
The 4K UHD restoration of "It's a Wonderful Life" offers a visually stunning experience, showcasing a level of detail and depth never before seen in this classic film. The restoration was meticulously executed using the original nitrate negatives along with additional fine grain sources for specific scenes, introducing Dolby Vision and HDR10 into the presentation. The transfer, at 3840 x 2160p resolution, enriches the grayscale by revealing profound textures and vibrant contrasts. The classic black-and-white visuals are significantly enhanced, showcasing deep, inky blacks and bright whites that add dimensionality to the film. The 1.33:1 aspect ratio preserves the original theatrical experience while the careful handling of 35mm film grain maintains the cinematic authenticity.
This release marks a substantial improvement over previous versions, which suffered from excessive digital noise reduction. Film enthusiasts will relish the newfound clarity, where even minor details like labels on prop tins are discernible. Paramount's ambitious use of 10-bit video depth and a wide color gamut fully exploits the monochrome palette, giving life to every shadow and highlight. While the restoration is not without minor inconsistencies, such as occasional softness due to inherent source limitations, the overall presentation is breathtaking.
Some scenes may exhibit slight digital fog or banding, potentially due to the constraints of merging various sources, yet these are rare. For fans experiencing "It's a Wonderful Life" in UHD for the first time, this edition is nothing short of a revelatory experience. The film now possesses a vibrancy and authenticity that captures its timeless charm and emotional impact with remarkable fidelity. Paramount’s efforts to preserve and present this cherished classic serve not only to enrich current audiences but also ensure its longevity for future generations.
Audio: 77
The 4K UHD Blu-ray of "It's a Wonderful Life" features a Dolby TrueHD 2.0 mono audio track that retains the film's classic sound profile, as used in the previous Blu-ray editions. This track excels in preserving the clean and crisp dialogue essential to the film's storytelling, demonstrating minimal distortion typically associated with films from this era. The track avoids any major signs of wear such as pops or hissing, offering a clear sonic presentation. Despite its mono limitation, there is a surprising depth to the audio that adds richness to the cinematic experience.
The sound design skillfully reproduces environmental details like bustling crowds and atmospheric elements such as blustering winds with commendable nuance. These effects, in conjunction with the clean dialogue, create a vivid auditory landscape that enhances scenes without overshadowing the primary audio components. The score, embodying both richness and mystery, is well-supported by front-end clarity, although it does exhibit some struggle at higher musical peaks.
Though some might desire an updated multi-channel mix for modern sound systems, this Dolby TrueHD track stays true to the film’s original sound intentions. It provides a warm, vintage audio experience while maintaining balance across complex sequences, such as the crowded dance scenes. This approach ensures historical fidelity without sacrificing audio quality, making it both a purist's delight and a testament to the film’s enduring audio charm. The thoughtfully remastered track substantiates its nomination for an Academy Award for Best Sound with its dense mix and subtle nuances.
Extras: 60
The 4K UHD Blu-ray release of "It's a Wonderful Life" offers a commendable array of newly produced extras, distinctively enhancing the historical and technical appreciation of this cinematic classic. These supplemental features are exclusively on the UHD disc, signed by Jon Mefford and his team, providing keen insights into the film's rich legacy and painstaking restoration process. The standout featurette, "Restoring a Beloved Classic," guided by Paramount's Andrea Kalas and Laura Thornburg, delves into the complexities and triumphs of the 4K restoration, illuminating every meticulous step from scanning original negatives to digital refinement. Another engaging piece, "Secrets from the Vault: It’s a Wonderful Life," features insights from Craig Barron and Ben Burtt, highlighting Frank Capra’s inventive filmmaking techniques like artificial snow creation under summer conditions. Lastly, "It’s a Wonderful Wrap Party" gives a rare glimpse into the film's celebratory conclusion with authentic home movie footage.
Extras included in this disc:
- Restoring a Beloved Classic: An in-depth exploration of the film’s comprehensive 4K restoration.
- Secrets from the Vault: It’s a Wonderful Life: A detailed historical dive into the film’s production and Capra’s cinematic innovations.
- It’s a Wonderful Wrap Party: Archival footage capturing the cast and crew’s wrap party festivities.
Movie: 98
Frank Capra's "It's a Wonderful Life," starring James Stewart in a career-defining role, is a cinematic triumph that continues to resonate deeply with audiences nearly 75 years after its initial release. Despite an underwhelming box office debut due to its significant production costs, the film has since earned its place as a beloved holiday staple and amongst the pantheon of great American cinema. The narrative follows George Bailey, whose selfless life choices champion the idea that personal sacrifice and community prosperity trump individual ambition. Capra, known for crafting films rich in optimism, yet unafraid of darker themes, masterfully contrasts George's noble spirit against the ruthless, capitalist Mr. Potter, delivering a poignant message about American values, empathy, and the immeasurable impact of one life on others.
Technically, the recent 4K UHD release of "It's a Wonderful Life" rejuvenates this classic with a new Dolby TrueHD 2.0 mono soundtrack and a 4K restoration sourced from the original nitrate negative. The clarity and detail bring fresh life to iconic performances by Stewart and Donna Reed, further enhancing the emotional intensity of scenes like George’s breakdown and Clarence’s intervention. The restoration preserves the film's authenticity while allowing modern audiences to experience Bedford Falls' transformation into Pottersville with striking visual fidelity.
Capra's masterpiece is deceptively simple in its storytelling but profound in its exploration of redemption and self-worth, offering an enduring lesson on the significance of every individual's existence. It meticulously constructs George Bailey’s despair and eventual epiphany through celebrated scenes that convey the consequences of a world without his influence. The film’s universal themes of love, sacrifice, and community transcend time, ensuring its place in both Christmas traditions and cinematic history.
Total: 80
The 4K UHD Blu-ray release of "It's a Wonderful Life" by Paramount embodies an exemplary blend of classic cinema with modern restoration technology, creating a must-have edition for fans and newcomers alike. The film, directed by Frank Capra and starring iconic figures such as Jimmy Stewart and Donna Reed, is a staple of cinematic history and remains a cherished component of holiday tradition. Paramount has treated this beloved classic with a meticulous native 4K restoration, enhanced with Dolby Vision HDR and Dolby TrueHD Mono sound, which not only revitalizes but remarkably enhances its timeless charm.
This rendition marks the best visual and auditory experience of the film to date, drawing viewers deeper into its moralistic and emotional narrative. The restored 1.33:1 HEVC aspect ratio ensures authenticity in its display, while subtitles in multiple languages add to its accessibility. Additional content supplements the offering, albeit limited, providing a fresh perspective even for those familiar with previous DVDs or Blu-ray editions. The extras may not be exhaustive but are certainly appreciable, delivering new insights into this treasured masterpiece.
In conclusion, "It's a Wonderful Life" in 4K UHD is as perfect as any dedicated aficionado could imagine. The restoration work has breathed new life into this enduring classic, making its acquisition an absolute imperative for serious collectors and film enthusiasts. Paramount's commitment to the physical format over digital offerings underlines the undiminished value of quality Blu-ray releases. This disc is not merely a nostalgic revisit but a pivotal release that commands attention on any home entertainment shelf, signaling a hopeful message for the future availability of classic titles in high-definition physical media. Highly recommended for its unparalleled quality and continued cultural significance.
avforums review by Casimir HarlowRead review here
Video: 90
It's a Wonderful Life's 4K restoration has been years in the making, with this UK Ultra HD Blu-ray bow every bit worth the wait, delivering the all-time classic in glorious native 4K with Dolby Vision...
Audio: 80
There's no sign of any track damage here - no hiss or pops, or high end distortion - with strong dissemination of the dialogue, and some nice atmospherics in the form of blustering wind that will send...
Extras: 60
It's a Wonderful Life's 4K disc actually includes a couple of Featurettes itself It's a Wonderful Life's 4K Blu-ray disc itself actually includes a couple of Featurettes itself, including an interesting...
Movie: 100
It's a Wonderful Life is surprisingly powerful, drawing you into the emotion of the journey right from the outset, establishing the core characters even as children before we meet their adult selves, and...
Total: 90
As perfect as any fan could have possibly imagined It's a Wonderful Life is a timeless classic and has been given some timeless treatment here courtesy of this loving, lavish native 4K restoration, complete...
AV Nirvana review by Michael ScottRead review here
Video: 100
I know it’s nice to have both versions of the movie (the Blu-ray included in the combo pack is the colorized version) but the colorized version was a made for TV alteration that really shows the cracks...
Audio: 70
It’s a Wonderful Life was never a high octane surround mix, but rather a simple 2.0 Mono track and trying to make a multi angle, wizz bang track out of the simple mix is just going slap happy with revisionism....
Extras: 60
...
Movie: 100
I could go on for quite literally PAGES discussing the implications of George and his loving compassion for those around him, and the deep implications of suicide and what it takes away from those around...
Total: 90
The film is one of those movies that just has me snuffling in tears by the very end, and probably is the most popular Frank Capra film in existence, and that’s saying something due to the massive amount...
Blu-ray.com review by Martin LiebmanRead review here
Video: 100
The period costumes, props, and set pieces are treasures for visual exploration; the picture thrives on displaying its characters and places and things, all of which the UHD presents with remarkably true...
Audio: 100
The presentation offers no major departures from the previous 2009 Blu-ray, here simply presenting the film's sonic essentials with pleasant clarity and good front-center placement....
Extras: 80
Restoring a Beloved Classic (2160p/HDRp, 13:03): Andrea Kalas, SVP, Archives at Paramount Pictures; and Laura Thornburg, Executive Director, Film Preservation at Paramount Pictures; discuss the 4K restoration...
Movie: 100
George is depicted as an upstanding citizen; he once saved his brother's life from the clutches of an icy grave; he saved the life of a citizen from a wrongly mixed prescription on account of a distraught...
Total: 40
...
Blu-ray Authority review by Matt BrightonRead review here
Video: 90
So while films like The Wizard of Oz sparkle in technicolor, this one has a more strong, constat look and feel to it....
Audio: 90
Surround effects aren’t present at all, but the entire movie seems to have a depth that I wouldn’t have thought possible given the age of the movie....
Extras: 50
We meet Paramount archivist Andrea Kalas and Paramount film preservationist Laura Thornburg as the duo guide us through the process of making this look as good as it does....
Movie: 0
The early part of the movie shows George as a child and his aspirations, even then, to explore the world....
Total: 100
I’m willing to bet that most people have seen this movie and if not, are at least familiar with it....
The Digital Bits review by Bill HuntRead review here
Video: 100
The blacks are deep and detailed, while the brightest areas of the image are a little more luminous (note that given the B&W nature of the film, both HDR options are equally appealing)....
Audio: 85
Additional audio options include English Audio Description, and Mono Dolby Digital in German, Spanish, French, Italian, and Japanese....
Extras: 75
Secrets from the Vault features film historian Craig Barron and legendary sound designer Ben Burtt talking about the film and its history, Capra’s work, and the process by which the filmmakers created...
Movie: 100
Stewart, in his first acting role after returning from service in World War II (he was a pilot in the Army Air Force) gives the performance of a lifetime as George Bailey, the likable everyman who yearns...
Total: 90
And I would love it if 4K fans and film enthusiasts alike purchased this release in huge numbers, because it would send a powerful message to the studio—one they really badly need to hear—which is this:...
DoBlu review by Matt PaprockiRead review here
Video: 80
Intact grain displays an unusual consistency – suspect, even – with a definite perkiness that avoids the appearance of digital noise....
Audio: 80
Bringing over the TrueHD mix made for the Blu-ray, the mono soundstage replicates dialog with masterful precision in its decidedly analog era source....
Extras: 40
Paramount includes a Blu-ray inside, yet only with the colorized version, sans all bonus features....
Movie: 100
Bailey shouting, “Merry Christmas” to a movie house, his daughter speaking of angels getting their wings, the hundreds of people crowding the home to help Bailey on Christmas Eve; all of it is a bundle...
Total: 75
A deserving classic, It’s a Wonderful Life is close to being a perfect film, with laughs, morals, drama, and a feel-good celebration of doing right by all....
Home Theater Forum review by Todd ErwinRead review here
Video: 100
The increase in resolution along with the use of HDR allow for greater detail (the award-winning snow-fall effects look much more natural now than ever before) and a broader grayscale, improving contrast....
Audio: 80
As Ben Burtt notes in one of the supplements, the film was nominated for an Academy Award for Best Sound, and after watching that segment and paying even more attention to the subtle details of the mix,...
Extras: 60
And instead of including the new Blu-ray release (which uses the same source master as this release), the only Blu-ray disc included in this set is the 2009 feature-only colorized version....
Movie: 90
In fact, if it were not for both the emergence of home video (just about every third-tier video label had released the film in some form on VHS, including Blockbuster) and the constant (and free) airplay...
Total: 80
However, the release overall is rather frustrating, as this should have included the restored version on Blu-ray rather than an older colorized version (or even a 3-disc release)....
AVSForum review by Ralph PottsRead review here
Video: 100
The 4K Ultra HD Combo Pack includes the black-and-white film in 4K high definition, as well as a colorized version on Blu-ray, along with three special features new to 4K Ultra HD disc: “Restoring a Beloved...
Audio: 80
has made an indelible impact on popular culture and continues to be a cherished part of our holiday tradition, remaining as powerful, and moving, as the day it was made....
Extras: 60
Disc 1: It’s a Wonderful Life Ultra HD Blu-ray NEW Restoring a Beloved Classic - Featurette NEW Secrets from the Vault - Featurette NEW...
Movie: 100
Return to Bedford Falls to experience the life-affirming message of director Frank Capra’s enduringly popular classic that tells the story of an angel that is sent from Heaven to help a desperately frustrated...
Total: 85
has made an indelible impact on popular culture and continues to be a cherished part of our holiday tradition, remaining as powerful, and moving, as the day it was made....
Director: Frank Capra
Actors: James Stewart, Donna Reed, Lionel Barrymore
PlotIn the small town of Bedford Falls, George Bailey is a selfless individual who has always put his dreams on hold to help others in his community. As a young man, George aspires to travel and see the world, but time and again, he sacrifices his ambitions for the greater good. He takes over his late father's struggling savings and loan business to prevent the avaricious Mr. Potter, a wealthy and unscrupulous banker, from taking over the town. Throughout his life, George provides financial support to the townspeople, enabling them to avoid falling under Potter's control. Although content with his loving wife, Mary, and their children, the mounting pressures and responsibilities weigh heavily on George.
On Christmas Eve, after a sequence of misfortunes threatens the existence of his family's business, George's spirits are at an all-time low. Overwhelmed by the potential ruin and disgrace, he contemplates suicide, thinking his family and town would be better off without him. At this critical juncture, George's distress is answered by an intervention from above. An endearing, yet bumbling angel named Clarence is sent to Earth to help George realize the value of his life. Clarence sets out to demonstrate to George the profound impact he has had on the lives of those around him and what Bedford Falls would have become if he had never been born.
Writers: Frances Goodrich, Albert Hackett, Frank Capra
Release Date: 07 Jan 1947
Runtime: 130 min
Rating: PG
Country: United States
Language: English, French