Civil War 4K Ultra HD Blu-ray Review
Score: 88
from 7 reviewers
Review Date:
Alex Garland's 'Civil War' on 4K Blu-ray is a must-watch, offering a chilling narrative, stunning 4K visuals, and a robust Dolby Atmos score, all packaged with insightful extras.
Disc Release Date
True 4K
HDR10
Dolby Vision
Dolby Atmos
Dolby TrueHD
Video: 96
Civil War's 4K UHD release is a visual tour de force, boasting an HEVC/H.265 encoded 2160p transfer, captured with high-end cameras up to 8K resolution, and finished with Dolby Vision and HDR10. The meticulous detail, vibrant yet naturalistic grading, and dynamic contrast make it reference-quality and demo-worthy.
Audio: 96
The Dolby Atmos mix of the "Civil War" 4K UHD Blu-ray provides an engaging, reference-quality audio experience with dynamic surround activity, immersive height channels, and powerful LFE that accentuates gunfire and explosions. Dialogue remains clear, while natural ambience and directional sound effects enhance realism throughout.
Extra: 64
The 4K UHD Blu-ray of 'Civil War' boasts an exceptional auditory experience, with immersive audio that masterfully places you in the film through impeccable surround steering and dynamic sound ranges. The key extra, 'Torn Asunder,' is a captivating six-part documentary offering deep insights into the film's production, making it a stellar addition.
Movie: 79
The 4K UHD Blu Ray of 'Civil War' presents a hauntingly palpable narrative that masterfully parallels our own polarized society. Addressing radical politicization through compelling vignettes and stunning VFX, the film captures the raw human emotions, highlighted by Kirsten Dunst's powerful performance, but suffers slightly from a clichéd ending and underdeveloped backstory details.
Video: 96
The 4K UHD Blu-ray release of "Civil War" offers an exemplary video presentation that sets a new benchmark for the format. Featuring an HEVC / H.265 encoded 2160p transfer at an aspect ratio of 1.85:1, the film utilizes a mix of high-resolution cameras, including the DJI Ronin 4D/Zenmuse X9 and Sony CineAlta Venice, capturing footage in 6K and 8K. The final product, completed with a 4K Digital Intermediate, is nothing short of stunning. The image displays remarkable clarity and fine detail, from the intricate textures on buildings and streets to the aging features on actors’ faces. The presentation benefits from high data rates between 75 to 85 Mbps on a 100 GB disc, ensuring the image has ample room to breathe.
Graded for Dolby Vision and HDR10, the dynamic range is exceptional, accentuating both highlights and deep shadows. Dolby Vision adds an orange-brown hue to certain scenes, enhancing the aesthetic with naturalistic yet vibrant colors. The rich color palette is vividly represented, from the lush hues in outdoor scenes to the dramatic embers in a wildfire sequence. Black levels are natural and crush-free, significantly enhancing detail in lower-lit scenes. Shadows in complex sequences, such as the climax at the White House, are masterfully rendered, demonstrating superior shadow detail.
The cinematography makes full use of depth of field, with selective focus adding a layered depth to many scenes. This creates an immersive experience, particularly noteworthy in scenes where a character’s eyes remain sharp while their surroundings subtly blur. From finely textured fabrics to expansive landscapes and intricate city exteriors, every frame is meticulously detailed. This level of detail affirms the film's presentation as a visual tour de force, making "Civil War" a must-have for 4K enthusiasts seeking reference-quality content.
Audio: 96
The Dolby Atmos surround mix of "Civil War" delivers an enthralling auditory experience that leverages the full potential of the platform. From the opening moments, which feature immersive blasts of white noise ping-ponging through all surround channels, the mix establishes an engaging soundstage. This effect, along with a substantial low-frequency rumble, sets the stage for a viewing experience where surround activity remains consistent and immersive. During sequences such as the firefight in Chapter 5, directionality is notably impressive, with nearfield sound placement in the bed channels enhancing the sense of presence.
Throughout the film, the Dolby Atmos track offers substantial auditory engagement, particularly during high-intensity scenes. Action sequences benefit from sensational bass that accentuates gunfire and explosions, shaking the room with precision. The overhead channels are effectively utilized, adding to the sense of being in the midst of the action. Helicopters and other flying objects provide a notable vertical dynamic. However, it is worth noting that in certain scenes, Atmos effects are limited, with multi-level conflicts sometimes lacking sufficient height channel engagement. Despite this, the overall mix remains robust and deeply enveloping.
In quieter moments, the Atmos track maintains its high standards by creating rich, authentic sonic environments with natural sounds like bird calls and rustling trees. Dialogue reproduction throughout the film is clean and clear, ensuring that speech is easily understandable even amid intense background action. Ambient effects contribute to a lively and complex soundstage, whether in bustling crowds or serene outdoor settings. The dynamic range of the mix encapsulates both extreme loudness and subtle quietude, ensuring an all-encompassing auditory experience that complements the visual narrative of "Civil War". The disc also features English Descriptive Audio and Spanish Dolby Digital 5.1 tracks, along with subtitles in English SDH and Spanish.
Extras: 64
The 4K UHD Blu-ray release of "Civil War" is a standout for its exceptional extra features. Headlining this is the six-part documentary "Torn Asunder: Waging Alex Garland’s Civil War," running just under an hour, which offers a deep dive into the film's production process. Produced by Charles de Lauzirika, known for his exemplary documentary work, it provides detailed insights into specific sequences with illuminating behind-the-scenes footage and cast interviews. It’s refreshing and avoids the typical promotional fluff, creating a compelling narrative that complements the film’s journey. The release also includes the theatrical trailer and a few A24 promotional trailers, along with a digital code for convenience. This collection of extras significantly enhances the value of the disc.
Extras included in this disc:
- Torn Asunder: Waging Alex Garland’s Civil War: Six-part documentary detailing the film's production.
- Theatrical Trailer: Original trailer for "Civil War."
- Amazon Blu-Ray Exclusive: Director and Cast Q&A: Additional interviews and insights.
- Other A24 trailers: Promotional trailers for A24 films "MaXXXine," "The Iron Claw," "Ex Machina," and "Men."
Movie: 79
"Civil War," directed by Alex Garland, is a deeply resonant film that merges typical war movie elements with an unorthodox narrative. Drawing inspiration from classics like "Apocalypse Now," the film presents a haunting journey through a war-torn United States. It offers a unique take on political radicalization, focusing less on the conflict's origins and more on its repercussions. Through the lens of war journalists traveling to Washington D.C. to secure an interview with a beleaguered President, Garland crafts a disturbing and plausible depiction of modern socio-political fractures. Characters like the weary Lee (Kirsten Dunst) and the hopeful Jessie (Cailee Spaeny) navigate this harrowing landscape, reflecting broader societal issues such as media influence, empathy erosion, and generational divides.
Visually, the film excels with impressive VFX work that convincingly conveys the scale of the war. The performances are uniformly strong, with Kirsten Dunst and Stephen McKinley Henderson delivering standout portrayals. Dunst's depiction of a seasoned photojournalist captures the nuanced struggle between personal disillusionment and professional duty. Garland's use of stark black-and-white photography accentuates the film’s anti-partisan stance, emphasizing the universal human cost of political strife over partisan loyalty. The intense third act, set against the backdrop of a battle-ravaged White House, delivers visceral action sequences that rival urban warfare classics.
While Garland's decision to remain deliberately vague about specific political allegiances has sparked criticism, it underscores the film's central theme: the inevitable violence stemming from unchecked radicalism, irrespective of ideological underpinnings. However, this ambiguity can also make the story seem muddled at times. Despite this, "Civil War" maintains an engaging narrative through its smaller, emotionally charged moments and its provocative portrayal of journalism's role in conflict zones. The film’s timely message about division and the dire need for dialogue makes it both a compelling and unsettling experience. Through its unflinching realism, "Civil War" offers a sobering reflection on contemporary societal fractures, making it essential viewing for those attuned to current political dynamics.
Total: 88
Alex Garland’s "Civil War" is a masterclass in both visual and thematic storytelling, perfectly suited to a 4K UHD Blu-ray release. This version features a stunning native 4K transfer and an impressive Dolby Atmos soundtrack, elevating the home viewing experience to a new level of immersion. The disc is packed with technical prowess, offering exceptional clarity, color grading, and sound design that accentuates the film’s tension and atmosphere. The 4K release also includes an insightful making-of documentary that provides a deeper appreciation for Garland’s meticulous craftsmanship.
"Civil War" is a powerful film that blurs the lines between reality and dystopia, delivering a narrative rich in painful themes and thought-provoking ideas. The film does not shy away from presenting its harrowing vision of a fractured United States, adding a layer of unsettling relevance to today’s world. The performances, particularly by Kirsten Dunst, are outstanding and add emotional depth to the film’s complex storyline. While there are some minor cinematic contrivances, these do not detract from the overall impact of the film, which remains gripping and impactful from start to finish.
In conclusion, "Civil War" on 4K Blu-ray is a must-have for fans of high-quality cinema and home theater enthusiasts alike. Despite initial concerns about the UK release lacking certain features, it matches—and perhaps even surpasses—the US version in terms of technical excellence and supplementary content. This release is highly recommended for those seeking the ultimate audio-visual experience, promising to entertain as much as it terrifies. It’s a timely and haunting film that deserves to be seen in the best possible format.
avforums review by Mark CostelloRead review here
Video: 100
It’s a single standard amaray release, with the two discs in their own trays (not stacked) but without a slipcover or any form of booklet....
Audio: 100
The colour grading is incredibly rich and super contrasty, almost to the point of oversaturation at times, but it never veers into that territory, delivering images with the widest of contrast and colour...
Extras: 50
The dynamics of the sound are equally adept, with the track able to go from whisper quiet to raging audio inferno in the blink of an eye, all helped by a massively wide audio range – LFE is deep and powerful,...
Movie: 80
While these vignettes work from a narrative and character perspective – the small town trying to forget the war is happening and go on as if nothing has happened, the rednecks using the war as an excuse...
Total: 80
Regardless, the UK disc is superb and should be considered a huge recommendation for those wanting the very best in sound and vision....
Blu-ray.com review by Jeffrey KauffmanRead review here
Video: 100
Dolby Vision / HDR adds just a touch of an orange-brown flavor to some of the yellow graded material, notably a couple of exposition scenes with Dunst and Henderson, one in a hotel, and later out in a...
Audio: 100
Wow, is all I can say to sum up this listening experience, but I'll specify a bit more by mentioning I'm not sure whether it's a "new, improved" part of A24's logo or perhaps the DNA masthead, or simply...
Extras: 50
Torn Asunder: Waging Alex Garland's Civil War (HD; 56:58) is an interesting six part making of documentary that offers a number of good interviews and a wealth of behind the scenes footage....
Movie: 70
That may seem like a veritable fool's errand given some of the depictions in the film, which offer an apparently authoritarian President under siege during his third term as well as secessionist states...
Total: 70
Vis a vis the redolently titled documentary mentioned in the opening paragraph above, long before most people even knew the process by which a cabinet secretary could be removed from office, my late father,...
The Digital Bits review by Bill HuntRead review here
Video: 100
Another standout scene happens later in the film, as the characters are driving through a forest fire at night—Sammy gazes through the window as a shower of luminous sparks and embers swirls around them....
Audio: 100
Extras: 95
In the second, you’re embedded with the film crew during the shooting of the first real combat skirmish the team sets out to document, and Garland and the cast talk about good journalism and how it’s gone...
Movie: 95
But as a cinephile, I’ve always appreciated Garland’s work, most recently his Hulu science fiction series Devs, so I resolved to keep an open mind....
Total: 98
Whether you consider this an “important” work or you simply approach it as a piece of cinema, Alex Garland’s Civil War is well worth your time....
DoBlu review by Matt PaprockiRead review here
Video: 80
Dolby Vision provides the kick, emboldening fireballs via intense brightness, the solid black levels keeping pace....
Audio: 80
Extras: 60
...
Movie: 60
It’s not even a warning about where the country is headed, rather it’s a telling indictment on what so many appear to want, and the brutal, graphic nature of what those people want....
Total: 70
...
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 100
Even in the big finale, where the exteriors are lower-lit and rely upon the action to really illuminate the staging, there’s just such deep contrast and enhanced black levels to really pull the most out...
Audio: 100
The film opens with overwhelming white noise, which does in fact fill the surround channels and sets the stage for what’s to come – a jarring soundscape frequently cut by loud, bass-heavy notes that threaten...
Extras: 60
As for supplements, there’s a terrific six-part making-of documentary that focuses specifically on the production of key sequences in each part....
Movie: 80
Whether you take Civil War as being for or against the political actions it depicts is completely up to you, but I found it entrancing in the way it shows the viewer the clear text they could be angry...
Total: 80
There is a great new making-of documentary included as a supplement to deepen your appreciation of the film rounding out this release as well....
AVSForum review by Ralph PottsRead review here
Video: 100
Whether it be the finest minutia in physical features or textures on the surfaces of objects, buildings, streets, or the interior of the various offices/venues depicted onscreen, the imagery is pleasing....
Audio: 96
In listening to the Dolby Atmos surround mix I found it to be an entertaining listening experience that made excellent use of the platform....
Extras: 70
Torn Asunder: Waging Alex Garland’s Civil War Six-Part Documentary • Theatrical Trailer • Amazon Blu-Ray Exclusive: Director and Cast Q&A Digital Code...
Movie: 70
There is literally no background on the events that led up to the conflict or specifics on why these journalists need to get the Washington in order to get an interview with the President....
Total: 84
Ralph Potts AVS Forum Blu-ray Reviews Reference Review System: JVC DLA-NZ7 4K Ultra High-Definition Laser Front Projector (Calibrated with Calman color calibration software and Portrait Displays C6 HDR2000...
Why So Blu?Read review here
Video: 100
The greys and blues are complimentary to the tone of the film, and there of course are many instances of brown from the landscapes in which the journalists travel....
Audio: 100
Dynamically, the sound field takes you into the battles, the chases and even the quiet moments....
Extras: 70
The sole extra on the disc is a multi-part documentary, Torn Asunder: Waging Alex Garland’s Civil War, on the making of the film that runs just under an hour....
Movie: 100
The message in the film is undeniable – Without some way to get together, even if we disagree, we may face a civil war just like the one depicted in the film, and this viewer would hate to see this as...
Total: 90
At once a timely statement of what could be, and a harrowing piece of action/thriller filmmaking, you will be on edge watching the film and worried for the principal characters the whole time....
Director: Alex Garland
Actors: Kirsten Dunst, Wagner Moura, Cailee Spaeny
PlotIn a near-future America, the nation is engulfed in a brutal civil conflict that has divided the country into hostile factions. Amidst this turmoil, a determined woman named Lily must navigate a life of secrecy and rebellion. While she appears to lead an unremarkable life, she covertly channels vital resources and information to the resistance. Her connection to an enigmatic underground leader, Javier, proves crucial as tensions escalate and military operations intensify. Both share a deep-seated vendetta against the oppressive regime, fueling their relentless pursuit of freedom.
As the civil strife continues to fracture communities and subvert trust amongst neighbors, Lily's teenage daughter, Emma, struggles to comprehend the somber realities of their world. She innocently fosters friendships in a perilous landscape, unaware of the dangerous factions lurking around every corner. Emma's coming-of-age journey becomes intertwined with her mother’s clandestine activities, leading to tension and heartache. Shattered by loss and driven by love, Lily and Emma face their greatest trials yet, constantly forced to question their ideals and allegiances. As battles rage on, they must confront difficult choices that will indelibly shape their future.
Writers: Alex Garland
Release Date: 12 Apr 2024
Runtime: 109 min
Rating: R
Country: United States, United Kingdom
Language: English