Trekkies Blu-ray Review
Score: 80
from 1 reviewers
Review Date:
Trekkies doc explores Star Trek's cultural impact, blending cast insights with fans' devotion.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 83
The AVC encoded presentation of Trekkies, with a 1.33:1 aspect ratio, showcases its 16mm roots through a grainy texture, detailing cosplay, interiors, and convention scenes with realistic colors and satisfactory delineation, despite minor source imperfections.
Audio: 83
The 5.1 DTS-HD MA mix ensures clarity and immersion, with frontal, intelligible interview conversations, dynamic scoring, and atmospheric crowd details, though low-end tones are not emphasized.
Extra: 66
In "A Trek Back," Denise Crosby and Roger Nygard reflect on creating "Trekkies," highlighting their collaborative spirit, meticulous nine-month shoot, and efforts to honor Star Trek fandom without mockery, leading to a successful theatrical release.
Movie: 86
Trekkies," directed by Roger Nygard and produced by Denise Crosby, delves respectfully into the Star Trek fandom, exploring its community, passion, and quirky dedication through conventions and personal stories.
Video: 83
The Blu Ray of "Trekkies" features an AVC encoded image with a 1.33:1 aspect ratio that faithfully retains the essence of the original 16mm cinematography. This deliberate choice offers viewers an authentically grainy and film-like visual experience, typical of documentaries shot during this era. The preservation of the source material is commendable, with minimal distractions such as the occasional presence of hairs on the film being the only slight blemishes. This release showcases the raw and unfiltered reality of Star Trek fandom, capturing the intricate details of cosplay costumes, facial expressions, and the vibrant interiors of fans’ homes and convention spaces with an impressive clarity.
Detail in the video presentation is notable, achieving a significant depth that allows for an immersive inspection of the cultural phenomenon it documents. The texture of makeup, the craftsmanship in the costumes, and even the minutia within crowded convention floors are presented with a level of detail that brings the viewer closer to the Star Trek community's heart. Color rendition is another area where this Blu Ray excels, displaying a full spectrum that enhances the viewing experience. The colors of uniforms pop with vitality, and the natural skin tones and varied backdrops contribute to a visually engaging documentary.
Delineation throughout the feature is achieved with competence, ensuring that even in lower light conditions or more densely packed scenes, viewers can discern the meticulous details that make "Trekkies" a fascinating study of fandom. This attention to technical quality in video presentation not only respects the documentary's subject matter but also enhances the overall appreciation for the depth and diversity found within the Star Trek community. With its faithful representation of original textures, vibrant color palette, and keen eye for detail, the Blu Ray video section of "Trekkies" stands as a testament to both the film's cultural significance and the respect given to its preservation for home cinema enthusiasts.
Audio: 83
The audio presentation on the Blu Ray edition of "Trekkies" employs a 5.1 DTS-HD Master Audio mix that orchestrates a focused yet immersive auditory experience, particularly tailored for the documentary's format. The dialogue from interviews, which constitutes the bulk of the audio content, is rendered with pristine clarity. This ensures every word from the plethora of participants is easily intelligible, effectively conveying their enthusiasm and passion without any loss of detail. The mix positions the bulk of its soundstage at the front, providing a direct pathway for the spoken content, thereby creating a closeness between the viewer and the individuals sharing their stories.
Accompanying the clear and direct dialogue, the score is threaded throughout with an attention to clarity that enhances the viewing experience without overwhelming the crucial interview audio. Instrumentation in the score is distinguished by its clarity and separation, subtly extending into the surround channels, thereby enveloping the viewer in a coherent auditory space. This approach underscores the emotional tones of the documentary without detracting from its vocal content.
Ambient sounds from convention settings expand the sound environment further, adding layers to the soundscape with crowd noises and other atmospherics. These elements are introduced judiciously, enriching the overall sense of place and occasion without encroaching on or muddling the primary audio elements. The low frequency channel sees limited engagement, reflecting a mix that prioritizes speech intelligibility and scores over pronounced bass effects. This choice is fitting for a feature primarily centered on personal interviews and experiences, ensuring that every element plays its part in supporting the narrative without unnecessary distraction.
Extras: 66
The extra presentation of the Blu Ray of "Trekkies" offers an insightful glimpse behind the scenes through its main feature, "A Trek Back," where Denise Crosby and director Roger Nygard delve into the creation of the documentary. Within a candid setting of a movie theater, the duo reminisces about their initial collaboration and the genesis of "Trekkies," highlighting the intensive nine-month filming period, strategies for engaging with the Star Trek community, and their thoughtful approach to portraying fan culture without mockery. Their discussion sheds light on technical challenges, such as utilizing 16mm cameras and rehearsing with fans to capture genuine enthusiasm. Additionally, Crosby's insistence on a theatrical release and subsequent appreciation from influential figures like J.J. Abrams underscore the project's uniqueness and impact. The inclusion of a theatrical trailer adds a nostalgic touch to the Blu Ray extras, rounding out the special features with a classic promotional piece.
Extras included in this disc:
- A Trek Back: A conversation with Denise Crosby and director Roger Nygard about the making of Trekkies, encompassing their collaborative journey, filming challenges, and their respectful portrayal of Star Trek fan culture.
- Theatrical Trailer: Promotional trailer for "Trekkies.
Movie: 86
Trekkies," directed by Roger Nygard and produced by Star Trek alumnus Denise Crosby, dives deeply into the heart of Star Trek fandom, presenting a universe that has captivated audiences for nearly seven decades. Released theatrically in 1999, this documentary ventures into the vibrant world of Star Trek conventions of the 1990s, providing an intimate look at the fans whose lives have been profoundly influenced by Gene Roddenberry's visionary creation. The film treads a fine line, managing to explore its subjects with humor and respect without veering into mockery or disdain. Through its exploration, "Trekkies" reveals a rich tapestry of individuals united by their shared passion for the Star Trek universe, highlighting the joy and solace they find in their engagement with this beloved franchise.
Denise Crosby, leveraging her insider status, enables the documentary to penetrate the close-knit community of Trekkies, giving viewers an unparalleled view of the convention circuit—once a series of intimate gatherings that have since evolved into massive fan conventions. Through Crosby's interactions, viewers are introduced to various fans, from those attending in full costume seeking external validation and internal satisfaction, to unique individuals like a dentist who has transformed his practice into a Starfleet-themed sanctuary, ensuring that patients receive not just medical care but an immersive Star Trek experience. The documentary smartly captures the essence of fandom, presenting it as a space for emotional expression, community building, and personal identity.
Roger Nygard's direction abstains from constructing a conventional narrative, opting instead for a snapshot approach that highlights the lives of several fans. These range from Gabriel, a teenager with dreams of contributing to the Star Trek lore, to Barbara, known for her Starfleet uniformed appearance at the Whitewater trial, each story unfolding with a blend of humor and sincerity. The focus on individuals like these showcases not just their personal dedication to Star Trek but illuminates the broader implications of fandom as a source of hope, community, and empowerment. In doing so, "Trekkies" not only respects its subjects but elevates their stories, offering viewers a nuanced understanding of the positive impact that immersion in fantasy can have on real lives.
Total: 80
In the Blu Ray presentation of "Trekkies," a documentary directed by Roger Nygard and hosted by Denise Crosby, viewers are given an exhaustive look into the fervent world of Star Trek fandom. This exploration is enriched by candid interviews with a range of Star Trek alumnae, including the likes of DeForest Kelly, Leonard Nimoy, Nichelle Nichols, Kate Mulgrew, and James Doohan. Notably, Doohan's poignant narrative about aiding a suicidal fan underscores the profound impact of Star Trek on its audience. Beyond the glitterati of its cast, the film delves into the lives of the fans themselves, showcasing their dedication and the lengths to which they celebrate their adoration for the franchise. Through Nygard's lens, we navigate a path that wavers between the eccentric and the heartfelt, revealing a deep-seated respect for the community that has turned Star Trek into a cultural phenomenon.
Central to "Trekkies" is not just an exhibition of fandom but an investigation into what drives this devotion and how it is perceived by those who created the very content being idolized. The interviews with Star Trek's actors and creators offer a layered understanding of this dynamic, balancing between amusement and bewilderment at the fandom's intensity. This balance is crucial, positioning the documentary as an empathetic study rather than a mere spectacle. The production quality of the Blu Ray enhances this experience, with crisp visuals and audio that faithfully convey both the grandeur of Star Trek conventions and the more intimate moments of fan interaction.
In conclusion, "Trekkies" on Blu Ray serves as a compelling tribute to the enduring legacy of Star Trek and its fans. Nygard and Crosby skilfully navigate through the vibrant tapestry of Star Trek culture, presenting a narrative that is both informative and profoundly respectful. Through careful preservation of technical details and a thoughtful extraction of emotions and stories, this presentation stands as an essential exploration for both fans and newcomers to the franchise alike. The documentary achieves a rare balance, celebrating the eccentricities while uncovering the deep connections that make Star Trek a pivotal part of its fans’ lives.
Blu-ray.com review by Brian OrndorfRead review here
Video: 90
Detail reaches as far as possible, with a natural sense of "Star Trek" cosplay, including makeup textures and fibrous costumes....
Audio: 90
The 5.1 DTS-HD MA mix provides a simple, frontal understanding of interview footage, with the participants offering intelligible remarks and comfortable surges of excitement....
Extras: 70
With the both of them interested in "Star Trek" fan culture, a plan was made to create a proof-of-concept reel at the next gathering of "Star Trek" fans, generating material that proved there was something...
Movie: 90
The world of "Star Trek" is enormous, with all types of media generating an impressively realized universe of characters, vehicles, and environments, giving fans a chance to completely immerse themselves...
Total: 90
Thoughts from the cast and crew are important to "Trekkies," understanding how such worship is received, but the primary appeal of the documentary is time with the public and their tireless commitment...
Director: Roger Nygard
Actors: Denise Crosby, Frank D'Amico, Barbara Adams
PlotThe documentary delves into the fervent and vibrant world of "Star Trek" fans, known affectionately as Trekkies, offering an eye-opening look into the lengths to which these enthusiasts will go to express their devotion to the franchise. With an engaging blend of humor and sincerity, it captures the essence of "Star Trek" fandom, showcasing individuals from various walks of life, including a dedicated fan who wears her Starfleet uniform to her job at a Whitewater, Wisconsin, post office, codifying her belief in the series' ideals of hope and equality in her daily life. By exploring conventions, fan clubs, and even personal collections that rival museum exhibits, it reveals the profound impact that a television series can have on its audience, transforming their lives and inspiring them in myriad ways beyond mere entertainment.
Furthermore, the documentary examines the cultural and social impact of "Star Trek" through interviews with its fervent followers, as well as through conversations with some of the series' cast members, who offer their perspectives on the phenomenon. It highlights how "Star Trek" has not only fostered a tight-knit community among its fans but also spurred creativity and innovation, with many citing the series as an inspiration for pursuing careers in science, technology, and other intellectual pursuits. The film juxtaposes the often-stereotyped image of fans as obsessive geeks with the reality of a diverse and passionate community, illustrating how science fiction can influence personal identity, and how fandom can lead to meaningful, productive engagement with the world.
Writers: N/A
Release Date: 08 Nov 2002
Runtime: 86 min
Rating: PG
Country: United States
Language: English, Klingon