Life Is Beautiful Blu-ray Review
La vita � bella
Score: 52
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
Balancing dramatic subtext and comedic surface with a remarkable performance by Benigni, this Blu-ray offers a decent audio and video package for a touching, must-see film.
Disc Release Date
Video: 48
The Blu-ray of 'Life Is Beautiful' features an AVC encoded 1080p transfer in 1.85:1, offering improved clarity and precision despite inherent softness and muted colors. While skin tones remain washed out and occasional digital noise is present, the overall presentation is solid with good detail and minimal compression artifacts.
Audio: 53
Life Is Beautiful's lossless Italian DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 mix offers nuanced sound quality, with clear and crisp dialogue, lifelike rear activities during camp scenes, and an Oscar-winning score by Nicola Piovani that is both encompassing and whimsical. However, the track shows limited scope and dynamic range.
Extra: 41
Extras include 'Making Life Beautiful,' a 23-minute promotional featurette showcasing Benigni's behind-the-scenes direction and acting, Academy Award TV commercials, and a theatrical trailer, all offering good insights despite being somewhat PR-heavy.
Movie: 81
Life is Beautiful’s Blu-ray release maintains its heartfelt, audacious charm, impeccably balancing whimsical comedy with the stark horrors of the Holocaust through Roberto Benigni's joyous, larger-than-life portrayal of Guido. The film's high-definition presentation enhances its visual storytelling, preserving its essence and emotional resonance.
Video: 48
The Blu-ray presentation of "Life Is Beautiful" is a 1080p transfer in a 1.85:1 aspect ratio, encoded with AVC. Despite being a significant improvement over previous home media versions, videophiles with high expectations may find the inherent softness of the film's visuals somewhat disheartening. Historically, since its theatrical release and through subsequent formats, the film has never exhibited razor-sharp detail. This muted sharpness aligns well with the whimsical tone of the movie and provides an aesthetically pleasing if understated experience. Some viewers may observe minimal digital noise at the beginning, particularly in the mist-laden opening sequence, but other compression artifacts are kept tightly under control.
The color palette is predominantly muted, contributing to the overall nostalgic and period-specific ambiance of the film. Noteworthy bursts of color, such as the neon green horse or sporadic bright reds in costumes, provide contrast and deeper saturation amid generally restrained hues. However, flesh tones remain somewhat washed out, resembling previous editions rather than offering a more lifelike rendering. This could be seen as a point of contention for those seeking more naturalistic skin tones. Despite these limitations, the Blu-ray offers solid fine detail and above-average clarity, resulting in an engaging viewing experience that fans of the film will appreciate in its high-definition debut.
Audio: 53
The DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 mix for "Life Is Beautiful" presents a nuanced and subtle audio experience that aligns well with the film's aesthetic and narrative style. While it lacks high-impact, high-energy surround effects, it excels in creating a quiet, immersive atmosphere that suits Benigni's quasi-mime physical comedy and the emotionally charged but restrained storyline. The lossless audio mix performs admirably, delivering clear and crisp dialogue with strong fidelity. Noteworthy elements include the distinctive directionality of sound effects and a fulfilling ambient soundscape, particularly evident in scenes set in the concentration camp's large courtyard.
Nicola Piovani's Oscar-winning score is another standout feature, providing a delightful auditory experience with its whimsical yet slightly reserved melodies. The score envelops listeners, offering an encompassing presence that enriches emotional engagement. Despite the track's generally limited dynamic range and scope, the mix produces lifelike activity, especially in the rear channels during busier scenes like the arrival at the concentration camp. The sparse but effective use of discrete sound effects, such as crisp gunshots and ambient noises from the camp, enhances the overall auditory realism. While it's not demo material for showcasing high-definition audio capabilities, this DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 mix is a commendable effort, offering a respectable balance that serves both the film's dramatic intentions and its technical delivery.
Extras: 41
The Blu-ray extras for "Life Is Beautiful" provide a comprehensive look at the film's conception and promotional journey. "Making Life Beautiful" offers a blend of documentary-style insight and promotional content, delivering behind-the-scenes footage of Roberto Benigni both directing and acting, which, despite its emphasis on publicity, gives viewers valuable glimpses into the filmmaking process. The "Academy Award Television Commercials" present the television spots aired during the Oscar broadcast, although notable moments like Benigni's iconic chair-dance are absent. The "Theatrical Trailer" is included, albeit in standard definition.
Extras included in this disc:
- Making Life Beautiful: Behind-the-scenes featurette with footage of Benigni directing and acting, mixed with promotional content.
- Academy Award Television Commercials: TV spots aired during the Oscar telecast.
- Theatrical Trailer: Standard definition trailer.
Movie: 81
"Life Is Beautiful" emerges as a remarkably crafted cinematic achievement, successfully navigating the tightrope between comedy and the harrowing realities of the Holocaust. Roberto Benigni's tour de force performance as Guido imbues the film with an infectious spirit of optimism and love, even amidst the darkest periods of human history. This delicate balance is achieved largely through Benigni's portrayal of Guido's unwavering positivity and ingenious attempts at shielding his son Giosuè (played by a remarkable Giorgio Cantarini) from the brutal truths of their internment. The film's fable-like narrative structure aids in bridging the emotional gap, allowing viewers to see the world through Giosuè's innocent eyes while being fully aware of the grim underlying reality, making Guido’s efforts all the more poignant.
The first part of "Life Is Beautiful" is marked by whimsical charm and comedic undertones. Guido's slapstick antics and romantic pursuit of Dora (Nicoletta Braschi) set against a backdrop subtly tinged with rising fascism create a rich prelude that contrasts sharply with the film's latter half. The transition to the horrors of the concentration camp is handled with finesse, as Guido concocts an elaborate 'game' to protect his son’s innocence. This narrative pivot not only highlights Benigni's dexterity in blending humor with gravity but also underscores the thematic core of the film: an indomitable human spirit in the face of unfathomable adversity.
Guido’s elaborate ruse to shield Giosuè from the harsh realities around them forms the emotional bedrock of "Life Is Beautiful." Benigni's exaggerated yet endearing portrayal of Guido adds a layer of warmth, making his character’s exuberant efforts both heartbreaking and uplifting. The film maintains its whimsical lens through Giosuè’s perspective but does not shy away from the grimness, creating a sophisticated dialectic that is both fantastical and profoundly human. The Blu-ray release accentuates these dichotomies, presenting "Life Is Beautiful" in all its visually lush and emotionally resonant glory.
Total: 52
The Blu-ray release of "Life Is Beautiful" masterfully preserves the film's delicate balance between tragedy and whimsy. The story, centering on Guido's unyielding optimism amidst the horrors of World War II, is portrayed with such unique sensitivity that it leaves an indelible mark on its audience. The movie's ability to extract profound human emotion from the darkest of circumstances demonstrates Roberto Benigni's superb acting and direction. His ability to juxtapose a comedic surface with a poignant, dramatic undertone makes this film a standout piece that resonates deeply with viewers.
The technical aspects of the Blu-ray release do justice to the film's original charm. The video quality is excellent, capturing the vivid and contrasting tones that reflect both the joyous and harrowing moments of Guido's journey. The audio package is equally commendable, providing clear and immersive sound that enhances the overall viewing experience. These technical enhancements ensure that "Life Is Beautiful" can be appreciated in the highest quality possible, making it a worthwhile addition to any film collection.
Conclusively, "Life Is Beautiful" transcends typical Holocaust narratives by infusing its story with hope and resilience. The film’s remarkable emotional depth, combined with a well-balanced direction, allows it to address serious subjects while maintaining a heartfelt yet bittersweet tone. This Blu-ray release not only preserves but amplifies these elements, making it highly recommended for both new viewers and long-time fans alike. Highly recommended.
Blu-ray.com review by Jeffrey KauffmanRead review here
Video: 70
The film has never been abundantly sharp from its theatrical exhibition onward through various home media releases, and while the Blu-ray is certainly a major step upward in clarity and precision, some...
Audio: 80
Dialogue is clear and crisp and well prioritized in the mix, fidelity is strong, and the track sounds very good, albeit somewhat limited in scope and dynamic range....
Extras: 50
Making Life Beautiful (SD; 23:27) is a nice little made for television enterprise that promoted the film after its international awards triumphs....
Movie: 90
Part of that is due to the fact that the film plays like, to use the term voiced by the narrator, a "fable," and that "once-removed-from reality" approach helps to bridge the gap between the film's considerable...
Total: 80
That this film should address such serious subjects with such an ostensibly cavalier attitude might seem to be objectionable, at least on its face, but this film is such a wonderfully wrought little gem...
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 60
There is some digital noise, especially during the movie's beginning, which quite possibly could detract from viewing....
Audio: 60
Dialogue is always clear, which probably wasn't that hard to achieve since Guido shouts most of his lines....
Extras: 40
– This featurette features your standard making of EPK-type material like some behind the scenes footage of Benigni directing and acting, along with quite a bit of promotional fluff thrown in....
Movie: 80
It's refreshing to come across a character so upbeat, so full of life, even though he has every reason in the world not to be....
Total: 60
The world of film is often filled with pessimistic characters, so it's nice to see an optimist who really can make a difference....
Director: Roberto Benigni
Actors: Roberto Benigni, Nicoletta Braschi, Giorgio Cantarini
PlotIn 1930s Italy, a charismatic and optimistic Jewish-Italian man named Guido falls in love with Dora, a gentle schoolteacher from a wealthy family. Despite challenges, he wins her heart through his wit, humor, and relentless spirit. They marry and have a son, Giosuè. As anti-Semitic laws intensify, their lives change drastically. Guido and Giosuè are taken to a concentration camp, and Dora, though not Jewish, voluntarily follows to be close to her family. Inside the camp, Guido uses his imagination to shield Giosuè from the horrors around them, convincing him they are part of a grand game where the winner earns a tank. His endless humor and creativity provide a protective shield for his son amid growing terror.
Daily life in the camp becomes a series of challenges as Guido continues his charade, maintaining his son’s innocence through playful deception and audacious bravery. Each encounter with guards and other prisoners pushes Guido to new heights of inventiveness, forging small pockets of hope and resilience. Amid the brutal regime and ever-present danger, Guido's unwavering determination transforms their grim reality into a surreal adventure, keeping Giosuè's spirit unbroken. Their touching bond and the relentless quest for survival stand as a testament to the human spirit's enduring capacity for love and courage.
Writers: Vincenzo Cerami, Roberto Benigni
Release Date: 20 Dec 1997
Runtime: 116 min
Rating: PG-13
Country: Italy
Language: Italian, German, English