The Breadwinner Blu-ray Review
Score: 71
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
The Breadwinner is a superbly crafted film with emotionally charged storytelling, impressive animation, and strong voice work, beautifully rendered on Blu-ray with exceptional video, audio, and comprehensive bonus features.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 74
The Breadwinner's Blu-ray offers an excellent 2.39:1 AVC-encoded 1080p transfer with dazzling color saturation and deep, inky blacks. Despite minor issues like edge shimmering and occasional banding, the animation displays refined textural qualities and majestic clarity, rendering it a visual treat.
Audio: 74
The DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 track for 'The Breadwinner' offers clear and potent musical definition, precise dialogue, and a well-defined sound stage, enveloping viewers with detailed, immersive effects, especially in bustling scenes like the Kabul marketplace.
Extra: 56
The Breadwinner Blu-ray extras include insightful commentary by the filmmakers on the animation process, narrative construction, and sound design, enriching the experience with behind-the-scenes featurettes and a trailer, complemented by an introduction from Nora Twomey and Angelina Jolie.
Movie: 76
"The Breadwinner" is a beautifully constructed yet dark and realistic animated film set in Taliban-controlled Afghanistan, highlighting the struggles of females through detailed, elegant visuals and exceptional narrative depth. Voiced by Saara Chaudry and directed by Nora Twomey, it balances grim realities with a vibrant color palette, yielding a compelling cultural discourse.
Video: 74
The 2.39:1 AVC encoded Blu-ray of "The Breadwinner" presents a visually stunning demonstration of how exceptional animation can translate brilliantly to the home screen. The lush and vibrant color palette is exceptionally well-rendered; for instance, the deep maroon of Parvana’s cloak and the shiny red of her favorite dress exhibit rich hues that stand out remarkably. The film's predominantly earthy, dusty browns are rendered with exquisite clarity, enhancing the authenticity of the Afghani setting. Black levels are consistently deep and inky, although minimal visual anomalies can be detected, such as intermittent banding in the sky and some close-up shots that exhibit horizontal banding. Additionally, slight edge shimmering occasionally disrupts the otherwise impeccable presentation.
In terms of textural quality, "The Breadwinner's" 1080p transfer does not disappoint, delivering an enriching, majestic clarity that accentuates every organic and natural detail. Whether it’s the terrain, clothing, or subtle character marks like bruises and scuffs, the Blu-ray captures these elements with superb precision. The colors remain lively and deeply saturated, offering nuanced shades that stand out vividly against the predominantly earthen backgrounds. Particularly noteworthy are the boldly colored garments, fruits, eyes, and rugs—each popping with considerable intensity and contrast. Overall, the 1080p image is sturdy and refined, with no major source or encoding issues detracting from the viewing experience. This Blu-ray provides a magnificent visual experience that enhances the animated masterpiece it represents.
Audio: 74
The Breadwinner's DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 lossless soundtrack offers a highly detailed and immersive auditory experience. Musical elements are excellently rendered, with fine instrument detail presenting robustly across the sound stage. Lilting Arabic tones are distributed smoothly through all six channels, ensuring a rich and enveloping soundscape. Dialogue is sharply focused and anchored in the front-center, maintaining clarity and presence throughout. The surround channels, while not overly aggressive, provide intricate detailing, particularly effective during marketplace scenes where the hustle and bustle of Kabul’s streets vividly surround the listener.
The use of Low-Frequency Effects (LFE) is well-balanced and judicious, enhancing the musical score and punctuating moments of elevated activity without overwhelming the overall mix. Discrete effects distinguish between the film's real-world action and its inner story landscapes, adding a layer of sonic precision. The audio track succeeds in creating an engaging and believable environment, drawing the viewer into the film’s rich auditory tapestry. Overall, this DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 track stands out for its nuanced approach and sonic excellence, making it an exemplary aspect of The Breadwinner's Blu-ray presentation.
Extras: 56
The Blu-ray extras for "The Breadwinner" offer a rich, comprehensive exploration of the film's production and creative process. Notably, the audio commentary with director Nora Twomey and various key filmmakers offers an intricate yet accessible discussion on the narrative and visual construction, making it a great companion to the film. Complementing this is an array of featurettes, including introductions by Twomey and executive producer Angelina Jolie, as well as behind-the-scenes insights into animation, music, and sound design. These featurettes collectively provide a thorough understanding of the collaborative effort behind the film’s creation. Additionally, trailers for related GKids films further enhance the viewing experience.
Extras included in this disc:
- Introduction by director Nora Twomey and executive producer Angelina Jolie: Brief thoughts from both on the film.
- Audio commentary with the filmmakers: Deep dive into the film's origin, narrative, and visual construction.
- Behind the Scenes with the Cast: Reflections on the story and characters.
- Animating the Film: Insight into digital construction of characters and environments.
- Creating the Music and Sound: Examination of the sonic elements supporting the narrative.
- Telling the Story: In-depth discussion on adapting the source material and casting.
- Theatrical Trailer: The original marketing trailer.
- More from GKids: Trailers for additional animations like "Song of the Sea" and "Miss Hokusai."
Movie: 76
"The Breadwinner," directed by Nora Twomey, stands as a testament to the maturity and depth achievable within the animated medium. Set in Taliban-ruled Afghanistan, the narrative juxtaposes stark, often harrowing themes with the vivid richness of its animation. Parvana, voiced by Saara Chaudry, embodies resilience and determination as she navigates the brutal realities of a society restrictive towards women. After her father’s unjust imprisonment, she disguises herself as a boy to sustain her family and attempts to free him, highlighting the courage and sacrifices inherent in her role.
The film balances its dark thematic core with a visually striking color palette, featuring deep maroons juxtaposed with bright greens and blues. This duality emphasizes both the enduring suffering and fleeting joys of its characters' lives. Through these meticulously crafted visuals and the fundamental human experiences they underscore, the story gains a rich narrative complexity. The animation—detailed yet unobtrusive—seamlessly integrates with the storyline, turning frames into a canvas that supports rather than overshadows the harrowing yet hopeful narrative.
Voice performances are another cornerstone, with Chaudry and Ali Badshah delivering compelling authenticity that enhances the film's emotional impact. While some tangential story elements such as the tale of the Elephant King may initially seem like detours, they ultimately enrich the central plot upon full revelation. Through stunning animation and profound storytelling, "The Breadwinner" transcends its medium to create an immersive exploration of culture, history, and human resilience.
Total: 71
"The Breadwinner" Blu-ray offers an exceptional cinematic experience, both emotionally and technically. Directed by Nora Twomey and written by Anita Doron and Deborah Ellis, the film brings to life a story rooted in cultural authenticity, with an emotional potency that resonates deeply with viewers. The Blu-ray release showcases the film in a stunning 2.39:1 AVC aspect ratio, ensuring the visual elements are presented with crisp clarity. The English DTS-HD MA 5.1 audio track adds depth to the immersive experience, capturing every nuance of the powerful voice performances by Saara Chaudry, Soma Chhaya, and Noorin Gulamgus.
The animation in "The Breadwinner" is both capable and complementary to its dramatic narrative, enhancing the story without overshadowing it. The film seamlessly balances timeliness and timelessness, making it a poignant viewing experience. Universal's Blu-ray does justice to the film's intricate animation and sound design, offering an impressive visual and auditory presentation that fully immerses the audience into the world of the story. Additionally, the Blu-ray includes valuable extras that provide deeper insights into the film's creation and impact.
In conclusion, "The Breadwinner" has been lauded globally for its emotionally resonant and culturally authentic storytelling. Though it narrowly missed winning the Best Animated Feature Oscar to "Coco," its delicate craftsmanship brims with love, heart, and palpable emotion. The Blu-ray release not only delivers a top-tier viewing experience but also includes substantive extras that enrich the viewer's understanding of the film. Strongly recommended as a great watch.
AV Nirvana review by Michael ScottRead review here
Video: 80
Blacks are deep and inky, but there are a few visual anomolies that mar the picture from being truly excellent....
Audio: 80
Musical definition is clear and potent, with a strong representation across the sound stage....
Extras: 60
• Introduction by director Nora Twomey and executive producer Angelina Jolie • Audio commentary with the filmmakers • The Making of The Breadwinner • Original Trailer...
Movie: 80
The artwork is so simple, yet so elegantly done that you get lost in the beauty of it all and forget about the hardships and pain that the characters suffer through on a daily basis....
Total: 80
The cultural moires and nuances have been given a very heavy dose of authenticity, and was a VERY close second for Best Animated Feature at the Oscars this year (supposedly Coco won out, but I wouldn’t...
Blu-ray.com review by Martin LiebmanRead review here
Video: 90
Textural qualities are highly impressive, with the Blu-ray more than capable of presenting, with enriching and majestic clarity and detail, all of the organic and natural textures seen throughout the film,...
Audio: 90
Several discrete effects help define the film's real and story worlds, while more intensive, room-filling effects rumble and douse the stage with pinpoint sonic excellence....
Extras: 60
Telling the Story (1080p, 7:49): A further discussion of the source book and the filmmakers' efforts to make the film as real as possible, which encompasses voice casting, interviewing real Afghans ahead...
Movie: 80
The film's colorful visual strokes support a story that's simultaneously dark and uplifting, revealing the realities of life under an iron fist and strict code but also revealing the realities of the human...
Total: 80
The Breadwinner's impressive dramatic heft and emotionally charged narrative, capable and complimentary animation, and strong voice work make it an easy nominee for the Animated Film Oscar, though Coco...
Director: Nora Twomey
Actors: Saara Chaudry, Soma Chhaya, Noorin Gulamgaus
PlotIn war-torn Kabul, young Parvana lives with her family under the repressive Taliban regime, which denies women the right to work or even be in public without a male escort. When Parvana's father is unjustly arrested, the family’s survival is jeopardized as they lose their sole male provider. With limited options and her family's well-being at stake, Parvana cuts her hair and disguises herself as a boy named Aatish to earn money and gather food. This new identity allows her to navigate the city's dangerous streets more freely and seek ways to free her father from prison.
As Parvana embarks on this perilous journey, she encounters various challenges and forms new friendships, all while the constant threat of discovery looms over her. She weaves elements of hope and fantasy into her grim reality by telling a tale of a young boy on a quest to retrieve stolen seeds from an evil elephant king. Her storytelling serves as a powerful metaphor for her own struggles and determination. The narrative intermingles Parvana's courageous efforts with her family's resilience, painting a poignant picture of life and survival under tyranny without revealing the resolution of their plight.
Writers: Anita Doron, Deborah Ellis
Release Date: 17 Nov 2017
Runtime: 94 min
Rating: PG-13
Country: Ireland, Canada, Luxembourg, United States
Language: English