The Man in the White Suit Blu-ray Review
Score: 73
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
Kino Lorber’s Blu-ray of The Man in the White Suit offers a strong 2K transfer of Alexander Mackendrick's timeless, thought-provoking comedy, highly recommended.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 76
The Man in the White Suit Blu-ray, presented in 1080p with a 1.37:1 aspect ratio and MPEG-4 AVC, boasts impressive sharpness and grayscale, although some scratches and occasional flicker persist. Originally restored in 2K, further manual cleanup could enhance its already strong visual depth and clarity.
Audio: 76
The English DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0 track on 'The Man in the White Suit' Blu-ray provides clear, sharp dialog and a balanced mix, despite minor inherited recording limitations. Whimsical sound effects and Benjamin Frankel’s score integrate seamlessly, with all age-related audio issues effectively resolved.
Extra: 56
The Blu-ray extras for 'The Man in the White Suit' provide a rich dive into the film's legacy through a detailed featurette with Stephen Frears and Ian Christie, despite a less engaging, rambling commentary by Dr. Dean Brandum, complemented by original and additional Kino Lorber trailers.
Movie: 86
Alexander Mackendrick's 'The Man in the White Suit' (1951) on Blu-ray offers pristine visuals and insightful extras, capturing Alec Guinness's portrayal of a scientist whose indestructible fabric sparks a satirical socioeconomic conflict, highlighting the tension between progress and stability in post-war Britain.
Video: 76
Presented in its original aspect ratio of 1.37:1 and encoded with MPEG-4 AVC, the 1080p transfer of Alexander Mackendrick's The Man in the White Suit arrives on Blu-ray courtesy of Kino Lorber. This release derives from StudioCanal's Vintage Classics line, following an early 2K restoration initially introduced in the United Kingdom. The overall quality of the video presentation is robust, highlighted by notable depth, clarity, and fluidity that maintain their integrity on larger screens. The grain structure is exposed nicely, though it could benefit from being slightly more refined and pronounced. Notable efforts in stability are present, but further optimization could elevate the visual quality.
Sharpness is consistently excellent, with particularly impressive grayscale rendering, especially in black levels and contrast utilization. Occasional scratches and flicker are detectable, including a conspicuous scratch towards the film’s end; however, these do not detract significantly from the overall viewing experience. The restoration is commendable, although additional manual cleanup work and budget for modern enhancements could make meaningful improvements. This Region-A locked Blu-ray does not feature a chapter index on the main menu, yet the film is divided into 8 chapters.
Overall, while there are areas for potential enhancement, Kino Lorber's rendition of The Man in the White Suit offers a solid visual experience that aligns well with its original theatrical presentation.
Audio: 76
The Blu-ray release of "The Man in the White Suit" features a single audio track: English DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0. For accessibility, English SDH subtitles are available for the main feature. This format offers exceptional clarity, sharpness, and depth in audio presentation, with dialogue being particularly easy to follow. The age of the recording does introduce a slight unevenness in elements such as chamber music, notably around the 01:20:01 mark, but these issues are inherent to the original recording. Importantly, there are no audio dropouts or distortions present.
The DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0 mono mix typifies its era with a limited range on both ends of the aural spectrum. Nevertheless, it effectively combines Sidney’s experimental sound effects—characterized by whimsical blurps and bloops—with Benjamin Frankel’s score and other sound effects. This integration with clear and comprehensible dialogue results in a well-rounded and faithful audio experience. Notably, any age-related anomalies, such as hiss, have been meticulously addressed, ensuring a clean listening experience throughout.
Extras: 56
The Blu-ray release of "The Man in the White Suit" includes a commendable array of extras that deliver a comprehensive appreciation of both the film and its historical context. The highlight of these is the featurette "Revisiting The Man in the White Suit," where director Stephen Frears and notable film historians discuss the film's unique qualities and Mackendrick's directorial legacy. However, the audio commentary by Dr. Dean Brandum is less impressive, marred by a mundane and hesitant delivery. Despite small technical limitations in some features, such as non-HD trailers, the collection effectively enriches the viewer’s understanding of this classic.
Extras included in this disc:
- Trailer: Original trailer for "The Man in the White Suit."
- Revisiting The Man in the White Suit: Insights from Stephen Frears and film historians.
- Audio Commentary: Dr. Dean Brandum on the film's themes and relevance.
- Additional Trailers: From Kino Lorber’s catalog: "Kind Hearts and Coronets," "The Lavender Hill Mob," and "The Captain's Paradise."
Movie: 86
Alexander Mackendrick's "The Man in the White Suit" (1951) is a masterfully crafted Ealing Studios production, arriving on Blu-ray courtesy of Kino Lorber. This film represents a quintessential blend of satirical social commentary and comedic narrative. Alec Guinness stars as Sidney Stratton, a chemist on a relentless quest to invent an indestructible, dirt-resistant fabric. Stratton's obsession and scientific rigor drive him from lab to lab until his groundbreaking creation is celebrated by his employer, Mr. Birnley (Cecil Parker). However, the fabric's perfection soon incites panic amongst the textile industry magnates and labor unions alike, fearing the catastrophic economic ramifications of such an imperishable material.
Mackendrick, along with screenwriters Roger MacDougall and John Dighton, adeptly balances wit and farce while delving into the deeper implications of industrial progress. The narrative takes time to build, with Stratton's first successful experiment occurring around 25 minutes in, preceded by a series of humorously explosive failed attempts. As the story progresses, various actors within the industry—capitalists and workers—converge to confront Stratton, leading to intense debates about economic dependency and social stability.
Alec Guinness delivers an engrossing performance as the single-minded scientist committed to his ideals, stubbornly refusing lucrative offers to sell his invention. Joan Greenwood provides a delightful contrast as Daphne Birnley, Mr. Birnley's progressive daughter, who admires Sidney's ideals despite their conflict with her father's interests. Supporting performances from Ernest Thesiger as the repelled Sir John Kierlaw and Vida Hope as a union organizer also add significant weight to the narrative. The film is visually enhanced by the pristine Blu-ray presentation, ensuring this thought-provoking classic continues to resonate with modern audiences.
Total: 73
The Man in the White Suit, directed by Alexander Mackendrick, stands as one of Alec Guinness' most remarkable performances, providing a clever blend of comedy and socio-economic commentary. This Ealing Studio classic intriguingly explores themes of progress and its potential drawbacks on industrialized societies. Questions about the actual benefits of technological advancements and the delicate balance of supply-and-demand systems are as relevant today as they were at the film's original release.
Kino Lorber’s Blu-ray edition features a high-quality transfer sourced from StudioCanal’s strong 2K restoration, originally introduced in the UK. The visual presentation is commendable, capturing the nuanced cinematography and pristine imagery that black-and-white films can uniquely offer. The audio fidelity, matching the visual excellence, ensures that dialogue and background scores are crisp and clear, encapsulating the film's vintage charm while enhancing modern viewing experiences.
Conclusively, The Man in the White Suit is not only a must-have for Ealing fans but also stands as a highly recommended blind buy for any cinema aficionado. Its thoughtful probing into economic dilemmas couched in a comedic framework makes it an enduringly relevant piece of cinema. Kino Lorber's Blu-ray release is a definitive version to own, delivering an exceptional balance of visual integrity and historical context. HIGHLY RECOMMENDED.
Blu-ray.com review by Dr. Svet AtanasovRead review here
Video: 80
The restoration is very nice, but it is arguably the one in the Ealing catalog that I think could benefit the most from some additional manual cleanup work....
Audio: 90
Some of the chamber music that enhances the action occasionally sounds just a tad uneven, but virtually all of the unevenness is a limitation inherited from the original recording....
Extras: 60
Revisiting The Man in the White Suit - in this featurette, director Stephen Frears (The Grifters, Dangerous Liaisons), film historian Ian Christie, and author and British film historian Richard Dacre discuss...
Movie: 100
There is a fascinating sequence in the film where business and labor come together, both absolutely terrified, because they have realized that Sidney's indestructible fabric will put an end on their relationship....
Total: 80
One of Alec Guinness' best performances is in Alexander Mackendrick's The Man in the White Suit, a rather uncharacteristically pessimistic comedy that asks a number of intriguing questions that may actually...
Home Theater Forum review by Matt HoughRead review here
Video: 90
Sharpness is exceptionally good throughout, and the grayscale is impressive, too, especially in the black levels combined with the expert utilization of contrast....
Audio: 80
The wonderfully whimsical blurps and bloops of the lab that signify Sidney’s experiments in full operation are a recurring sound effect combined with Benjamin Frankel’s background score and other sound...
Extras: 60
Revisiting The Man in the White Suit (13:55, HD): discussions of the achievements of Ealing Studio in general and The Man in the White Suit in particular are offered by, among others, director Stephen...
Movie: 80
Based on his play, the script by Roger MacDougall (assisted by John Dighton and director Alexander Mackendrick) takes a fair amount of screen time to get going, clearly twenty-five minutes until Stratton...
Total: 80
Alexander Mackendrick’s The Man in the White Suit combines comic circumstances with a sobering reflection on economic necessity that gives this fondly remembered classic additional relevance even today....
Director: Alexander Mackendrick
Actors: Alec Guinness, Joan Greenwood, Cecil Parker
PlotSidney Stratton, an eccentric and determined chemist, is working on creating an indestructible fabric that never wears out or gets dirty. Employed at a textile mill, he conducts secret experiments using the company's laboratory. After several setbacks and unplanned explosions, Sidney finally succeeds in developing a groundbreaking white suit woven from this revolutionary material. News of his invention spreads rapidly, attracting the attention of both the textile mill's owner, Michael Corland, and union leader Bertha Birnley. Both are initially thrilled by the potential economic impact but soon realize the existential threat it poses to their industries and jobs.
As the implications of Sidney's invention become clear, tensions rise between various stakeholders, including rival mill owners and workers who fear unemployment. A collective effort emerges to suppress the fabric's production, leading to mounting pressure on Sidney to abandon his groundbreaking work. Despite facing mounting resistance from all sides, Sidney remains undeterred, driven by his vision of a brighter future improved by technological advancement. The narrative captures the clash between innovation and economic interests, exploring how a single scientific breakthrough can disrupt established societal frameworks and challenge conventional wisdom.
Writers: Roger MacDougall, John Dighton, Alexander Mackendrick
Release Date: N/A
Runtime: 85 min
Rating: Approved
Country: United Kingdom
Language: English