I Am Cuba 4K Ultra HD Blu-ray Review
Soy Cuba
Score: 86
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
Criterion's 4K restoration of 'I Am Cuba' boasts breathtaking visuals and a definitive HDR transfer, making it a highly recommended upgrade.
Disc Release Date
True 4K
Video: 90
Criterion's 'I Am Cuba' 4K UHD Blu-ray features a new 4K restoration with excellent image stability and organic visuals, presented in HDR on UHD and SDR on Blu-ray. Despite minor grain and clarity fluctuations, this release remains the best home video presentation of the film to date.
Audio: 90
The 4K UHD Blu-ray of 'I Am Cuba' features Spanish and Russian LPCM 1.0 tracks, with faithful and clear dialogue and sound mix, despite occasional mild background hiss. This release likely offers the best audio quality the film has seen on home video.
Extra: 81
The 4K UHD Blu-ray of 'I Am Cuba' lacks bonus features, but the accompanying Blu-ray compensates with a robust set, including Vicente Ferraz's documentary 'I Am Cuba, The Siberian Mammoth,' insights from Bradford Young, archival commentary by Martin Scorsese, a remastered trailer, and an illustrated leaflet with an essay by Juan Antonio García Borrero.
Movie: 71
I Am Cuba holds acclaim for its stunning visual content and technical prowess, featuring innovative infrared film and dynamic tracking shots, despite initially being met with ambivalence due to its communist propaganda roots. Criterion's 4K UHD Blu-ray flawlessly showcases these aspects, enriched by substantial supplemental features.
Video: 90
Criterion's release of "I Am Cuba" comes in a 4K UHD Blu-ray/Blu-ray combo pack, with the 4K UHD disc being Region-Free and the Blu-ray disc Region-A locked. This new release features a pristine 4K restoration that is particularly impressive. Presented in its original 1:33:1 aspect ratio, the film benefits from meticulous attention to detail, making for an excellent viewing experience. Although HDR and Dolby Vision are not supported in native 4K, the overall image quality remains exceptional. For those who watch the film in 1080p, the quality of the presentation remains convincing, though the superior handling of darker scenes is more noticeable on a larger screen in the 4K format.
Technical parameters such as film grain, grayscale, and fine detail retention are superbly managed, enhancing the film’s organic feel. Notably, some minor density and clarity fluctuations exist, particularly in scenes that exhibit a documentary-like appearance. Shadow nuances have been distinctly handled, occasionally showing minor inconsistencies that could benefit from better management. Image stability is robust, free from large cuts or significant distractions; however, occasional white specks appear. Comparing 4K with 1080p presentations reveals that both formats offer solid density levels and strong visuals, although the differences are subtle. The 4K presentation slightly edges out in handling darker areas with more depth on very large screens.
In summary, this UHD Blu-ray release does a stellar job of presenting "I Am Cuba" with top-notch visual fidelity. From the faithful representation of film grain to the careful treatment of greyscale, this release stands as likely the best home video presentation of the film to date. Minimal scratches, tears, or dirt on the transfer further emphasize the high-quality restoration efforts undertaken for this cinematic classic.
Audio: 90
The 4K UHD Blu-ray release of "I Am Cuba" features two primary audio tracks: Spanish LPCM 1.0 and Russian LPCM 1.0, with optional English subtitles for both. The Spanish track has been meticulously preserved and remastered from the original 35mm magnetic tracks, delivering remarkable clarity and stability. However, listeners may occasionally detect mild background hiss. The Russian track is unconventional, as it overlaps the original Spanish narration/dialogue, which can create an awkward and less immersive viewing experience.
Faithful to Carlos Fariñas’ dynamic music score, both audio tracks on this release effectively capture the film's original auditory essence. The presentation ensures dialogue and sound mix are rendered crisply, with minimal instances of distortion, such as crackling or popping. This release sets a high standard for the film’s auditory presentation, potentially marking the zenith of its home video audio quality.
Extras: 81
The extras on the 4K UHD Blu Ray of "I Am Cuba" are remarkable for their depth and variety, although none are available on the 4K disc itself. The accompanying Blu-ray disc includes a comprehensive 2004 documentary by Vicente Ferraz, "I Am Cuba: The Siberian Mammoth," offering a detailed account of the film's production and its rediscovery in the early 1990s, complete with contemporary interviews. Additional features include insightful discussions from well-respected figures like cinematographer Bradford Young and the acclaimed director Martin Scorsese, who each provide context and appreciation for the film’s historical and artistic significance. The remastered trailer is a notable addition for those interested in seeing how the film was marketed during its re-release. A thoughtfully illustrated leaflet featuring an essay by film critic Juan Antonio García Borrero completes the extras package, providing valuable historical and technical insights.
Extras included in this disc:
- I Am Cuba, The Siberian Mammoth: Documentary on the film’s production and rediscovery.
- Bradford Young: Insightful discussion by cinematographer Bradford Young.
- Martin Scorsese: Archival feature about Scorsese's involvement in film's redistribution.
- Trailer: Remastered trailer for I Am Cuba.
- Leaflet: Illustrated leaflet with an essay by Juan Antonio García Borrero.
Movie: 71
Mikhail Kalatozov's "I Am Cuba" (1964) arrives on 4K UHD Blu-ray courtesy of Criterion, presented in its original Spanish or Russian languages, with optional English subtitles. The film stands as a benchmark in Soviet-Cuban propaganda cinema, blending visual artistry with political messaging. Kalatozov, a devout communist, directed this ambitious project which was greenlighted by high-ranking Party officials and co-produced with Fidel Castro's government. The narrative structure is divided into four vignettes that illustrate different lives experiencing revolutionary change in post-Revolution Cuba. Each vignette is distinct yet unified by a voice declaring itself "The Voice of Cuba."
"I Am Cuba" showcases Kalatozov's signature visual style seen in "The Cranes Are Flying," featuring long tracking shots and intricate close-ups that create visually arresting sequences. Notable technical feats include the use of infrared film from the Soviet military and dynamic wide-angle shots. These techniques are most strikingly executed in scenes like the funeral procession of a slain student and an impressive rooftop-to-pool tracking shot. Despite initial ambivalence from Cuban and Soviet audiences, the film's rediscovery in the 1990s has shifted appreciation towards its innovative cinematography rather than its propagandistic intent. The committed performances of the largely Cuban cast, along with 1,000 Cuban soldiers, further enhance the film's visual impact, although the pacing and editing receive some criticism.
The narrative is deeply intertwined with political messages. For instance, a farmer burns down his crop rather than submit to capitalist forces, while student activists engage in revolutionary acts. Two segments particularly demonize Americans through unsavory encounters with Cuban women, reinforcing anti-imperialist sentiments. Though initially met with controversy, today "I Am Cuba" is celebrated for pushing visual boundaries and continues to serve as an inspiration for filmmakers focusing on revolutionary themes and technical excellence.
Total: 86
The recent 4K UHD Blu-ray release of "I Am Cuba" by Criterion stands as an exemplary presentation of this historically significant film. Directed by Soviet maestro Mikhail Kalatozov, the film is renowned for its visually stunning, bravura camerawork. This release brings forth a sophisticated restoration that excels in both native 4K and 1080p formats. The HDR transfer is particularly noteworthy, offering deep contrasts and remarkable clarity that elevate the cinematic experience to new heights.
This edition not only elevates the film visually but also enriches the viewer's understanding through a comprehensive suite of special features. These extras delve into the intricate process behind the making of this propagandist epic, providing valuable insights into its production and subsequent influence on modern cinema. The documentary elements, interviews, and commentaries are well-curated, making this release a significant upgrade from previous DVD editions.
Despite its origins as an instrument of communist propaganda, and its initial rejection by Cuban and Soviet audiences, "I Am Cuba" has transcended its intended purpose to become a subject of critical study and admiration for its artistic audacity. Criterion's meticulous restoration makes this 4K UHD Blu-ray an essential addition to any serious film collection. Very highly recommended for both new viewers and seasoned aficionados.
Fidel Castro exterminated many thousands of his own people to preserve a brutal communist regime that transformed Cuba into one of the poorest countries in the world. As of today, Cuba is still in shambles because of Castro's dark legacy. An enormously ambitious co-production helmed by Soviet director Mikhail Kalatozov, "I Am Cuba" is the Ben-Hur of communist propaganda. It preaches Castro's lies to Cubans and the world with a breathtaking, borderline surreal arrogance. For this, it is perhaps worth seeing because a lot of these lies are resurfacing again. Criterion's upcoming combo pack introduces a recent 4K restoration of "I Am Cuba" that looks good in native 4K and 1080p.
Blu-ray.com review by Dr. Svet AtanasovRead review here
Video: 90
The release introduces a new 4K restoration, which cannot be viewed with HDR or Dolby Vision grades in native 4K. However, the overall quality of the presentation is very good....
Audio: 90
Many years ago, my first viewing of I am Cuba was with the Russian track that is included here....
Extras: 70
BLU-RAY DISC I am Cuba, The Siberian Mammoth (2004) - presented here is Vicente Ferraz's recent documentary about the production, reception, and rediscovery of I am Cuba in the early 1990s....
Movie: 60
The Cuban Missile Crisis had created plenty of doubters and dissidents, so I am Cuba was a crucial messenger for the ones Castro's thugs had not yet identified and terminated, as well as the ones that...
Total: 60
Fidel Castro exterminated many thousands of his own people to preserve a brutal communist regime that transformed Cuba into one of the poorest countries in the world....
Home Theater Forum review by t1g3r5fanRead review here
Video: 100
The film is presented in its original 1:33:1 aspect ratio, taken from a brand new 4K transfer created from a 35mm fine grain positive for this release; on the UHD Blu-ray disc, the movie is presented in...
Audio: 100
The film’s original Spanish soundtrack is presented on a PCM track – remastered from the original 35mm magnetic tracks – for this release; the alternate Russian dub for the movie is also presented on a...
Extras: 100
This feature-length documentary from 2004 by Brazilian filmmaker Vicente Ferraz recounts the film’s production and convoluted release history from key participants in the film’s making; featuring interviews...
Movie: 90
Made as part of a close association between Cuba and the Soviet Union to forward a global vision of communism (not to mention a celebration for Fidel Castro’s triumphant revolution), director Mikhail Kalatozov...
Total: 100
Criterion has likely delivered the definitive version of the movie on home video with a terrific HDR transfer and a solid slate of special features that delve into the making of this landmark film....
Director: Mikhail Kalatozov
Actors: Sergio Corrieri, Salvador Wood, José Gallardo
PlotThe film's narrative unfolds through four distinct vignettes, each illustrating different facets of life in pre-revolutionary Cuba. The first story centers on Maria, a nightclub worker in Havana who longs for a better life but is trapped in a cycle of exploitation. Her encounters with American tourists highlight the socio-economic disparities and moral decay prevalent in her surroundings. The second vignette follows Pedro, an elderly farmer who sees his idyllic life shattered when the government seizes his land to build a luxury hotel. Driven to desperation, Pedro decides to take drastic measures to reclaim his livelihood.
The third segment shifts focus to Enrique, a university student in Havana involved in the burgeoning revolutionary movement. His story captures the growing unrest and fervor among the youth, as they rally against the oppressive regime. The final vignette depicts Mariano, a peasant who joins the guerrilla fighters after witnessing the brutal suppression of his village. Through these interconnected stories, the film paints a vivid picture of the social and political turmoil that ultimately leads to the Cuban revolution.
Writers: Enrique Pineda Barnet, Yevgeniy Yevtushenko
Release Date: 01 Dec 1995
Runtime: 141 min
Rating: Not Rated
Country: Cuba, Soviet Union
Language: Spanish, English