Wings Blu-ray Review
Score: 68
from 3 reviewers
Review Date:
Wings’ Blu-ray release showcases exceptional restoration with impressive clarity, detail, and audio options, despite minimal extras, making it a must for cinephiles.
Disc Release Date
Video: 68
Wings debuts on Blu-ray with a stunning 1080p, 1.34:1-framed transfer, preserving its original presentation with sepia-toned, black-and-white, and blue shading visuals. Paramount's restoration delivers a clean, smooth image with strong fine detail, excellent contrast, and vibrant color accents, truly revitalizing this 85-year-old classic.
Audio: 68
Wings' Blu-ray audio presentation excels with a remarkable DTS-HD MA 5.1 track featuring a re-recorded score by J.S. Zamecnik, lush sound effects by Ben Burtt, and a faithful Dolby Digital 2.0 pipe organ soundtrack by Gaylord Carter. The clarity, directionality, and dynamic range substantially enhance the viewing experience.
Extra: 55
The Blu-ray extras for 'Wings' provide rich historical context, detailing the film's demanding production process in 'Grandeur in the Sky', showcasing meticulous restoration efforts in 'Restoring the Power and Beauty of Wings', and offering insights into WWI aviation in 'Dogfight!', all presented in high definition.
Movie: 92
"Wings" on Blu-ray soars with pristine 1080p/AVC video and a robust DTS-HD Master Audio track, reviving its groundbreaking World War I aerial sequences and timeless themes of love, valor, and friendship with stunning clarity. Despite occasional narrative drag, the film’s authenticity, heart, and technical prowess outshine many modern counterparts, making it an indispensable classic.
Video: 68
The Blu-ray presentation of "Wings" by Paramount showcases a superior restoration that preserves the film’s historical integrity while enhancing visual quality to a remarkable degree. The 1080p, 1.34:1-framed transfer ensures that the original visual experience remains intact, using vertical black bars to retain the film's intended aspect ratio. Beginning with a vibrant, high-definition Paramount logo sequence, the transition into the film's sepia overlay scenes is seamless. The imagery is punctuated by brief instances of black-and-white and blue-toned visuals, with vivid oranges highlighting the machine gun fire and fiery plane crashes. Fine details are robust, particularly on foreground elements such as costumes and facial textures, although background elements occasionally appear softer and slightly warped. The overall restoration reveals minimal signs of wear, featuring a visible but controlled grain structure that successfully transports viewers back in time.
Visually, "Wings" impresses with its flawlessly mastered sepia-toned and black-and-white sequences, offering a pristine visual experience free from the common pitfalls associated with silent films. Meticulous restoration has resulted in an image that captures impressive depth and immediacy, immersing viewers directly into the aerial battles and dramatic scenes. Instances of hand-painted yellow flames during crash sequences are vividly detailed, enhancing the dynamic battle visuals. Despite a few sporadic rough patches and the occasional missing frame—a common occurrence given the film’s age—the presentation maintains deep black levels and excellent contrast throughout. Shadow detail and texture are equally commendable; close-ups retain solid clarity even if they lean towards a slightly gauzy appearance characteristic of the era. This Blu-ray release is a testament to modern restorative technologies, delivering an enviable blend of historical fidelity and contemporary visual excellence.
Audio: 68
The Blu-ray release of "Wings" offers an exceptional auditory experience, highlighted by two distinct soundtracks. The primary track, a DTS-HD MA 5.1 re-recorded score by J.S. Zamecnik, exquisitely orchestrated by Dominik Hauser and featuring pianist Frederick Hodges, is particularly noteworthy. This DTS presentation is lauded for its clarity and spaciousness, delivering crisp and clear instrumentation across a broad dynamic range. The inclusion of sound effects by Ben Burtt further enriches the soundstage with precision and authenticity—propellers whirring, machine gun fire crackling, and artillery shells whizzing by, all flawlessly integrated into the mix. These effects are not merely supplementary; they enhance the overall cinematic experience without detracting from the period ambiance, ensuring that even purists may appreciate this modern enhancement.
In addition to the 5.1 mix, the Blu-ray includes a Dolby Digital 2.0 track featuring a pipe organ score composed and performed by Gaylord Carter. Although not as immersive as the lossless DTS track, the organ accompaniment is clean and well-balanced, offering a distinct and traditional silent film experience devoid of unnecessary embellishments. Despite lacking the additional sound effects present in the DTS track, this organ rendition still stands out for its clarity and spacious sound.
Overall, the juxtaposition of these two soundtracks—the dynamic and encompassing DTS-HD MA 5.1 track and the more straightforward DD stereo organ score—provides viewers with compelling reasons to revisit "Wings." Each track shines in its own right, enhancing the film's legacy with contemporary audio technology while remaining faithful to its original silent film roots. This thoughtful presentation underscores the importance of quality audio in elevating the silent film genre.
Extras: 55
The Blu-ray extras of "Wings" offer a compelling and detailed look behind the scenes of this silent classic, providing rich context and technical insights into its creation and restoration. "Wings: Grandeur in the Sky" delivers a thorough retrospective on the 1920s film industry landscape, production obstacles, and critical military support. Commentary from experts and Wellman's son highlight intricate production details, from casting to authentic aerial sequences. "Restoring the Power and Beauty of Wings" provides an engaging view of the painstaking restoration process, featuring stunning before-and-after comparisons and insights into the recreation of its score and sound effects. "Dogfight!" explores the evolution of wartime flight and the significance of World War I dogfights, appealing to aviation enthusiasts.
Extras included in this disc:
- Wings: Grandeur in the Sky: In-depth retrospective on the film's production.
- Restoring the Power and Beauty of Wings: Detailed look at the restoration process.
- Dogfight!: Evolution of aerial combat during World War I.
Movie: 92
"Wings" Blu-Ray Movie Review
"Wings" (1927) stands as a timeless testament to cinematic excellence, even after nearly a century since it first soared onto the silver screen. The film remarkably delivers on its promises of action, romance, and drama, seamlessly blending these elements into a narrative that’s both engaging and emotionally rich. The storyline centers on small-town rivals Jack Powell (Charles Rogers) and David Armstrong (Richard Arlen) vying for the affection of Sylvia Lewis (Jobyna Ralston), all while navigating the perils of World War I. Their rivalry shifts from romantic contention to an unbreakable bond of friendship as they become ace aviators in the U.S. Air Force. The impressive aerial sequences are notably groundbreaking, presenting intricate dogfights and in-flight visuals that remain astonishingly coherent and authentic. These scenes elevate the film to a level of modern-day continuity and authenticity, rarely seen in silent-era productions.
Director William A. Wellman’s meticulous attention to detail is evident throughout, particularly in the juxtaposition of in-flight and on-ground action, which achieves an impressive level of spatial continuity. Performances are deftly executed within the context of silent film norms, with Rogers and Arlen bringing nuanced emotional depth to their characters. Clara Bow’s portrayal of Mary Preston is both effervescent and poignantly vulnerable, reinforcing the film’s emotional core. The supporting cast, including a brief but memorable appearance by a young Gary Cooper, further solidifies the film’s impact. "Wings" is not just about grand spectacles but delves deeply into themes of valor, friendship, and the irreversible impacts of war, creating a well-rounded narrative that resonates even today.
The Blu-Ray restoration is a visual and auditory triumph. Utilizing a 1080p/AVC MPEG-4 video codec and defaulting to a DTS-HD Master Audio orchestral track (with an optional Dolby Digital 2.0 organ track for purists), this edition invites both new and returning audiences into its world with pristine clarity and sound. The synchronized orchestral score heightens each scene's emotional resonance, serving as an integral component that complements the film’s vibrant narrative structure. Overall, "Wings" successfully bridges its historical roots with contemporary viewing standards, offering an immersive experience that validates its foundational status in cinematic history.
Total: 68
The Blu-ray edition of "Wings" is a remarkable testament to the art of film restoration and a fitting tribute to the winner of the first Best Picture Academy Award. Paramount's efforts have resulted in an impressive 4:3 high-definition transfer that maintains the original film grain while enhancing clarity and detail, particularly notable in close-up shots and foreground elements. The digital recreation of tints and handschiegel effects shines brilliantly without any evident digital manipulation, preserving the film’s authenticity. The slight wear and tear remain, but do not detract from the viewing experience.
Two distinct soundtracks underscore the dual aspects of this cinematic treasure: a 5.1 DTS-HD Master audio re-recorded score by J.S. Zamecnik featuring pianist Frederick Hodges, and a DD stereo pipe organ score performed by Gaylord Carter. Both deliver immersive experiences, with the piano score additionally boasting sound effects from Ben Burtt that enhance the film's dynamic surroundings. Language support includes English intertitles and subtitles in French, Spanish, and Portuguese, ensuring accessibility for a wider audience.
Supplementary featurettes enrich the historical context of "Wings," including a 36-minute making-of documentary ("Wings: Grandeur in the Air"), a 15-minute restoration feature ("Restoring the Power and Beauty of Wings"), and a 13-minute exploration of World War I aerial combat recreation ("Dogfight!"). Although more extras would be appreciated given the film's historical significance, what is included provides valuable insight into its production and restoration journey.
Compare 1927's "Wings" to 2001's "Pearl Harbor"; there's a similarity in plot and action that's unmistakable. This comparison facilitates an eye-opening look into the evolution of cinematic craftsmanship. Despite technological advancements in visuals and sound, "Wings" demonstrates that compelling storytelling and character engagement remain the heart of cinematic success. Paramount’s meticulous restoration is a must-have for cinephiles, collectors, and casual viewers alike, making "Wings" very highly recommended.
Blu-ray.com review by Martin LiebmanRead review here
Video: 90
A visible grain structure retains, and the cumulative result is a veritable time machine that takes audiences back decades thanks to the horsepower of today's best restorative and projection video technology....
Audio: 90
The effects, however, aren't so unnatural that they pull the audience out of the movie; there's an authenticity to the experience that benefits the movie and each plays seamlessly in the greater context....
Extras: 50
Wings: Grandeur in the Sky (1080p, 25:56): A strong retrospective feature that examines the cinematic landscape of the 1920s, the early history of the project, the difficulties in making an aerial combat...
Movie: 90
It's a movie that encapsulates all that's good in the medium, and shows that it's the raw elemental ingredients and the superficially simplest yet most inwardly complex of human emotions that speak to...
Total: 80
The technology has certainly evolved greatly, but in a way, the eye candy visuals of today -- not to mention basics like enhanced sound and color -- don't necessarily make a movie "better" because both...
The Digital Bits review by Barrie MaxwellRead review here
Video: 85
Audio: 85
One caveat though, the piano score also includes sound effects (gunfire, explosions, airplane engine noise, etc.) by Ben Burtt that have been quite seamlessly integrated into the film, and result in some...
Extras: 85
Movie: 95
Wings is a stunning achievement - a film that is dramatically honest, at times thrilling in its depiction of the World War I air war, poignant in its portrayal of the toll of war on both soldiers and family,...
Total: 88
One caveat though, the piano score also includes sound effects (gunfire, explosions, airplane engine noise, etc.) by Ben Burtt that have been quite seamlessly integrated into the film, and result in some...
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 80
Any print defects have been erased, and the hand-painted bursts of yellow flames used to enhance fiery crashes and heated dogfights are startlingly distinct, adding an extra layer of style and a flash...
Audio: 80
The music score, which incorporates many period and classical melodies, fills the room with superior fidelity and an exceptional clarity of tone as it perfectly complements light-hearted, dramatic, and...
Extras: 40
Those involved in the process cite the challenges they faced in reviving 'Wings,' how they resisted the temptation to "over-clean" the film, how the color was digitally replicated and matched from notations...
Movie: 100
The more things change, the more they remain the same, and though the film industry has come a long way since 'Wings' dazzled audiences with spectacular aerial sequences and ambitious battle scenes, here...
Total: 80
This World War I tale of courage, friendship, romance, and devastation, even after 85 years, still possesses the power to dazzle our senses and wring a potent emotional response, and Paramount's glorious...
Director: William A. Wellman, Harry d'Abbadie d'Arrast
Actors: Clara Bow, Charles 'Buddy' Rogers, Richard Arlen
PlotSet against the backdrop of World War I, the story revolves around two young men, Jack Powell and David Armstrong, who come from the same small town but are vying for the affection of the same woman, Sylvia Lewis. While Sylvia loves David, Jack mistakenly believes she loves him. As the war intensifies, both Jack and David enlist as fighter pilots. Through rigorous training and the perilous nature of aerial combat, the two men, initially rivals, form a strong bond of friendship. Their mutual acquaintance Mary Preston, who secretly harbors feelings for Jack, also plays a significant role in their journey, serving as an ambulance driver on the front lines.
As Jack and David face the brutal realities of war, their skills as pilots are put to the ultimate test. They experience the chaos and camaraderie of battle, authoring daring dogfights that illustrate the harrowing conditions of aerial warfare. Amidst the thick of combat, their friendship is tested and deepened, even as they confront their own personal struggles and the looming specter of death. Amidst the chaos, the characters navigate love, loyalty, and the extraordinary demands of their turbulent world.
Writers: John Monk Saunders, Hope Loring, Louis D. Lighton
Release Date: 05 Jan 1929
Runtime: 144 min
Rating: PG-13
Country: United States
Language: English