The Meaning of Life 4K Ultra HD Blu-ray Review
Score: 77
from 4 reviewers
Review Date:
Monty Python's film & Blu-rays: hilariously upgraded, a mix of genius and flaws, now in 4K glory.
Disc Release Date
True 4K
HDR10
DTS:X
DTS-HD MA
Video: 85
The latest 4K restoration of 'The Meaning of Life' impresses with sharper details, richer colors, and a faithful filmic look, despite inherent imperfections.
Audio: 70
The new DTS:X soundtrack enriches the audio experience with clear, natural dialogue and music, maintaining good clarity and immersion without radically transforming the original design.
Extra: 78
Despite no new extras, this release faithfully ports 2013's content to 4K, featuring a 60-min reunion, behind-the-scenes looks, and nostalgic Python humor.
Movie: 76
Monty Python's The Meaning of Life," a patchwork of their finest and dullest moments, dazzles in UHD despite its uneven ride, marking the end of an era for the iconic comedy troupe.
Video: 85
The Ultra HD Blu-ray release of Monty Python’s The Meaning of Life marks a significant milestone in the history of this iconic film's home video presentation. Shot on 35mm film using Arriflex 35 BI3 and BL3 cameras, and undergoing a new 4K restoration from the original negatives, this edition benefits from a native 3840 x 2160p resolution, HDR10 grading for enhanced dynamic range, and is encoded with the HEVC (H.265) codec. The meticulous restoration work has addressed previous issues such as smeary grain and edge enhancement which plagued earlier releases. Furthermore, the optical work and soft focus shots intrinsic to the film's production have been treated with respect to preserve its original aesthetic, balancing sharpness and detail with the filmic texture of its grain structure. The overall video presentation is direct and focused on delivering an organic, filmic experience that leverages the latest in home cinema technology.
The HDR color grading elevates the visual experience by introducing a richer, more nuanced color palette that breathes new life into the film's diverse and dynamic scenes. From the vibrant neon hues in the final song and dance number to the more tempered flesh tones and naturalistic environments, colors are presented with greater depth and realism. Despite the challenges inherent in the source material, including optical effects and moments of soft focus, this release showcases an impressive balance between clarity and cinematic texture. Fans will appreciate the nuanced improvements in facial details, textures of clothing, and environmental details that were not as discernible in previous versions. The grain structure remains faithful to the film’s original look, ensuring an authentic viewing experience.
Universally praised for its clean and stable presentation, this Ultra HD release of The Meaning of Life significantly outperforms its predecessors in both visual fidelity and viewer immersion. This is thanks to both the advanced restoration techniques and modern encoding strategies that maximize bit rates for optimal quality across the entirety of the film. The meticulous attention to removing print damage while preserving the film's original textures offers viewers a superior picture quality that celebrates Monty Python's unique blend of humor and visual storytelling. The use of HDR10, despite the lack of Dolby Vision, contributes to richer colors, deeper blacks, and improved contrast, making this version a must-have for fans and cinephiles alike who seek the definitive home video edition of this classic film.
Audio: 70
In the audio presentation of "The Meaning of Life" 4K UHD Blu-ray, the introduction of a new DTS:X soundtrack largely enhances the viewing experience without dramatically reinventing the original audio scheme. This upgrade maintains the essence of the classic, ensuring that voices remain crisp and natural, notably anchored to the front but now enriched with greater depth through strategic utilization of surround and overhead channels. Despite its attempts to elevate the soundscape, particularly in musical sequences where there is a noticeable lushness and a well-executed balance between vocals and instruments, the implementation does not fully exploit the potential of a fully immersive 3D audio experience. Subtitles are available in an impressive variety of twelve languages, catering to a broad international audience.
Technical specifics reveal that this reimagined audio experience benefits notably from added clarity and slightly expanded spatial dynamics, albeit within the confines of the film's original sound design. Noteworthy is the fidelity in musical numbers and select sound effects, where enhanced bass and thoughtful channel usage contribute to a more enveloping atmosphere. Occasionally, however, new foley effects and overdubs appear incongruous with the vintage texture of the film, breaking the audio-visual congruity. The dialogues, crucial to the comedic impact, stay predominantly clear and are effectively separated from the background score and ambient noises, affirming the overall quality of this remixed track.
Despite its strengths, especially in musical richness and dialogue clarity, the DTS:X mix occasionally feels underused, hinting at missed opportunities for a truly dynamic soundscape that could further leverage channel movement and overhead audio. The track does indeed offer an improvement over its predecessor by engaging more channels to enliven the mix, yet it stops short of delivering a fully multi-dimensional sonic experience one might expect from such a contemporary format. Ultimately, while it stands as a commendable effort to breathe new life into a classic film’s auditory realm, it showcases more of an evolutionary step rather than a revolutionary transformation in audio presentation.
Extras: 78
The extra features of the 4K UHD Blu-ray edition of "The Meaning of Life" offer a comprehensive dive into the making and legacy of this Monty Python classic, albeit without introducing new material. Fans and newcomers alike will appreciate the thoroughness with which existing content from previous editions, notably the 30th Anniversary and Special Edition DVD releases, have been meticulously compiled. The highlight is undoubtedly the "The Meaning of Monty Python: 30th Anniversary Reunion," offering a poignant, humorous look back with the surviving members of Monty Python. Though some may find the absence of new extras a missed opportunity—particularly the lack of a new audio commentary by John Cleese, Michael Palin, and Eric Idle—the wealth of content, from deleted scenes and making-of documentaries to sing-alongs and a reflection on the film's music, ensures there's plenty to explore. The inclusion of both the UHD and redundant Blu-ray discs, along with a Movies Anywhere digital copy, adds value for collectors and fans of physical media, despite some features like the Director's Cut from the 2003 DVD not making the transition.
Extras included in this disc:
Audio Commentary: Featuring Terry Jones and Terry Gilliam.
Soundtrack for the Lonely: A unique listening experience.
The Meaning of Monty Python: Celebrating the 30th Anniversary with a reunion.
The Snipped Bits: A collection of deleted scenes.
The School of Life:
- The Meaning of Making 'The Meaning of Life': A behind-the-scenes look.
- Education Tips: Tips from the Python team.
- Un Film de John Cleese: A special featurette.
- Remastering a Masterpiece: Insight into the remastering process.
Show Biz:
- Song and Dance: Exploring the musical segments.
- Songs Unsung: Discussing the songs not included.
- Selling 'The Meaning of Life': The marketing aspect.
Fish:
- Virtual Reunion: The Pythons reunite.
- What Fish Think: A comedic piece on the thoughts of fish.
Sing-Along Mode: For an interactive experience with the film's songs.
Movie: 76
Monty Python’s The Meaning of Life delivers a 4K UHD Blu-ray presentation that is as eclectic and chaotic as the film itself. Universal has upgraded the 1983 classic to a stunning 2160p/HDR video that enhances the visual comedy and satirical edge for which the Pythons are renowned. Accompanied by a new DTS:X audio track, the film’s iconic sketches, from the grandiose musical numbers to the infamous Mr. Creosote scene, are given a level of sound quality that immerses the viewer right into the Python team’s bizarrely humorous world. However, it's notable that this release lacks any new special features, relying instead on the legacy supplements provided on both the UHD and included Blu-ray disc, which remains unchanged from the dated 2013 VC-1 disc version.
The film itself, released in 1983 as Monty Python's final cinematic outing together before Graham Chapman's sad passing, represents both the height of their collective genius and the depths of their more divisive content. It returns to their Flying Circus roots with a series of loosely connected sketches that tackle everything from modern medicine to British Imperialism with their signature blend of incisive wit and irreverence. Despite its uneven pacing – starting strong with wildly amusing skits before delving into less cohesive and more controversial segments – the film showcases Monty Python’s ability to combine insightful critique with outrageous humour.
While not without its criticisms for a lack of cohesive narrative and some sketches that miss the mark, The Meaning of Life's place in the Monty Python canon cannot be understated. Its impressive start includes the expanded 'The Crimson Permanent Assurance' short and maintains sporadic brilliance with sketches like Mr. Creosote and "Every Sperm is Sacred," highlighting Python’s unique comedic voice. This 4K UHD presentation breathes new life into these moments, ensuring they resonate as powerfully today as they did upon the film's original release. Though this edition does not surpass earlier films in terms of supplemental material, its technical upgrades make it a must-own for fans and collectors alike, serving as a bittersweet reminder of Monty Python's unparalleled contribution to comedy.
Total: 77
Monty Python's "The Meaning of Life" has long been lauded for its eclectic mix of irreverently humorous sketches, and its transition to 4K UHD Blu-ray by Universal is commendable. The new 2160p/HDR video presentation is striking, providing a significant visual improvement over the older Blu-ray editions. This upgrade beautifully enhances the film's detailed imagery, making the Python team's final cinematic endeavor pop with vibrancy on screen. Although the transition to a new DTS:X audio track may not represent as dramatic an enhancement as the video upgrade does, it nonetheless offers a more immersive listening experience over its previous 5.1 surround sound iteration. While the set doesn't introduce any new extras—opting instead to port over previously released materials—it ensures fans have access to a comprehensive collection of bonus content, all now conveniently located on the UHD disc.
The film itself, with its dizzying array of sketches that range from the sublimely hilarious to the outright bizarre, demonstrates the Monty Python crew's unparalleled knack for comedy. Now nearly four decades past its original release, its satirical stabs at life's grand absurdities haven't lost their edge, resonating well with both longstanding fans and newcomers alike. The synthesis of movie and medium here is particularly noteworthy; despite no additions in terms of extras or the film's original Dolby Stereo soundtrack, the sheer quality of this 4K presentation makes it the go-to version for anyone wishing to experience the film in the highest fidelity possible.
In conclusion, Universal's foray into upgrading Monty Python’s "The Meaning of Life" to 4K UHD Blu-ray is a resounding success, albeit a cautious investment for those wary of its premium price. For avid enthusiasts of the Python legacy, this edition serves as an indispensable addition to their collection, providing both an aural and visual feast that newly illuminates the film’s riotous critique of human nature and society. As such, it stands as a must-have for purveyors of classic comedy seeking to revel in the Pythons’ unmatched wit and creativity with the added splendor brought forth by modern technology.
avforums review by Mark CostelloRead review here
Video: 80
But after previous releases struggled with the more filmic elements of the image, this new 4K disc seems to be a course correction of sorts for the film....
Audio: 70
Again, the dialogue sits clearly in the mix of the sound effects and score and while never having a huge array of set pieces that need a massive amount of aural support, the mix is more than capable....
Extras: 70
However there are also some fantastic peaks behind the movie making curtain in the Meaning of….. and both the featurettes on the songs....
Movie: 70
Coupled with the shackles being removed almost completely from the studio financing it (legend has it, funding was approved off the back of a single poem read to executives, with no script being shown...
Total: 70
a worthy upgrade for fans Universal’s new 4K disc not only corrects some of the digital issues found on previous releases to deliver a much more filmic and natural image, but it even bestows the film with...
Blu-ray.com review by Martin LiebmanRead review here
Video: 90
The general palette has a more lifelike realism about it, with deeper shades all around yet more precise color accuracy to offer superior primaries and abundantly rich secondaries....
Audio: 70
Rather, this is the core audio experience from the previous disc with a mild sense of added fullness but certainly nothing that redefines the audio essentials....
Extras: 80
The Meaning of Monty Python: 30th Anniversary Reunion 2003 Prologue by Eric Idle The Snipped Bits: Included are Martin Luther, An Expert, The Cheese Lady, Randy in the Jungle, The Hendys, Mr. Creosote...
Movie: 70
The legacy supplements are included on both the UHD disc and the bundled Blu-ray, which is identical to the dated 2013 VC-1 disc....
Total: 80
The new audio track is less the major upgrade and is more a subtle refinement of the old 5.1 track....
The Digital Bits review by Tim SalmonsRead review here
Video: 95
The Meaning of Life has never looked particularly good on home video, only gradually improving with each new release, particularly because of its limitations in terms of the number of opticals, soft focus...
Audio: 85
It doesn’t offer much in terms of overhead spread, but there’s wonderful staging and panning all around, lending fine support to sound effects and the various musical numbers with deep, rumbling bass—especially...
Extras: 90
This includes the previous audio commentary with Terry Gilliam and the late Terry Jones, all of the deleted scenes (though Terry Jones’ commentary on two of those scenes is not optional), the excellent...
Movie: 90
Monty Python’s The Meaning of Life was released in 1983 and was the last film that all of the original members of the comedy troupe were a part of before the unfortunate passing of Graham Chapman several...
Total: 90
Over the years since its original release, the appreciation for Monty Python’s The Meaning of Life has gradually increased, many recognizing it as a sloppy but much more mature and interesting work than...
High-Def Digest review by Matthew HartmanRead review here
Video: 90
Where the previous Blu-ray was pretty good, it still had plenty of room for improvement and Universal delivers a new transfer that easily outpaces past disc releases....
Audio: 70
As I said at the outset, this is a stronger track overall because all of the channels are working whereas the old 5.1 mix was pretty much a static front/center affair without much of any side or rear presence...
Extras: 80
For a more thorough breakdown of the bonus features, check out our original 2013 Blu-ray review Audio Commentary featuring Terry Hones andvTerry Gilliam Soundtrack for the Lonely The Meaning of Monty Python:...
Movie: 80
The bits that make up the whole of this hilarious venture are scarcely related and can differ greatly from one piece to the next, but they’re amazingly funny!...
Total: 80
While no new bonus features were included, it’s nice to see Universal excavate the corpses of past releases and haul up all of those existing aged bonus bits and slap them onto this new 4K disc....
Director: Terry Jones
Actors: John Cleese, Terry Gilliam, Eric Idle
PlotThe film is a series of comedic sketches, loosely structured around the stages of human life, examining its significance and absurdities. It opens with a short segment called "The Crimson Permanent Assurance," where elderly office workers rebel against their corporate oppressors, turning their building into a pirate ship and setting off on an adventure. This serves as a surreal preface before the main narrative begins.
The opening scene after "The Crimson Permanent Assurance" sets the tone for a provocative and irreverent exploration of the human condition, with a birth segment depicting the impersonal, industrial nature of a hospital delivery room. The film proceeds to ruminate on various stages of life, including childhood and education, where pupils are humorously subjected to eccentric teachers and bizarre curriculum. As the film progresses, it tackles themes such as war, with soldiers being lectured on the battlefield about proper etiquette, and religion, where congregants witness surprising interpretations of faith. The storyline is interspersed with musical numbers that satirize the topics at hand, blending comedy with commentary.
Writers: Graham Chapman, John Cleese, Terry Gilliam
Release Date: 31 Mar 1983
Runtime: 107 min
Rating: R
Country: United Kingdom
Language: English