Miracle on 34th Street Blu-ray Review

The Blu-ray video presentation of "Miracle on 34th Street" offers an admirable yet not groundbreaking visual experience with its 1080p/AVC-encoded transfer. The original black-and-white cinematography remains intact, free from any colorization, which will please traditionalists. The picture exhibits an overall clean look due to significant dirt removal, eliminating the previously prevalent flecks, specks, and scratches seen on past DVD releases. While the contrast has been balanced to appear more natural, it may appear somewhat flat to discerning viewers. The grayscale variance is weaker compared to DVDs, but displays a more even gradation, despite the whites leaning towards lighter grays and the occasional shadow detail crush.

The transfer boasts an appreciable enhancement in sharpness over earlier DVDs, with close-ups appearing more precise and detail-oriented. The light, consistent grain structure imparts authentic texture without being overwhelming. While black levels don't achieve the rich depth often expected in modern transfers, they are robust enough to avoid looking washed out, complemented by well-shaded grays and controlled whites. Furthermore, no digital noise reduction (DNR) has been applied, and the print shows minimal signs of damage, making this a commendable job by Fox. Minor occurrences of telecine wobble and occasional contrast flicker are present but are not significant enough to detract from the viewing experience.

In essence, this Blu-ray transfer is a solid upgrade from previous DVD versions, although it may not represent a monumental leap forward. Collectors and purists will appreciate the refined presentation and cleaner image quality achieved in this release. However, casual viewers might find the differences insufficient to justify the upgrade, especially given the absence of a colorized version of the film in this edition.

The audio presentation of "Miracle on 34th Street" on Blu-ray has been expertly expanded to a DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 surround track, which comfortably outperforms both the original monaural and the included 2.0 Dolby Digital tracks. A transformation to a multi-channel mix breathes new life into this classic film, adding inviting ambient sounds such as department store chatter, machinery in the mail sorting plant, and occasional sound effects like a buzzing doorbell. This surrounds blend, although subtle and without the high fidelity of modern production, significantly enriches the viewing experience by making it more immersive.

The clarity of dialogue is markedly improved from the slightly muffled and compressed character of the 2.0 mix, ensuring that all vocal expressions are distinctly articulated. Cyril J. Mockridge's iconic score benefits from excellent fidelity and tonal depth, though some high-end elements, like horns and strings, may occasionally seem brash. Despite some minor hissing during quiet scenes and a somewhat weak bass presence, the overall dynamic range remains satisfactory. The result is a track that not only maintains its integrity free of pops or distortions but also manages to punch up isolated musical accents while preserving traditionalist fans' option with the original mono track.

In summary, while the DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 mix might not provide a significantly aggressive or transformative multi-channel experience, it is unquestionably cleaner and more involving. It respectfully enhances the timeless charm of "Miracle on 34th Street" without radically altering its original audio landscape.

The Blu-ray release of "Miracle on 34th Street" offers a robust selection of extras that, while varied in depth and engagement, collectively provide valuable insights into the film's production and legacy. The commentary by Maureen O'Hara is a mixed experience, delivering charming anecdotes and behind-the-scenes tales, but is marred by long silences. The AMC Backstory featurette is particularly enlightening, covering the film's inception, production challenges, and novel marketing strategies. Fans of classic Hollywood will appreciate the Fox Movietone News clip from the 1947 Academy Awards and the succinct yet fascinating Promotional Short. However, the Macy's Thanksgiving Day Parade featurette repeats much of the documentary material with added focus on the parade scenes. The Poster Gallery provides a visually engaging presentation of the film’s marketing history. Each extra is thoughtfully included, with most content preserved in standard definition for authenticity.

Extras included in this disc:

• Commentary by Maureen O'Hara: Personal stories and reminiscences from actress Maureen O'Hara.
• AMC Backstory: Miracle on 34th Street: Documentary on the film’s conception, production, and marketing challenges.
• Macy's Thanksgiving Day Parade: Floating in History: Featurette focusing on the Macy's parade scenes in the film.
• Fox Movietone News: Hollywood Spotlight: Archival news brief from the 1947 Academy Awards.
• Poster Gallery: Self-playing gallery showcasing nine posters for the film.
• Promotional Short: A marketing teaser from Fox avoiding direct mention of the film's holiday theme.

"Miracle on 34th Street," originally released in 1947, retains its charm and relevance, even finding new appreciation on Blu-ray. This disc exclusively features the black-and-white version, contrary to some misleading packaging that suggests a colorized edition. Fans of the original will be pleased with this release, ensuring the film's timeless cinematography and inherent charm remain intact. The story celebrates faith and the spirit of giving, juxtaposed against the commercialism of the holiday season. Maureen O'Hara plays Doris Walker, a pragmatic single mother who organizes Macy's Thanksgiving Day Parade. When a mysterious old man named Kris Kringle, portrayed by Edmund Gwenn, steps in to play Santa Claus, he claims to be the real deal, challenging Doris and her daughter Susan's rationalist views.

Gwenn's performance as Kris Kringle is truly exceptional, earning him a well-deserved Academy Award. His twinkle-eyed charisma perfectly embodies the cinematic essence of Santa Claus, making it easy for viewers to believe in his character. Natalie Wood, as Susan, delivers a convincingly skeptical yet heartwarming portrayal, forming an endearing bond with Gwenn's Kringle. John Payne supports admirably as Fred Gailey, the lawyer who defends Kringle’s sanity in court. The screenplay by George Seaton weaves together diverse themes including retail rivalry, holiday commercialism, and the importance of faith and imagination.

The film deftly balances whimsy with real-world issues, showcasing beautifully crafted moments that evoke both laughter and tears. Highlights include Kris Kringle singing with a Dutch orphan and the climactic courtroom scenes which capture the essence of holiday triumph and belief. Despite its age, "Miracle on 34th Street" aligns well with contemporary societal norms, portraying relatable characters and situations. Its genuine sentiment and heart make it an enduring classic worthy of annual viewing, reminding audiences young and old of the true spirit of Christmas.

The Blu-ray release of "Miracle on 34th Street" offers viewers the opportunity to experience this enduring holiday classic in the best quality yet available. The transfer delivers a notable improvement in both picture and sound quality over previous DVD versions, although it does not achieve a level of pristine perfection. The black and white presentation (the only version included) retains the film's original charm and enhances its nostalgic appeal.

The audio quality on this Blu-ray is commendable and provides a more immersive experience compared to earlier releases. While some might miss the colorized version, the original monochrome faithfully preserves the movie's authentic feel. The narrative, characterized by its bright outlook, inspired script, and first-rate performances, remains impactful and engaging, ensuring that "Miracle on 34th Street" continues to be a perennial favorite.

In conclusion, this Blu-ray release only contains the original black and white version of the film, which is likely the one most fans will prefer. "Miracle on 34th Street" shines as a bonafide holiday classic, deserving a spot in every film lover's collection. Its improved audiovisual quality makes it a worthwhile addition, and without a doubt, this enduring treasure comes highly recommended.