Gold Blu-ray Review
Oro
Score: 41
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
Despite its mildly disappointing picture quality and lack of extras, 'Gold' is a compelling sci-fi drama on progress versus greed, with strong design elements.
Disc Release Date
Video: 47
The Blu-ray presentation of 'Gold' offers a minor improvement over its previous DVD release, with a 1080p/AVC MPEG-4 encode. However, the transfer struggles with age-related artifacts like scratches, white specks, and discoloration, affecting black levels and overall clarity. Despite its flaws, it represents the best available version but is in dire need of full restoration.
Audio: 47
The 2.0 LPCM and uncompressed PCM mono sound mixes exhibit age-related hissing, pops, and limited dynamics, lacking bass and precise dialogue clarity; yet they offer some presence and warmth, with certain sound effects like the hum of the gold machine standing out.
Extra: 0
This Blu-ray of 'Gold' is a bare-bones release with no supplementary material included.
Movie: 76
"Gold" (1934) offers a striking blend of melodrama and visual elements, critiquing greed and scientific misuse through the tale of a machine that turns lead into gold, with strong performances despite dated aspects. The Blu-ray by Kino Classics features excellent special effects, solid production design, and lasting genre appeal.
Video: 47
The Blu-ray release of "Gold" presents a mixed bag in terms of its video quality, reflecting its age and the limitations of the available source material. The AVC encoded image (1.33:1 aspect ratio) sees no extensive restoration, leading to noticeable wear and tear throughout the film. Viewers will encounter scratches, skipped frames, and fluctuating flicker which can detract from the immersion. Despite these issues, detail retrieval remains commendably strong, particularly in close-ups where facial textures and set designs achieve a level of clarity that surpasses previous DVD editions.
However, the condition of the source content results in consistent white specks, dirt, and occasional hairs appearing on-screen. Instances of scratches and vertical lines are quite noticeable, and there's a minimal telecine judder accompanied by mild discoloration — both indicative of the aged elements rather than faults in the transfer process. Contrast levels vary, with highlights sometimes blooming and fading, affecting the finer details in close-up shots. Blacks are generally stable but lack the depth required for truly rich images, making shadow delineation weak.
Overall definition and clarity bounce between sharp and soft/blurry moments, enveloped in a natural grain that adds a layer of authenticity to the historic film. While contrast can run hot at times, resulting in lackluster whites, the video presentation is arguably the best available given the current state of preservation. That said, "Gold" desperately needs a complete restoration to maximize its visual potential.
Audio: 47
The 2.0 LPCM sound mix on the "Gold" Blu-ray presents distinct age-related challenges, manifesting as continuous hiss and occasional pops. Dialogue remains largely intelligible and adequately prioritized, but it lacks precision and clarity, occasionally suffering from overlapping background noise. Emotional cues within the dialogue are clear, making it possible to follow character interactions effectively despite some auditory imperfections. The score, while somewhat deficient in definition, conveys its intended emotional undertones. Notable sound effects, such as the gold machine’s hum, do manage to stand out and add depth to the audio landscape.
The uncompressed PCM mono soundtrack offers an improvement over earlier home video editions but retains some notable shortcomings. Background hissing, mild noise, popping, and cracking are persistent, particularly distracting during dialogue-heavy scenes often found in sci-fi dramas like this. Although vocals hold a central focus, inconsistencies in decibel levels can make them occasionally hard to understand. The track is also notably lacking in bass presence, impacting both the musical score and overall audio dynamics, which feel flat and confined. Acoustical details, such as the underwater atomic reactor explosion, tend to clip, but the audio benefits from decent imaging that provides a warmer sense of presence. While these high-resolution audio elements show areas for admiration, they also underscore the limitations inherent in the source material and its historical context.
Extras:
The Blu Ray of "Gold" disappoints with its lack of supplementary content, offering no additional material beyond the primary feature. This bare-bones release fails to enrich the viewer's experience with insights or behind-the-scenes content typically expected by enthusiasts. The absence of extras dims the appeal for those who appreciate comprehensive, well-rounded releases. The technical presentation, while important, cannot compensate for the complete lack of added value through supplemental features.
Extras included in this disc:
- None
Movie: 76
Karl Hartl's 1934 film "Gold" is an intriguing exploration of human ambition set within the framework of science fiction, critiquing greed and the misuse of scientific breakthroughs. The narrative revolves around Werner Holk, portrayed by the competent Hans Albers, who finds himself embroiled in a complex scheme involving the creation of a machine that purportedly transforms lead into gold. This premise, a blend of ancient alchemical desires and modern scientific aspirations, serves as fertile ground for a drama rife with corporate machinations, unrequited love, and existential conflicts. Despite its occasional melodramatic slackness, Hartl's direction delivers periodic moments of clarity, supported by fine performances that convey the emotional weight of longing and despair effectively.
The film’s technical craftsmanship is notable, particularly its special effects and production design, which remain impressive even by today's standards. "Gold" strategically employs striking visual elements that contribute to creating an atmospheric narrative imbued with tension and intrigue. While Hans Albers' role as Holk initially seems a bit dated due to his age, his portrayal of a tormented engineer driven by vengeance lends depth to the character. Equally intriguing is Brigitte Helm's portrayal of Florence, the daughter of a British industrialist, whose spoiled exterior belies a deeply lonely and conflicted individual. Helm’s nuanced performance brings tragic gravitas to the character, highlighting the cold indifference of the world she inhabits.
A historical context further enriches the film, as "Gold" was produced during Nazi Germany’s era under Joseph Goebbels' propaganda ministry. Despite possible ideological influences, the film's core narrative wrestles with the profound issues of scientific progress versus corporate greed and the potential for economic catastrophe born from such convergence. In summary, "Gold" presents an extraordinary piece of cinema deserving recognition for its audacious themes and technical prowess.
Total: 41
Karl Hartl's German sci-fi drama, "Gold," intertwines ancient alchemical desires with the emerging reality of modern-day science, setting up a compelling conflict between scientific progress and corporate greed. The narrative tracks scientists who believe they've uncovered the secret to transmuting lead into gold, bringing to the screen intense themes of economic collapse and the dangers of unchecked ambition. The film's visual standout is undeniably the gold machine—a striking and elaborate design element that not only commands screen time but also serves as a powerful symbol of the movie's core themes. Noteworthy is that footage of this machine was later repurposed for the 1953 feature "The Magnetic Monster," highlighting its enduring visual impact.
The Blu-ray transfer of "Gold" presents a mostly adequate viewing experience. The picture quality, while not exemplary, is serviceable, maintaining the film's vintage aesthetic without considerable enhancement. The audio quality, conversely, offers a modestly superior experience, capturing the film's dialog and sound effects with greater fidelity. However, the release is notably bare-bones, lacking any supplemental materials which might have provided valuable context or analysis for this classic work. As such, this release may appeal primarily to dedicated genre enthusiasts and cinephiles familiar with the historical significance of the film.
In conclusion, "Gold" stands out as a historical artifact from the era of Nazi Germany, combining elements of science fiction with poignant social commentary. The film adeptly addresses real-world issues such as class disparity and the perils of industrial ambition. Despite its middling Blu-ray presentation, "Gold" remains a significant piece for collectors and fans of classic sci-fi, offering a rich blend of thematic depth and visual ingenuity.
Blu-ray.com review by Brian OrndorfRead review here
Video: 80
Detail is surprisingly strong, capturing expressive performances largely showcased in close-up, exploring facial textures with clarity, and set design achievements are also open for inspection when focus...
Audio: 60
However, dialogue exchanges aren't completely overwhelmed, finding dramatics relatively secure, just not precise....
Extras: 0
...
Movie: 80
"Gold" is broadly defined but competently managed by Hartl, who blends striking visual elements with melodrama, creating a somewhat slack but effective offering of entertainment that hopes to rattle moviegoer...
Total: 60
The big draw of the film is the gold machine, which emerges as a major visual in a picture that's generally strong with design elements (footage of the machine was recycled for use in 1953's "The Magnetic...
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 40
Contrast sometimes runs a bit hot, blooming the highlights and fading much of the image, especially ruining the finer details in the faces of the cast, but other times, whites appear lackluster and dull,...
Audio: 60
The hissing is most distracting when characters talk, which is a lot, especially for sci-fi drama such as this, and although vocals are well-prioritized in the center, they are not always intelligible...
Extras: 0
...
Movie: 80
At first, the plot may not seem worth much interest, especially for a two-hour early talkie that even during its own time was considered too lengthy, but the filmmakers complicate the maddened pursuit...
Total: 40
Made during the reign of Nazi Germany, at the heart of Karl Hartl's classic sci-fi drama is a remarkable tale on scientific progress versus corporate greed, the sobering, looming fear of economic collapse...
Director: Karl Hartl
Actors: Hans Albers, Friedrich Kayßler, Brigitte Helm
PlotScientist Werner Holk is devastated when his pioneering experiment to transmute lead into gold is sabotaged, resulting in the death of his mentor, Professor Achenbach. Driven by revenge and a desire to continue his research, Holk infiltrates the laboratory of a rival scientist, who is backed by an unscrupulous British industrialist intent on exploiting the alchemical breakthrough for immense profit. As Holk navigates the dangerous waters of duplicity and greed, he must gather evidence of the rival's involvement in the sabotage and unmask their true intentions.
Holk forms an unexpected alliance with the industrialist's conflicted daughter, Florence. She is torn between her loyalty to her father and her growing admiration for Holk's integrity and dedication to scientific advancement. Together, they uncover a web of industrial espionage and moral compromise that threatens to engulf them both. As tensions rise and the stakes become deadly, Holk faces a critical decision: pursue his scientific dreams at any cost or abandon his quest to ensure justice is served.
Writers: Rolf E. Vanloo
Release Date: 21 Oct 1934
Runtime: 120 min
Rating: N/A
Country: Germany
Language: German