Being Flynn Blu-ray Review
Score: 52
from 3 reviewers
Review Date:
De Niro shines despite a clichéd script and mediocre performances; excellent video and audio quality make 'Being Flynn' worth a rental but not a purchase.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 65
Being Flynn’s Blu-ray presents a faithful 1080p/AVC-encoded transfer true to the film’s subdued, cooler palette with satisfying primary colors and lifelike skin tones. Detail is notably good in mid-level and close-up shots, capturing textures without notable compression artifacts or anomalies, despite softer wide-angle elements.
Audio: 65
Universal's DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 track for 'Being Flynn' excels in clear dialogue delivery and ambience creation, despite its restraint in surround and LFE usage. Dynamic sound effects enhance key scenes while the soundstage effectively captures the bustling city and shelter environments.
Extra: 11
The only extra, 'The Heart of Being Flynn' (HD, 6 min.), is a brief, promotional making-of featurette with interviews from De Niro, Dano, and the real Nick Flynn, mixed with plenty of film clips.
Movie: 47
Despite Robert De Niro's standout performance, 'Being Flynn' struggles with a lackluster, unfocused narrative that fails to explore its themes deeply, leaving the supporting cast underutilized and the story ultimately unconvincing. Presented with solid AV on a 50GB Blu-ray, the film's technical execution is commendable but cannot salvage the overall viewing experience.
Video: 65
The Blu Ray video presentation of "Being Flynn" is a faithful representation of the film's aesthetic, aligning with the creative intentions of director Paul Weitz and cinematographer Declan Quinn. The 1080p/AVC-encoded transfer captures the movie’s subdued color palette, dominated by drab browns, blacks, and off-whites, without losing the integrity of its visual storytelling. The overall cooler palette fits well with the narrative’s setting, and while primary colors lack intensity, they are rendered with fidelity. Complexions are handled proficiently, exhibiting lifelike textural details. Resolution is commendable, particularly in close-ups and mid-level shots revealing subtle textures in faces and objects. Wide-angle shots do present inherently softer elements but maintain average delineation. Contrast and black levels are stable, providing depth without overpowering dynamics. Notably, video anomalies and compression-related artifacts are non-existent, indicating a pristine quality encoding.
The visual details are meticulously presented, enhancing the film’s somber theme. Facial features on characters like Robert De Niro and Paul Dano are sharply defined, capturing stubble and individual hair strands with clarity. Julianne Moore’s freckles are distinctly visible, as is the detailed texture in the clothing that evolves with the characters’ journey. The Street-based attire of Jonathan shows detailed wear and tear, contributing to the authenticity of the narrative. Each rip, wrinkle, and smudge is perceptible, emphasizing the film’s grounded realism. Despite the film’s unremarkable cinematography, Being Flynn’s 1080p video presentation excels in detail and cleanliness—artifacting, banding, and other distractions are absent. Overall, while avoiding visual pyrotechnics, this Blu-Ray delivers a detailed and restrained visual experience that aligns perfectly with the story’s intent.
Audio: 65
The DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 soundtrack for "Being Flynn" is expertly crafted to support the film's somber and introspective narrative. Dialogue is rendered with impeccable clarity and prioritization, ensuring that even the most subdued lines are intelligible. Both De Niro's and Dano’s performances are given prominence in the soundscape, effectively anchoring the auditory experience. While sound effects are not the focal point, dynamic energy and aural satisfaction are achieved through careful use of the full soundstage. The low-frequency effects, though restrained, provide necessary depth and impact, particularly in scenes involving the bustling activity of the city and the chaotic environment of the homeless shelter.
Surround channels are utilized effectively to create an immersive atmosphere reminiscent of the urban setting depicted in the film. Ambient sounds, such as street noise and shelter chatter, are accurately reproduced, enhancing the realistic portrayal of these environments. The mix’s ability to balance these elements without overwhelming the central dialogue underscores its technical proficiency. Directionality and channel pans are subtle yet commendable, providing a well-rounded audio experience that matches the film's tonal restraint.
Overall, while "Being Flynn" does not boast an excessive or flashy sound design, the DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 track excels in delivering a faithful and convincing auditory presentation. The sound mix manages to capture the essence of the film’s dramatic moments and atmospheric subtleties, demonstrating a high level of craftsmanship that aligns perfectly with the movie's narrative needs.
Extras: 11
The Blu-ray extras of "Being Flynn" are underwhelming in both depth and quantity. The primary feature is a short, six-minute behind-the-scenes look titled "The Heart of Being Flynn." While this extra includes brief interviews with key members of the cast and crew, such as De Niro, Dano, and the real Nick Flynn, it remains highly promotional and offers minimal insightful content. The inclusion of clip-heavy segments from the movie and quick-hit interviews makes it feel more akin to an extended trailer than a substantial featurette. The technical capacities like My Scenes, BD-Live, and pocket BLU are useful but standard.
Extras included in this disc:
- The Heart of Being Flynn: A brief promotional making-of featurette with cast and crew interviews.
- My Scenes bookmark feature: Custom scene bookmarking.
- BD-Live enabled: Internet-based interactive features.
- pocket BLU: Mobile connectivity for enhanced viewing options.
Movie: 47
"Being Flynn" features standout performances from Robert De Niro, Paul Dano, and Julianne Moore. De Niro, portraying the deranged Jonathan Flynn, gives a compelling performance, reminding us of his prowess in dramatic roles. However, the narrative does not fully capitalize on its potent actors. Based on Nick Flynn's memoir 'Another Bullshit Night in Suck City,' the film falls short in delivering an engaging and coherent storyline. Director Paul Weitz seems disconnected from the material, resulting in a script that struggles to encapsulate the complex relationship between the father and son.
The film’s structure is marred by a lack of focus and emotional depth. Characters are underdeveloped, with Nick coming across as a passive, uninspired figure—a stark contrast to the volatile Jonathan. Dano’s portrayal of Nick fails to resonate, weighed down by a limited script that doesn't offer much for him to work with. On the other hand, De Niro's performance as a delusional and self-absorbed would-be novelist injects much-needed vitality into the film. Unfortunately, his performance often outshines the underwhelming support from the rest of the cast, including talented actors like Julianne Moore and Olivia Thirlby.
Overall, "Being Flynn" suffers from a wishy-washy narrative that lacks direction and fails to leverage the rich source material and its talented cast. While De Niro’s portrayal of Jonathan offers a glimpse of his acting brilliance, the film itself stumbles through its runtime, failing to establish a compelling and emotionally resonant narrative. The movie's technical execution and performances can’t fully compensate for its narrative shortcomings. The film remains mired in unfocused storytelling, making it difficult to connect with or care about the characters’ journeys.
Total: 52
"Being Flynn" presents a compelling yet ultimately unfulfilling cinematic experience. Despite the pedigree of its cast, particularly Robert De Niro's commendable performance, the film is mired by a script that leans heavily into clichés surrounding family struggles and addiction. Director Paul Weitz's adaptation fails to transcend these familiar themes, resulting in a narrative that feels predictable and lackluster. Although De Niro's portrayal breathes some life into the film, it is not enough to compensate for the shortcomings in the screenplay and the performances of his co-stars.
Universal's Blu-ray release of "Being Flynn" offers a technical presentation that is far superior to the film it houses. The video transfer is pristine, capturing every nuance of the visual storytelling with remarkable clarity. The DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 surround track is robust and enveloping, providing an immersive audio experience that enhances the overall viewing. These technical strengths are highlights of this Blu-ray edition, demonstrating the commitment to high-quality home entertainment.
In conclusion, while "Being Flynn" might not meet the high expectations set by its thematic potential and cast, it does deliver on the technical front. The Blu-ray is an excellent showcase of high-definition video and superior sound quality, making it a worthwhile rental for those interested in a technically proficient presentation. However, due to its narrative and character shortcomings, it may not warrant a place in your permanent collection.
Blu-ray.com review by Kenneth BrownRead review here
Video: 80
Primaries lack punch as well, crush and poor delineation are factors, and contrast is a bit dim, but, again, every degree of faithfulness goes a long way....
Audio: 80
The LFE channel and rear speakers are undeniably restrained, guarded even, but Jonathan's antics in the homeless shelter, Nick's descent into drug addiction, and other choice scenes give each channel the...
Extras: 10
The only extra to be had is "The Heart of Being Flynn" (HD, 6 minutes), a much too short behind-the-scenes EPK that features little more than quick-hit interviews with key members of the cast and crew....
Movie: 50
Which brings us back to Weitz, who doesn't quite know what he wants to do with "Another Bullshit Night in Suck City," other than showcase two eccentrics -- one downtrodden and unsure, one outspoken and...
Total: 60
With a spot on video transfer and a solid DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 surround track, Being Flynn is at least worth renting, if only to see how wide the gap between De Niro and Dano extends....
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 80
It's a down-to-earth drama so there isn't much in the way of any visual pyrotechnics that are going to wow the eyeballs, but the picture presented looks great considering the subdued nature of the movie....
Audio: 80
It lacks any sort of bells and whistles, but that's because the movie is much more focused on the dialogue between the characters, so it's nice to know that the dialogue is clear....
Extras: 0
Interviews with De Niro, Dano, and the real Nick Flynn are spliced in between scenes in the movie....
Movie: 40
Nick is a downtrodden youngster with little hope for the future, which is either an astute prediction, or a self-fulfilling prophecy, as when we see him in the present, he's jobless and can't hold down...
Total: 40
'Being Flynn' might be worth a look, but I really couldn't recommend people picking it up and owning it....
AVSForumRead review here
Video: 84
This video presentation offers little in the way of high Gloss, razor sharp imagery but it seems to represent the film’s elements well....
Audio: 82
This is not a film that requires heavy use of surround sound to deliver its message but it does rely on the entire soundstage for proper atmosphere and low frequency detail from time to time....
Extras: 20
The heart of Being Flynn – 6 minute featurette My scenes bookmark feature BD-Live enabled pocket BLU...
Movie: 60
His father Jonathan (De Niro), however, scrapes through life on his own terms and has not seen his son in 18 years....
Total: 62
Screen Onkyo PR-SC5508 THX Ultra 2 Audio/Video Processor Sherbourn Technologies - 7/200 Seven Channel Amplifier Oppo BDP-93 Universal Disc/3D capable Blu-ray Player (HDMI Audio/Video)...
Director: Paul Weitz
Actors: Paul Dano, Robert De Niro, Julianne Moore
PlotNick Flynn is a young writer trying to find his way in life, grappling with the memory of his late mother and the absence of his father. He begins working at a homeless shelter where, by a twist of fate, he encounters his estranged father, Jonathan, a self-proclaimed great writer who is now homeless. Jonathan's egotistical and erratic behavior clashes with Nick, leading to tumultuous interactions that force Nick to confront his own struggles with identity, family legacy, and forgiveness.
As Nick navigates the challenges of his life, he finds himself increasingly affected by his father's presence. Their strained relationship oscillates between moments of connection and conflict, illustrating the impact of Jonathan's mental instability on both their lives. Through these encounters, Nick begins to reflect on his own aspirations and choices. The story explores the themes of reconciliation and self-discovery as Nick tries to understand the man who abandoned him while also searching for his own place in the world amidst chaos and uncertainty.
Writers: Paul Weitz, Nick Flynn
Release Date: 19 Apr 2012
Runtime: 102 min
Rating: R
Country: United States
Language: English