Goodnight Mommy Blu-ray Review
Ich seh, Ich seh
Score: 65
from 5 reviewers
Review Date:
Goodnight Mommy is a slow-burn psychological horror with exemplary video and audio quality on Blu-ray, earning high praise for its depth and direction—highly recommended.
Disc Release Date
Video: 75
Goodnight Mommy's 1080p transfer presents a visually pallid yet thematically compelling look with deep blacks, sharp details, and natural grain from its 35mm source. The film features muted primary colors, earthy tones, and vivid exterior shots, maintaining excellent clarity with minimal artifacts.
Audio: 74
The German lossless DTS-HD MA 5.1 track on 'Goodnight Mommy' delivers atmospheric audio with clear dialogue, subtle surround effects, and a fair dynamic range. While not aggressive in its rear channel usage, it excels in creating an immersive environment with detailed background sounds and well-placed low-frequency effects.
Extra: 24
The sole Blu-ray supplement, 'A Conversation with Filmmakers Veronika Franz & Severin Fiala' (1080p, 12:48), offers an insightful discussion on the film's inspirations, story evolution, and audience impact, albeit not heavy on film specifics.
Movie: 83
"Goodnight Mommy" is a masterclass in minimalist horror and psychological tension, eschewing cheap scares for a slow-burn narrative that keeps viewers unnerved through elegant precision and atmospheric dread. Its subtle storytelling, superb performances, and steady, lingering cinematography make it an engrossing watch that stays with you long after it ends.
Video: 75
The Blu-ray presentation of "Goodnight Mommy" in 1080p excels in capturing the film's unique visual style and thematic elements. The transfer maintains a high resolution that brings forth appreciable detail, particularly in close-up shots. Facial features and clothing textures appear sharp and textured, although they do not reach the level of precision seen in top-tier transfers. Wider exterior shots of green grass and vegetation provide a natural depth and sharpness, enhancing the film's rural Austrian setting. However, the restrained chromatic range—characterized by muted primary colors and subdued secondary hues—suits the film's somber tone and dark cinematography. The skin tones are aligned with this choice, appearing slightly pale yet lifelike.
Technically, the transfer is proficient, utilizing AVC/MPEG-4 encoding and presented in a 2.40:1 aspect ratio. Black levels are consistently deep and inky, free from crush, and shadow detail is well maintained. The film benefits from its 35mm roots, boasting natural grain levels that lend an authentic filmic texture to the visuals. Instances of minor banding are present but largely negligible, ensuring that the overall image clarity remains compelling. The exterior scenes feature striking colors, particularly the vibrant greens and rich reds, juxtaposed with the predominantly low-lit, indoor settings which exhibit a more pallid color palette that heightens the film's unsettling atmosphere.
Overall, "Goodnight Mommy's" Blu-ray transfer showcases an expertly balanced representation of its visuals. The image is devoid of significant artifacts, preserving the eerie and immersive aesthetic intended by its creators. The nuanced use of color and lighting contrasts effectively accentuate the psychological horror while maintaining a visually coherent and atmospherically rich presentation.
Audio: 74
The audio presentation of "Goodnight Mommy" on Blu-ray is characterized by its atmospheric DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 lossless soundtrack, which excels in clarity and detail. Dialogue is consistently clear and well-prioritized within the center channel, ensuring that every spoken word is discernible without any balancing issues. This track is adept at delivering the film's subtle soundscape, emphasizing the immersive qualities of ambient noises like rustling grasses, buzzing insects, and distant thunder. These elements create a textured auditory environment that complements the visual storytelling.
The surround sound elements are utilized sparingly but effectively, predominantly during scenes set outdoors or those requiring heightened tension. Instances of driving rain and thundering storms are delivered with articulate precision and satisfying depth. While the soundtrack may lack frequent bombastic effects, it compensates with an expansive dynamic range and judicious use of low-frequency effects that support the onscreen action without overwhelming it.
Overall, the audio mix is not designed for a robust, action-packed experience; instead, it delivers a slow-burn thriller ambiance with meticulous attention to environmental details. The soundtrack's restraint in terms of musical score and explosive sounds is intentional, enhancing the film’s suspenseful atmosphere. Subtle but effective surround touches imbue the mix with spatial dimension, making this a technically impressive and engaging audio presentation.
Extras: 24
The Blu-ray release of "Goodnight Mommy" includes a single, yet substantial, extra feature titled "A Conversation with Filmmakers Veronika Franz & Severin Fiala." This engaging 12-to-13-minute supplement (HD) provides invaluable insights from the directors about the film's inception, the creative process behind the script, and their approach to instilling fear. The filmmakers share their inspirations, discuss how they want audiences to perceive the movie, and elaborate on the psychological elements of fear incorporated into their storytelling. This interview is conducted in German with English subtitles, offering a detailed, educational exploration of the movie’s conceptual evolution.
Extras included in this disc:
- A Conversation with Filmmakers Veronika Franz & Severin Fiala: Insights from the directors on the film's origins, script development, and audience perception, in German with English subtitles.
Movie: 83
"Goodnight Mommy" is a meticulously crafted psychological thriller that leans heavily on atmosphere and slow-building tension rather than conventional horror tropes such as jump scares and gore. The narrative centers on twins Lukas and Elias (played masterfully by Lukas and Elias Schwarz), who live in the tranquil yet unsettling German countryside. Their mother (Susanne Wuest) returns home from the hospital with her face wrapped in bandages, altering the dynamic within their idyllic home. As her behavior becomes increasingly strange and hostile, the boys suspect she may not be their real mother, leading them to take drastic measures to uncover the truth. The film expertly doles out clues, maintaining a gripping sense of suspense and dread through minimalist storytelling, subtle character development, and elegant cinematography.
Directors Veronika Franz and Severin Fiala exhibit exceptional control in their filmmaking, opting for a patient and methodical approach. The camera work is characterized by its steady and deliberate movements, creating a visual language that is both engrossing and unsettling. This compositional precision ensures that every frame serves a purpose, often lingering just long enough to build an eerie ambiance. This cinematic restraint complements the narrative's psychological complexity, where the fear of what's hidden becomes more terrifying than the eventual reveal itself. The actors' performances further amplify this tension, as they deftly balance between vulnerability and malevolence, ensuring that viewers remain on edge throughout.
"Goodnight Mommy" distinguishes itself within the horror genre by focusing on a psychological depth that stays with viewers long after the credits roll. While comparable to films like "It Follows" and "The Babadook" in its mastery of slow-burn horror, it carves out its unique identity through its unsettling exploration of identity and maternal bonds. The film's minimalist approach is both its strength and signature, turning every atmospheric detail into a potential piece of the dark puzzle it slowly assembles. This is not a film that resorts to easy scares but instead immerses its audience into a haunting experience driven by raw human fears and expertly executed suspense.
Total: 65
"Goodnight Mommy" stands out as a rewarding psychological thriller that withstands and invites repeated viewings. The film builds its narrative on simplicity, combining slow-burn tension with impactful reveals that grip the audience’s attention throughout. The plot's intricacies might leave viewers pondering its depths and meanings after the credits roll. Anchor Bay’s Blu-ray edition offers robust video and audio fidelity, creating an immersive home-viewing experience.
Though the supplementary content is rather sparse, consisting mainly of an interview featurette, its limited nature inadvertently complements the film by allowing viewers the space to form their interpretations without overly guided insights. This minimalistic approach sustains the movie's mystique and hypnotic draw, aspects essential to its engagement.
"Goodnight Mommy" is marked by excellent performances and stellar direction, ensuring its position as a remarkable entry in the horror genre. While it may not secure a longstanding place in horror film history, its unique blend of psychological intrigue and emotional intensity makes it highly recommended for horror aficionados.
In conclusion, "Goodnight Mommy" on Blu-ray is an engaging and technically proficient release. Despite the limited extras, it is a compelling purchase for those seeking a thought-provoking and visually striking addition to their collection.
Blu-ray.com review by Martin LiebmanRead review here
Video: 80
Colors are never a priority, however, as much of the movie takes place inside, with shades drawn, and clothes, furniture, and accents mostly taking on flat, earthy colors....
Audio: 80
The film opens with the sounds of rustling grasses and buzzing insects that surround the listener, presenting with easy, accurate definition that nicely recreates the idyllic environment....
Extras: 20
A Conversation with Filmmakers Veronika Franz & Severin Fiala (1080p, 12:48) features the writing/directing tandem sharing a few thoughts regarding the film, including inspirations, story evolution, their...
Movie: 90
The three main actors are magnificent when it comes to keeping the audience in the dark and reinforcing the core idea that centers on the psychology of perception, that sight alone doesn't make something...
Total: 60
Goodnight Mommy is a textbook example of a movie that will prove rewarding on multiple viewings, with the second serving as an opportunity to explore it more deeply, armed with the understanding of where...
The Digital Bits review by Tim SalmonsRead review here
Video: 90
Audio: 90
It’s a very quiet film with almost no score and very little dialogue, building its atmosphere without much in the way of boisterous aural activity....
Extras: 35
Movie: 80
The horror genre received a number of critically-acclaimed movies this year, including We Are Still Here, Bone Tomahawk, Tales of Halloween, and the recently-released Krampus, amongst many others....
Total: 74
Goodnight Mommy may not be one of the more well-remembered and studied pieces of horror filmmaking in years to come, but it still offers something of value, even if it is a little bit of everything that...
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 80
Colors are striking in the exterior sequences for sure, but again, this movie takes place mostly in low lit scenarios indoors, so there is a pale color spectrum through most of the movie....
Audio: 80
There is very little here in the way of score or music, but it's always well-utilized and balanced and always adds to each suspenseful moment....
Extras: 20
- The director and writer sit down and discuss the origins of the story, the development of the script, how the movie is supposed to play to audiences and how the audiences should perceive the film....
Movie: 80
Franz and Fiala rely on the less is more approach here, only giving few clues as to what the characters are going through, and it's a very tense and unnerving ride from start to finish....
Total: 60
The video and audio presentations are both very good, however the one and only extra is a let down....
AVSForum review by Ralph PottsRead review here
Video: 90
That coupled with the drab lighting schemes and dark cinematography makes for a visually pallid but thematically affecting look....
Audio: 84
Dialogue is firmly planted in the center channel and clearly renders voices and effects with appropriate distinction and balance within the front soundstage....
Extras: 30
...
Movie: 90
While this is billed as a horror, and it is, it eschews cheap scares and overt genre type elements in favor of a slow burning narrative that builds tension much like a psychological thriller....
Total: 74
Sony Playstation 3 Blu-ray disc Player (HDMI Audio/Video) System Controller: Apple iPad/iRule Pro HD Universal Remote Control Canton "Ergo" and In-Ceiling series speakers Axiom Audio QS8 Quadpolar speakers...
Why So Blu?Read review here
Video: 90
The color levels go from colorful, to muted, to washed out in certain scenes depending on the theme and tone that is being conveyed....
Audio: 90
The film isn’t your typical loud crash and bang type but when there are parts of action driven violence involved the soundtrack picks up the slack where needed....
Extras: 20
It’s more of an educational type of interview, so if you’re looking for answers on film specifics then you will be sorely disappointed....
Movie: 80
When their mother returns from the hospital her face and head is completely bandaged around and it worries the boys, because not only did their mom return from the hospital after having some sort of procedure...
Total: 80
The Blu-ray has great video and audio and the interview with the filmmakers is informative....
Director: Severin Fiala, Veronika Franz
Actors: Lukas Schwarz, Elias Schwarz, Susanne Wuest
PlotTwin brothers return to their secluded home after their mother undergoes cosmetic surgery, finding her face bandaged and behavior unsettlingly different. The boys, Lukas and Elias, grow increasingly suspicious of the woman claiming to be their mother, noting alarming changes in her demeanor and routine. As their mother enforces strict rules and becomes cold and distant, the twins' apprehension escalates. They start to suspect that she might be an impostor, leading them to test her identity through increasingly severe means. Their once familiar home turns into a place of fear and uncertainty, where they can no longer distinguish reality from paranoid delusion.
The tension mounts as the twins' methods to uncover the truth grow more desperate and violent, straining their relationship with the woman further. The eerie atmosphere and mounting psychological pressure push the boundaries of trust and reality. The house, now a confinement for all three, becomes a battleground for truth and deception. What begins as a quest for reassurance spirals into a harrowing psychological ordeal, with the boys determined to reveal the true identity of the woman beneath the bandages—an endeavor that takes them down a dark and dangerous path.
Writers: Veronika Franz, Severin Fiala
Release Date: 11 Sep 2015
Runtime: 99 min
Rating: R
Country: Austria
Language: German