My Bodyguard Blu-ray Review
Score: 45
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
"My Bodyguard" offers a touching yet unsentimental look at youth with stellar performances, though its conclusion feels like a cop-out, muting its emotional power.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 53
The AVC encoded image (1.84:1 aspect ratio) and Kino Lorber's presentation of 'My Bodyguard' preserve its grainy, filmic qualities with vibrant colors and compelling detail, despite minor scratches and speckling; however, the absence of subtitles and fewer chapter divisions than the DVD may disappoint some viewers.
Audio: 33
The 2.0 DTS-HD MA audio presentation is serviceable with occasional sync issues, excels in delivering the score frontally, and maintains clear but fluctuating dialogue within a rich atmospheric context; a 5.1 upgrade deemed unnecessary.
Extra: 46
The extras for 'My Bodyguard' Blu-ray include a new, engaging audio commentary by Director Tony Bill and film programmer Jim Healy, five upconverted TV spots in 1.33:1, and a widescreen HD theatrical trailer, providing a nostalgic and insightful look into the film's production and reception.
Movie: 56
'My Bodyguard' is a tender 1980s coming-of-age drama marked by solid young performances, particularly Adam Baldwin's debut as the enigmatic Linderman, balancing sensitive explorations of bullying and trauma with moments of warmth and humor. While pacing issues persist, it remains a noteworthy directorial debut for Tony Bill.
Video: 53
The AVC encoded image (1.84:1 aspect ratio) presentation reveals the signs of an older master, yet these do not significantly detract from the viewing experience. The film's inherent graininess is well-preserved, retaining the desired filmic quality and enhancing detail visibility such as nuanced facial expressions and textures within the high school settings. Despite the inherent cinematographic softness, overall clarity remains satisfactory. Colors, particularly the autumnal palette, are rendered accurately, emphasizing greenery and the vibrant costumes with effective delineation. Minor speckling is present, though no major damage is evident.
The Blu-ray release by Kino Lorber, distributed through a deal with Fox, adheres to the original theatrical aspect ratio of 1.85:1 and is produced on a BD-25 disc. The grainy aesthetic typical of the original film stock is maintained, showing improved vibrancy, clarity, and sharpness over previous DVD releases. There are, however, occasional scratches that appear briefly and some minor grain flickering. The film has been divided into only eight chapters, contrasting with the eighteen on the Fox DVD. It’s also worth noting that subtitles or captions are omitted, which were available on the prior Fox disc release.
Audio: 33
The 2.0 DTS-HD Master Audio track on the Blu-ray of "My Bodyguard" showcases a mixed performance that is intermittently marred by minor sync issues, specifically noticeable in the opening reel. While dialogue exchanges lack crisp definition, they remain adequate enough to convey emotional nuances and group dynamics effectively. Unfortunately, the scoring isn't pristinely clear, but the instrumentation survives well enough to retain the intended moods. Despite these issues, the audio track excels in atmospheric detail, making settings like bustling classrooms and urban environments easy to follow.
Dave Grusin's warmhearted score primarily occupies the front channels and offers a comforting, if somewhat understated, presence throughout. While dialogue is often clear and intelligible, there are instances where the volume may need adjustment, particularly for quieter scenes where subtitles would be beneficial. Compared to the DVD release, which included both mono and Stereo Surround options, the absence of a 5.1 upgrade in this Blu-ray release might be seen as a missed opportunity for an enhanced auditory experience. However, the overall audio presentation remains reasonably effective within its DTS-HD MA 2.0 confines.
Extras: 46
The Blu-ray extras for "My Bodyguard" are a commendable assortment that enriches the viewing experience significantly. The Audio Commentary with Director Tony Bill and Film Programmer Jim Healy is engaging and anecdotal, providing in-depth insights that fans and cinephiles will appreciate. Healy’s palpable enthusiasm, coupled with Bill's firsthand recollections, makes for a compelling listening session. The inclusion of five TV spots offers a nostalgic glimpse into the film's original promotion, albeit upconverted from DVD quality to HD format. The original theatrical trailer, presented in high-definition widescreen, adds further value. Collectively, these features present a well-rounded package that complements the main content admirably.
Extras included in this disc:
- Audio Commentary with Director Tony Bill and Film Programmer Jim Healy: Engaging and anecdotal commentary.
- Five TV Spots: Upconverted from DVD format, presented in 1.33:1.
- Original Theatrical Trailer: Presented in widescreen, high-definition.
Movie: 56
"My Bodyguard," directed by Tony Bill, tackles the universal theme of high school bullying with a focus on verisimilitude devoid of the cartoonish extremes seen in contemporaneous films like "The Karate Kid." The story follows teenager Clifford Peache (Chris Makepeace) as he navigates a new school and the terror imposed by bully Melvin Moody (Matt Dillon). After confronting the relentless harassment, Clifford enlists the aid of aloof school outcast Ricky Linderman (Adam Baldwin), establishing a transactional relationship that evolves into an unexpected friendship. The film’s screenplay by Alan Ormsby ensures Clifford's life of relative privilege juxtaposes sharply against the raw brutality of Moody's intimidation tactics, though Moody's character lacks depth beyond his 'tude.
The pacing of "My Bodyguard" has notable flaws, especially in how it handles the narrative arc of Linderman's imposing presence. This confrontation peaks too early, creating a mid-film climax that disrupts the overall rhythm, but also allowing subsequent space for more profound character development. Linderman's haunted background—marked by familial trauma and an accidental shooting—is treated with surprising sensitivity, enriching his connection with Clifford. This exploration deviates from typical teen flick formulas, giving more emotional weight to their bond.
The film successfully anchors its drama with strong performances from a young cast, heightened by veteran Ruth Gordon's spirited turn as Clifford's grandmother. Despite its age, and some outdated elements in script and costuming, Tony Bill’s directorial debut melds timeless themes of friendship and resilience with authentic teenage experiences. While not without its narrative imperfections, "My Bodyguard" remains a poignant and emotionally resonant coming-of-age tale.
Total: 45
My Bodyguard serves as an evocative exploration of adolescence seen through the lens of Chicago's urban landscape. The performances by Chris Makepeace, Adam Baldwin, and Matt Dillon are stellar, effectively conveying the nuanced dynamics of teenage insecurity and relationships. The film's realistic portrayal of the struggles of youth, combined with its unsentimental tone, offers a compelling narrative that remains engaging throughout. Kino has done commendable work with the Blu-ray release, providing a good video presentation and an adequate lossless audio track that enhances the viewing experience without overshadowing the story's simplicity.
However, the film's approach to certain themes leaves room for critique. There's a noticeable lack of depth in handling Clifford's character development, and the resolution of the bullying narrative feels somewhat superficial. Specifically, the decision to rely on violence as a means to an end detracts from the film’s authenticity, turning what could have been a powerful message into a rather clichéd conclusion. The commentary track featuring Bill provides valuable insights and is perhaps the most notable feature on the Blu-ray disc, offering fans of the cast additional appreciation for their performances.
In conclusion, My Bodyguard oscillates between moments of genuine emotional resonance and missed opportunities for deeper exploration. While the performances and certain plot elements shine, the film ultimately settles for a conventional ending that does not fully capitalize on its potential for an impactful message. Despite this, the Blu-ray release is recommended for those who appreciate strong acting and a nostalgic glimpse into youth culture. The added commentary offers further enjoyment and insight, making it a worthwhile acquisition for fans and collectors alike.
Blu-ray.com review by Brian OrndorfRead review here
Video: 70
An especially grainy movie, filmic qualities are preserved, while detail is compelling, locating the nuances of facial reactions and the general textures of the high school classrooms and hallway decorations....
Audio: 50
Atmospherics are thick, but classroom bustle is easy to follow, along with urban activity....
Extras: 60
...
Movie: 60
The second half of "My Bodyguard" spotlights Linderman's pain and secretive past, warming up to Clifford's positive attention, which also includes dinner and a palm reading with Gramma, who temporarily...
Total: 70
The ending basically endorses a "violence solves everything" message that doesn't make sense, indulging wish-fulfillment while the rest of the movie strives to remain authentic to Clifford's plight....
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 60
The film stock used on productions like these always had a grainy appearance and that aesthetic is preserved by Kino....
Audio: 40
Dialog is often clear and intelligible but you may find yourself turning it up for certain scenes (here subtitles would have been helpful.)...
Extras: 40
Healy is very passionate about the film (he saw it four times during its theatrical run) and although Bill hasn't watched it in a long time, he recounts several anecdotes about cast members and a few production...
Movie: 60
This 1980 indie is told from the point of view of Clifford (Chris Makepeace), a shy and smart high school sophomore whose acclimating himself to a new school in Chicago....
Total: 60
...
Director: Tony Bill
Actors: Chris Makepeace, Adam Baldwin, Matt Dillon
PlotClifford Peache, a new student at a Chicago high school, finds himself targeted by the school bully, Melvin Moody, and his gang. Clifford is confronted daily, enduring harassment and threats for protection money. The situation worsens until he learns about Ricky Linderman, a formidable and reclusive student rumored to have a dark past. Despite warnings and fear from others, Clifford decides to approach Ricky with a bold proposition: to act as his bodyguard.
Ricky, initially reluctant and distant, eventually agrees to Clifford’s proposal. Their alliance disrupts the school's social order, with the once-untouchable Moody now facing resistance. Gradually, a friendship forms between Clifford and Ricky, revealing layers of their personal struggles and vulnerabilities. As they confront their fears and adversaries, the bond between the two teenagers strengthens, offering a blend of courage, camaraderie, and the pursuit of respect in an environment overshadowed by intimidation.
Writers: Alan Ormsby
Release Date: 26 Sep 1980
Runtime: 102 min
Rating: PG
Country: United States
Language: English