The Flag of Iron Blu-ray Review
Tie qi men 鐵旗門
Score: 52
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
With creative fighting methods overshadowing a simple plot, 'The Flag of Iron' offers decent technical merits in its nicely packaged Blu-ray release.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 58
The Blu-ray of 'The Flag of Iron' offers an AVC encoded 1080p transfer that reveals both strengths and weaknesses; while the HD remaster from 35mm negatives enhances resolution and addresses damage, the image suffers from digital artifacts like smearing, frozen grain, and inconsistent color replication, with reds tending towards orange.
Audio: 53
The Flag of Iron's audio presentation in LPCM 2.0 Mono, whether in Cantonese, Mandarin, or English, showcases a characteristic boxiness with evident reverb and slight distortion, yet delivers life through boomy drums and smooth bass despite its dated feel.
Extra: 36
While this release stands out with a singular engaging commentary by Mike Leeder and Arne Venema, its real charm lies in the thoughtfully curated physical extras, including a detailed booklet by Andrew Graves, reversible sleeve art, and original poster reproduction, embodying 88 Films' commitment to enriching presentation.
Movie: 61
"The Flag of Iron" exemplifies Shaw Brothers' shift from coherent stories to innovative martial arts choreography, introducing bizarre fighting styles with flags and unconventional weapons like segmented abacuses. Despite its creative combat, the film's energy wanes, and a convoluted plot with superfluous characters diminishes its impact.
Video: 58
"The Flag of Iron" is released on Blu-ray by 88 Films featuring an AVC encoded 1080p transfer presented in a 2.37:1 aspect ratio. Contrary to the packaging that suggests a 2.35:1 aspect ratio, this new HD master, derived from the original 35mm negatives, delivers a mixed bag in terms of visual quality. While resolution and clarity seem indicative of a recent scan, detail levels fluctuate, likely owing to anamorphic optical artifacts native to Shawscope lenses. The video displays episodes of softness and blurriness, specifically in wide shots, which detracts from the overall detail fidelity. Moreover, there are indications of noise reduction, resulting in a grain field that appears less organic and sometimes near posterizing effects with oily or liquid-looking color splotches.
Despite the noted restoration efforts nearly eliminating print damage, the presentation remains imperfect, with potential grain addition after filtering. This occasionally disrupts picture integrity through frozen grain and smearing issues, negatively impacting texture reproduction. Colors predominantly focus on primary hues; however, replication remains average. The film features notable reds, such as the cloaks worn by leads in the opening act, yet other tones appear flat with problematic flesh tones. Black levels contribute to the loss of dimensionality due to their murky quality, though the bright contrast adds some vitality to the image.
This release represents a rare divergence from what has generally been high-caliber presentations by both 88 Films and Arrow Films. While the remastering hints at advancements in handling classic Shaw Brothers material, issues such as inconsistent grain management and color fidelity challenges suggest there’s room for improvement in future endeavors.
Audio: 53
The audio presentation of "The Flag of Iron" on Blu-ray provides Cantonese, Mandarin, and English options in LPCM 2.0 Mono. These tracks, typical of releases from labels like 88 Films and Arrow Films, carry a characteristic boxiness and diluted reverb. While this creates a sound reminiscent of dialogue and effects emerging from a cavernous space, it may lead to slight distortion and occasional sibilance.
Despite these limitations, the audio manages to inject dynamic range into its dated mix, particularly evident in the prominent boomy drums of the score that resonate with a rich bass texture. While the routine, worn dialog in the English dub introduces some static, it remains largely unobtrusive. Optional English subtitles are available for clarity and assistance.
Overall, while the audio retains some vintage quirks typical of its genre era, it successfully breathes life into the film's soundscape, offering an engaging auditory experience that complements its visual restoration.
Extras: 36
The Blu-Ray release of "The Flag of Iron" is complemented by a select range of extras, consistent with 88 Films' commitment to quality packaging and insightful content. While the quantity of supplements may be limited compared to previous titles in the 88 Asia Collection, the offering remains valuable. The standout feature is an audio commentary by Asian film experts Mike Leeder and Arne Venema, providing an engaging, if occasionally overlapping, dialogue that enriches the viewing experience. Noteworthy, too, is the inclusion of a detailed booklet with an insightful essay by Andrew Graves, enhancing the understanding of the film's cultural context. Additionally, the package features a reversible sleeve with new artwork by R.P. "Kung Fu Bob" O'Brien and a fold-out reproduction of the original Hong Kong poster, adding both aesthetic and collector's appeal.
Extras included in this disc:
- Audio Commentary with Mike Leeder and Arne Venema: A dynamic discussion, though sometimes overlapping.
- Booklet with Essay by Andrew Graves: Provides contextual insights into the film.
Movie: 61
"The Flag of Iron" Blu-ray stands as a notable offering in the Shaw Brothers' cinematic legacy, particularly for enthusiasts of the so-called Venoms Mob. Released towards the franchise's end in 1980, this film encapsulates the transitionary period of the studio, highlighting both its strengths and weaknesses. While the narrative centers on themes of betrayal and revenge, it lacks depth, offering instead a rather convoluted plot that can be underwhelming. The focus thus shifts to the inventive fight choreography, heralding a shift from traditional martial arts styles to more theatrical displays. These inventive and unorthodox techniques, featuring peculiar weapons like flags or abacuses, provide an eye-catching spectacle that compensates for the film's narrative shortcomings.
Commentators Mike Leeder and Arne Venema bring attention to the film's striking juxtaposition of brotherhood with rampant subterfuge, a recurring theme in the Venoms series. Yet, they note that "The Flag of Iron" lacks the zest seen in earlier films. The production quality reflects Shaw Brothers' shift towards television, imbuing the film with a "movie of the week" feel. Costumes border on campy, adding a distinct charm and visual flair, akin to a retro dancehall extravaganza rather than a rigid historical piece.
Despite its narrative flaws and sporadic pacing, "The Flag of Iron" lures viewers into its whimsical world through humor-laden initial acts and inventive battles. However, momentum wanes as predictable genre tropes unfold. The concluding acts fail to rejuvenate the film with their brevity and lackluster execution relative to prior thrilling scenes. The film’s erratic tonal shifts oscillate between fantastical escapism and dramatic tension, resulting in an experience that's eclectic if uneven—a grindhouse spectacle that piquantly juxtaposes convention with unabashed chaos.
Total: 52
"The Flag of Iron" Blu-ray release is an interesting addition to the kung fu genre, blending classic storytelling with inventive action sequences. The film navigates a familiar narrative of betrayal and revenge but stands out through its creative choreography and unique fighting methods. While the plot does not break new ground and at times takes a backseat to the action, fans of martial arts films will still find much to appreciate. The choreography showcases eighteen distinctive fighting styles, captured with agility and precision, making each set piece a highlight of the viewing experience.
From a technical standpoint, the Blu-ray release by 88 Films offers an acceptable presentation, though not without room for improvement. The video transfer maintains a satisfactory clarity and color consistency, but could benefit from enhanced sharpness and detail to fully bring the dynamic action to life. The audio quality is adequate, delivering a clear dialogue and impactful sound effects that complement the onscreen melee. The packaging is attractive and aligns with 88 Films' reputation for releasing quality collector items, offering added appeal for collectors and enthusiasts of the genre.
In conclusion, while "The Flag of Iron" might not match the high standards set by recent stellar kung fu releases, it remains an entertaining watch, particularly for those intrigued by unique martial arts techniques. Its value lies in the engaging fight scenes rather than a gripping narrative. For aficionados of martial arts cinema, this Blu-ray provides a commendable addition to their collection, despite its technical confinements.
Blu-ray.com review by Jeffrey KauffmanRead review here
Video: 70
Detail levels are quite good a lot of the time, but this is another Shaw Brothers effort where Shawscope and its lenses can contribute both anamorphic oddities but also downright cloudiness and blurriness,...
Audio: 60
These are typically bombastic tracks, and like many of the other releases from both 88 Films and Arrow Films, there's an undeniable boxiness, with some probably too "wet" reverb that can make both effects...
Extras: 20
I believe this may be the first release that sports only a commentary (as below), but this does come with what is evidently 88 Film's "tradition" of a nicely appointed insert booklet, a reversible sleeve...
Movie: 70
The fact that those last listing from the UK market were released by 88 Films may augur well for their eventual debut in Region A, and since 88 Films and Arrow seem to be going like gangbusters to get...
Total: 70
What with a varying number of Venoms, eighteen kinds of fighting styles, and 36 chambers of Shaolin, you might need an oversized abacus to keep track of it all, but The Fist of Iron is actually rote enough...
DoBlu review by Matt PaprockiRead review here
Video: 60
This causes an overall reduction in fidelity and detail, negating any gains from the fresh mastering....
Audio: 60
The score’s boomy drums allow range to seep in, the bass smooth enough to give this dated track life....
Extras: 60
Asian film experts Mike Leeder and Arne Venema provide a commentary on the disc, which is great, but the included booklet with an essay by Andrew Graves is worth mentioning too....
Movie: 60
While not logical, seeing a duel between two men waving flags is eye-catching and exciting, like an Olympic sport, but with life on the line, not a judge’s scorecard....
Total: 60
Betrayal and revenge serve as the core story to Flag of Iron, but it’s a film defined more by its creative fighting methods than its plot....
Director: Cheh Chang
Actors: Phillip Chung-Fung Kwok, Sheng Chiang, Li Wang
PlotIn a martial arts clan, the Iron Flag gang operates under the strict code of honor. The gang's leader, sober and fair, maintains discipline, but his trusted associate, a cunning yet ambitious brother, desires more power. As tensions bubble under the surface, an unexpected betrayal unfolds when an assassin from a rival clan is hired to sow discord. The assassination of the leader leaves the gang in chaos and leadership up for grabs. Amidst confusion and accusations, members set out on a quest to uncover the truth behind the deadly conspiracy and exact revenge on those responsible.
With respect hanging by a thread, the bond of brotherhood is put to the test. The remaining loyal disciples band together, fueled by vengeance and a thirst for justice, seeking clues that will lead them to the mastermind pulling the strings. Their journey exposes them to treacherous encounters and deadly confrontations, each step revealing how deep-seated the betrayal runs. As they hone their skills and gather allies, internal conflict threatens their unity. A critical confrontation looms, forcing the brothers to face unimaginable peril. A final showdown sets the stage for a battle not only for justice but also for redemption, as they strive to restore honor to their shattered clan and ensure peace.
Writers: Cheh Chang, Kuang Ni
Release Date: 01 Feb 1984
Runtime: 113 min
Rating: R
Country: Hong Kong
Language: Mandarin